WPC| PHs% qFECn.6Վ+2 PZmU4-F^@Lƈ:G9q'AGSq?0\CGӻ>-94܅kp/CZ"knq`*B+`Mc0WQg \g1t mg {' $_=2l)`e'05]!0/N4Pb%PbcQzcr+Z[XrL_] *|џ *3bOfjD4˙D6A١mkQ@M/4'UHGR- DU 2CDjm3v{WQ82vnY|_Ðl >#b5_CJOk3 RN&;09Vp˖SU❣4ܙLrKy޵>ë7=Ti{l+)U.> %lbrv 0D= n D 0(L U:t w 4f U:z 0 0DM U : U: #! N&( m********* AQA 0DX B 0D D/ B, D3I<6X9`(CourierX   *D$X6XXX `   1    ݀Thevalueofthetruckisnotapparentfromtherecord.Thisvalueisin `  directcorrelationtotheclassificationoftheoffenseoftheft.ThereareseveralreferencestothedefendantbeingconvictedofaClassCfelonyfortheft,whichcorrelatestoatheftofover$10,000butlessthan$60,000.SeeTenn.Code   Ann.3914105(4)(1997).However,thepresentencereportreflectsthedefendantwasindictedfortheftover$1000butlessthan$10,000,aClassDfelony.X6XXX6SeeTenn.CodeAnn.3914105(3)(1997).Neitherthejudgmentnor d indictmentforthetheftoffenseareintheappellaterecord.#X6XXX6#ԀHowever,thismatter J isnotrelevanttoourdeterminationinthiscase.(3#$  !   !#"  XXXX$XX   Ad FILEDXX$  September3,1999CecilCrowson,Jr.AppellateCourtClerkdAh 3|xe<6X9`(CourierXx6X@`7X@($,  AZ"Arial RegulareeEeeDeePeDeUeeeeeEeeEeeeDeeEeeEeeDeeDeeDe eeӀe{Z=',cAZ"Arial Regular(I(2+$$  !  XXXX `   0  (#$  0  ,cAZ"Arial Regular,yAZ"Arial RegularHP LaserJet 8000 DN PS0U !#(C<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3#$  !   d($$   1  ''' dxdP Pd""""'dxd  !  eeeeee`   TR[A'Legal3'A' Legal3'T XXXX8  XXdd8  eeer(<,(j 8` `@Ef ` ttx0` re_ et(>.*jx` `@E~ ` 8ttxPX te@ INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE F  ̀@(ATJACKSON   @CC%JULY1999SESSION     STATEOFTENNESSEE, h     ) p  4   `     h     ) p     `  Appellee, h     ) p C.C.A.No.02C019812CC00385 f   `     h     ) p  L  vs. `     h     ) p HardinCounty 2   `     h     ) p       JEFFERYRUSSELLUTLEY,    ) p Hon.C.CreedMcGinley,Judge    `     h     ) p     `  Appellant. h     ) p (Sentencing) p  `     h      p  `     h      `     h      p FORTHEAPPELLANT: h      p FORTHEAPPELLEE: h  GUYT.WILSON   h      p PAULG.SUMMERS  4 DistrictPublicDefender h      p AttorneyGeneral&Reporter    RICHARDW.DEBERRY  h      p PATRICIAC.KUSSMAN    AssistantPublicDefender h      p AssistantAttorneyGeneral !x 117NorthForrestAvenue h      p 425FifthAve.N.,2dFloor "^ Camden,TN38320 h      p Nashville,TN372430493 #D  `     h      p  `     h      p G.ROBERTRADFORD  p%  `     h      p DistrictAttorneyGeneral \&   `     h      p 111ChurchStreet `     h      p Huntingdon,TN38344 `     h      p JOHNW.OVERTON  ) $  `     h      p AssistantDistrictAttorneyGeneral  *!%  `     h      p P.O.Box484 +f"&  `     h      p Savannah,TN383720484  ,L#' OPINIONFILED:________________AFFIRMEDJAMESCURWOODWITT,JR.,JUDGE  7V.3  T;17 @qq* OPINION  ;P28 ЇX6XX X6'X, XX' # X6XXX6?#Thedefendant,JefferyRussellUtley,appealsfromhissentences `  imposedforarsonandtheftintheHardinCountyCircuitCourt.SeeTenn.Code ,  Ann.3914301(a),14103(1997).ThetrialcourtimposedconcurrentthreeyearsentencesintheTennesseeDepartmentofCorrection.Inthisdirectappeal,thedefendantchallengesthemannerofserviceofhissentences.Afterareviewoftherecord,thebriefsoftheparties,andtheapplicablelaw,weaffirmthetrialcourt.X6XX X6 \  # X6XXX6*#X6XX X6 Thefactsofthiscasearenotdescribedindetailintherecord.OnOctober14,1998,thedefendantpleadedguiltytoarsonandtheft.TheguiltypleaforarsonaroseoutofaMay29,1998incidentinwhichthedefendantsetfiretoanapartmentwhichcausedsomedamage.ThetheftoffenseoccurredonJune7,1998,whenthedefendantandhiscodefendantstoleaNissanpickuptruckvaluedoverathousanddollars($1000). #  1      ׀   Atthetimeofsentencing,the23yearolddefendanthadasparseemploymenthistory.Hehadbeenmarriedforafewmonthsandhadtwostepchildren.Hedroppedoutofhighschool,buthelaterobtainedhisGED.Thedefendanthaspreviousconvictionsforassault,aggravatedassault,theft,possessionanddistributionofintoxicatingliquor,andDUI. # X6XXX6#X6XX X6Thedefendantcontendsheshouldhavebeengrantedsomeformof P-#( alternativesentencing.