WPC J.;㱽,C-٧~,@ H?afԏ^ .9eD%` >2,lъ'DH4JV7b.G~*%{{j{xWռذSflžgfvho:]:b+(HO{_Z%K%)2"Y\$ť__$Rr];x4B:U,<6%Hz ](~tv@{"`DYs \5t} M戙8WPйkgNRDpBG% Tµ8딋,VLQ Sz 3-Mj,i@&wTH0j(a>K9o2='δqpRV؉_ 9pxRLY.dZglV0% "1 gap>ӓ6NZR.ggiW4N~sfʭ9 7Ϫl/Ѽ1[b %\^ b 0nUNwD4H\ zk m  #  _ %  N^ 0D`UNEb 0 B 0 D3 D- 0K ASS 0l 0D ATۤ+s (`$.8dd8    ("  Z6Times New Roman Regular^p+hv̕t3|x C:\PROGRA~1\COREL\WORDPE~1\TEMPLATE\CUSTOM~1\REVISE~1.WPTC:\Program Files\Corel\WordPerfect Office 2000\Template\Custom WP Templates\revised standard opinion.wptU HP LaserJet 8000 Series PS0Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5  R$      1  Q   _ ` Q.Okay.AtanytimefromthetimethatyoumixedthecompoundandputthetrayinMs.Greenes  mouthwasthereanyindicationofanydifficulty,anygaggingorcoughingoranythingofthatnature? t    ` A.Yeah,shedidsomegaggingattheverybeginningwhenIplacedthetray. L    ` Q.Atthebeginning.Okay.Didshesayanything?     ` A.Itsverydifficulttotalkwiththattrayinyourmouth.No.  \    ` Q.Didyougettheimpressionshewastryingtosayanything?       ` A.Igottheimpressionshewastryingtoexplaintomethatshewasgagging,yes.(#$  0  (I Z6Times New Roman Regular- -(|G2$ !.8<d XXd8         0  w0 d(|3H$ !.8<d XXd8     VVVV'dxd)!dxdx( $ Figure  1  ^_X`YE<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(|3H$ !.8<d XXd8     ($$   1  X[Z&OLE 2.0 Box <=8C HKKKK !.8 d d8     _  i8dXXdd 8  @ iINTHECOURTOFAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @WW$ATKNOXVILLE#i #Ԉ &   August29,2001Session L XZXi #iXXZ#LINDAF.GREENEv.DR.WOODYSTINSON,D.D.S.XZXi  J @@ AppealfromtheCircuitCourtforJeffersonCounty  J @@No.16,369IWilliamM.Dender,Judge  6 FILEDDECEMBER3,2001    @@*AV) ` dE<` A   @@TTNo.E200100628COAR3CV   AV) ` dE<|` A }     HoustonM.Goddard,P.J.,Dissenting d     Irespectfullydissentfromthemajorityopinion,believingthatthereissufficientevidence, (x whenviewedunderthestandardweapplyastosummaryjudgments,tofindthattakingthe d strongestlegitimateviewoftheplaintiffsproofandindulgingallfavorablereasonableinferences P tobedrawntherefromthereismaterialevidencetoshowthatDr.Stinsonkneworshouldhave < known#iXXZl#XZXithatMs.Greeneswallowedtheimpressionsubstance. (   IsaythisbecauseMs.GreenetestifiedshetoldDr.Stinsonthatshehadswallowedthe  substance.Havingsaidthis,Irecognizeshevolunteeredthatshedidnotknowwhetherheheardher  ornot,but,ofcourse,shecouldnotknowwhatheheard.Hedidtestifythatshetriedtotellhim  somethingbuthecouldnotunderstandbecauseofthetraywhichwasinhermouth. #  1      ׀ t   Additionally,theproofshowsthatMs.Greenwasweepingwhenthedoctorcamebackinto L  theroom,asshownbythefollowingtestimonyinherdiscoverydeposition: 8!   #`"  Q.Allright.LetsmovetoNovember13,97.Thatwasthelastdatethat  yousawDr.Stinson.Takemethroughinasmuchdetailasyoucanremember  everythingthatoccurredonthatparticularvisit,justtakeitfromthetimeyou  walkedinthedoor. t  A.Myappointmentwasat1:30.Iwalkedinaround1:15andIdsayit L  wasaboutbetween30and40minutesandtheycalledmeback.Hewentahead 8  andnumbedme.AndIdontknowwhatallwenton.Hewasrunningfromroom $ t toroomwithalltheseotherpatientsinbetweenme.AndIknowhestarted  ` grindingonmyteethandIdontknowhowlongthattook.Andheleftagain,  L  camebackin,numbedmeagain,leftagain.Ordonesomething.Hestucka  8  needleinmyteeth.Iguessthatswhathewasdoing.AndIbelievehestarted $  grindingonmyteethagain.    Thenhedonetheimpressionandthatswhenthatstuffwentdownmy   throat.See,heevidentlyoverfilledthetray.Itdidnthavenowhereelsetogo.   Iwascrying.Thenursewasholding!orhishelperwasholdingitinmymouth p whilehewenttoanotherofficewithanotherpatient.Andhecamebackin.Iwas \ gaggingrealloudandshesaid Dontmoveorwellhavetodoitover.There H wasntnowhereelseforittogo. 4  Itoldhimwhenhecamebackin,Isaid!becauseIwascrying.Isaid A  \ bigbunchofthatstuffwentdownmythroat.AndIdontknowifheheardme H orwhat,buthedidntsayanything.Ithought,well,maybeitwontkillmeto 4 myself.AndIlefthisofficeat7:30thatnightwiththatstuffinmystomach.     Inlightofthefactthatshehadgaggedandwascrying,evenifthedoctorhadnotheardwhat  shesaid(hetestifiedthatshesaidsomethingwhichhecouldnotunderstand),Iconcludethatitwas  incumbentuponhimtomakeinquiryastothecauseofherdistress.    Iaccordinglywouldvacatethesummaryjudgmentandremandthecasefortrial. X     `     h   _________________________________________ $D #    `     h   HOUSTONM.GODDARD,PRESIDINGJUDGE#iXXZ#XZXi %0!$ #iXXZ#XZXi#iXXZ#