Justices Say Court Erred in Allowing Evidence

The Tennessee Supreme Court sent a Hamblen County case back to Chancery Court for retrial after ruling that the trial court allowed evidence to be presented that was irrelevant and prejudicial, and saying that allowing the jury to hear it probably affected the verdict. The trial court had invalidated the marriage of Raymond Smallman and Linda Caraway, which had been conducted shortly before Smallman's death, and refused to allow Caraway to have Smallman’s will admitted to probate as his widow. The Chattanoogan has this story. Read Justice Sharon Lee's opinion and Justice William Koch's concurring and dissenting opinion.