News

Reminder: Supreme Court Historical Society Event Friday

The Tennessee Supreme Court Historical Society will hold a cocktail reception this Friday at The Cordelle in Nashville. The event will honor retired Justice William Koch and welcome the newest members of the court. Tickets are $100 and can be purchased on the society’s website or through Linda Knight, (615) 244-4994. The Cordelle is located at 45 Lindsley Ave., Nashville 37210. Download the invitation.

read more »

Retention Election Spending Topped $2.4 Million

Opposing sides in the state's Supreme Court election battle spent a record-shattering $2.4 million, a final tally of expenditures reveals. Justices Connie Clark, Sharon Lee and Gary Wade collectively spent $1.13 million to win another eight years on the bench, while Tennesseans for Fair Courts spent $345,000 to back them, the Chattanooga Times Free Press reports. On the “no” side, the Tennessee Forum spent nearly $718,000 to defeat the justices, $605,000 of which came from Lt. Gov. Ron Ramsey's PAC. The Republican State Leadership Committee also reported giving money to Tennessee Forum and spent another $196,865 itself. The Tennessee chapter of Americans for Prosperity spent money on radio ads criticizing the justices, but since the ads did not call on voters to retain or reject the justices, the expenditures were not subject to reporting rules.

read more »

Bell Working on Plans in Case Amendment 2 Fails

State Sen. Mike Bell, R-Riceville, said today that he is working on a legislative contingency plan for how appellate judges are selected in the event that voters reject Amendment 2 in the upcoming election, Chattanoogan.com reports. Bell said he is considering a range of ideas including non-partisan elections and the approval of judges by district rather than statewide election. “I am looking over several proposals to see what would be the best fit for Tennessee.” Bell also said that if Amendment 2 is rejected he would file legislation as soon as possible after the election to give lawmakers time to review it before the General Assembly convenes in January. 

read more »

Court of Appeals Judge Sworn In

The Hon. Brandon Gibson was sworn in yesterday as the newest judge on the Tennessee Court of Appeals, Western Section. Gibson was appointed by Gov. Bill Haslam in December to replace Judge David R. Farmer, who retired in August. Gibson’s husband held the Bible as Gov. Haslam administered the oath of office during ceremonies at the Madison County Courthouse Chancery Courtroom. The Tennessee has more.

read more »

Opinion: Ruling Gives Police Too Much Control Over Information

“The Tennessee Court of Appeals in Nashville...kicked the can farther down the wrong road when it expanded police powers so they could keep just about anything and everything they want secret from citizens,” Deborah Fisher writes in the Tennessean. Fisher, who is executive director of the Tennessee Coalition for Open Government, says the court’s ruling last Tuesday allows law enforcement to keep information confidential if it is relevant to an ongoing investigation. That broad protection, Fisher says, can be used to protect anything. The decision came in a case brought by the Tennessean and a media coalition seeking to access records related to four former Vanderbilt University football players awaiting trial for rape.

read more »

U.S. Supreme Court Lets Gay Marriage Rulings Stand

The U.S. Supreme Court today unexpectedly cleared the way for a dramatic expansion of gay marriage in the United States, the Associated Press reports. In declining to hear appeals from five states seeking to preserve bans on gay marriage, the court effectively made those marriages legal in Wisconsin, Indiana, Oklahoma, Utah and Virginia. Couples in six other states should be able to get married in short order as well since those states are covered by the same appellate rulings. Though today’s decision certainly was a boost to the gay marriage movement, the issue is far from settled. Challenges are still pending in 20 states and one appeals court may be poised to rule in favor of state bans, which would set up the first split among the circuits. Nashville lawyer Bill Harbison, who represents plaintiffs in a case from Tennessee pending in the Sixth Circuit, said he expects the Supreme Court to take up the case if the appeals court becomes the first to uphold a state ban. “Obviously we don’t know how the [Sixth] Circuit will rule, but indicators are that the Supreme Court would take a case if it went the other way,” Harbison said in an interview with Knoxnews.

