WPC? U8N4}#!J@o=H^k$Zkd( Í~S_’&ei 73UgŒ8qؓ:vn jˆLک>3p@@%Gu7Q2&UkSgi+(Z(Fqj~ x pdLL@n`.`%W>C:GF"T$ M3/@JYۛLw{u>w cMe}"aOD9)AߕMVy|isR;|SST֫[LJv Iol 2U 1f?@$|.â.=afyjC^(oژgbM epƌF -$y52AP~7,UNh % 0(U:w@4^r  0z! 0D & . M$ D3(U:[$U: 0D B7777 AQT 0Dk 0D D/ B"(hH  Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($,  AZ"Arial Regular DDeӀ&\"-3|xSentencing  ; ' IB012R120IB012R12 .      (*(2$ !   `   0  (#$  0     $ `   2    Therecordreflectsthattheunrelatedchargesincludeafelonyandmisdemeanor  offense.However,theyareirrelevanttothedeterminationofthisappealsincethefelonywasnotcommittedwhiledefendantwasonbond;andconsecutivesentencingisnotmandatoryforamisdemeanoroffensecommittedwhileonbondforafelony.   $ `   1    Althoughthetrialcourtstatedatthesentencinghearingthatthesentenceswould  runconcurrently,thewrittenjudgmentsofconvictionaresilentastowhetherthesentencesaretorunconcurrentlyorconsecutively.Tenn.R.Cr.P.32(c)(3)providesthatifadefendantissentencedforafelonycommittedwhileonbondanddefendantisconvictedofbothoffenses, thesentenceshallbeconsecutivewhetherthejudgmentexplicitlysoordersornot.Nevertheless,wewillremandforentryofmodifiedjudgmentstoavoidanyconfusion.   $ `   1    Althoughthetrialcourtstatedatthesentencinghearingthatthesentenceswould  runconcurrently,thewrittenjudgmentsofconvictionaresiletnastowhetherthesentencesaretorunconcurrentlyorconsecutively.Tenn.R.Cr.P.32(c)(3)providesthatifadefendantissentencedforafelonycommittedwhileonbondanddefendantisconvictedofbothoffenses, thesentenceshallbeconsecutivewhetherthejudgmentexplicitlysoordersornot.Nevertheless,wewillremandfornetryofmodifiedjudgmentstoavoidanyconfusion.   $ `   1    Althoughthetrialcourtstatedatthesentencinghearingthatthesentenceswould  runconcurrently,thewrittenjudgmentsofconvictionaresilentastowhetherthesentencesaretorunconcurrentlyorconsecutively.Tenn.R.Cr.P.32(c)(3)providesthatifadefendantissentencedforafelonycommittedwhileonbondanddefendantisconvictedofbothoffenses, thesentenceshallbeconsecutivewhetherthejudgmentexplicitlysoordersornot.Nevertheless,wewillremandforentryofmodifiedjudgmentstoavoidanyconfusion.   $ `   2    Therecordreflectsthattheunrelatedchargesincludeafelonyandmisdemeanor  offense.However,theyareirrelevanttothedeterminationofthisappealsincethefelonywasnotcommittedwhiledefendantwasonbond;andconsecutivesentencingisnotmandatoryforamisdemeanoroffensecommittedwhileonbondforafelony.  ("  X٪XXX'XX٪   Ad FILEDX٪X'   May20,1999  CecilCrowson,Jr.XX٪AppellateCourtClerk """"'dxd,cAZ"Arial Regular  ("  X٪XXX'XX٪   Ad FILEDX٪X'   May17,1999  CecilCrowson,Jr.XX٪AppellateCourtClerk ,cAZ"Arial Regular(3$ !   d'(!)*C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1  ++' dxdP Pd !  X٪XXX  TR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'Tr&<,(j 8` `@E` ttx$ rr&<,(j 8` `@E` ttx$ r@  INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE@=='ATKNOXVILLE@$APRIL1999SESSIONSTATEOFTENNESSEE, @-)  ` @-) p NO.03C019806CR00223   L   ` Appellant,@-)  8  @-) p ROANECOUNTY     VS. @-)   @-) p HON.E.EUGENEEBLEN,   JOYELIZABETHBARRON, @-) p JUDGE    @-) ` Appellee.