WPC% L=+v&$;9rIY{.?Bos[EOE "R[F#Pٹܒ60XqFn(㯅AVCvI f0L x.:R_k-b(3 5A:|t n]Fnۨ_nnbTftq+YlXwMtK_/@J"3jSQ]#yiz]n?ǵ" =`e*GT'?X{OSEMbI?+8E# U: %  04 0  0D  4 w@r=   b  erk] 0D! D/!%"b6# D3># AQq## 0D$ 0D$ B% B-%U:J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J%J% 0D%HP LaserJet 4 PlusHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nL,  AZ"Arial RegularX( 7$` ` TR[A' Legal[A' LegalA' LegalA' LegalTV&3|x3((3C6$  7!` TR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T   `   0  (#$  0    C6$ `   1    ݀See,e.g.,WillieJacksonv.State,No.02C019606CR00195,Shelby  County(Tenn.Crim.App.Aug.8,1997);BillyKilburnv.State,No.02C019608CC  00251,ObionCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.July29,1997);WalterE.Ingramv.State,  No.02C019608CR00258,ShelbyCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.July28,1997);JamesMorningCraftv.State,No.02C019606CR00194,ShelbyCounty(Tenn. Z Crim.App.July18,1997);JerryW.Hardinv.State,No.02C019609CC00303, B  HenryCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.July18,1997);LeslieL.Colemanv.State,No. * n 01C019605CR00203,DavidsonCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.May16,1997);Joseph  V Veresv.State,No.01C019602CC00070,PutnamCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Apr.  > 24,1997),app.filed(Tenn.May2,1997);DennisDunningv.State,No.02C01  &  9603CR00102,ShelbyCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Mar.12,1997),app.filed(Tenn.    Mar.12,1997);RonaldAlbertBrummittv.State,No.03C019512CC00415,   LoudonCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Mar.11,C P C 1997),app.filed(Tenn.Mar.17,1997);   JimmyEarlLoftonv.State,No.02C019603CR00073,ShelbyCounty(Tenn.Crim.   App.Mar.7,1997),app.filed(Tenn.Apr.18,1997);RoyBarnettv.State,No. j  03C019512CV00394,HamblenCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Feb.20,1997),app. R  filed(Tenn.Apr.21,1997);WilliamEdwardBlakev.State,No.03C019603CR :~ 00110,KnoxCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Feb.12,1997),app.filed(Tenn.Feb.27, "f 1997);DoyleCarterv.State,No.01C019511CC00398,DavidsonCounty(Tenn.  N Crim.App.Feb.12,1997);EricC.Pendletonv.State,No.01C019604CR00158, 6 DavidsonCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Feb.12,1997),app.filed(Tenn.Mar.24,  1997);JohnnyTillmanv.State,No.03C019512CR00413,KnoxCounty(Tenn.  Crim.App.Feb.12,1997),app.filed(Tenn.Feb.18,1997);StephenKoprowskiv.  State,No.03C019511CC00365,No.03C019511CR00378,AndersonCounty  (Tenn.Crim.App.Jan.28,1997),apps.filed(Tenn.Jan.30,1997);RickieJ.Wallen z v.State,No.03C019601CC00039,SullivanCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Jan.9, b 1997),app.filed(Tenn.Feb.5,1997);JohnnyL.Butlerv.State,No.02C019509 J CR00289,ShelbyCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Dec.2,1996),app.filed(Tenn.Jan. 2v 24,1997);WallaceButlerv.RickyBell,Warden,No.02C019510CC00297, ^ FayetteCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.Nov.19,1996).        33D333D333D3D3Ӏ h\RA' Legal\    - -         C6$ `   1    ݀Thiswas13daysafterthedefendanthadbeenplacedonprobation. T6$ `   2    ݀Theindictmentforassaultwasdismissedsummarilyaftertherevocation.  T6$ `   3    ݀Thetrialjudgehadindicatedthathewasconcernedaboutthedefendant  havingcontactwiththevictim.However,heannouncedhewouldnotconsiderthisbecausetheprobationgrantdidnotprohibitthis.Thedefendantraisedthisasanissueonappeal,butthisdoesnotentitlethedefendanttorelief.H h\RA' Legal\   T6$ `   2    ݀Theindictmentforassaultwasdismissedsummarilyaftertherevocation. S T6$ `   3    ݀Thetrialjudgehadindicatedthathewasconcernedaboutthedefendant  havingcontactwiththevictim.However,heannouncedhewouldnotconsiderthisbecausetheprobationgrantdidnotprohibitthis.  T6$ `   3    ݀Thetrialjudgehadindicatedthathewasconcernedaboutthedefendant  havingcontactwiththevictim.However,heannouncedhewouldnotconsiderthisbecausetheprobationgrantdidnotprohibitthis.Thedefendantraisedthisasanissueonappeal,butthisdoesnotentitlethedefendanttorelief. T6$ `   2    ݀Theindictmentforassaultwasdismissedsummarily???afterthe  revocation.(3$ !  ++' dxd  ("  ,XXXX,4YX,X   Ad FILED,XX,4Y   March9,1999  CecilCrowson,Jr.,;X,XAppellateCourtClerk - -****'dxd'(!)"C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1   dP Pd,cAZ"Arial Regular6b$Triangle0  7!