WPC UF4ykVlB9 jfCB3({O&$3Q}sNzzb#6%la?lmU̓`G2WR3 )Νe:ͱ#zʳG>Ѯ4aȫF.Au0>V`(7#)N + /!@[Zj*#=<1Rh}} i"G!*K궧YJpV:K(V7}N3ql8**wr% lZ["ɕS{:r!L Neú#Z.[þmB =0ɖ;gHp޶rאHGնu@]>"8y3~OyX%h8+[*# LU:W % 0Dw@4/> 0 0DW \ 9 0@^UU:)U:0000000 B8 AQU 0Dl 0D 0D D/88 Bg D3HP LaserJet 4HPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nL,cAZ"Arial RegularX($X JKLMUN[OPpeQ RDSӀq$lar3|x^   $X   2    5XXTheappellantfiledhisprosepetitionforawritofhabeascorpuspriortoreceivingpermissionto  appealtothesupremecourtinthepostconvictionproceeding.Hisappealinthatcaseiscurrentlypending.Althoughnotraisedbyeitherside,wenotethattheappellantshabeascorpuspetitionmayrunsimultaneouslywithhisappealtothesupremecourtsincethecasesinvolveseparateanddistinctissues.SeeLaneyv.State,826S.W.2d117,11819(Tenn.1992).(8(3$ !X     0  (#$  0   R  $X   3    XXTrialcourtsmaysummarilydismissapetitionforawritofhabeascorpusifthepetitionfailsto  stateacognizableclaimonitsface.SeeTenn.CodeAnn.2921109(Supp.1997). /  $X   5    XXTherapestatutesinvolvedinappellantscasedonotspecifyamentalstate.Tenn.CodeAnn.  3913502,3913503(1989).Therefore,asoursupremecourtnotedinHill, thementalelementis  satisfiediftheindictmentallegesthatthedefendantcommittedtheproscribedactwithintent,knowledge,orrecklessness.Seeid,(citingTenn.CodeAnn.3911301(c)).Becausetherapeoffenses B : necessarilyrequireamentalstateofintent,knowledge,orrecklessness,thenatureoftherapechargesintheindictmentinferstherequisitemensrea.Seeid.󀀀   $X   4    XXTheappellantwaschargedwithmultiplecountsofrapeandaggravatedrapethatoccurred  betweentheyears1983andNovember4,1993.Eachcountsetforthadateorarangeoftimeinwhichtheparticularoffenseoccurred.Ontherapecountsthatoccurredbefore1989,theappellantwaschargedwithviolatingTennesseeCodeAnnotatedSection392603(repealed1989).    T  $X   5    XXSeeHill954S.W.2dat729.Therapestatutesinvolvedinappellantscasedonotspecifya  mentalstate.Tenn.CodeAnn.3913502,3913503(1989).Therefore,asoursupremecourtnotedinHill, thementalelementissatisfiediftheindictmentallegesthatthedefendantcommittedthe | proscribedactwithintent,knowledge,orrecklessness.Seeid,(citingTenn.CodeAnn.3911 B : 301(c)).Becausetherapeoffensesnecessarilyrequireamentalstateofintent,knowledge,orrecklessness,thenatureoftherapechargesintheindictmentinferstherequisitemensrea.Seeid.󀀀  $X   1    5XXTherecordisunclearastowhichcountswereincludedinappellantspleaagreement.,cAZ"Arial Regular  ""  XXXXXX   Ad FILEDXX   September9,1998  CecilCrowson,Jr.5XXAppellateCourtClerk ,cAZ"Arial Regular d!"#$&C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  (3$ !  ($$   1  ((' dxdP Pd'dxd !X  PPPFFPTR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T  7XXdXXd7  PSr )<,(j 8` `@E  ` ttx$X rߛS@ INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @*ATKNOXVILLE@&JANUARY1998SESSIONFRANKCRITTENDEN,   8   ) 80   0      8   )  PFFPPP03C01PPPFFP9707CC00315    Appellant     8   )     0      8   )  MORGANCOUNTY   v.  0      8   )     0      8   )  HON.E.EUGENEPFFPPPELBENPPPFFP #    CHARLESJONES,Warden, 8   )   exrel.STATEOFTENNESSEE 8   )  (HabeasCorpus) z    0      8   )FortheAppellant:     8     FortheAppellee:  FrankCrittenden,proPFFPPPsePPPFFP   8     JohnKnoxWalkup    PFFPPPM.C.R.C.F.PPPFFP,No.244405   8     AttorneyGeneral&Reporter  