# X6XXX6b#X6XX X6ԀWhenthereisachallengetothelength,range,ormanner /%* ofserviceofasentence,itisthedutyofthiscourttoconductadenovoreviewof   therecordwithapresumptionthatthedeterminationsmadebythetrialcourtarecorrect.SeeTenn.CodeAnn.4035401(d)(1997).Thispresumptionis   conditionedupontheaffirmativeshowingintherecordthatthetrialcourtconsideredthesentencingprinciplesandallrelevantfactsandcircumstances.Statev.Ashby,823S.W.2d166,169(Tenn.1991). Theburdenofshowingthat   thesentenceisimproperisupontheappellant.Id.Intheeventtherecordfailsto ` demonstratetherequiredconsiderationbythetrialcourt,reviewofthesentenceispurelydenovo.Id.Ifappellatereviewreflectsthetrialcourtproperlyconsidered   allrelevantfactorsanditsfindingsoffactareadequatelysupportedbytherecord,thiscourtmustaffirmthesentence, evenifwewouldhavepreferredadifferentresult.Statev.Fletcher,805S.W.2d785,789(Tenn.Crim.App.1991). !`  Inmakingitssentencingdetermination,thetrialcourt,attheconclusionofthesentencinghearing,determinestherangeofsentenceandthendeterminesthespecificsentenceandtheproprietyofsentencingalternativesbyconsidering(1)theevidence,ifany,receivedatthetrialandthesentencinghearing,(2)thepresentencereport,(3)theprinciplesofsentencingandargumentsastosentencingalternatives,(4)thenatureandcharacteristicsofthecriminalconductinvolved,(5)evidenceandinformationofferedbythepartiesontheenhancementandmitigatingfactors,(6)anystatementsthedefendantwishestomakeinthedefendantsbehalfaboutsentencing,and(7)thepotentialforrehabilitationortreatment.SeeTenn.CodeAnn.4035210(a),(b)(1997);Tenn.CodeAnn.40 `6-0 35103(5)(1997);Statev.Holland,860S.W.2d53,60(Tenn.Crim.App.1993). @8.2 # XGXXXG#XGXX XG  :04  # XGXXXG #XGXX XGInthepresentcase,thetrialcourtssentencingdeterminationis `  entitledtothepresumptionofcorrectness# XGXXXG #XGXX XGbecause# XGXXXG!#XGXX XGtherecordreflectsthatit @  consideredtherelevantsentencingeeprinciples.# XGXXXG"#ee     XGXX XG   Adefendant whoisanespeciallymitigatedorstandardoffenderconvictedofaClassC,D,orEfelonyispresumedtobeafavorablecandidateforalternativesentencingoptionsintheabsenceofevidencetocontrary.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035102(6)(1997).Thus,adefendantwhomeetsthecriteriaofsection4035102(6)ispresumedeligibleforalternativesentencingunlesssufficientevidencerebutsthepresumption.However,offenderswhomeetthecriteriaarenotautomaticallyentitledtosuchreliefbecausesentencingissuesshouldbedeterminedbythefactsandcircumstancespresentedineachcase.Statev.Taylor,  744S.W.2d919,922(Tenn.Crim.App.1987).ee# XGXXXG"#XGXX XGee Thedefendant,aRangeIstandardoffender,enjoyedthepresumptionoffavorablecandidacyforalternativesentencingfortheoffensesinvolvedinthiscase.SeeTenn.CodeAnn.4035102(6)ee(1997).Further,thedefendantwas `'  eligibleforprobationbecausehiseffectivesentencewasthreeyears.