WPC5 4 ix%?*>4KzQ$-\ȠA{:cl3h]9rX ȏ]z<;VH"QyҶ]ey?4NwF[<[)0J\4`9p#V]W dKp6:55yyK_ jjr9~x| jr]r)iX*zW (2H@gf?Uo4BYan[/,өs)Vm녇q,$>dMf]ThB.\i!&e0"B""ǟ\JLtj5Z\WMA(=ojgy.! U0XS̝~q^B_4H[4 (P.1L_uK/dw db PՄl8k\W* {]TÅS 3Bj07"X1j<-ra ]h^Ƞ73]g*# LU NW % 0UNw@44H1W B 0? 0D `(   U: AQ$ 0D 0D. 0Drr D/ B D3HP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nLl(hH  Z 6Times New Roman RegularX(3c$7|XXdXXd7  HTXXTR[A' Legal[A' LegalA' LegalA' LegalT(Y Z 6Times New Roman Regular DDEӀu[%3|x '  %$HDXX `   1    XXDHusbanddiedinMay,1998.Counselassuredusduringargumentthathisdemise  abatednodecretalactionofthecourt. d((3%$ 3c!7XXdXXd7  HDXXTR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T   `   0  (#$  0   V  %$HDXX `   2    XXDThebreakupofthemarriagebeingimminent,Wifesoldherseparatelyowned  residenceandpurchasedamoremodernone,theentireequityinwhichwasawardedtoher.H ""  X XXXN  XX   Ad FILEDX X N  December3,1998CecilW.CrowsonAppellateCourtClerkdAh ,cAZ"Arial Regular!"#$&C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  (3$ !  ($$   1  ((' dxdP Pd 'dxd 3c!7XXdXXd7  HDXXTR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T    ED7XdXXd7   %  r )<,(j 8` `@E0` 8ttxPh  rINTHECOURTOFAPPEALSOFTENNESSEEt )>.*jx;` `@E0` 8ttxPh? tߛATNASHVILLEs ANNS.WING,   h     ) p DAVIDSONCIRCUIT  T  `     h     ) ` Plaintiff/Appellant h     ) p NO.01A019712CC00752 $ t  `     h     )v. `     h     ) p HON.MARIETTAM.SHIPLEY D   `     h     ) p JUDGE T  JAMESE.WING,   h     ) d   `     h     ) ` Defendant/Appellee    ) p AFFIRMED  CarolL.SolomanandThomasF.Bloom,Nashville,forAppellant.F.DulinKelly,Hendersonville,forAppellee.   E  OPINION#E   # 4 , `     h      p INMAN,SeniorJudge |!  ` Thisisadomesticrelationsdisputeinvolvingmoneyonly.ThetrialcourtheldthatacertificateofdepositandoneinvestmentaccountweretheseparatepropertyofHusbandanddeclinedtoawardWifealimonyorthetotalamountofherattorneyfees.Sheappealsandpresentstheseissuesforreview.  `  DEOurreviewofthefindingsoffactmadebythetrialCourtisdenovoupon ,l'% therecordofthetrialCourt,accompaniedbyapresumptionofthecorrectnessofthefinding,unlessthepreponderanceoftheevidenceisotherwise.Tenn.R. t0+) App.P.,Rule13(d)#EDw #DE;Campbellv.FloridaSteelCorp.,919S.W.2d26(Tenn. 2-+ 1996).#ED #  40-  ` Thepartiesweremarriedin1972.Wifewasneveremployedforwages 6H2/ duringthemarriage,intowhichshebroughtanunencumberedresidenceand$9,000.00cash.Husbandowned400acresofundevelopedlandinStewart 8;639 County,whichhesoldindifferenttractsatvaryingtimesduringthemarriage.  ` HusbandwasgainfullyemployedbytheWaterDepartmentofMetroNashvillein1972.Hewaspaidweekly,andhabituallydeposited$200.00ofhissalary,givingtheremaindertoWifeexceptforanamountnecessaryforhispersonalexpenseswhichwouldaccruethesucceedingweek. ` Husbandwasawardedacertificateofdepositfor$25,000.00,uponafindingthatitwashisseparatepropertybecausethefundsweregeneratedfromthesaleoftheStewartCountyacreage.   #  1      ׀HusbandwasalsoawardedhisNations  Securitiesaccountof$31,431.13,uponafindingthatthesefundsweremostlygeneratedbythesaleoftheacreage. ` WifewasawardedanIRAof$13,500.00,acertificateofdepositof$10,000.00,thenetproceedsfromthesaleofherresidenceof$45,000.00,a liquidaccountof$10,000.00,onehalfofHusbandsvacationpay,and$996.67ashershareofHusbandspension. p  #  2       p"  ` Themaritalestateaggregated$105,000.00,ofwhich$70,500.00wasawardedtoWife,plus$30,000.00asherseparateproperty,and$1,126.00monthlyalimonyandattorneyfeesof$5,000.00. ` Husbandwasawarded$33,721.00ashisshareofthemaritalestate,onehalfoftheEEbonds,andhisseparatepropertypersonalestate,aspreviouslymentioned. ` Thetrialjudgeobservedthatthepartiesweresoabsorbedbybitternessovermoneymattersthataproperperspectivewaslost.ThedispositionoftheHusbandsearningsvisavistheproceedsofthesaleofhisStewartCountyland p3., isdifficulttoascertainfromthetestimony,butitisclearthattheCourtwasimpermissiblyexpectedtotakeandstateafinancialaccountingbetweenthesepartiesduringthelongdurationoftheirmarriage. ` WifearguesthatthecertificateofdDepositandtheNationsSecuritiesaccountcontainedcommingledfundsandthereforewereasmaritalpropertyaccordingtoWadev.Wade,897S.W.2d415(Tenn.App.1994),andthussheis P  entitledtoanequitableshareoftheseaccounts.Husbandwasnotawardedalloftheproceedsfromthesaleofhisseparateproperty;thetrialjudgeclearlystruggledwiththeobfuscativetestimonyinordertodealwiththisissuefairly,andwecannotsaythattheevidencepreponderatesagainstthejudgment.Thetrialcourtswidediscretioninthedistributionofmaritalpropertywillnotbedisturbedonappealabsentclearabuse.Evansv.Evans,558S.W.2d851(Tenn. ` App.1977),Fisherv.Fisher,648S.W.2d244(Tenn.1983);Barnhillv.Barnhill, 0 826S.W.2d443(Tenn.App.1991). P   ` TheplaintiffcomplainsthattheCourterredinfailingtoawardalimonyin p" futuroorinsolido.Sheinsiststhatherneedforalimonyclearlyappearsbecause $ hermonthlyincomeisonly$1,200.00,whichisinsufficientforhersupport. ` TheCourtawardedtheplaintiff$996.17permonthashershareoftheϜHusbandspension,andfoundthatshehadsufficientassets sothatanawardofalimonyisinappropriate.ShearguesthatsincetheHusbandwasawarded$100,000.00inliquidassets, hisestatewillcertainlybeabletopaysomeamountasalimonyinsolido. ` T.C.A.365101(d)(1)prescribesthevariousfactorstobeconsideredindeterminingthealimonyissue.Thecriticalfactorsaretheneedontheonehand,andtheabilitytopayontheother.Loydv.Loyd,860S.W.2d409(Tenn.App. 730 1993).Thetrialcourtconsideredthesefactorscarefully,andconcludedthatan 9 52 awardwouldbeinappropriate,sinceHusbandwouldretainonly$348.02ofhisMetropPension,andhisSocialSecurity,aggregating$1,497.02,exclusiveofincomederivedfromthihisseparatepropertythispersonalestate.Wifewasawardedthelionsshareofthemaritalestate,andwecannotfindthattherefusaltoawardalimonywasanabuseofdiscretion. ` TheWifewasawardedabout50percentofherattorneyfees.Shearguesthattheentireamountofherfeesshouldhavebeenawardedbecauseshelacksthenecessaryfunds.Asinalimonyissues,thetrialcourthaswidediscretioninthematterofattorneyfees.Wifewasawardedsubstantialamountsandwecannotsaythattherefusaltoawardattorneyfeeswasanabuseofdiscretion.See,Houghlandv.Houghland,844S.W.2d619(Tenn.App.1992).Therequest @ ofWifethatshebeawardedherattorneyfeesonappealisdenied. ` Thejudgmentisaffirmedatthecostsoftheappellant.   `     h     _______________________________ ~#  `     h     WilliamH.Inman,SeniorJudgeCONCUR:_______________________________HoustonM.Goddard,PresidingJudge_______________________________CharlesD.Susano,Jr.,Judge