AG Announces Settlement with Anti-Competitive Pharma Business

Attorney General Herbert Slatery announced today that Tennessee, 48 other states and the District of Columbia have reached an agreement with Cephalon Inc. and affiliated companies, now a part of Teva Pharmaceutical Industries, following alleged anti-competitive conduct. The $125 million settlement concludes an investigation into a scheme by Cephalon to block generic competition to its sleep-disorder drug, Provigil. Cephalon prevented competition by filing patent infringement lawsuits against potential competitors, and then paid those competitors to delay the sale of their generic versions of the drug. In total, the states will receive $35 million for distribution to consumers who purchased Provigil. Tennessee and its consumers will receive an estimated $3.32 million.

read more »

ABA Annual Meeting Includes FBI Director, Marcia Clark as Speakers

The American Bar Association (ABA) annual meeting in San Francisco continues today. Offerings at the meeting include updates about the legal implications of electronic devices such as home security systems, cellphones and fitness trackers that collect and exchange data, and the Zika virus. Today, FBI Director James Comey was among experts who examined the use of emerging technology by criminals and terrorists to evade detection, and Marcia Clark, who was the lead prosecutor in the O.J. Simpson case, was on tap to discuss her new work of fiction.

read more »

ABA Meeting Opens, Includes Diversity Commission Findings

The American Bar Association kicks off its annual meeting today in San Francisco with topics to be explored including national security at the U.S. border and in the cyber realm, the impact of new voting laws on the upcoming fall elections and the integration of transgendered soldiers in the U.S. military. On Saturday, the ABA Diversity and Inclusion Commission, formed by outgoing ABA President Paulette Brown, will unveil the results of its work. The group spent months reviewing and analyzing the state of diversity and inclusion in the legal profession, the judicial system and the ABA, with the aim of formulating methods, policies, standards and practices to “move the needle” and advance diversity and inclusion. “The legal profession is the best, but we can do better," Brown said. "It can no longer be acceptable for us to be the least diverse of all comparable professions.” Learn more from the ABA's Diversity and Inclusion Portal.

read more »

ABA Asks Court to Limit ‘Laches Defense’ in Patent Cases

The ABA has filed an amicus brief urging the U.S. Supreme Court to apply a 2014 copyright ruling, which limited use of the “laches defense,” to patent cases. The doctrine of laches allows dismissal of suits that are unreasonably delayed. The ABA argues patent cases should not be subject to laches during the statutory six-year damages period, and that laches should be available only in the most extraordinary circumstances and to prevent injunctive and other prospective equitable relief. Neglecting to take this action will “continue to encourage rushed, premature filings, and discourage non-litigation resolutions such as settlement,” the brief argues. The ABA Journal has more on the issue.

read more »

Online IP Courses Now Available

Online programs offering insights into various aspects of intellectual property law are now available online. CLE sessions cover fair use defenses, Lanham Act updates, patent infringement and licensing updates, Tennessee’s statutory right of publicity, and international norms of intellectual property protection. Access courses at the links above.

read more »

Led Zeppelin Duo Prevails in Copyright Suit

A Los Angeles jury today found Led Zeppelin frontman Robert Plant and guitarist Jimmy Page not guilty of copyright infringement on perhaps their most famous song, "Stairway to Heaven," CNN reports. The case centered on claims that Led Zeppelin copied key note patterns in the first two minutes of their hit from a song by the 1960s psychedelic band, Spirit.

read more »

Court Still to Rule on Most Controversial Cases

The U.S. Supreme Court issued five decisions Monday, including rulings (1) upholding a patent review procedure known as inter partes review, which has been used by Apple and Google to invalidate patents; (2) directing lower courts in Alabama, Louisiana and Mississippi to re-examine three convictions for evidence of racial prejudice in jury selection; and (3) directing the U.S. Labor Department to do a better job of explaining why it is changing a longstanding policy on whether certain workers deserve overtime pay. With just one week left in the court’s current term, however, the most contentious cases still need to be resolved, including regulation of Texas abortion clinics, the use of race in college admissions, the legality of the president’s immigration executive orders, and the public corruption conviction of Virginia’s former governor. WKRN looks at the remaining cases.

read more »

Court Rules on Attorneys Fees in Copyright Suit

The U.S. Supreme Court yesterday revived a $2 million fee dispute for attorneys who argued for the winner in a 2013 copyright case over resold textbooks. The Justices unanimously agreed that that federal courts should examine a variety of factors in deciding whether to award fees to winners in copyright infringement cases and sent the case back to a lower court for a new ruling. Read more from The New York Times

read more »