@-) p (Sentencing) d (  @(#(#( FORTHEAPPELLANT: L JOHNKNOXWALKUP AttorneyGeneralandReporter   TODDR.KELLEY   AssistantAttorneyGeneralCordellHullBuilding,2ndFloor425FifthAvenueNorthNashville,TN372430493 CHARLESE.HAWK   F DistrictAttorneyGeneral FRANKA.HARVEY  #" AssistantDistrictAttorneyGeneralP.O.Box703Kingston,TN377630703 L'"&  FORTHEAPPELLEE: L& JOEH.WALKER  $( DistrictPublicDefender WALTERB.JOHNSONII  + AssistantDistrictPublicDefender502RoaneStreetP.O.Box334Harriman,TN377480334  F1 (  @( OPINIONFILED:򀀀 |.)7 REVERSEDANDREMANDEDJOEG.RILEY,JUDGE  62@  7hXXdXXd7   r@qq* OPINION    ` ARoaneCountyGrandJuryindicteddefendantinFebruary1997forfourcriminaloffenses,includingthreefelonies.Whileonbond,defendantcommittedanotherfelonyinLoudonCounty.ShepledguiltyinLoudonCountyandwassentencedinNovember1997.Subsequently,shepledguiltyandwassentencedontheRoaneCountychargesinJune1998.ThetrialcourtallowedtheRoaneCountysentencestorunconcurrentlytotheLoudonCountyconvictions.   #  1      ׀Thestate P  appealsthisdecisionandarguesthatconsecutivesentencingismandatoryunderthesecircumstances.Defendantconcedestheissue,andweagree.Thus,weREVERSEandREMANDforentryofmodifiedjudgmentswhichreflectthatthesentencesfortheRoaneCountyconvictionsrunconsecutivelytotheLoudonCountydrugconviction.@+ FACTS  4  ` InFebruary1997,aRoaneCountyGrandJuryindictedJoyElizabethBarronfortwoaggravatedburglaries,theftofpropertyunder$500,andtheftofpropertyover$1000(RoaneCountyNos.11640and11641).Whileoutonbondfortheseoffenses,defendantcommittedadrugrelatedfelonyinLoudonCounty(LoudonCountyNo.9398.) ` DefendantpledguiltyandwassentencedontheLoudonCountyoffenseinNovember1997.ShesubsequentlypledguiltytotheRoaneCountychargesinJune1998.ThetrialcourtallowedtheRoaneCountysentencestorunconcurrently totheLoudonCountydrugoffense.Thestateappealed,claimingthattheRoane .l). CountyconvictionsshouldrunconsecutivelytoLoudonCountyNo.9398andotherunrelatedcharges.   #  2      ׀ |  @" CONSECUTIVESENTENCING   d  ` Tenn.R.Crim.P.32(c)(3)provides:8 ` 8 ` ` [w]hereadefendantisconvictedofmultipleoffensesfromonetrialorwherethedefendanthasadditionalsentencesnotyetfullyservedastheresultoftheconvictionsinthesameorothercourtandthelawrequiresconsecutivesentences,thesentenceshallbeconsecutivewhetherthejudgmentexplicitlysoordersornot.Thisruleshallapply:  x x  `  ...8 ` 8 ` ` (C)Toasentenceforafelonywherethedefendantwasreleasedonbailandthedefendantisconvictedofbothoffenses....  x x DefendantcommittedtheLoudonCountydrugoffensewhileonbondfortheRoaneCountyoffenses.Shepledto,andwasconvictedof,theLoudonCountyoffense;thenshepledto,andwasconvictedof,theRoaneCountyoffenses. ` Underthesecircumstances,thesentencingstatutediveststhetrialcourtofdiscretionandrequiresthesentencestorunconsecutively. Inanycaseinwhichadefendantcommitsafelonywhile...releasedonbail...andthedefendantisconvictedofbothsuchoffenses,thetrialjudgeshallnothavediscretionastowhetherthesentencesshallrunconcurrentlyorcumulatively,butshallorderthatsuchsentencesbeservedcumulatively.Tenn.CodeAnn.4020111(b).Thelastsentencingcourthastheresponsibilitytodeterminewhetherornotasentenceshouldbeservedconsecutively.Statev.Arnold,824S.W.2d176,178(Tenn.Crim. ,`'* App.1991). ` TheRoaneCountytrialcourt,asthelastsentencingcourt,hadtheresponsibilitytoreviewdefendantsvariousconvictionsinordertodeterminethatdefendantssentencesshouldrunconsecutively.Thetrialcourterredwhenit 3.2  r     r     r     r     r     r     r    allowedthesentencesinRoaneCountyNos.11640and11641torunconcurrentlywithLoudonCountyNo.9398incontraventionofTenn.CodeAnn.4020111(b)andTenn.R.Crim.P.32(c)(3).̀@xx( CONCLUSION  0   ` Basedupontheforegoing,weREMANDforentryofmodifiedjudgmentstoreflectthesentencesforRoaneCountyNos.11640and11641runningconsecutivelytothesentenceforLoudonCountyNo.9398./(#____________________________ `     h      p JOEG.RILEY,JUDGE  `  CONCUR: `  ____________________________  ! JERRYL.SMITH,JUDGE ____________________________  `'"% NORMAMcGEEOGLE,JUDGE