WPC n?7,(+ W,!-JQTF.{ ig=%vLnqjڳ.?JƗjLqMZBr ^\tÊ~f0R2ζUe =|JM_c JN#X`ot`;H쳿X[VbLxG?_%u6b[Dl!`wܤJ;+$̩\՚y#riChⴵYTRU_]&ލ2${#l@:޸ϨEk>s5Vɨ°d[`BeYVNf$F3?~ݬmV%,3yhiiYp٨Y= 'Xzӗ}u-;Xu57kMk&",qxٽ(yB 5\Jj'CbBP6`5s+7 8?qpP0*5լ* 8xFUNl % 0( U: w@" 4b v   0z 0DHH$W D3{U: 0D BBBBB AQ_ 0Dv 0D D/ B-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 0DJ(hH  Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($,  AZ"Arial Regular DDDDDeӀ&3|xProbation Revocation   ' IB012R120IB012R12 .   (*(2$ !   `   0    $ `   2    Wenotethatdefendantsoriginalprobationrulescalledforanalcoholanddrug  assessmenttowhichdefendantneversubmitted.(#$  0   >  $ `   1    Thetrialcourtrevokeddefendantsprobationontwoprioroccasions.Thefirst  revocationinAugust1995resultedinan18dayjailsentence,followedbyextensionofprobationforoneyear,andanordertoperform50hoursofcommunityservice.ThesecondrevocationinFebruary1996resultedindefendantsplacementintheDepartmentofCorrectionforexecutionofhissentence.TheDepartmentofCorrectionreleaseddefendantbackontoprobationinJuly1996. >  $ `   1    Thetrialcourtrevokeddefendantsprobationontwoprioroccasions.Thefirst  revocationinAugust1995resultedinan18dayjailsentence,followedbyextensionofprobationforoneyear,andanordertoperform50hoursofcommunityservice.ThesecondrevocationinFebruary1996resultedindefendantsplacementintheDepartmentofCorrectionforexecutionofhissentence.TheDepartmentofCorrectionreleaseddefendantbackontoprobationinJuly1996.  ("  XXXX<XX   Ad FILEDXX<   May26,1999  CecilCrowson,Jr.XXAppellateCourtClerk """"'dxd   ,cAZ"Arial Regular(3$ !   d'(!)*C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1  ++' dxdP Pd6b$Triangle0 !  XXXX  TR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'Tr&<,(j 8` `@E` ttx$ rߛ@  INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @=='ATKNOXVILLE@$APRIL1999SESSIONSTATEOFTENNESSEE, @-)  ` @-) p NO.03C019810CC00350   L   ` Appellee,@-)  8  @-) p BLOUNTCOUNTY     VS. @-)   @-) p HON.D.KELLYTHOMAS,JR.,   DAVIDLYNGRIBBLE, @-) p JUDGE    @-) ` Appellant.@-) p (ProbationRevocation) d (  @(#(#( FORTHEAPPELLANT: L JULIEA.MARTIN P.O.Box426  Knoxville,TN379010426(OnAppeal) MACKGARNER  X DistrictPublicDefender419HighStreetMaryville,TN37804(AtHearing)  F  FORTHEAPPELLEE: L JOHNKNOXWALKUP  $! AttorneyGeneralandReporter ELLENH.POLLACK  $ AssistantAttorneyGeneralCordellHullBuilding,2ndFloor425FifthAvenueNorthNashville,TN372430493 MICHAELL.FLYNN   F* DistrictAttorneyGeneral KIRKANDREWS  #- AssistantDistrictAttorneyGeneral363CourtStreetMaryville,TN378045906 f&!0 (  @( OPINIONFILED:򀀀 -(6 AFFIRMEDJOEG.RILEY,JUDGE  521? 7FXXdXXd7  r@qq* OPINION    ` Thedefendant,DavidLynGribble,appealsasofrightthetrialcourtsjudgmentuponrevocationofprobation.Defendantadmittedhisprobationviolation,andthetrialcourtsentencedhimtoservesixmonthsinthecountyjailwithworkreleaseeligibility.Inadditiontoincarceration,thetrialcourtordereddefendanttoserveanadditionalsixmonthsonintensiveprobationwiththeconditionthathecompleteanoutpatientalcoholtreatmentprogram.WefindnoabuseofdiscretionbythetrialcourtandAFFIRMitsjudgmentinallrespects.@+ FACTS    ` InNovember1994,defendantpledguiltytofacilitationofaggravatedassaultandreceivedatwoyearsentence.Thetrialcourtimmediatelyplacedhimonsupervisedprobation.InMay1998,thedefendantadmittedhisthirdprobationviolationatissuehere.   #  1      Essentially,defendantignoredtherequirementsofhis : probation:hefailedtoreporttohisprobationofficer;failedtoperformtherequiredcommunityservice;andfailedtopayrestitution,probationfees,andcourtcosts. ` Thedefendanttestifiedthatafterreleasefromincarcerationfollowinghissecondprobationviolation,helosthisjoband wasstayingdrunkallthetime,reallywasntdoingnothingelse.Justhangingoutwithmyfriends.Duringthisperiod,defendantgotbehindonhiscommunityserviceandmonetaryobligationstothecourtwhicheventuallycausedhimto justquitgoing[toprobationappointments.] ` However,defendantclaimstohavematuredconsiderablysincethattime.Hebeganarelationshipwithhisfianceeandcurrentlysupportsherandheryoungdaughter.Defendantcreditstherelationshipwithhelpinghimto straightenouthislife;.hHemaintainssteadyemploymentandclaimstonolongerdrink. 1,2  ` Thetrialcourtfounddefendantsfailuretoreporttobeachronicproblem.Itdeterminedthatsuchfailuremadeitimpossibleforthecourttoaddressdefendantsunderlyingproblems,particularlyanapparentalcoholproblem.Sothatitmightmaintainsupervisionofthedefendantuponrelease,thetrialcourtordereddefendanttoservesixmonthsinthecountyjail,followedbysixmonthsofintensiveprobation,aswellascompletionofanoutpatientalcoholtreatmentprogram.@  # PROBATIONREVOCATION    ` Defendantclaimsthatgiventhe turnaroundinhislife,thetrialcourtabuseditsdiscretionwhenitrevokedhisprobation.Hearguesthetrialcourtshouldgivehimanotheropportunitytocompleteprobationwithoutadditionalincarceration.Inthealternative,hearguesthatsixmonthsincarcerationisanexcessiveperiodoftime.Finally,thedefendantclaimsthatthecourtabuseditsdiscretioninorderingcompletionofanalcoholtreatmentprogram.񀛀 ` Uponafindingbyapreponderanceoftheevidencethatapersonhasviolatedaconditionofprobation,atrialcourtmayrevokeprobationandordercommencement ofthejudgmentasoriginallyentered,orotherwise...provided p&!$ ...thedefendanthastherighttoappeal.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035311(d)(emphasisadded).Thedecisiontorevokeprobationrestswithinthesounddiscretionofthetrialcourt.Statev.Mitchell,810S.W.2d733,735(Tenn.Crim. ,`'* App.1991).Revocationofprobationissubjecttoanabuseofdiscretionstandardofreview,ratherthanadenovostandard.Statev.Harkins,811S.W.2d79,82 / +. (Tenn.1991).Discretionisabusedonlyiftherecordcontainsnosubstantialevidencetosupporttheconclusionofthetrialcourtthataviolationofprobationhasoccurred.Id.;Statev.Gregory,946S.W.2d829,832(Tenn.Crim.App.1997).The p504  evidenceneedonlyshowthatthetrialjudgeexercisedaconscientiousand P726 r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    r    intelligentjudgment,ratherthanactingarbitrarily.Gregory,946S.W.2dat832;   Statev.Leach,914S.W.2d104,106(Tenn.Crim.App.1995).   ` Inthiscase,theprobationofficertestifiedthatdefendantsimplyignoredhisprobationrequirements.Defendantadmittedhisviolations.And,inspiteofhisassertionthathenolongerdrinksduetothedisapprovalofhisfiancee,thedefendantacknowledgedthathe stayeddrunkafterreleasefromincarcerationfollowingthesecondprobationviolation. ` Thetrialcourtdidnotabuseitsdiscretionbyorderingthedefendanttoservesixmonthsconfinement,andfurtherrequiringthatdefendantsubmittooutpatientalcoholtreatment.   #  2      ׀Defendantscontentionsarewithoutmerit.  @xx( CONCLUSION  P  ` Basedupontheforegoing,wefindnoabuseofdiscretionbythetrialcourtandAFFIRMitsjudgmentinallrespects./(#____________________________ `     h      p JOEG.RILEY,JUDGE  #!  CONCUR: P(#&  ____________________________  ,`'* JERRYL.SMITH,JUDGE ____________________________  0,/ NORMAMcGEEOGLE,JUDGE