WPC  >GbU!>sSa:d#;\+ ' =^7E:  iN/mY͉YR(N6/g]rdf ROmew zLL޶}=6ds1 ;Z%sn@fٞSYS$ G(C=IcŌK,i-7f4F0fBNd-~:KPj,=\0eGFFa7eb@LkO#Q-,UNF % 0( U: w@ 4< P _ g U:P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P B D3 0D AO m m 0D3 D/w B (hH  Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($,  AZ"Arial Regular 34D56D7U89D:U;5e<ӀuM%3|xE  XXXX jX X   Ad FILED XX j  November19,1998CecilW.CrowsonAppellateCourtClerkdAM ,cAZ"Arial Regular d%%%%'dxd(3$ !  -C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5($$   1  ' dxdP Pd !  ;;;;XXXX  TR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T<r *<,(j 8` `@E` 8ttxP  rߛ<@  INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @FF'ATNASHVILLE@#NOVEMBER1998SESSIONGENEH.CRANK, @-)  ` @-) p NO.01C019708CR00318   L   ` Appellant,@-)  8  @-) p DAVIDSONCOUNTY     VS. @-)   @-) p HON.J.RANDALLWYATT,JR.,   STATEOFTENNESSEE @-) p JUDGE    @-) ` Appellee.@-) p (HabeasCorpus) d (  @(#(#( FORTHEAPPELLANT: L GENEH.CRANK,ProSe $  #108161  SouthCentralCorrectionalCenterApolloAA225P.O.Box279Clifton,TN;;384250279;; X  FORTHEAPPELLEE: L JOHNKNOXWALKUP  $ AttorneyGeneralandReporter KARENM.YACUZZO    AssistantAttorneyGeneralCordellHullBuilding,2ndFloor425FifthAvenueNorthNashville,TN372430493 VICTORS.JOHNSONIII   F& DistrictAttorneyGeneral2222ndAvenueNorthWashingtonSquare,Suite500Nashville,TN372011649 `&!, (  @( OPINIONFILED:򀀀 -(2 AFFIRMEDJOEG.RILEY,JUDGE  5,1;  74XXdXXd7@qq* OPINION    `  ` Petitionerappealsthesummarydismissalofhispetition;;forwritof;;;;habeas T corpus.Thepetitionerclaimshisindictmentforaggravatedrapeandfirstdegree $ t burglarywasvoidforfailingtosetforththerequisitemensrea.However,therecord  D doesnotcontaintheindictmentatissue,therebyprecludingtheCourtfromconductinganadequatereview.Nevertheless,assumingthattheindictmentreadsasclaimedbypetitioner,wefindnomerittohisclaimand AFFIRM thetrialcourts \  dismissalofthehabeascorpuspetition. 4 @$ PROCEDURALHISTORY     ` Petitionerfiledforawritofhabeascorpuswiththetrialcourt.Hechallenged t thevalidityofhis1984indictmentforaggravatedrapeandfirstdegreeburglary.Petitionerclaimedthattheindictmentfailedtoallegethepropermensrea,making ` itfaciallyinvalidanddivestingthetrialcourtofjurisdictionasperStatev.Hill,954 0 S.W.2d725(Tenn.1997).Thetrialcourtdismissedthepetition.@, I.  D% $  ` Withoutavalidindictment,therecanbenojurisdictionand;;no;;;;prosecution.;;Dykesv.Compton,__;;S.W.2d;;__,__(Tenn.1998).;;;; [;;T]he;;;;validityofanindictment *&* andtheefficacyoftheresultingconvictionmaybeaddressedthroughapetitionforwritofhabeascorpuswhentheindictmentissodefectiveastodeprivethecourtof L.). jurisdiction.;;Id.at__.Thus,thiscaseisproperlybeforeourCourtintheposture 0l+0 ofahabeascorpusproceeding. 18-2 99::@, II.  9l4:  ` Itistheappellantsdutytopreparearecordwhichconveysafairandaccurateaccountofwhattranspiredwithrespecttotheissueswhichformthebasisoftheappealinordertoallowforameaningfulappellatereview.Tenn.R.;;App;;.P.24;Statev.;;Oody;;,823;;S.W.2d;;554,559(Tenn.;;Crim;;.;;App;;.1991).Thisappealis `  basedsolelyuponsufficiencyoftheindictment,yetpetitionerfailedtoincludeacopyoftheindictmentintherecord.Tenn.CodeAnn.2921107(b)(2)providesthatifpetitionerinapetitionforwritofhabeascorpusisrestrainedofhisliberty by  virtueofanylegalprocess,acopythereofshallbeannexed,orasatisfactoryreasongivenforitsabsence.Thisprovisionofthestatuteis mandatoryandthefailuretocomplywithsamemaybegroundsfordismissingthepetition.Stateex P rel.Woodv.Johnson,216Tenn.531,393;;S.W.2d;;135,136(1965);seealsoState 0 exrel.;;Kuntz;;v.;;Bomar;;,214Tenn.500,381;;S.W.2d;;290,291(1964).Thus, ` petitionerhasnotmetthedutywhichentitleshimtoacompleteappellatereview.π ` However,therecordisnotcompletelydevoidofmaterialuponwhichan   appellatereviewcanbeconducted.Petitionerdidallegetheindictmentswordinginhisoriginalpetitionforwritofhabeascorpus.Thus,weelecttoaddress $" petitionersappealonthemeritsinspiteofthelessthancompleteappellaterecord.