Judicial Selection Deferred to Next Week

Legislative action this week on judicial selection issues ended in almost as big a muddle as it began.

Today, Sen. Brian Kelsey, R-Collierville, deferred action to Monday night on his constitutional amendment, SJR 710, which would remove merit panels from the process and replace it with Washington-style confirmation when selecting and retaining judges in Tennessee.

Meanwhile, the House seems set to pass only the House counterpart to the Kelsey plan and not move forward with the two resolution strategy that seemed to be emerging at the end of last week. The House counterpart to Sen. Mark Norris’s resolution (SJR 183), which was successful in the Senate on Monday night, will not see consideration in the House Finance Committee until Tuesday at the earliest.

Lost in all of the mêlée is any consideration of how the next election for all judges -- which the constitution requires to be held in August 2014 -- will be conducted. The TBA and allies in the business, civic and legal communities remain committed to stability and consistency, which the current process offers while the debate on the need for and the best outline of future changes takes place.

Contact with lawmakers -- and as importantly, feedback with the TBA on that contact -- are important ways each lawyer can contribute to the future of a fair and impartial court system.