News

Baumgartner Arrested on Federal Charges

Former Knox County Criminal Judge Richard Baumgartner was arrested on federal charges today after a federal grand jury indicted him on seven counts of failing to report felonious activity. He appeared in handcuffs in court this afternoon before U.S. Magistrate Judge Clifford Shirley and with his lawyer Don Bosch. In the state case, Baumgartner avoided jail time and a felony conviction when Special Judge Jon Kerry Blackwood granted him judicial diversion. His plea agreement barred the filing of additional state charges but did not preclude a federal prosecution. The News Sentinel has more

read more »

Jury Finds MTSU Roommate Guilty of 2nd Degree Murder

A jury convicted Shanterrica Madden, the roommate of slain MTSU basketball player Tina Stewart, of the lesser charge of second-degree murder after two hours of deliberation today. Prosecutors had argued for first-degree murder  Stewart was fatally stabbed in the chest March 2, 2011. NewsChannel 5 has more

read more »

Drug Court Employees Understand Offenders

Workers in the Hamilton County Drug Court can empathize with participants because they have been in their shoes. The Times Free Press has this story

Haslam Signs 'Gateway Sex,' Anti-Abortion Bills into Law

Gov. Bill Haslam has signed legislation that adds the concept of “gateway sexual activity” to the state’s abstinence-first sex education curriculum. Other bills now law are the Life Defense Act of 2012, which requires abortion providers to have admitting privileges at a hospital in the county where they perform an abortion or in a neighboring county; and a bill that will let prosecutors charge alleged assailants with a second count of assaulting or murdering an embryo after an attack on a pregnant woman. The Tennessean has the story

read more »

Victim's Friend Testifies in MTSU Murder Trial

Defense attorney Joe Brandon Jr. and District Attorney General Bill Whitesell continued with the second day of the trial of  Shanterrica Madden, accused of killing her roommate, MTSU basketball player Tina Stewart. Jurors heard a friend of Stewart's say she heard Madden pleading with Stewart to let her leave her bedroom moments before their argument turned deadly. The case is before Judge Don Ash in Murfreesboro. The Daily News Journal is following the trial

read more »

Social Media at Center of Murder Accusations

Social media gets maligned in court sometimes, but yesterday transcripts of violent text messages aided in charges being dropped against a 20-year-old Chattanooga man who was accused of soliciting murder on Facebook. Gerald Webb, Carl Parks Jr.'s attorney, showed the text messages in which the alleged murder target had threatened to have Parks, his mother and cousins killed in retaliation for their break-up and a dispute over a money loan. Prosecutor Lila Statom then dropped a charge of solicitation of murder charge against Parks. The Times Free Press reports

read more »

Sheriff's Department Settles Civil Rights Lawsuit

The Humphreys County Sheriff's Department has settled a federal case involving the beating and Tasering of an unarmed man in January 2011. The U.S. Department of Justice had criminally indicted the department earlier this year for violating the civil rights of Darrin Ring, who reportedly was beaten and Tasered for 19 minutes – sustaining broken ribs and a punctured lung. Ring will be paid $350,000. The settlement resolves all charges except those pending against a Waverly police officer, who allegedly performed the Tasering. WSMV has more

read more »

Disgraced Judge's Pill Supplier Back in Custody

Christopher Lee Gibson, who gained notoriety as the pill supplier to former Knox County Judge Richard Baumgartner, is back behind bars after being arrested for a probation violation, according to the News Sentinel. Gibson had been free on bond pending appeal of a four-year sentence imposed for a probation violation that stemmed from his involvement with Baumgartner. He was arrested Monday for possession of oxycodone and failure to report the incident to his probation officer. Gibson was a felon on probation in Baumgartner's court when he began selling prescription painkillers to the judge.

read more »

Overcrowding Fix Would Move Women's Jail

A Putnam County commissioner has a plan to fix the current overcrowding situation at the Putnam County Justice Center. It starts with remodeling the old jail/clerk's office and making it a women's jail annex. The Herald Citizen has details

read more »

Are Cameras That Help Fight Crime Also Invading Privacy?

