News

Judge Grants Mistrial In Vanderbilt Rape Case

Nashville Criminal Court Judge Monte Watkins has granted a mistrial for Brandon Vandenburg and Cory Batey, two former Vanderbilt University football players convicted of rape. “The defendants have a right to a fair and impartial trial, a right that was violated by juror #9’s conduct," Watkins’ order reads. Following the trial, defense attorneys discovered a juror had been a rape victim 15 years ago. They argued the juror could not be impartial based on his experience, the Tennessean reports. The decision did not address how the case will go forward or whether a new trial date will be set.

read more »

Tennessean: DA Builds Staff With Defense Attorneys

One-third of new prosecutors hired by Nashville District Attorney Glenn Funk served most recently as defense attorneys, a review of records by the Tennessean shows. Of the 23 attorneys he has hired, eight came from a public defender’s office or a private criminal defense practice. Four others worked as defense attorneys at some point in their careers. The newcomers “represent a shift in the type of experience” for the office, the paper says.

read more »

More Tools Available to Aid Domestic Violence Victims

The Upper Cumberland Family Justice Center has begun using a training program to help law enforcement better help domestic violence victims who are in critical danger, the Herald-Citizen reports. Several area law enforcement jurisdictions are using the Maryland Model Lethality Assessment Program (LAP), which has 11 assessment questions for a police officer to ask domestic violence victims. And in Grundy County, the Sheriff's Office is using a tracking device able to alert victims when an offender is close, in hopes of warding off another attack.  WRCB has more.

read more »

Governor Rejects 3 for Judge, Asks for More Names

Gov. Bill Haslam has rejected three nominees submitted to him for appointment to a vacant Hamilton County Criminal Court judgeship and asked for a new slate of nominees. The additional names are choices to replace Rebecca Stern as Criminal Court judge. The 11-member Governor’s Council for Judicial Appointments had nominated two assistant district attorneys general, Leslie Longshore and Boyd Anderson, along with Mike Little, a deputy public defender. The seat was left open by the retirement of Criminal Court Judge Rebecca Stern. Knoxnews has more.

read more »

Annual Judicial District Report Shows Improvement

The state comptroller’s office has released its annual review of funds administered by Tennessee’s district attorneys general and judicial drug task forces for the fiscal year ending June 30. The report shows continued improvement in the way funds are managed across the state, Chattanoogan.com reports. Comptroller Justin P. Wilson complimented the District Attorneys General Conference for its efforts to improve financial operations by offering training and education to its members.

read more »

Chattanooga Family Justice Center to Open July 1

The new Chattanooga Family Justice Center, scheduled to open July 1, will provide a central location for victims of family violence to access needed services. Executive Director Valerie Radu tells WRCB-TV that the center’s first goal is to increase reporting of domestic violence by educating the community about available resources. Local law enforcement estimate that more than 30 percent of violent crime is driven by domestic abuse.

read more »

Rep. Armstrong Indicted on Fraud, Tax Charges

A federal grand jury today indicted veteran state Rep. Joe Armstrong, D-Knoxville, on charges he used insider knowledge on a bill he supported to earn $500,000 in a scheme involving the purchase and sale of cigarette tax stamps. He has been charged with conspiring to defraud the United States, attempting to evade and defeat income taxes and making false statements. Armstrong’s accountant already pleaded guilty to helping the legislator by funneling the profits through the accounting firm and lying on Armstrong’s tax return. Knoxnews has the story.

read more »

Judicial Commissioner Charged with Assault

Lincoln County judicial commissioner Brian Thomas Rutledge has been indicted on an assault charge stemming from an incident in February in which he allegedly grabbed a man by the neck following an argument at a Fayetteville market. Rutledge was released on his own recognizance, Knoxnews reports.

read more »

State Agency Withdraws from Execution Lawsuit

Facing objections from legislators and a Senate Government Operations Committee hearing set for August, the Office of Post-Conviction Defender has decided to abandon its role in a lawsuit seeking information about executions, Knoxnews reports. The office, which is tasked with representing death row inmates in appeals, was representing a group of inmates suing the state for information about the people and drugs involved in executions. Nashville attorney Kathleen G. Morris now will provide pro bono representation to the death row inmates.