read more »

Register by Oct. 27 for 2014 TBA Academy

If admission to practice before the U.S. Supreme Court is one of your career goals, don’t miss the opportunity to make it a reality during the 31st Annual TBA Academy, Dec. 2-3, in Washington, D.C. A select group of Tennessee attorneys will be able to take part in a private ceremony before the court and enjoy other events in the nation's capital. A reception and celebration dinner kick off the Academy, which also includes the opportunity to earn three hours of CLE credit. The group will stay at the Hay Adams Hotel, located across from the White House. Interested candidates should complete the required forms by Oct. 27. For information and a step-by-step guide on how to sign up, visit the TBA website.

read more »

Retired Chief Justice Reid Honored at Portrait Unveiling

Family, friends and current and retired judges gathered at the Supreme Court Building in Jackson last week to honor retired Supreme Court Chief Justice Lyle Reid. The event featured the unveiling of Reid's portrait and included remarks from current Chief Justice Sharon G. Lee; retired Chief Justice Frank F. Drowota; Brownsville lawyer Larry Banks; and Nashville lawyer Charles W. Bone. Reid began practicing law in Brownsville in 1957. His long and distinguished career also included service as assistant state attorney general, deputy commissioner of commerce and insurance, member of the state House of Representatives and judge on the Court of Criminal Appeals. He was elected to the Tennessee Supreme Court in 1990 and served there for eight years. He now practices law in Covington. The AOC has more on his life.

read more »

Court Seeks Comments on Rule Change Package

The Tennessee Supreme Court has published the annual package of recommendations from the Advisory Commission on Rules of Procedure and Evidence. Proposals include new authority for appellate courts to suspend rules; requirements for electronic copies of transcripts; specification of the color of application responses and amici in TRAP 9 and 11 matters; and refinement of criminal contempt provisions. Four TBA sections — Appellate Practice, Litigation, Tort and Insurance Law, and Criminal Justice — will review the recommendations and propose comments on behalf of the association. Comments on the proposals are due Nov. 27.

read more »

Supreme Court Historical Society Event Set for Oct. 17

The Tennessee Supreme Court Historical Society will hold a cocktail reception Oct. 17 at The Cordelle in Nashville. The event will honor retired Justice William Koch and welcome the newest members of the court. Tickets are $100 and can be purchased on the society’s website or through Linda Knight, (615) 244-4994. The Cordelle is located at 45 Lindsley Ave., Nashville 37210. Download the invitation.

read more »

Appeals Court Upholds Christian-Newsom Torture-Slaying Sentence

A state appeals court has upheld the conviction and sentence of Letalvis Cobbins, one of the men convicted of participating in the kidnapping, torture and killing of Knoxville couple Channon Christian and Chris Newsom in 2007. Cobbins claimed his trial was tainted by the drug use and misconduct of former Knoxville Criminal Court Judge Richard Baumgartner, who resigned from the bench and pleaded guilty to official misconduct in March 2011. A three-judge panel of the Court of Criminal Appeals found that the Tennessee Supreme Court already ruled that Baumgartner's conduct outside the courtroom did not prevent Cobbins from receiving a fair trial. The Chattanooga Times Free Press has more.

read more »

Ohio Judge Named Chief of 6th Circuit Appeals Court

Ohio-based Judge R. Guy Cole Jr. has been tapped as the new chief judge of the U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals. In his new position Cole will oversee the administrative responsibilities of the Cincinnati-based court. Prior to his nomination to the court, Cole worked as a litigator at the U.S. Department of Justice, as a law firm partner and as a bankruptcy judge. For years, he also taught courses on habeas and the 14th amendment at Ohio State University’s Moritz College of Law. WDEF News 12 has the story.

read more »