High-tech cameras that create a detailed picture of the whereabouts of cars, regardless of whether they are suspected of any link to criminal activity, are being used in Tennessee. This type of government surveillance is also raising privacy concerns across the country and is pushing police departments to consider how the cameras and records should be used. “I’m sure that there’s going to be people out there that say this is an invasion of privacy,” said Gallatin Detective James Kemp. But “the possibilities are endless there for solving crimes." The Tennessean has more

read more »

MTSU Murder Trial Begins, Self-Defense the Issue

Jury selection was to begin today in Chattanooga in the trial of Shanterrica Madden, accused of killing MTSU basketball guard Tina Stewart. Madden’s claim of self-defense comes at a time of intense national debate over what are known as Stand Your Ground self-defense laws, resulting from the fallout of the shooting death of Florida teen Trayvon Martin. MTSU Criminal Justice professor and Murfreesboro lawyer Lance Selva explains the law and the issues a jury will have to consider when deciding whether to believe a claim of self-defense. The Tennessean has the story

read more »

Self-Surrender Program for Misdemeanors This Week

Nashville residents who have failed to comply with the booking requirements of state misdemeanor citations and who are now named in arrest orders are about to be given a second chance. The Metropolitan Police Department, in association with the General Sessions Courts, District Attorney’s Office, Public Defender’s Office, Criminal Court Clerk and Davidson County Sheriff’s Office, will host a Failure to be Booked Self-Surrender Program this Friday and Saturday.

read more »

Legislature Wraps Up 107th Session

The 107th Tennessee General Assembly adjourned Tuesday – the earliest adjournment since 1998 – after a flurry of action in the final days. Legislation approved and sent to the governor included:

HB 2385/SB 2247, which overhauls the Tennessee Regulatory Authority. Read more from the Knoxville News Sentinel

SB 3597/HB 3576, which prohibits state colleges and private colleges receiving more than $24 million in state funds from imposing antidiscrimination policies on religious student groups. The bill, designed to address a situation at Vanderbilt University, was vetoed by Gov. Bill Haslam today. WATE.com has more

HB 2868/SB 3005, which expands state racketeering laws to include criminal gangs, and imposes additional jail time and fines of up to $250,000 for gang members. The Times Free Press reports

SB 1325/HB 1379, which requires proof of citizenship to get state services. Learn more in the Memphis Daily News

SB 2580/HB 2725, which requires drug testing for some welfare recipients. The Tennessean reports

HB 3234/SB 2908, which authorizes referendums on whether Shelby County’s suburbs may form municipal school districts. The Memphis Daily News has more

The legislature did not act on a contentious gun issue that would have allowed employees to store weapons in vehicles parked on company lots and failed to pass a measure that would have allowed Tennessee to join an interstate compact challenging the federal health care law

read more »

Rutherford Drug Court Wins Increased Funding

While other state programs and services saw funding cuts in the recently approved budget agreement, the Rutherford County Drug Court secured an additional $37,500 for its operations, for a total of $87,500. Officials who led the fight for the funding increase said this particular court is “setting the standard for intervention and treatment in Tennessee.” Read more in the Murfreesboro Post

read more »

Courts Recognized for Language Access Programs

The Tennessee Administrative Office of the Courts (AOC) recently received several awards from the Consortium for Language Access in the Courts for its efforts to eliminate language barriers for persons with limited English proficiency. Among the initiatives recognized were those providing remote interpreting services through Internet video conferencing, interpreter services in criminal cases for non-indigent defendants, and translation of order of protection forms into five languages. The AOC also was recognized for its successful legislative efforts to secure an additional $2 million in funding to cover interpreter services in all cases. The AOC reports

read more »

Court to Consider Retroactivity of Padilla Decision

The Supreme Court agreed today to consider the retroactivity of its 2010 decision finding that lawyers have a Sixth Amendment obligation to warn their clients when guilty pleas can result in deportation. At issue is whether the ruling in Padilla v. Kentucky applies to defendants whose convictions became final before the date of the opinion. According to the cert petition, “federal and state courts are openly and intractably divided” over whether the Padilla holding applies retroactively. Read more in the ABA Journal

read more »

Child-Porn Sentences Under Scrutiny

Child-pornography offenders are the focus of an intense debate as to whether the federal sentences they face have become too severe, the Associated Press reports. The U.S. Sentencing Commission plans to release a report this year that is likely to propose changes to the sentencing guidelines that it oversees. Some federal judges and public defenders say Congress has skewed the guidelines to the point where offenders who possess and distribute child pornography can go to prison for longer than those who actually rape or sexually abuse a child. Others oppose any push for leniency.