read more »

Judge's Ruling Could Affect Up to 80 Cases

Law enforcement in Sullivan County has not been in compliance with Rule 3 of the Tennessee Rules of Criminal Procedure for at least two decades, putting 75 or 80 pending cases in jeopardy, according to a local judge. Rule 3, which requires a written and sworn statement of the arresting officer before a magistrate, apparently was not being followed during after-hours arrests. Local law enforcement has been scrambling to re-file thousands of affidavits of arrest but the ruling has caused defendants in pending cases to file dismissal motions, the Kingsport Times-News reports.

read more »

Judge Hears Vandy Rape Mistrial Motion

Nashville Criminal Court Judge Monte Watkins heard more than four hours of testimony and arguments yesterday related to requests for a mistrial in the Vanderbilt rape case. Defense attorneys for Brandon Vandenburg and Cory Batey, who were convicted in January of raping an unconscious student in a dorm, say a juror heard 104 questions during jury selection that should have prompted him to disclose he was a victim of statutory rape as a teen. Watkins is expected to rule on the motions next week. The Tennessean has more.

read more »

Public Defender to Host Session on Expungement

Richard Hughes, public defender for the 10th Judicial District, will host an educational program on June 30 to explain the process by which certain offenders may have the chance to expunge their criminal records. The session is scheduled to run from 4 p.m. to 7 p.m. at Hughes’ office located at 85 Central Ave. in Cleveland. For more information, contact the public defender’s office at (423) 478-0329. The Cleveland Banner has more.

read more »

New Website Presents Database of Collateral Consequences of Conviction

A new National Inventory of Collateral Consequences of Conviction is now available through a website produced by the National Institute of Justice and the American Bar Association’s Criminal Justice Section. The interactive site lets attorneys select one or more jurisdiction in the database, then identify legal sanctions and restrictions imposed. The work is part of the ABA’s efforts to reform collateral consequences so that they serve public safety goals, but do not impose high social and economic costs.

read more »

Former Public Defender Questions Treatment of Inmates

Policies that send non-violent offenders to jail and require fees for many services and products should be reconsidered, a former public defender contends. Bill Shulman, a 25-year associate professor of criminal justice at Middle Tennessee State University in Murfreesboro and former elected public defender for Davidson County, told the Daily News Journal he thinks the solution is to quit locking up so many people who are not a threat physically to society and allow more to serve punishments in other ways. 

read more »

TBI Releases New Data on Domestic Violence

A recent study by the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation shows domestic violence resulted in 270 murder victims in Tennessee from 2012 to 2014. The review also found that simple assault accounted for more than 68 percent of all domestic violence offenses, that females were three times more likely to be victimized than males and that victims were six times more likely to be abused by a spouse than an ex-spouse. Read more in the Memphis Daily News.

read more »

DA’s Conference Issues New Training Resources

The Tennessee District Attorneys General Conference’s Justice and Professionalism Committee has released the first installment in a series of training resources to be provided to all Tennessee prosecutors, Chattanoogan.com reports. The DVD-based training focuses on the responsibilities of prosecutors during constitutional discovery. Additional resources will review advances in DNA, forensic science and digital evidence in cases involving children, the elderly and victims of sex crimes, human trafficking and domestic violence.

read more »

Inmate Wants to Donate Organs to Ailing Parents

Kenneth Thomas, an inmate housed at the Turney Center in Only, is asking the Tennessee Supreme Court to allow him the right to die in prison so his organs can be harvested for his ailing parents. Thomas, 37, was convicted of a 1999 murder and sentenced to life in prison. He is eligible for parole in 2063, but believes he will never be released, WKRN News 2 reports. 

read more »

Developer in Assault Case Sues Nashville Government

Nashville real estate developer David Chase has filed suit against Metro government and its police department, the Business Journal reports. In the complaint, Chase claims police violated his civil rights, failed to follow proper procedure, used excessive force and subjected him to false arrest. He also alleges that his former girlfriend was friends with at least one of the officers who arrested him. Chase’s arrest made news when reports surfaced that a judge waived the required 12-hour cooling off period, which allowed Chase to leave the county jail and allegedly assault the woman a second time.