Nashville Lawyer Files Copyright Suit Against Pop Star Ed Sheeran

Nashville attorney Richard Busch from the firm King and Ballow is representing two California songwriters who have filed a copyright lawsuit against pop star Ed Sheeran. The songwriters, Martin Harrington and Tom Leonard, claim Sheeran ripped off their song as the basis for his hit, “Photograph.” Busch has won many landmark music copyright cases in his career, including one on behalf of Marvin Gaye’s family against Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams over their song “Blurred Lines.” Read more from The Tennessean

read more »

Justin Bieber, Skrillex Face Nashville Copyright Suit

Pop stars Justin Bieber and Skrillex were sued in Nashville court this week for using without permission a vocal riff that singer-songwriter Casey Dienel said was hers, the Tennessean reports. Dienel, who performs under the name White Hinterland, said the Bieber and Skrillex song "Sorry" features a vocal riff in the same key and using the same notes as the riff in her song "Ring the Bell." Read more and listen to the two cuts.

read more »

Star Trek Copyright Suit Could Impact Software Developers

A copyright battle over of a 2014 short film’s use of Star Trek themes and Klingon – the language spoken by fictional humanoids – could impact legal disputes over programming languages. The Language Creation Society recently sided with the creators of Prelude to Axanar in an amicus brief, saying that if the language is copyrighted, then all ideas subsequently expressed in it could be too. Quartz explains how the lawsuit could impact software developers’ ability to copy codes and also outlines other cases where symbol copyrights are being debated. 

read more »

Redskins Seek Supreme Court Hearing in Trademark Case

The Washington Redskins filed a petition yesterday asking the U.S. supreme Court to to hear its case over its controversial trademark. The NFL team is asking for its case to be heard alongside The Slants, an Asian-American band, who wants to trademark their name. A federal appeals court ruled in favor of the band’s trademark attempt, but the government has asked the Supreme Court to overturn that ruling. The case challenges the same piece of U.S. law that the Redskins’ case does, CNN Money reports.  

read more »

Entertainment and Sports Forum Set for May 19

The TBA’s annual Entertainment & Sports Forum is planned for May 19, 12:30 – 4:45 p.m., at Belmont University College of Law, Baskin Center, 1900 Belmont Blvd. in Nashville. This year’s forum, titled “Nashville: The Intersection of Television, Fashion and Music,” is approved for four CLE credits. Topics include an inside perspective on the intellectual property issues for the TV show "Nashville,” and a discussion of the ethical challenges when using social media and online platforms to market your practice. Register by May 15 to avoid a late fee. 

read more »

Register Today for the 135th Annual TBA Convention

Join us on June 15-18 in Nashville for the 135th Annual Convention! Registration for the 2016 TBA Convention includes:

  • free access to all TBA CLE programming;
  • the Opening Reception;
  • the Bench Bar Programming and Luncheon;
  • Law School and general breakfasts;
  • the Lawyers Luncheon;
  • the Thursday evening Joint (TBA/TLAW/TABL) Reception;
  • the Thursday night dinner and entertainment at the George Jones Museum;
  • and the Friday night Dance Party.

read more »

Memphis Inventor Sues Carrier for 'Stealing His Ideas'

Steve Olita, a Memphis-area inventor, is suing Carrier Corp. for allegedly using his ideas in its Collierville factory without paying licensing fees, The Commercial Appeal reports. He says the air conditioner manufacturer worked with one of his former employees to copy his ideas to avoid paying. Olita also filed a separate lawsuit against former employees and other companies.

read more »

Mentors in Intellectual Property Needed

The TBA Mentoring Program is looking for volunteer mentors who practice intellectual property law in the Davidson County or Williamson County areas. Mentoring is the most effective way to pass along skills, knowledge and wisdom and it is critical to a new lawyer’s success. There are many new attorneys signed up for this program, but there is a shortage of mentors to match them with. 

To qualify as a mentor, you must have a minimum of eight years of experience with no formal BPR investigation pending or disciplinary action imposed in the last 10 years. For more information on the program, visit

If you’re interested in signing up, please contact Kate Prince at 615-277-3202.

read more »

Fastcase Will Face No Defense in Suit to Access State Laws

Casemaker agrees with Fastcase: state law is not copyrightable. Fastcase filed a federal suit against Casemaker after its parent company Lawriter demanded Fastcase take down Georgia Administrative Rules and Regulations from its platform. Lawriter has a contact with the state to publish the laws, but Casemaker CEO says the company will not defend the Fastcase suit. Read more from the ABA Journal.

read more »

Does monkey have standing to assert copyright in selfie photos? Judge is skeptical

Originally published in ABA Journal - January 7, 2016

By Debra Cassens Weiss

A federal judge in San Francisco hearing arguments on Wednesday appeared unlikely to find standing in a copyright suit filed on a behalf of a monkey who shot selfies published in a wildlife book.