P.O.Box2000PFFPPPWartburgPPPFFP,TN.378872000 8     TimothyF.PFFPPPBehanPPPFFP    0      8     AssistantAttorneyGeneral  0      8     425FifthAvenueNorth  0      8     PFFPPP2dPPPFFPFloor,PFFPPPCordellPPPFFPHullBuilding  0      8     Nashville,TN.372430493  0      8     CharlesE.Hawk  0      8     DistrictAttorneyGeneral  0      8     P.O.Box703  0      8     Kingston,TN.377630703OPINIONFILED:_____________________AFFIRMEDWILLIAMM.BARKER,JUDGE v8n17S Ї@-OPINION Theappellant,FrankCrittenden,appealsasofrighttheMorganCountyCriminalCourtsdismissalofhisproPFFPPPsePPPFFPpetitionforawritofhabeascorpus.Weaffirm   thejudgmentofthetrialcourt. OnDecember15,1994,theappellantpledguiltytoeight(8)countsofathirtysix(36)countindictmentcharginghimwithaggravatedrape,rape,andunlawfulsexualcontactwithhisdaughter.  #  1      ׀Thetrialcourtsentencedappellanttotwentyfive   (25)yearsforeachoftheeightcounts,withfourcountstobeservedconcurrentlyandfourcountstobeservedconsecutively,foratotaleffectivesentenceofonehundred(100)years.Nodirectappealwastakenfromthetrialcourtsjudgment. Appellant,thereafter,filedapetitionforpostconvictionreliefallegingthat,butfortheineffectiveassistanceofhiscounsel,hewouldhavefiledatimelynoticeofappealfromthetrialcourtssentencingorder.ThisCourtaffirmedthetrialcourtsfindingthatappellanthadwaivedhisrighttoadirectappealandupheldthedismissalofhispostconvictionpetition.SeeFrankCrittendenv.State,No.PFFPPP01C01PPPFFP9510CR 4 , 00344(Tenn.Crim.App.atNashville,Nov.27,1996),perm.app.granted(Tenn.Nov. " 24,1997).N  #  2      ׀ #   TheappellantfiledaproPFFPPPsePPPFFPpetitionforawritofhabeascorpusonJanuary3, %" 1997,challengingthevalidityofhisindictment.RelyinguponthisCourtsdecisioninStatev.RogerDaleHill,No.PFFPPP01C01PPPFFP9508CC00267(Tenn.Crim.App.atNashville, 8)0"& June20,1996),perm.app.granted(Tenn.1996),appellantarguedthattheindictment +#( wasunconstitutionalinfailingtoincludetherequisitemensPFFPPPreaPPPFFPfortheaggravated ,%* rapeoffenses.Thetrialcourtsummarilydismissedappellantspetitionupondeterminingthattheindictmentcontainedsufficientlanguagetoinformtheappellant p0h). oftherapecharges.Thetrialcourtfurtherruledthatanydeficiencyintheindictmentdidnotrenderthejudgmentvoid,andanychallengetotheindictmentshouldhavebeenraisedpriortotheswearinginofthejury. Weagreewiththetrialcourtsdecisiontodismissappellantshabeascorpuspetition.   %  3      ׀First,itisquestionablewhethertheappellantcanchallengehisindictmentin 80 ahabeascorpusproceeding.SeeStateexrel.Newsomv.Henderson,424F@@FPFFPPPS.W.2dPPPFFPF@@F   186,189(Tenn.1968);Haggardv.State,475S.W.2d186,187(Tenn.Crim.App.   1971);Brownv.State,445S.W.2d669,674(Tenn.Crim.App.1969).Butcf.Archer   v.State,851F@@FPFFPPPS.W.2dPPPFFPF@@F157,164(Tenn.1993)(statingthathabeascorpusreliefis h` available onlywhenitappearsuponthefaceofthejudgmentortherecordoftheproceedingsuponwhichthejudgmentisrenderedthataconvictingcourtwaswithoutjurisdictionorauthoritytosentenceadefendant,orthatadefendantssentenceofimprisonmentorotherrestrainthasexpired). Nevertheless,evenwhenaddressedonthemerits,appellantsclaimmustfailinlightofoursupremecourtsdecisioninStatev.Hill,954S.W.2d725,729(Tenn. 0 ( 1997).InHill,theCourtupheldanindictmentthatisvirtuallyidenticaltotheindictment ! inappellantscase.Onthecountsofrape,appellantsindictmentstatedinpertinentpart:8  0 [F@@FPFFPPPO]nPPPFFPF@@Fadayin____,   %  4      ׀inDavidsonCounty,Tennesseeandbefore `'X $ thefindingofthisindictment,[FrankCrittenden]didengageinunlawfulsexualpenetrationof[thevictim](Female,F@@FPFFPPPD.O.B.PPPFFPF@@FFebruary17,1978),andforceorcoercionwasusedtoaccomplishtheact,inviolationofTennesseecodeAnnotated3913503,andagainstthepeaceanddignityoftheStateofTennessee.   (# (# Onthecountsofaggravatedrape,theindictmentstatedasfollows:$8  0 [F@@FPFFPPPO]nPPPFFPF@@Fadayin____,inDavidsonCounty,Tennesseeandbeforethefindingofthisindictment,[FrankCrittenden]didengageinunlawful \0T). sexualpenetrationof[thevictim](Female,F@@FPFFPPPD.O.B.PPPFFPF@@FFebruary17,1978),achildlessthanthirteen(13)yearsofage,inviolationofTennesseeCodeAnnotated3913502,andagainstthepeaceanddignityoftheStateofTennessee.  (# (#   ThelanguageinappellantsindictmentsetsforththestatutoryprovisionsmakingitaClassBfelonyforanyonetounlawfullysexuallypenetrateavictimwiththeuseofforceorcoercion,Tenn.CodeAnn.FF3913503(b),FFandaClassAFelonyforanyonetounlawfullysexuallypenetrateavictimwhenthevictimislessthanthirteen(13)yearsofage.Tenn.CodeAnn.FF3913502(b).FFAlthoughthemensF@@FPFFPPPreaPPPFFPF@@Fforthe   rapeoffensesisomittedfromtheindictment,weconcludethatitcanbelogicallyinferredfromthenatureandlanguageofthePPcharges.KKKGGKIG GIGGI  %  5      IJJLJXXJLJSeeHillJNNO,ONJJNJ954JPPJS.W.2dJPPJat729.JNLXXLJ#XX*+#JNPP RJ Theindictmentcontainsfactsconstitutingeachoffenseandprovidessufficientnoticeofthechargesasmandatedbyourconstitution. Basedupontheforegoing,weconcludethattheindictmentisvalidandaffirmthejudgmentofthetrialcourt. (  0      8     ___________________________  0      8     WILLIAMM.BARKER,JUDGE #  "  CONCUR:____________________________GARYR.WADE,PresidingJudge____________________________JOSEPHM.PFFPPPTIPTONPPPFFP,JUDGERRRRRRRRRRRRPPIP    IRMMRMMRMMRNNRMMRMMRMMRNNRMMRMMRMMRNNRMMRMMRMMRNNRMMRMMRMMRNNRMMRMMRMMRMMQMP    MQPPQQMP    MQ@ INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEEQMP    MQQMP    MQ@*ATKNOXVILLEQMP    MQQMP    MQ@&JANUARY1998SESSIONQMP    MQFRANKQPFFPQPPCRITTENDENPPQPFFPQ,   8   )     0      8   )  QPFFPQPP03C01PPQPFFPQ9707CC00315    Appellant     8   )     0      8   )  MORGANCOUNTYNO.8335   v.  0      8   )     0      8   )  HON.E.EUGENEQPFFPQPPELBENPPQPFFPQ #    CHARLESJONES,Warden, 8   ) z  exrel.STATEOFTENNESSEE 8   )  (HabeasCorpus) h`   0      8   )  0      8   )  Affirmed 6.   0      8   )@TT,JUDGMENT   Cametheappellant,proQPFFPQPPsePPQPFFPQ,andalsocametheattorneygeneralonbehalfof  theState,andthiscasewasheardontherecordonappealfromtheCriminalCourtofMorganCounty;andinconsiderationthereof,thisCourtisoftheopinionthatthereisnoerrorinthejudgmentofthetrialcourt. Inaccordancewiththeopinionfiledherein,itis,therefore,orderedandadjudgedbythisCourtthatthejudgmentofthetrialcourtisaffirmed,andthecaseisremandedtotheCriminalCourtofMorganCountyfortheexecutionofthejudgmentofthatcourtandforthecollectionofthecostsaccruedbelow. Itappearingthattheappellantisindigent,thecostsofappealwillbepaidbytheStateofTennessee.8  0      8   WilliamM.Barker,Judge  0      8   GaryR.Wade,PresidingJudge  0      8   JosephM.QPFFPQPPTiptonPPQPFFPQ,JudgeQ