WPC  )~nPVޯaS4Ds1^ɐP>'"XH2Ů&sN)HjjۊoSC>X^2sబqL}wLcxҥ1ֵr-v 9Tz;U V@@' |Eba.XY%ば1kԩJj@,*`Rk@KnF\4cJ e?ukiɧWh-1$kBiGޒ X-3TRa:][̏"5 Fu\g\,@ql4ֆ{ (^JuH|rϽT) TfS'f->j9tEŌND qCP9pdlՓi!hgê*\VgYmLJi9^tk=a6"a[65] cW#U N % 0:N U@ ^ S w_ 4c w  m  E B HP LaserJet 40500(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX($USUS.,(I Z(Times New Roman c9-s 3j1,on1 3|xU  d !USUS.,  _   XX@tt#X`XU#XX`INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @WW$ATKNOXVILLE#X`X#XX`Ԉ &    @  @` April23,2002Session L #X`XL# XX`STATEOFTENNESSEEv.JOSEPHAND_EVANGELINE_ԀCOMBS  J @@ #X`X#AppealfromtheCriminal @ CourtforSullivanCounty  p @@No.S41,992andS41,993R.JerryBeck,Judge 4  @@*AV) ` dE< ` A  \  @@TTNo.E20002801CCAR3CD W  No.E20002800CCAR3CD C  September25,_2002_ /  AV) ` dE<` A      GaryR.Wade,_P.J._,concurring.      WhileIconcurintheresultsreachedbythemajority,itismyviewthatthefailuretocharge  thelesserincludedoffensesoffacilitationofespeciallyaggravated_kidnapping_Ԁandfalse v imprisonmentonthechargeofespeciallyaggravated_kidnapping_Ԁandrecklessendangermentand b assaultonthechargeofaggravatedassaultwas,infact,error.Themajorityimpliesthatbutdoesnot N soassert.Ialsobelievethattheerrorisharmlessbeyondareasonabledoubtastoeachofthose : convictions.Mostrecently,inStatev.Allen,69S.W.3d181,189(Tenn.2002),X`XXX`oursupremecourt &v establishedthatacontextualanalysisoftheentirerecordwasnecessaryinordertodetermine b whetherthefailuretochargealesserincludedoffensequalifiedasharmlessbeyondareasonable N doubt.Inmyopinion,theAllenrulingnegatesanyimplicationin#X`XXX`V#Statev.Williams,977S.W.2d : 101,106(Tenn.1998),X`XXX`thatthefailuretoinstructonlesserincludedoffenseswillalwaysbe & harmlesswhenthejuryreturnsaverdicttwolevelsinexcessofanomittedlesserincludedoffense.    #X`XXX`F #WithregardtodefendantJosephCombsconvictionforaggravatedperjury,Ifullyagreethat   thetrialcourtsfailuretoprovideaninstructiononthelesserincludedoffenseofperjurywaserror !  thatdoesnotqualifyasharmlessbeyondareasonabledoubtandthatanewtrialshouldbegranted r"! ontheprimarycharge.X`XXX` ^#"    `     h     ___________________________________ '^"&    `     h     GARYR.WADE,PRESIDINGJUDGE#X`XXX` #