U.S. District Judge William Orrick said during the hearing there was no indication the federal copyright law gave animals the right to sue, report the Recorder (sub. req.), Ars Technica and the Associated Press.

“While Congress and the president can extend the protection of law to animals as well as humans,” Orrick said during the hearing, “there is no indication that they did so in the Copyright Act.”

People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) had sued on behalf of the crested macaque named Naruto, the monkey believed to have snapped selfies with a photographer’s unattended camera. The photographer, David Slater, obtained a British copyright and published the photos in a book by his company Blurb.

PETA says proceeds from the photo should benefit Naruto. The photos have also been published by Wikimedia, which contends works from nonhuman sources aren’t covered by copyright unless a human makes substantial changes.

Orrick said he didn’t believe PETA could establish standing to sue, but he would likely give PETA a chance to file an amended complaint, according to the coverage by the Recorder.

One of the monkey's selfies from Wikimedia Commons.

read more »

Tennessee Fashion Law: Protecting Brands and More

The TBA will offer a first-of-its-kind Tennessee Fashion Law CLE on March 31 at the Tennessee Bar Center in Nashville. Topics include protecting fashion brands through copyright, regulations that govern merchandize labeling and disclosure, and employment issues unique to fashion law. The course, scheduled from 1 to 4:15 p.m., is approved for three CLE credits.

read more »

City of Rocky Top Settles with Copyright Holders

The city of Rocky Top settled its lawsuit with House of Bryant Publications, the copyright holders of the popular bluegrass tune with the same name. The company sued the city in 2013 in an effort to prevent the name change. The city is now allowed to sell trademarked items, as long as money raised goes to the city. The Associated Press reports a separate settlement with the development group that proposed the tourist complex, Rocky Top Tennessee Marketing and Manufacturing, is still under negotiation.

read more »

Court Ruling Could Help Redskins in Trademark Case

A U.S. Court of Appeals ruling that says the government cannot reject trademarks it deems offensive to others could help the Washington Redskins defend the team's own trademark protections. The Federal Circuit court’s ruling comes in a case involving an American-Asian band, The Slants, whose application to trademark its name was rejected by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. The court said banning offensive trademarks violates the First Amendment. The Redskins are currently appealing the government’s pending withdrawal of its trademark protection. Read more from The Washington Post.

read more »

Rutherford Clerk's Office Owes More Than $175k in Penalties

A state audit revealed the Rutherford County Circuit Court Clerk’s office faces $175,135 in penalties and interest because of software problems, the Daily News Journal reports. Circuit Court Clerk Melissa Harrell blamed the penalties on former Circuit Court Clerk Laura Bohling. "Prior to my election to the position of Circuit Court Clerk in August 2014, the previous court clerk had been working for close to two years to implement a new software system that, in the end, cost the taxpayers of Rutherford County close to $1 million in equipment, labor and overhead costs," Harrell said. The audit also noted  "discrepancies in operations at the Rutherford County Sheriff's Department are currently being investigated."

read more »

Nashville Artist Fights Beside Attorneys for Higher Royalty Rates

George Johnson, a Nashville singer-songwriter and non-attorney, has gained attention for standing toe-to-toe with attorneys in a case that will determine new royalty rates for record labels, artists and popular internet music services. Artists and record labels are asking the Copyright Royalty Board to set the rate for non-interactive music at $.0025 cents per stream, compared to rate proposals from the service providers starting at $.0005 per stream. Johnson, the only artist representing in the rate-setting hearing, says artists and labels should be paid a licensing fee of between 10 cents and $1 for each song. Read more from The Tennessean.

read more »

Consumers More Vulnerable to Cybercrime, Norton Says

A new report released by Norton, a cybersecurity company, reveals in the 12 months to September, more than 348 million identities were exposed as a result of data breaches. Norton says consumers globally spent $150 billion in the past year dealing with the issues related to cybercrime. Read more from the Wall Street Journal’s Law Blog.

New State Logo Gets Trademark Approval

Gov. Bill Haslam’s new state logo, which has received criticism for its simple design and high cost, has received approval from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, Humphrey on the Hill reports. The patent office originally denied the trademark application on the basis that it was primarily a geographic description. The Haslam administration changed the name of the application to the executive branch of Tennessee state government, which satisfied the examiners.

read more »