read more »

Former President Calls for Abolition of the Death Penalty

A recent poll showed that 61 percent of Americans would choose a punishment other than the death penalty for murder and just 1 percent of police chiefs think that expanding the death penalty would reduce violent crime, former President Jimmy Carter writes in the Atlanta Journal Constitution. He points out that 90 percent of all executions are carried out in China, Iran, Saudi Arabia and the United States, and that while Southern states carry out more than 80 percent of the U.S.'s executions they have a higher murder rate than any other region. "Our nation’s focus is now on punishment, not rehabilitation," he writes in the opinion piece, which calls to abolish the death penalty. Read his column

read more »

Grand Jury Praises Community Corrections, Makes Other Recommendations

The Hamilton County Grand Jury's recent report praised the county's community corrections program, saying its use of electronic monitoring is cost effective and its low rate of recidivism is remarkable. Among its many recommendations, the group suggests expanding community corrections for non-violent offenders, providing more work opportunities for inmates, increasing fees for jury service, and hiring truant officers to ensure kids are attending school. Read the full report on Chattanoogan.com

read more »

Connecticut Abolishes Death Penalty

Connecticut Gov. Dannel Malloy signed a bill into law Wednesday that abolishes the death penalty, making the state the 17th in the nation to abandon capital punishment, and the fifth to do so in the last five years. The law is effective immediately, though prospective in nature, meaning it will not apply to those already sentenced to death. It replaces the death penalty with life in prison without the possibility of release as the state's highest form of punishment. WCYB Channel 5 has the story from CNN.

read more »

Smith Asks Not to Hear DUI Cases

Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals Judge Jerry L. Smith requested yesterday that he not be assigned to any drunk driving cases until his own charges for driving under the influence are resolved. Presiding Judge Joseph M. Tipton agreed to the request. Smith was arrested Monday night in Knoxville after refusing a blood alcohol test. The Tennessean has more

read more »

Attorney Accused of Forging Judge's Signature

Hamilton County attorney Andrew Stinnett has been charged with forging Judge Howell People's signature on an order of protection for one of his clients. The client quotes Stinnett as saying, "I'm friends with Judge Peoples so we don't need to go back to court." When Peoples found out about the possible forgery, he contacted the district attorney, WDEF News Channel 12 reports. Stinnett is currently suspended for practicing law while suspended and not informing clients he was suspended. He will be back in court May 1 on the criminal charges.

read more »

No Automatic Action Against Judge Charged with DUI

A drunk driving charge filed Tuesday against Court of Criminal Appeals Judge Jerry Lynn Smith won't impact his ability to hear cases for now according to two state agencies. A spokeswoman with the state Administrative Office of the Courts said Tuesday "it's just too soon for us to comment" on Smith's arrest but "an arrest for a misdemeanor does not preclude a judge from hearing cases." Timothy Discenza, disciplinary counsel for the Court of the Judiciary, said no automatic sanctions are activated against Smith with his arrest and it is too early to speculate on what action the court might take. The News Sentinel has more

read more »

Opinion: Abu Ali's Defense Did Not Do Justice

Nashville lawyer Bradley MacLean writes on behalf of his client, Abu Ali Abdur’Rahman, who is on Tennessee's death row. Pointing out that his original counsel, Lionel Barrett, himself has acknowledged his part in Abu Ali's conviction because he conducted no investigation and failed to present key evidence in his defense, MacLean is working to have the sentence changed from death to life in prison. He says what may be the last appeal has now been filed with the U.S.Supreme Court. MacLean and the late William Redick took over Abu Ali’s case in 1996. Federal Judge Todd J. Campbell had set aside the death sentence, to be overturned by the Sixth Circuit. Sixth Circuit Judge R. Guy Cole Jr., in his dissenting opinion, wrote that the “sentence of death resulted from a breakdown in the adversary process that renders the result unreliable.” Read it in the Tennessean

read more »

Criminal Court of Appeals Judge Arrested

Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals Judge Jerry L. Smith is facing charges after he was arrested for driving under the influence in Knoxville. Smith, of Nashville, was arrested Monday night on Cumberland Avenue. WBIR reports

read more »