WPC# YXGsU-Imc)(>Թ>;xM++NY ,)}fO/Hl(',_Ek?*V0Pcu"BެgebnX"kZF2 J\ ND +us%]U9kޖajLڍFϸ'MG7sOPog+rusPx/4&p=LĥK,HιKہXCMͼ?U$(X?L"XKK$ukG>^9ҕ-9T .c ,W#a>%7XM& n}si |,tQB6Bu波5R= 4ۍjS}\Ơh/U,ݶQ/5GlYw4\1xqU: gWF<֞Xj^EpIۥ5chU.F %t bz ~ 9 n% 0(U:w<4 0 0DeU:U:U:AU: J U:.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.! Bh!h!h!h!h!h!h!h! D3!!! 0D!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AO!K"K" 0D# D/U# B#<6X9`(CourierX   ,$XB2XXX `   4    ݀Thisrulestatesasfollows: `   ` (f)WithdrawalofPleaofGuilty.Amotiontowithdrawapleaofguiltymaybemadeuponashowingbythedefendantofanyfairandjustreasononlybeforesentenceisimposed;buttocorrectmanifestinjustice,thecourtaftersentence,butbeforethejudgmentbecomesfinal,maysetasidethejudgmentofconvictionandpermitthedefendanttowithdrawtheplea. `  XB2XXXB2 ` Tenn.R.Crim.P.32(f).#XB2XX XB2K#  $XyXXX `   1    ݀Thisrulestatesasfollows: `   ` IfanypersonwhohasnotpreviouslybeenconvictedofafelonyoraClassAmisdemeanorisfoundguiltyorpleadsguiltytoamisdemeanorwhichispunishablebyimprisonmentoraClassC,DorEfelony,thecourtmay,withoutenteringajudgmentofguiltyandwiththeconsentofsuchperson,deferfurtherproceedingsandplacethepersononprobationuponsuchreasonableconditionsasitmayrequire.... `  ` Tenn.CodeAnn.4035313(a)(1)(A)(1997).  $XyXXX `   2    ݀ Ajudgmentofconvictionshallsetforththeplea,theverdictorfindings, `  andtheadjudicationandsentence.Tenn.R.Crim.P.32(e).3|x *<6X9`(CourierXx6X@`7X@($,  AZ"Arial Regular))E)[))E))E))E))D)U))E))E))E))E))E))D)D)e)***ӀuM%  ,$XXXX `   3    ݀Thesameconclusion,albeittheminorityposition,wasreachedbythe `  authorofthisopinionashereachedinStatev.StephenJ.UdzinskiandDonna P  Stokes,No.01C019810CC00431,slipop.at12(Tenn.Crim.App.,Nashville, @  Feb.5,1998).InUdzinski,adefendantwhohadbeengrantedjudicialdiversion 0  attemptedtoappealthevalidityofasearchwarrantthroughacertifiedquestionoflawpursuanttoTennesseeRuleofCriminalProcedure37(b)(2).Theauthorofthisopinionconcluded,despitethedisagreementoftheothertwomembersofthatpanel,thatadefendantwhochoosestoacceptjudicialdiversionhasnoappealasofrightbecausetherehasbeennojudgmentofconviction.Udzinski,  slipop.at1112.(I(2$  !  XyXXX `   0  (#$  0  ,cAZ"Arial Regular  ,$XB2XXX `   3    Theauthorofthisopinionhasreachedthesameconclusion,albeitthe `  minorityposition,ashereachedinStatev.StephenJ.UdzinskiandDonna P  Stokes,No.01C019810CC00431,slipop.at12(Tenn.Crim.App.,Nashville, @  Feb.5,1998).InUdzinski,adefendantwhohadbeengrantedjudicialdiversion 0  attemptedtoappealthevalidityofasearchwarrantthroughacertifiedquestionoflawpursuanttoTennesseeRuleofCriminalProcedure37(b)(2).Theauthorofthisopinionconcluded,despitethedisagreementoftheothertwomembersofthatpanel,thatadefendantwhochoosestoacceptjudicialdiversionhasnoappealasofrightbecausetherehasbeennojudgmentofconviction.Udzinski,  slipop.at1112.,cAZ"Arial Regular  ,$XB2XXX `   2    ݀ Ajudgmentofconvictionshallsetforththeplea,theverdictorfindings, `  andtheadjudicationandsentence.Tenn.R.Crim.P.32(e).,cAZ"Arial Regular  ,$XB2XXX `   3    ݀Thesameconclusion,albeittheminorityposition,wasreachedbythe `  authorofthisopinionashereachedinStatev.StephenJ.UdzinskiandDonna P  Stokes,No.01C019810CC00431,slipop.at12(Tenn.Crim.App.,Nashville, @  Feb.5,1998).InUdzinski,adefendantwhohadbeengrantedjudicialdiversion 0  attemptedtoappealthevalidityofasearchwarrantthroughacertifiedquestionoflawpursuanttoTennesseeRuleofCriminalProcedure37(b)(2).Theauthorofthisopinionconcluded,despitethedisagreementoftheothertwomembersofthatpanel,thatadefendantwhochoosestoacceptjudicialdiversionhasnoappealasofrightbecausetherehasbeennojudgmentofconviction.Udzinski,  slipop.at1112.,cAZ"Arial Regular XyXXX#XXy   Ad FILEDXyX#  May13,1999CecilW.CrowsonAppellateCourtClerkdAM ,cAZ"Arial Regular d""""'dxd(3$  !  -C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5($$   1  ' dxdP Pd  !  ))))`   TR[A'Legal3'A' Legal3'T X4XXX7 4 XXdd7  *r*<,(j 8` `@Ef ` 8ttxP`  rߛ* @ INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE P  ̀@@@'ATNASHVILLE 0  @#FEBRUARY1999SESSION    STATEOFTENNESSEE, h     ) p   `     h     ) p  `   `  Appellee, h     ) p C.C.A.No.01C019808CR00344 P   `     h     )vs. `     h     ) p WilsonCounty x  0   `     h     ) GLENNAKIDD,   h     ) p Hon.J.O.Bond,Judge  p   `     h     ) `  `  Appellant. h     ) p (BestInterestGuiltyPlea) P  `     h     FORTHEAPPELLANT: h      p FORTHEAPPELLEE:   GLENNAKIDD(prose) h      p JOHNKNOXWALKUP   P.O.Box499   h      p AttorneyGeneral&Reporter  Shelbyville,TN37162 h       p  `     h      p GEORGIABLYTHEFELNER  !`  `     h      p AssistantAttorneyGeneral `     h      p 425FifthAve.N.,2dFloor  #@   `     h      p Nashville,TN372430493 $0  `     h      p TOMP.THOMPSON,JR. p&  `     h      p DistrictAttorneyGeneral  `'   `     h      p 203GreentopSt.,P.O.Box178 P(!  `     h      p Hartsville,TN370740178 `     h      p ROBERTN.HIBBETT   +!$  `     h      p AssistantDistrictAttorney `     h      p 119CollegeSt. `     h      p Lebanon,TN37087  -$'  `     h      p OPINIONFILED:________________))APPEALDISMISSED))JAMESCURWOODWITT,JR.,JUDGE  @8.2  ;15 @qq* OPINION  `  XyXX X4'X, XX' # X4XXXy>#Thedefendant,GlennaKidd,appealsfromtheWilsonCountyCriminal   Courtsentryofherguiltyplea.OnMarch31,1998,thedefendantenteredabestinterestguiltypleatoonecountofpassingaworthlesscheck.ThejudgegrantedjudicialdiversionofoneyearpursuanttoTennesseeCodeAnnotatedsection4035313. #  1      ׀OnApril16,1998,thedefendantfiledaprosenoticeofappeal.Inthe @  defendantsbrief,sheasksthiscourttodismissthechargeagainsther.Thedefendantcontendsthatshewascoercedandthreatenedintosigningabestinterestguiltyplea.Followingareviewoftherecord,thebriefsoftheparties,andtheapplicablelaw,wedismisstheappealforlackofjurisdiction. Adefendantmayappealasofrightfromany judgmentofconviction)> )) ) #  2        onaguiltypleaifthepleaagreementcontainedanexplicitreservationoftherighttoappealacertifiedquestionoflaw,or ifthedefendantseeksreviewofthesentenceandtherewasnopleaagreementconcerningthesentence,oriftheissueswerenotwaivedbytheguiltypleaandtheseissuesareapparentfromtherecord.Tenn.R.App.P.3(b);seealsoTenn.R.Crim.P.37(b)(2).Thedefendant @)" enteredabestinterestguiltypleaandwasjudiciallydivertedpursuanttoTennessee  +!$ CodeAnnotatedsection4035313.Accordingtothissection,the))court,withthe @  consentofthedefendant,))defersfurtherproceedingsandplacesthedefendanton   probationwithoutenteringajudgmentofguilty.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035313(a)(1)(A)(1997).Afinaldispositionofthecasedoesnotoccuruntileitherthedefendantviolatesaconditionoftheprobationortheprobationperiodends.See `  id.at(a)(2).Specifically,thissectionstates: @  `  Uponviolationofaconditionoftheprobation,thecourtmayenteranadjudicationofguiltandproceedasotherwiseprovided.If,duringtheperiodofprobation,suchpersondoesnotviolateanyoftheconditionsofprobation,thenuponexpirationofsuchperiod,thecourtshalldischargesuchpersonanddismisstheproceedingsagainsttheperson.Dischargeanddismissalunderthissubsectioniswithoutcourtadjudicationofguilt.... ` Id.Therefore,underjudicialdiversionthereisno judgmentofconvictiontoappeal  pursuanttoTennesseeRuleofAppellateProcedure3,)))))))))) #  3      כ))unlessthedefendant !` violatesaconditionoftheprobationandthecourtentersanadjudicationofguilt.̀ ThiscourtmaytreatanimproperlyfiledRule3appealasaRule10extraordinaryappeal.SeeStatev.Leath,977S.W.2d132,135(Tenn.Crim.App. @)" 1998);Statev.JamesDoe,No.01C019102CR00046,slipop.at56(Tenn.Crim.  +!$ App.,Nashville,June29,1992).TennesseeRuleofAppellateProcedure10(a)providesthatanextraordinaryappealmaybesought ifthelowercourthassofar .%( departedfromtheacceptedandusualcourseofjudicialproceedingsastorequireimmediatereview....InStatev.Willoughby,594S.W.2d388,392(Tenn.1980), @  oursupremecourtheldthatanextraordinaryappealshouldonlybegrantedwhenitisestablishedthat:(a)therulingofthecourtbelowrepresentsafundamentalillegality,(b)therulingconstitutesafailuretoproceedaccordingtotheessentialrequirementsofthelaw,(c)therulingistantamounttothedenialofeitherpartyofadayincourt,(d)theactionofthetrialjudgewaswithoutlegalauthority,(e)theactionofthetrialjudgeconstitutedaplainandpalpableabuseofdiscretion,or(f)eitherpartyhaslostarightorinterestthatmayneverberecaptured. Underthesecriteria,treatingthedefendantsimproperRule3appealasaRule10extraordinaryappealisnotappropriateunderthecircumstancesofthecaseatbar.Thetrialjudgepossessedtheauthorityanddiscretiontoacceptthedefendantsguiltypleaandgrantjudicialdiversion.Furthermore,thedefendantcouldchallengeherguiltypleainapostconvictionproceedingifanadjudicationofguilteveroccurs.SeeTenn.CodeAnn.4030203))(1997).Additionally,adirect %  appealisnottheusualmechanismforchallengingthevalidityofaguiltyplea.*See `'  Statev.*Antonio))Demonte))Lyons,No.))01C01))9508CR00263(Tenn.))Crim)).))App))., @)" Nashville,Aug.15,1997)(guiltypleasaregenerallychallengedbymotionsinthetrialcourtpursuanttoTennesseeRuleofCriminalProcedure32(f),orifRule32(f)isnotavailable,thenbypostconvictionpetition).Thepresentcaseillustratestheprobleminraisingtheguiltypleaissueondirectappeal.ThesparserecordreflectsonlyabriefpleasubmissionhearingwhichthetrialcourtheldpursuanttoTennesseeRuleofCriminalProcedure11.Thedefendant,whowasservingasherowncounsel,indicatedthatshewas)subitting))submitting)thebestinterestpleavoluntarily.Thisrecordisdevoidofanybasisforthiscourttofindthatthepleawasinvalid.Cf. @8.2 Statev.BrandonWilson,No.03C019609CC00352,slipop.at10(Tenn.Crim.  :04 App.,Knoxville,Sept.1,1998)(directappealchallengetovalidityofguiltyplea,baseduponmentalincompetency,entertainedbyappellatecourtwhentherecordreflectedafullevidentiaryhearinginthetrialcourtontheissueofcompetency),perm.))app)).))granted)))))))(Tenn.199)))1)))9)))),))).))).)))).)))))))  ))))Foralltheabo))))))vereasons,)))ru)))theRule3)))apeal))))willno))))l)))appeal)));))))))3will)))will  notbetreatedas)*an*)appealunderRule10.))))) ThestatecontendsthatthedefendanthaswaivedherrighttoappealtheentryofherbestinterestguiltypleabecauseshedidnotfileamotiontowithdrawherguiltypleainthetrialcourtpursuanttoTennesseeRuleofCriminalProcedure32(f). #  4      ׀Ifthedefendantwasattemptingtowithdrawherguiltyplea @ pursuanttoRule32(f),thensheshouldhavefiledamotiontowithdrawherguiltypleainthetrialcourt.However,inalllikelihood,thisissueismootbecausethedefendantsoneyeardiversionperiodendedonMarch31,1999.Attheendofthediversionperiod,dependingonthedefendantscompliancewiththeconditionsofprobation,thedefendantwillbedischargedandtheproceedingsdismissedoranadjudicationofguiltwillbeentered.SeeTenn.CodeAnn.4035313(a)(2) %  (1997).Ifajudgmentofconvictionisentered,thedefendantcouldfileamotiontowithdrawherguiltypleapursuanttoRule32(f)beforethejudgmentbecamefinal.SeegenerallyStatev.AntonioDemonteLyons,No.01C019508CR00263(Tenn.  +!$ Crim.App.,Nashville,Aug.15,1997). -#& Ї Wefindthatthiscourtlacksthejurisdictiontoreviewthedefendantsappeal.Accordingly,theappealisdismissed.)))))) )))̛      )))   h     h         h      p      x      h     ________________________________    h     JAMESCURWOODWITT,JR.,JUDGECONCUR:_______________________________DAVIDG.HAYES,JUDGE_______________________________JOHNEVERETTWILLIAMS,JUDGE