` TR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T  ݛ7XXdd7    PPOY;3r&#%<,(j 8` `@Ef ` ttx$,` rߛ3INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEAL%  SOFTENNESSEE `  ATKNOXVILLEJANUARY1999SESSION  STATEOFTENNESSEE, h     ) p C.C.A.NO.03C019707CR00291 v   `     h     ) p  \   ` Appellee   h     ) p HAMILTONCOUNTY  B   `     h     )v. `     h     ) p HON.DOUGLASA.MEYER, (#     `     h     ) p JUDGE   JERRYALLENELLISON, h     ) p  z   `     h     ) p (Revocationofprobation) ` Ѐ ` Defendant/Appellant    ) F FORTHEAPPELLANT: h      p FORTHEAPPELLEE: $ ArdenaJ.Garth   h      p JohnKnoxWalkup  DistrictPublicDefender h      p AttorneyGeneral&Reporter v 11thJudicialDistrict `     h      p R.StephenJobeDonnaRobinsonMiller h      p AssistantAttorneyGeneral "( AssistantDistrictPublicDefender   p CriminalJusticeDivision n# Suite300701CherrySt. h      p 425FifthAvenueNorth T$ Chattanooga,TN37402 h      p 2dFloor,CordellHullBuilding :%  `     h      p Nashville,TN372430493 (#   &   `     h OPINIONFILED򀀀 27-3 AFFIRMEDJOHNK.BYERS3P    P    3SENIORJUDGE ;P28S P    3P    3  OPINION  `     ` Thisisanappealbythedefendantfromthejudgmentofthetrialcourtwhichrevokedapreviouslygrantedprobationtohim. ` Thejudgmentofthetrialcourtisaffirmed. ` InDecember1996,thedefendantenteredapleaofincest,whicharosefromhissexualintercourseandoralsexwithhisstepdaughteroneighttotenoccasionswhenshewasfourteenandfifteenyearsofage.OnMarch13,1997,thetrialjudgesentencedthedefendanttoservesixyearsfortheoffense.Thedefendantserveda30day shocktimeinjailandonApril21,1997theremainderofthesentencewassuspendedandthedefendantwasplacedonintenseprobation. x  2  ` OnMay6,1997,apetitionwasfiledtorevoketheprobationbecausethedefendanthadbeenarrestedforassault.OnJune18,1997,thetrialcourtrevokedthedefendantsprobationandorderedhimtoservetheremainderofthesixyearsentence. ` Therecordshowsthatthedefendantandthemotherofthechildinthecaseweredivorcedsometimebeforethecasewasconcluded.Whenthedefendantwasreleasedfromjail,hebegantolivewithawomannamedBenson,whowasapparently19yearsofage. ` TheBensonwomantestifiedthatonMay4,1997shehidthetelephonefromthedefendantbecauseshethoughthewasgoingtocallthechilduponwhomhehadcommittedincest.Thedefendantfoundthetelephoneandtheystruggledovertheuse.  #  1      ׀Accordingtothewoman,thedefendantthrewherontothebedandbegan "/%* tochokeher.Inthecourseofthisaltercationthedefendantsaid ifIhavetogotojail,youregoingtodie.Theevidenceshowsthatanofficerwhoinvestigatedthis casesawmarksuponthewomansneck. 4&+0 ;TR[A' Legal[A' LegalA' LegalA' LegalT`   3;TR[A' Legal[A' LegalA' LegalA' LegalT`   ;TR[A' Legal[A' LegalA' LegalA' LegalT`   ;TR[A' Legal[A' LegalA' LegalA' LegalT`   ;TR[A' Legal[A' LegalA' LegalA' LegalT`   3 ` Therecordshowsthatthewomanattemptedtokeepthedefendantfrom goingtojailbytellingtheprosecutionthatshehadliedaboutwhatoccurred.Shewasremindedthatherswornaffidavitwasapartoftherecordandthatifshetestifiedtothecontraryshewouldbeprosecutedforperjury.33333333333 3  #  2      33Alloftheimpeaching  d evidencewasshowninthehearingandthewomantestifiedthatshespokethetruthwhensherelatedhowthedefendanthadassaultedher.Thedefendanttestifiedcontrarytothewomansversion. ` Thetrialjudgefoundthewomansstoryoftheassaulttobecredibleandhefoundthedefendanthadcommittedtheassault.333333v33v333v3  #  3      33 `  ` Thedecisiontorevokeprobationrestswithinthediscretionofthetrialjudge,Statev.Mitchell,810S.W.2d733(Tenn.Crim.App.1991),anditwillnotbe  reversedonappealunlessthereisashowingofanabuseofthatdiscretion.State  v.Harkins,811S.W.2d79(Tenn.1991).Toreversethejudgment,theremustbe T nosubstantialevidenceintherecordtosupporttheactionofthetrialjudge.Id. $h  ` Inthiscase,thetrialjudgefoundthatthedefendanthadcommittedtheoffenseofassaultashewasaccused.Theevidencesupportsthisfinding.Thetrialjudgedidnotabusehisdiscretioninrevokingthepreviouslygrantedprobation. ` Thejudgmentofthetrialcourtisaffirmed.I33O333tappearingthatthedefendantisindigent,333the333Thec33c3ost3s3ofthisappeal3is33are3taxedtothe3State33defendant3. `     h      ($(  `     h     JohnK.Byers,SeniorJudge 3.4 P    CONCUR:  ̀ T JamesCurwoodWitt,Jr.,Judgè    NormaMcGeeOgle,Judge