2013 Mock Trial Results

Kingsport Home School Wins 1st State Title, Moves on to Nationals

 

 

Members of the Kingsport Area Christian Home Education Association team celebrate after being awarded the 2013 championship trophy in the 33rd Annual Tennessee State High School Mock Trial Competition. Tennessee Supreme Court Justice William Koch, who presided over the championship round, poses with the team.

Photo by Stacey Shrader Joslin of the Tennessee Bar Association

NASHVILLE, March 20, 2013 — The Kingsport Area Christian Home Education Association (KACHEA) team claimed the state high school mock trial championship title this past weekend, defeating Montgomery Bell Academy of Nashville. The team now will represent Tennessee at the National High School Mock Trial Competition in Indianapolis, Ind., May 9-11.

The two-day state competition, sponsored by the Tennessee Bar Association Young Lawyers Division, involved 14 teams and 200 volunteers, including lawyers, law students and paralegals. In addition, sitting judges in the state presided over the trial rounds at the Metro Davidson County Courthouse in downtown Nashville. Tennessee Supreme Court Justice William Koch presided over the championship match Saturday evening.

The teams put their skills to the test arguing the fictitious case of State of Tennessee v. Cameron Paul, in which an auto mechanic is suspected of murdering Thor Brush, an investment broker who gets local businessmen to invest in a sham company. News of the scheme breaks and clients, including Paul, find they have lost everything. Brush is indicted and awaiting trial when he dies in a car crash. Paul had recently worked on Brush’s car and police determine the brakes were deliberately loosened. The state argues that Paul – upset about his financial loss – intentionally tampered with the car. The defense places blame on Brush, who was not wearing a seatbelt, was texting, and had fatal levels of medication in his system at the time of the crash.

It was KACHEA’s first year to compete in the championship round. It placed fourth last year. To reach the state competition, each team had to win its respective district competition held throughout February.

At a ceremony immediately preceding the championship round, students were recognized for their efforts. TBA President Jackie Dixon, an attorney with Weatherly McNally & Dixon PLC in Nashville, presented awards to the top 10 teams, the best lawyers and witnesses, the most valuable players for each team, and the team exhibiting the best sportsmanship-like behavior. See photos from the award ceremony below.

See photos of the championship round here.


Top 10 Teams


All photos by Landry Butler of the Tennessee Bar Association unless otherwise noted.

1. Kingsport Area Christian Home Education Association, Kingsport
Attorney Coach: David A. Greene, Covenant Trust LLC
(See photo above)

2. Montgomery Bell Academy, Nashville
Attorney Coach: Wade B. Cowan, Davies, Humphreys, Horton & Reese PLC
(Photo by Stacey Shrader Joslin of the Tennessee Bar Association)

3. Germantown High School, Germantown
Attorney Coach: Jay Watson, Attorney at Law

4. Chattanooga Southeast Tennessee Home Education Association, Chattanooga
Attorney Coaches: Hamilton County Chancellor Jeff Atherton & Scott Maucere,
Maucere Law Group

5. Harpeth Hall, Nashville
Attorney Coaches: Joy Boyd, Christy Crider & Maia Woodhouse, all with
Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz PC

6. Beech High School, Hendersonville
Attorney Coach: Thomas Dean, 18th Judicial District Attorney’s Office

7. Westminster Academy, Memphis
Attorney Coach: Stephen Leffler, Leffler Law Office

8. McCallie School, Chattanooga
Attorney Coach: Ira Long Jr., Weill & Long PLLC

9. The Webb School, Bell Buckle
Attorney Coach: Kathleen Camp, The Webb School

10. Franklin High School, Franklin
Attorney Coach: Terry E. Wood, 21st Judicial District Attorney General’s Office

Other schools competing included:

Bearden High School, Knoxville
      Attorney Coach: W. Matthew McWhirter, Bearden High School
Dyersburg High School, Dyersburg
      Attorney Coach: Jeff Lay, Jones, Hamilton & Lay
Jefferson County High School, Dandridge
      Attorney Coach: NA
Smith County High School, Carthage
      Attorney Coaches: J. Branden Bellar, Bellar & Winkler & Jacqueline M. Scott, Attorney at Law


Team Sportsmanship Award


Smith County High School of Carthage -- in its first visit to the state competition --
took the Team Sportsmanship Award. The award recipient is based on the votes
of other teams and presiding judges. The team is coached by J. Branden Bellar
with Bellar & Winkler and Jacqueline M. Scott, Attorney at Law, both of Carthage.


Individual Awards



Best Advocate for the Prosecution

Caroline Rogers (left) with Bearden High School was named the competition's Best Advocate for the Prosecution.

Melissa Temple with the Kingsport Home School team took second place in the Best Advocate for the Prosecution category.

Magi Higazi with Germantown High School took third place in the Best Advocate for the Prosecution category.


Best Advocate for the Defense

Brennan Day with Bearden High School was named the competition's Best Advocate for the Defense.

Cat Weiss with Harpeth Hall took second place in the Best Advocate for the Defense category. Due to an oversight she was not recognized publicly at the award ceremony.

Aaron Long with the McCallie School took third place in the Best Advocate for the Defense category.


Best Witness for the Prosecution

Marianne Dodson with Bearden High School was named Best Witness for the Prosecution.

Avery Field with Beech High School took second place in the Best Witness for the Prosecution category.

Lindsey Dunn with Dyersburg High School took third place in the Best Witness for the Prosecution category.


Best Witness for the Defense

McKay Proctor with Montgomery Bell Academy was named Best Witness for the Defense.

Brandon Lynan with Bearden High School placed second in the Best Witness for the Defense category.

Maddie Bouton with Franklin High School took third place in the Best Witness for the Defense category.


Team Most Valuable Players (MVPs)

Brandon Lynan with Bearden High School

Avery Field with Beech High School

Camille Heartfield with Chattanooga Southeast Tennessee Home Education Association

Noah Mulvaney with Dyersburg High School

Maddie Bouton with Franklin High School

Rachel Dufour with Germantown High School

Sarah Abel with Harpeth Hall 

Jessie McGaha with Jefferson County High School

Phillip Bunn with Kingsport Area Christian Home Education Association

Aaron Long with the McCallie School

McKay Proctor with Montgomery Bell Academy

Beau Carr with Smith County High School

Adam Mansell with The Webb School   

Amy Hall with Westminster Academy

 

 

 

 

Attached files

VOLUNTEERS


Participating Judges

The mock trial competition would not be possible without the support of the Tennessee judiciary. The following judges served as presiding judges during one or more of the competition's trial rounds:

Judge Lee Bussart Bowles
Marshall County General Sessions Court

Magistrate Judge Joe B. Brown
U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee

Chancellor William Cole
25th Judicial District Chancery Court

Judge Paul B. Conley III
Crockett County General Sessions Court

Judge Mark Fishburn
20th Judicial District Criminal Court

Commissioner Robert Hibbett
Tennessee Claims Commission

Judge John Aaron Holt
Davidson County General Sessions Court

Justice William C. Koch Jr.
Tennessee Supreme Court

Chancellor Russell T. Perkins
20th Judicial District Chancery Court

Judge Quinn Brandon Stewart
Municipal Court of Lewisburg

Judge A. Wilson Wages
Municipal Court of Millington

Judge Thomas T. Woodall
Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals

Mock Trial Committee

Chair:
Troy S. Weston
Eldridge & Blakney PC, Knoxville

Vice Chair:
William P. Holloway
Schell, Binkley & Davies LLC, Franklin

Committee Members:
Kristen Corn
City of Franklin

Joshua B. Dougan
Attorney at Law, Jackson

Candi Henry
Dodson, Parker, Behm & Capparella PC, Nashville

R. Holland Matthews
The Matthews Firm PLLC, Columbia

William E. “Bill” McManus
Attorney at Law, Jonesborough

Angela B. Rauber
City of Knoxville Law Department

Robert L. Sands
Dix & Associates PLLC, Murfreesboro

Thomas S. Santel Jr.
Cope, Hudson, Reed & McCreary PLLC, Murfreesboro

Staff:
Stacey Shrader Joslin
State Mock Trial Coordinator
Tennessee Bar Association, Nashville

