WPCz VOqNY4$e%h !jjظ(Z6<⯱Co 8$|$4{W!^H{ Ί3ǾCXe\sU;1zL6͈`ŕURp3O 4Ւ9y%>)}HqAQk7:ڐNMs 0@ѻeøC:Ӕc|{o(p@%&nq͐P^l0ۀ1M]*Rg [6 c1EdzD%[FZ:I ,ߝj *NtKV9."ct7s :Cn6\7.K{dͽP- RRX|} NUYi02[yS| ƯZƔE ~)w/M6ӶMb@r0ݰkZc|IkG¿cPekrsQUBF %  n 04K 4 P w@ # UFB #  N  m U:  U: BAAAAA D3^^^ 0D AO$$ 0D D/. B]<6X9`(*Courier 12pt10cpiX3|x <6X9`(*Courier 12pt10cpiXXx6X@JQX@( T$  ӢRC&  ShelbyMcMURRAYHodges Toof P D a U  Ӏ XTXXX.XXT   Ad FILED.   March11,1999  CecilCrowson,Jr.HAppellateCourt  Clerk <09Z .Courier New RegularHP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nLU,cAZ"Arial Regular XTXXX.XXT   Ad FILED.   March10,1999  CecilCrowson,Jr.HAppellateCourt  Clerk ,cAZ"Arial Regular d%%%%'dxd(3$ !  -C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5($$   1  ' dxdP Pd T!    _ `    7RDXXdXXd7TR[A'Legal3'A' Legal3'T  r *<,(j 8 `@E tt0"Hrr*<,(j 8 `@E tt0"Hr@LLINTHECOURTOFAPPEALS@@$  М    `     h  ATKNOXVILLE̜  JERRYHUGHESand@*@@*)     NANCYHUGHES    h   )    @*)  PlaintiffsAppellants@*) ( x @*)  v.@*)  LOUDONCOUNTY    @*)  03A019804CV00145    МLUMBERMENSMUTUAL@*) H   CASUALTYCOMPANY,INC.@*) `  Ѐ@*)  LOUDONCOUNTY (    InterveningPlaintiff@*)  03A019804CV00145 x    @*)   h    v.@*) 0  @*)̜BRIDGESTONE/FIRESTONE,INC.@*)  М@*)̜  DefendantAppellee@*) P     ̜@ OPINIONCONCURRINGINPART@@88)AND p @!DISSENTINGINPART@@* 8  XvXXX#XRDXX Xv#   ` Iconcurinthemajorityopinionastoallofthe .~ issuesraisedsavetheoneaddressingpunitivedamages.   ` UponviewingtheproofinalightmostfavorabletothePlaintiffsandindulgingallreasonableinferencesintheirfavor,Icannotfindatthetimethemotionforadirectedverdictastopunitivedamageswasmadeandsustainedthistobe themostegregiousofcasesorthatanyintentional,fraudulent,maliciousorrecklessconductbytheDefendanthasbeenshownbyclearandconvincingevidence.Hodgesv.S.C.Toof >*%0 &Co.,833S.W.2d896(Tenn.1992). +'2    `     h   _______________________________   `     h   HoustonM.Goddard,P.J.