# XGXXXG &#SeeTenn. @)" CodeAnn.4035303(a)(1997).Indeterminingwhethertograntprobation,thejudgemustconsiderthenatureandcircumstancesoftheoffense,thedefendantscriminalrecord,hisbackgroundandsocialhistory,hispresentcondition,includinghisphysicalandmentalcondition,thedeterrenteffectonothercriminalactivity,andthelikelihoodthatprobationisinthebestinterestsofboththepublicandthedefendant.SeeStillerv.State,516S.W.2d617,620(Tenn.1974).Thedefendant 4 +. bearstheburdenofestablishingsuitabilityforprobation,evenwhenthedefendantispresumedtobeeeeeligibleforprobationeesuitableforalternativeeeevseeeeeeeesentencinge.eeeeSeeTenn.CodeAnn.40 @8.2 35303(a)(b)(1997).XGXX XG  :04 Ї# XGXXXGV+#XGXX XGee# XGXXXG+#eXXX XrM# XrMXXXʷ.#XXX XrM# XrMXXX.#eXGXX XG # XGXXXG,#XGXX XGThetrialcourtimplicitlyfoundthedefendantwasnotamenableto @  rehabilitationbecausemeasureslessrestrictivethanconfinementewereeehadproveneunsuccessful.Thetrialcourtnotedthedefendantsfelonyrecorde,eandthefactthatthedefendant failedtoabidebytherulesandregulationsofpreviousalternativesentences.Inviewofthesefacts,thedefendantfailedtocarrytheburdenofestablishinghissuitabilityforprobation.Thetrialcourtsdeterminationthatthedefendantwasnotafitcandidateforprobationisamplysupportedbytherecord.# XGXXXG,#XGXX XGee   eeee Turningtootherformsofalternativesentencing,eeeeeeeanoffenderisee TobeeeligiblefortheCommunityCorrectionsprogram,eaneeifheeeoffendermustemeetesethefollowingcriteria: ` (1)Personswho,withoutthisoption,wouldbeincarceratedinacorrectionalinstitution;(2)Personswhoareconvictedofpropertyrelated,ordrug/alcoholrelatedfelonyoffensesorotherfelonyoffensesnotinvolvingcrimesagainsttheperson...(3)Personswhoareconvictedofnonviolentfelonyoffenses;(4)Personswhoareconvictedoffelonyoffensesinwhichtheuseorpossessionofaweaponwasnotinvolved;(5)Personswhodonotdemonstrateapresentorpastpatternofbehaviorindicatingviolence;(6)Personswhodonotdemonstrateapatternofcommittingviolentoffenses;andPersonswhoaresentencedtoincarcerationoronescapeatthetimeofconsiderationwillnotbeeligible. ` Tenn.CodeAnn.4036106(a)(1)(6)(1997).Althoughthetrialcourtdidnotmakeafindingregardingwhetherthedefendantwaseligibleforcommunitycorrections,wefindthedefendant# XGXXXG/#XGXX XGtobeineligible.Thedefendantwasconvictedofassaultand P7-1 aggravatedassault,whichindicatesapastpatternofviolentbehavior.SeeTenn. 09/3 CodeAnn.4036106(a)(5)(1997).# XGXXXG5#XGXX XGԀThus,thetrialcourtdidnoterrindenyinga `  communitycorrectionssentence.# XGXXXG86#XGXX XG eeeAdditionally,teeTehereeeeeiseeesufficienteeadditionaleeeeeevidenceintherecordtorebutthepresumptionofthedefendantscandidacyforeeeotherformsofealternativeeesentencing.Forallthedefendantsprevioussentences,hereceivedatleastaperiodofprobation.However,hecontinuedtocommitoffensesandhisprobationarysentenceswererevoked.Therefore,therecordsupportsthetrialcourtsfindingthatconfinementwasnecessarybecause measureslessrestrictivethanconfinementhavefrequently...beenappliedunsuccessfullytothedefendant.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035103(1)(C)(1997).# XGXXXG6#XGXX XGeee eeeAccordingly,eetheevidencesupportssentencesoftotalconfinement.eee  ЀThejudgmentisaffirmed.eee񀀀ee# XGXXXG#:#XGXX XGe !` eeee# XGXXXG>;#XGXX XGeeeHowever,eee# XGXXXG;#eeethetrialcourtfoundthedefendanthadviolatedpreviousalternative  \ sentencingrulesandregulationsandhadbeenrevokedfromprobation.Thus,trialcourtfoundthedefendantwasnotafitcandidateforalternativesentencingorprobation.eeeXGXX XGeeee e# XGXXXG?=#e Thesentencesimposedbythetrialcourtareaffirmed.eee    h     ________________________________    h     JAMESCURWOODWITT,JR.,JUDGECONCUR:_______________________________JOSEPHM.TIPTON,JUDGE_______________________________JOHNEVERETTWILLIAMS,JUDGE