WPC $vU)D[ſ!51~2`DJj_r%n|CƘW5 Qa-UTjA[X(}6U\> l(H)k81#9(%t%9WeԸ?@̊ l?&׬Y겡yZ|8Gcw xThT;s@ TEf9Var>+0o" L.dH6Rq $'2gLLU zp)Y9~ڜ{# B]ȽKE]W:iӠ*V63ǙSkVd⬩$B/'k/l6vb;ǘfsO0ؠ6EH,ԝ>j?gv(1.~1}פ6tDQ % 0 UB 4  n U: f 4 "w@>~U: B D3 0D AOT 0Di D/ BHP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nLh<( 9Z &Courier RegularX($  7'CXXdXXd7    iUX` hp x (#%'0*,.8135@8:<H?AXi<6X9`(*Courier 12pt10cpiuM%3|x<6X9`(*Courier 12pt10cpiXXx6X@JQX@,rAZ"Arial Regular \\RA' Legal\ XlXXXPXXl   Ad FILEDXlXP  January22,1999CecilW.CrowsonAppellateCourtClerkdAM     EDEDӀ,cAZ"Arial Regular d%%%%'dxd(3$ !  -C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5($$   1  ' dxdP Pd !  7XXdd7    iUX` hp x (#%'0*,.8135@8:<H?AXi  ݛXTR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T † : XlXXX7 l XXdXXd7р8 @ D x xINTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @%DATNASHVILLE@@66-R   AUGUST198986SESSIONSTATEOFTENNESSEE, h   )   80 Ѐ    h   )   r *<,(j 8` `@E ` 8ttxPX  rߛ Appellee, h   )  No.01C019711CC00521       h   )       h   )  CoffeeCounty   v.    h   )       h   )  HonorableGeraldEwell,Sr.,Judge       h   )PARKSA.BRYAN, h   )  (Firstdegreemurder) h`     h   ) Appellant. h   ) 4,  @&DCONCURRINGOPINION    Iconcurintheresultsreachedandmostofthereasoningusedinthemajorityopinion.However,Irespectfullydisagreewithitsconclusionthatallofthephotographswereproperlyadmitted. Twocolorphotographsfromtheautopsyshowtheribcageareaofthevictimsbodywiththeskincutaway.Asthemajorityadmits,theyare somewhatgraphicandgruesome.Beforethestatesoughttointroducethesephotographs,twodoctorshadtestifiedforthestaterelativetothevictimsinjuries.Onedescribedtheseverityofthebreaksinthevictimsribsasfollows:  8 AlotoftimesIprobablyseethreeorfourpeopleaweekwithribfractureswhicharesimplefractures.Wecallthemgreensticklikewhereyoumighttakealimboffthetreeandbenditupandbreakitandletitcomeback.Whenyoulookatit,itlookssolidandstillissolidandstrong,butithasasmallcrackinit.Thisparticularlady,shehadmultiplecompoundfractures.Herboneswereliterallybrokenapart,andthesebrokenportionsthenenteredthelungandcausedthelungtocollapseandthebleedingtooccur,soasyouknow,alotofpeoplehavefourorfiveorsixfracturedribsanddonothaveproblemswiththeirlungs,butthisparticularladyhadsomanymultiplecompoundfracturesthatthesefractureswereveryextensivesothatiswhatcaused D:<39 herslowbleedingdeath,andthesefracturedribsthenenteredthelung,andtheevidenceshowsthatshebledtodeathoveraperiodoftime.  x x   Thepathologistwasnolessbluntandgraphicinhistestimony. Atnotimedidthedefenseseektocontesttheextentoftheinjuriesasdescribedbythedoctors.Underthesecircumstances,IbelievethatthesetwophotographsshouldhavebeenexcludedunderRule403,T.R.A.P.enn.R.Evidencefromtheevidencebecausetheirprobativevaluewassubstantiallyoutweighedbythedangerofunfairprejudicetothedefendant..񛀀Inlightofthedoctorsgraphictestimonyandthedefendantsacquiescenceinthattestimony,thephotographsweresuperfluouslycumulativeintermsofprovingtheextentoftheribandinternaldamages.Ontheotherhand,giventhenatureofthedoctorstestimonyandtheotherphotographs,Idonotbelievethatthetwophotographsofconcernmoreprobablythannotaffectedtheoutcomeofthecase.SeeT.R.A.P.36(b).      h      p ____________________________    h      p JosephM.Tipton,Judge    h