@+ III.  0*%(  ` Petitionercomplainsthattheindictmentunderwhichhewasconvictedisvoidforfailingtoallegethepropermens;;rea;;foreachoffense.Wedisagree. / +.  ` OurSupremeCourtsdecisioninHillestablishedtherequirementsforavalid 1-0 indictmentwhenthelegislaturedoesnotexpresslyrequirenorplainlydispensewiththerequirementforaculpablementalstate,andtheindictmentfailstoallegeamentalstate.Thoserequirementsare:8 ` (1)thelanguageoftheindictment[mustbe]sufficienttomeettheconstitutionalrequirementsofnoticetotheaccusedofthecharge  :p59 againstwhichtheaccusedmustdefend,adequatebasisforentryofaproperjudgment,andprotectionfromdoublejeopardy; ` `  8 ` (2)theformoftheindictment[mustmeet]therequirementsofTenn.CodeAnn.4013202;and ` `  8 ` (3)thementalstate[mustbeableto]belogicallyinferredfromtheconductalleged. ` `  954;;S.W.2d;;at72627. ` AlthoughHillconcernedapost1989indictmentandthecaseunderreview P  isapre1989indictment,theSupremeCourtinDykesfoundtheHillanalysis as 0  relevanttocrimescommittedunderthe1979Actasitistothosecommittedunderthe1989Act.Dykes,__;;S.W.2d;;2__,__23at__3.Therefore,Hillisrelevanttopetitioners  1984indictment.@DD$ A.AggravatedRape  `  ` Theaggravatedrapestatuteatthetimeofpetitionersoffenseread:8 ` Aggravatedrapeisunlawfulsexualpenetrationofanotheraccompaniedbyanyofthefollowingcircumstances...Forceorcoercionisusedtoaccomplishtheactandthedefendantisarmedwithaweaponoranyarticleusedorfashionedinamannertoleadthevictimreasonablytobelieveittobeaweapon.Tenn.CodeAnn.392603(a)(1)(1982). ` `  Theaggravatedrapeindictmentallegedlyread:8 `  ...GeneH.Crank,heretofore,towit,onthe;;9th;;dayofJuly,1984andpriortothereturnofthisindictment,withforceandarms,intheCountyaforesaid,unlawfully,andunlawfully[sic]havesexualpenetrationofMarshaD.Warrenwhilesaiddefendantwasarmedwithaknifeoranarticleusedinamannerwhilehelead[sic]MarshaD.Warrentobelieveis[sic]wasaweapon.ThesaidunlawfulsexualpenetrationwasinviolationofTennesseeCodeAnnotated,Section392603,andagainstthepeaceanddignityoftheStateofTennessee.! ` `   ` ApplyingtheHillanalysistothischarge,itisobviousthatpetitionersclaim -@), fails.Thelanguageoftheindictmentclearlyadvisespetitionerofthecrimeforwhichheischarged;providesabasisforaproperjudgment;andprotectspetitionerfromdoublejeopardy.TheindictmentcomportswiththerequirementsofTenn.CodeAnn.4013202.4And45Furthermore5,66thereissufficientconductallegedfromwhichpetitionersmentalstatemaybelogicallyinferred.Thisissuehasnomerit.7 0948 7@{{! B.FirstDegreeBurglary    ` Thefirstdegreeburglarystatuteatthetimeofpetitionersoffenseread:8 ` Burglaryisthebreakingandenteringintoadwellinghouse,oranyotherhouse,building,roomorroomsthereinusedandoccupiedbyanypersonorpersonsasadwellingplaceorlodgingeitherpermanentlyortemporarilyandwhetherasowner,renter,tenant,lesseeorpayingguest,bynight,withintenttocommitafelony.Tenn.CodeAnn.393401(a)(1982). ` `  Petitionersburglaryindictmentallegedlyread:8 `  ...GeneH.Crank,heretofore,towit,onthe;;9th;;dayofJuly,1984,andpriortothereturnofthisindictment,intheCountyandStateaforesaid,unlawfully,feloniously,forciblyandviolently,didbreakandenter,inthenighttime,thedwellinghomeofanother,towit:oneMarshaD.Warren...tocommitafelony,towit:Larceny,didthenandthereandthereinunlawfullyandfeloniouslytake,stealandcarryawaycertaingoodsandchattel,towit:sixdollarsingoodandlawfulcurrencyoftheUnitedStatesofAmerica. ` `  & ` Again8,8theHillanalysisleadsustotheconclusionthatpetitionersclaimfails. P Thewordingoftheindictmentgivespetitionernoticeofthechargeagainsthim,providesthebasisforaproperjudgment,andprotectshimfromdoublejeopardy.Again,theindictmentcomportswithTenn.CodeAnn.4013202.Further,theindictmentallegesmorethansufficientconductfromwhichpetitionersculpablestateofmindmaybeinferred.Thisissuehasnomerit.@xx( CONCLUSION  p&!$  ` Basedupontheforegoing,we AFFIRM thetrialcourtsdismissalof 0*%( petitionerswritofhabeascorpus. ,`'*   :p59 Ї/(#____________________________ `     h      p JOEG.RILEY,JUDGE  `   CONCUR: ____________________________   DAVIDG.HAYES,JUDGE ____________________________  P L.T.;;LAFFERTY;;,;;;;SENIORJUDGE ;;;;