Slatery Named New Tennessee AG

Herbert Slatery has been unanimously selected the new Tennessee Attorney General by the state Supreme Court. Slatery is currently chief legal counsel to Gov. Bill Haslam. Prior to that appointment, he was in private practice in Knoxville with Egerton, McAfee, Armistead & Davis PC for 30 years. A Knoxville native, Slatery earned his bachelor's degree from the University of Virginia and law degree from the University of Tennessee. The Nashville Post reports Slatery said he was humbled and "profoundly grateful" for the apppointment and promised "no quick wholesale changes" to the office. Soon after the announcement current Attorney General Robert Cooper released a statement congratulating his successor and expressing his gratitude to those who served with him.

read more »

Ramsey Cites Favorites for AG, Comments on Election

Lt. Gov. Ron Ramsey says he is monitoring the attorney general selection process and has talked to three of the candidates – Republicans Doug Overbey, Herbert Slatery and Bill Young. “Between those three … I don’t have a favorite. I hope [the justices] just choose the most qualified one.” Speaking to The Nashville Scene and other reporters for the first time since his unsuccessful campaign to unseat three of the state’s Supreme Court justices, Ramsey praised the court for holding an open hearing of the candidates, but was critical that the final decision is going to be made “behind closed doors.” Ramsey also talked about the judicial selection vote, saying, “The people spoke. That’s what it’s all about. Their message that we don’t want partisan politics in the judiciary won out, even though I do think that’s almost comical because I do believe there’s partisan politics in the judiciary.”

read more »

Chief Justice Lee Investiture Sept. 17

Tennessee Supreme Court Justice Sharon G. Lee will be formally installed as chief justice of the court at a ceremony in Knoxville next Wednesday. The investiture will take place at 1 p.m. EDT in the Historic Post Office Building located at 505 Main St. Gov. Bill Haslam will administer the oath. A reception will follow. Justice Lee was appointed to the Supreme Court in 2008 by then Gov. Phil Bredesen. She will be the third woman to serve as chief justice. Download a press release with more details from the AOC.

read more »

Appeals Court Reinstates Defamation Suit Against Campfield

The Tennessee Court of Appeals reinstated a defamation lawsuit against Republican state Sen. Stacey Campfield yesterday, finding that the lower court erred in throwing out the $750,000 lawsuit filed by former Roger Byrge, a Democratic candidate for the state House in 2008. The appellate panel also found that the facts of the case might justify a finding of “actual malice” by Campfield, the Johnson City Press reports. The case stems from a blog post Campfield wrote claiming that Byrge had multiple drug arrests and that the mug shots were “gold.” It was later determined the arrest record belonged to Byrge’s son. Campfield was defeated in the Republican primary last month but his term does not end until after the general election in November.

read more »

Kirby Installation Ceremony Set for Next Week

The investiture ceremony installing Justice Holly Kirby as the newest member of the Tennessee Supreme Court will take place Sept. 19 from 10:15 to 11:15 a.m. in the historic courtroom of the University of Memphis School of Law. The school is located at One North Front St. Parking is available in Brinkley Plaza Parking Garage, 20 S. Front St., and Republic Parking Garage, 35 Monroe Ave. Seating in the courtroom, which is located on the third floor, is limited but overflow seating and live streaming will be provided in the Wade Auditorium and on the first floor. A reception following the ceremony will take place on the first floor. For questions, contact Laura Deakins, (901) 685-3951.

read more »

Law Prof: Justices Shouldn't Believe Everything in Briefs

U.S. Supreme Court justices are increasingly citing in their opinions facts contained within friend-of-the-court briefs — a perilous trend, law professor Allison Orr Larson from the College of William and Mary says in a recent New York Times article. Some amicus briefs are careful and valuable, citing peer-reviewed studies and noting contrary evidence, while others cite more questionable materials. Some “studies” presented in amicus briefs were paid for or conducted by the group that submitted the brief and published only on the Internet. Others seem to have been created for the purpose of influencing the court. Over the five terms from 2008 to 2013, the court’s opinions cited factual assertions from amicus briefs 124 times, Larsen found. The trend is at odds with the ordinary role of appellate courts, which are not supposed to be in the business of determining facts. That is the job of the trial court, where evidence is submitted, sifted and subjected to the adversary process, the article notes.