read more »

Court Rules on Passport Issue, Grants 3 Cases for Fall

The U.S. Supreme Court issued three opinions today, including one favoring the White House in a foreign-policy power struggle with Congress over whether Jerusalem-born Americans may list Israel as the place of birth on their U.S. passports. The court also agreed to hear three cases in the fall: when a three-judge panel must be convened to consider challenges to redistricting plans, how workers prove class action damages, and whether a defendant facing asset forfeiture can use funds not obtained from the crime to pay for legal representation. Finally, the court declined to hear four cases, including another challenge to the Affordable Care Act and a question of whether local governments may require handguns be disabled or locked up when they are not being carried. Read a wrap-up from SCOTUSblog.

read more »

UT Law Students Work on Hair Analysis Project

University of Tennessee College of Law students will play a key role in the federal government’s efforts to identify cases in which forensic hair samples may have resulted in wrongful convictions, Knoxnews reports. The FBI has publicly conceded that hair analysis is little more than guess work and “experts” who testified otherwise were wrong. The FBI Crime Laboratory and the U.S. Department of Justice have teamed up with the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers to identify cases where hair analysis was key to a conviction and the defendant is still incarcerated. Students will be researching cases in Tennessee.

read more »

Dean to Reconsider Police HQ Move

Mayor Karl Dean is now promising additional community meetings before deciding whether to pursue a controversial relocation of the Metro police headquarters to Jefferson St., the Tennessean reports. North Nashville residents oppose the relocation, which many said would bring added police patrol and racial profiling to the predominantly black area. The headquarters — which includes only administrative offices — would relocate from the aging downtown Criminal Justice Center. The mayor and Sheriff Daron Hall also want to move the downtown jail to a new $110 million facility in southeast Nashville.

read more »

NAACP Holds Criminal Justice Seminar Saturday

The Chattanooga NAACP will host its 8th Annual Criminal Justice Seminar this Saturday from 8:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. at the Chattanooga Choo Choo Imperial Ballroom. The theme of the event is "Know your Rights." Speakers include NAACP National Director of Criminal Justice Carlton Mayers, Tennessee ACLU Executive Director Hedy Wienberg, District Attorney General Neal Pinkston and the president of Georgia NOBLE, Robert Ford.  The Chattanooga Times Free Press has more.

read more »

Juvenile Court Offers Alternative Detention Program

The Madison County Juvenile Court program opened its new HERO program on Monday with a ribbon-cutting ceremony at the University of Memphis at Lambuth. The HERO program is an alternative option for youth ages 12 to 17 with nonviolent offenses and will meet every night on the Lambuth campus. Judge Christy Little said she hopes the program will provide a positive influence for the youth involved by seeing students on campus during the school year. The Jackson Sun has the story.

read more »

Supreme Court Denies New Trial After Witness’ Memory Loss During Testimony

The Tennessee Supreme Court rejected a Memphis defendant’s argument that he was entitled to a new trial because a witness on the stand said he was unable to recall his earlier statements about the murder. Marlo Davis was convicted of second degree murder and reckless homicide in the 2006 death of a man working on a rental property. During the investigation, one witness gave a sworn statement to police and then later testified at a preliminary hearing that he saw Davis shoot the victim. At trial, that same witness said he could not recall what happened that day and did not recall what he had said to police or at the hearing. On appeal to the Supreme Court, the court rejected the argument regarding feigned memory loss, saying that the trial court had no way of definitively determining if a witness was being truthful about their lack of memory. The AOC has more.

read more »

Inmate Indicted in Courthouse Powder Scare

A state inmate convicted of a 2013 armed robbery at a Sevier County adult lingerie store has been indicted in connection with the mailing of a suspicious substance to the Sevier County courthouse in February, Knoxnews reports. The white, powdery substance was mailed to the Sevierville offices of 4th Judicial District Attorney General Jimmy Dunn. The package also contained threats targeting an assistant district attorney general who had prosecuted the case against Rhodes, the release states. The substance proved to be benign, although six courthouse staffers were evaluated at a local hospital as a precaution.

read more »