Attorney Volunteers

Catherine Anglin
Katrina Atchley Arbogast
Ahsaki Baptist
Chris Barker
Anthony Berry
Robb Bigelow
Shauna Billingsley
Robert Black
Josh Bohannon
Rebecca Brady
Christopher Brown
Brad Carter
Cindy Chappell
Annie Christoff
Steve Christopher
Garth Click
Eva Close
Marisa Combs
Joann Coston-Holloway
Seth Crabtree
Jason Demastus
Chad Dickson
Jackie Dixon
Caitlin Doty
Kathryn Ellis
Amber Floyd
Nicole Grida
Mary Beth Haltom
Carolyn Hamilton
Philip Hatch
Ellie Hill
Kyle Hixson
Ashley Holliday
Chuck Holliday
Cherrell Hooper
Katie Jones
Tiffany Johnson
Jenney Keaty
Brittani Kendrick
Steven King
Will Kittrell
Caroline Knight
Sydney Koch
Michael Kurtz
Rachel Levinson
Aimee Luna
George Maifair
Jillian Mastroianni
Chris McCarty
David McDowell
Shane McNeill
Dora Misciagna
Chaz Molder
Adam Moore
Rachel Moses
Matthew Muenzen
William Neese
Daniel Osborne
Jason Pannu
Matt Potempa
Rachel Ralston Mancl
Mary Rau-Foster
Keisha Richardson
Nathan Shelby
Craig Smith
Sarah Smith
Leslie South
Jason Steinle
Jonathan Tinsley
Todd Tressler
David Veile
John Williams
Mason Wilson
Brian Winfrey
Stacie Winkler

Law Student & Other Volunteers

Sonia Boss
Cindy Brown
Arthur Earls
Kelley Groover
Renee Hooper
Terry Jones
Bianca Knight
Kimberlee McTorry
Nicholas Menefee
Paul Richardson
Mike Sandler

Local Competition Coordinators

District 1: Nicole Grida, Jonathan Nelson, Memphis
District 2: Ashley Holliday, Jackson
District 3: Cara Lynn, Columbia
District 4: Shauna Billingsley, Franklin
District 5: Rebecca Barnett & Peter Robinson, Nashville
District 6: Sue Hynds Dunning, Gallatin
District 7: K. Chris Collins & Jason Demastus, Chattanooga
District 8: Rachel Moses, Cookeville
District 9: George R. Maifair, Knoxville
Districts 10 & 13: Katherine Goodner & Shelby Ward, Knoxville
Districts 11 & 12: Erin D. McArdle, Jonesborough


CASE MATERIALS


District Competition Materials
2013 Problem (11/28/2012)
2013 Exhibits (11/28/2012)
2013 Rules (11/28/2012)
Memo re: Opening & Closing Statements (2/4/2013)

State Competition Materials
2013 Revised Problem (3/1/2013)
2013 Revised Exhibits (3/1/2013)
2013 Revised Rules (3/1/2013)
2013 State Team Resources
2013 State Volunteer Resources
2013 Final Bracket Results

General Materials
Frequently Asked Questions
2013 Scoresheet
Want to tweet about the 2013 competition? Use hashtag #TNMockTrial201


NATIONAL COMPETITION


The Kingsport Home School Team represented Tennessee at the 2013 National High School Mock Trial Championship in Indianapolis, Ind., May 9-11. The team placed seventh out of 48.


Return to main mock trial page