read more »

Justice Holder Retires, But Not Slowing Down

Tennessee Supreme Court Justice Janice Holder retired Aug. 31, but she isn't stopping or even slowing down. Read about her life as a lawyer, judge and justice, and what she plans to do now. Spoiler alert: It involves scuba, traveling, golfing, skeet shooting, welding, driving her 1964 red Corvair -- and staying involved in access-to-justice issues. Read the story in the September Tennessee Bar Journal. See the Corvair online, with more pictures in the print edition.

read more »

TBA Co-Hosting Reception for 3 Jackson Judges

The TBA is joining with the Jackson Madison County Bar Association, the Anne Schneider Chapter of the Lawyers’ Association for Women and Memphis Association of Women Attorneys to host a reception for three appellate judges on Aug. 21 in Jackson. The event will honor Court of Appeals Judge Holly M. Kirby, who will step down from the court to take a seat on the Tennessee Supreme Court, as well as Judges Judge David R. Farmer and Alan E. Highers, who are retiring from the court at the end of August. The event will run from 4:30 to 6:30 p.m. at the Jackson Country Club, 31 Jackson Country Club Dr. For more information or questions contact Brandon Gibson with Pentecost & Glenn at (731) 668-5995.

read more »

Governor to Swear In New Appellate Judge in Kingsport

Gov. Bill Haslam on Wednesday will give the oath of office to Judge Robert H. Montgomery Jr., who was appointed to the Court of Criminal Appeals Eastern Section last August. Montgomery, currently the Criminal Court Judge in Sullivan County, will replace Judge Joseph M. Tipton, who is retiring. The Investiture Ceremony will be held at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday at the Kingsport Renaissance Center Theater, 1200 East Center Street in Kingsport. A reception will follow. Call (423) 279-2732 for more information.

read more »

Process to Select AG Now Open; Cooper Wants 2nd Term

The Tennessee Supreme Court today announced the application process for filling the position of state Attorney General and Reporter for the next eight years. Candidates should complete and submit an application and other required materials by noon Central Time on Aug. 29. The court will consider all qualified candidates and notify those who will continue in the selection process, which will include a public hearing in Nashville.The current Attorney General, Robert Cooper, said today he would seek a second term in office. In announcing his intentions Cooper said, “Tennesseans sent a clear message last week that they want an independent, nonpartisan judicial branch. That is how I have run the Attorney General’s office over the last eight years, and I am proud of our many accomplishments.” The Tennessean has more.

read more »

TBA Co-Hosting Reception for 3 Jackson Judges

The TBA is joining with the Jackson Madison County Bar Association, the Anne Schneider Chapter of the Lawyers’ Association for Women and Memphis Association of Women Attorneys to host a reception for three appellate judges on Aug. 21 in Jackson. The event will honor Court of Appeals Judge Holly M. Kirby, who will step down from the court to take a seat on the Tennessee Supreme Court, as well as Judges Judge David R. Farmer and Alan E. Highers, who are retiring from the court at the end of August. The event will run from 4:30 to 6:30 p.m. at the Jackson Country Club, 31 Jackson Country Club Dr. For more information or questions contact Brandon Gibson with Pentecost & Glenn at (731) 668-5995.

read more »

Federal Judge Rules California Death Penalty Unconstitutional

U.S. District Judge Cormac J. Carney ruled yesterday that California’s death penalty violates the U.S. Constitution’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment, the LA Times reports. Carney called the California death penalty system “dysfunctional," with the result being an inordinate and unpredictable period of delay preceding an actual execution.

read more »

Justice Bivins Sworn in as Newest Member of Supreme Court

Judge Jeffrey Bivins was installed as the newest member of the Tennessee Supreme Court today (July 16) at the Franklin Theatre in downtown Franklin. Gov. Bill Haslam performed the swearing in. Photos by Allan Ramsaur.

Bivins Investiture

Judge Jeffrey Bivins is sworn in by Gov. Bill Haslam during ceremonies in Franklin.

read more »