WPCh ,&p0g&W~AߓbFAGg#ɓ. %a㤅u$k8`~A,rA{--|@ArL ȡ8*3 DÌ"z[]Ԍ-$w%64_t.4Ƨ0 &ގ&9 _tbˀˤ20fwiE6ժG[x9-TbO*AGG1Ar5bm\r ER"n" Sk\9r$H%;IV=~TۍPXE" O(x~sD4#2eE.D^D!DB9.lJa; xtSC#=&b9  )®M]QՏ$'^-XudX_AR+XgNTxI6a{Nn|~f;WԖDUy%&4\k4]+1^UU BF %  n 04K 4 0 w@ U> UFA #  N  m  0x} 0D9 UB!^?U:U: D3/// 0Dbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb B AO 0D D/ BK<6X9`(*Courier 12pt10cpiX3|x`<6X9`(*Courier 12pt10cpiXXx6X@JQX@( T$  h&  ShelbyMcMURRAY JKELMDNOPQRӀ^<( 9Z &Courier Regular<09Z .Courier New RegularHP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nLU  $      1    XX ` SubsequenttotheChancellorsgrantofsummaryjudgment,theco `  TrusteesquitclaimedthepropertyinquestiontoJohnS.Poindexter,III,andhissister,MargaretPoindexterVarner,whoarethebeneficiariesofthetrust.UponmotionoftheStrangsandorderentered,bothweremadepartiestothissuit.(((3$ T!       0  (#$  0    $      1    XX ` SubsequenttotheChancellorsgrantofsummaryjudgment,theCo `  TrusteesquitclaimedthepropertyinquestiontoJohnS.Poindexter,III,andhissister,MargaretPoindexterVarner,whoarethebeneficiariesofthetrust.UponmotionoftheStrangsandorderentered,bothweremadepartiestothissuit.  $      1    XX ` SubsequenttotheChancellorsgrantofsummaryjudgment,theco `  TrusteesquitclaimedthepropertyinquestiontoJohnS.Poindexter,III,andhissister,MargaretPoindexterVarner,whoarethebeneficiariesofthetrust.UponmotionoftheStrangsandorderentered,bothweremadepartiestothissuit.<6X9`(*Courier 12pt10cpi XXXXXX   Ad FILED   June25,1999  CecilCrowson,Jr.AppellateCourt  Clerk  T $      2    XX ` ItshouldbenotedthatnotwithstandingtheStrangsinsistence `  thattherearedisputedissuesofmaterialfact,underthethirdissuetheycontendthattheyareentitledtoasummaryjudgment.,cAZ"Arial Regular XXXXXX   Ad FILED   June24,1999  CecilCrowson,Jr.AppellateCourt  Clerk ,cAZ"Arial Regular>>>>'dxd(3$ !   d-C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5($$   1  ' dxdP Pd T!   RR_`   7XXdXXd7TR[A'Legal3'A' Legal3'T  ^Rr*<,(j 8 `@Ef  tt0"H` rR^^r*<,(j 8 `@Ef  tt0"H` r^RR@LLINTHECOURTOFAPPEALS@@$ `  @$ATKNOXVILLEJOHNS.POINDEXTER,III,and@*@@*)  HAMILTONCOUNTY x  x TRUSTCOMPANYOFGEORGIABANK  )  03A019810CH00323 @ OFSAVANNAH,N.A.,CoTrustees@*) h  oftheTrustUnderAgreement  @*) 0  withJOHNS.POINDEXTER,JR.@*)   @*)  HON.HOWELLN.PEOPLES, `    PlaintiffsAppellees@*)  CHANCELLOR (  @*)  v.@*)   Ѐ@*)     JAMESM.STRANG,JR.,and@*) H  wifeCHERYLSTRANG@*) p @*)  DefendantsAppellants@*)  AFFIRMEDANDREMANDED  BARRYL.ABBOTTandLEEDAVISOFCHATTANOOGAFORAPPELLANTSSCOTTN.BROWN,JR.,OFCHATTANOOGAFORAPPELLEES XXXX@$OPINION (#!    `     h      p   #XXX X# XXXXGoddard,P.J. '&    ` ThisisasuitfordeclaratoryjudgmentwhereinJohnS.Poindexter,III,andTrustCompanyofGeorgia#XXX X#ԀBankofSavannah, ,", N.A.,CoTrusteesofatrustestablishedbyJohnS.Poindexter,Jr.,seekadeterminationthatcertainrealestateheldbythemintrustwasnotencumberedbyarightoffirstrefusal,asinsistedbytheDefendants,JamesM.Strang,Jr.,andhiswifeCherylStrang.  50,8    ` TheTrialCourtgrantedasummaryjudgmentPPPP #  1      כinfavorof `   thePlaintiffs,resultinginthisappealwhereintheDefendantsraisefiveseparateissueswhichmaybesummarizedasfollows:1.  TheTrialJudgeimproperlygrantedsummaryjudgmentbecause @ hedidnotapplytheappropriatestandardinevaluatingthePlaintiffsmotionandtherearedisputedissuesofmaterialfact.@ #  2      כ P  2.  TheTrialCourtshouldhaveheldthatthePlaintiffswere   estoppedfromdenyingtheDefendantsrightoffirstrefusal,andinrefusingtheDefendantstherighttopurchasetheproperty.3.  TheTrialCourtshouldhavegrantedtheDefendantsmotion 0 forsummaryjudgment.   ` TheTrialJudgeenteredanexcellentmemorandumopinionregardingtheissuesraised.MI(IMN(NKJseeJKLSeeAppendix.)OLurreviewoftherecordOandthebriefsofthepartiesOpersuadesusthathecorrectlystatedtheQundisputedQmaterialfactsandcorrectlyappliedtheprevailinglaw.WeaccordinglyadopthismemorandumopinionastheopinionofthisCourt.   ` FortheforegoingreasonsthejudgmentoftheTrialCourtisaffirmedandthecauseremandedforcollectionofcostsbelow.CostsofappealareadjudgedagainsttheStrangsandtheirsurety. p0'2    `     h   _______________________________   `     h   HoustonM.Goddard,P.J.CONCUR:________________________________HerschelP.Franks,J.________________________________CharlesD.Susano,Jr.,J.PP