WPC  BxCB/BRo*73hAEKU@(ߝ?^6;"/ g:2A}φ#1c)-eU Z5mp p6Wp1z*[IÜ3GGLђɵwaEtkOVi!> bKKQ!l4%JaوV;4+rDIU$eC=15`եPc?~疲-@!w C-_)_U,Km(;/zTWG?08bXyUO6YY"ѽfN pH|BUEـX%Msk3?DԾ$$8B$Ӎӈ$Xoty[J[y؍b)W)"&*ЭsΣY@C@vSCHF\xV kE:W#U!N % 0:UN ^ _ wk 4o   m  U@ b N E B HP LaserJet 40500(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX($USUS.,("  Z6Times New Roman Regular$+ yG*tئ 3|xU (hH  Z(Times New Roman - - d !USUS.,  _  88XXdd8  XXINTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  ATKNOXVILLE#X8X#XX8 & May22,2001Session L #X8X-#XX8#X8X# XX8JOHNCLARKGARRISONV.STATEOFTENNESSEE#X8X# XX8 4  #X8Xh#XX8#X8X# AppealfromtheCriminalCourtforKnoxCounty n  No.69737Julian_Guinn_,JudgebyDesignation Z  AV) ` dE<` A n  No.E200000858CCAR3PC i  =Ӏ____________________________________ԀSeptember4,2001 U  AV) ` dE<` A A     Petitioner,JohnClarkGarrison,filedapetitionforpostconvictionreliefattackinghistwo < convictionsfortheftofpropertyoverthevalueof$10,000.00butlessthan$60,000.00.Petitioner ( wasrepresentedbycounselwhofiledthepetitionforpostconvictionreliefonhisbehalf.TheState  filedaresponsetothepetition.Thetrialcourtdismissedthepetitionwithoutanevidentiaryhearing,  findingthatalloftheissueswereeitherpreviouslydetermined,waived,insufficienttoassertspecific  allegationsofineffectiveassistanceofcounsel,orpresentednoquestionofconstitutional  deprivation.Weaffirmthejudgmentofthetrialcourt. t   Tenn.R.App.P.3AppealasofRight;JudgmentoftheCriminalCourtAffirmed  L q ThomasT._Woodall_,J.,deliveredtheopinionofthecourt,inwhichGaryR.Wade,_P.J._,and $t RobertW._Wedemeyer_,J.,joined. ` GregoryP.Isaacs,Knoxville,Tennesseefortheappellant,JohnClarkGarrison. 8 PaulG.Summers,AttorneyGeneralandReporter;PatriciaC._Kussmann_,AssistantAttorney   General;RandallE._Nichols_,DistrictAttorneyGeneral;andC.LeonFranks,AssistantDistrict !  AttorneyGeneral,fortheappellee,StateofTennessee. "! @66' OPINION  p$#   Wehavereviewedtheappellaterecordinthisparticularcase,theopinionsinvolvingthiscase H&!% inthreepriorappeals,andhavetakenjudicialnoticeoftheappellaterecordinthecaseofStatev. 4'"& JohnClarkGarrison,No.03C019601CR00050,1998WL300587,at*23,KnoxCounty(Tenn.  (p#' _Crim_.App.,Knoxville,June10,1998),perm.toapp.denied(Tenn.1999)(concurringinresults  )\$( only),asperapreviousorderofthiscourtfiledasaresultofamotionbyPetitionertosupplement )H%) therecordinthiscase. *4&*   InthepetitionforpostconvictionrelieffiledbyPetitionersretainedcounselinthis , (, proceeding,heallegedfivegroundsforpostconvictionrelief.Inhisfirstground,thePetitioner -(- _allegesthathisconstitutionalrightstodueprocesswereviolatedwhenthetrialcourtorderedan  illegalsentencewhichwasvoidabinitio.Forthetwoconvictionsoftheft,Petitionerwasgiven  sentencesofincarcerationandorderedtopayrestitution.HewassentencedinSeptember1995.The  Petitionerarguesthatatthetimehewassentenced,thelawdidnotallowforaDefendanttobe t requiredtopayrestitutionunlessitwasinconjunctionwithasentenceofprobation.CompareTenn. ` CodeAnn.4035104(c)(1995),withTenn.CodeAnn.4035104(c)(Supp.1996)(effective L  July1,1996).Therefore,hearguesthathissentenceisillegalandvoidabinitio.Thispreciseissue 8  wasaddressedinoneofPetitionerspreviousappealstothisCourt,andwasresolvedagainstthe $ t Petitioner.SeeStateofTennesseev.JohnClarkGarrison,No.E199900121CCAR3CD,2000  ` WL1661491,at*23,KnoxCounty(Tenn.Crim.App.,Knoxville,Nov.6,2000),perm.toapp.  L  denied(Tenn.2001).HefiledanapplicationforpermissiontoappealtotheTennesseeSupreme  8  CourtpursuanttoRule11oftheTennesseeRulesofAppellateProcedure.Thesupremecourtdenied $  hisapplicationonMay14,2001.Thus,thisissuehasbeenpreviouslydetermined.See X8XXX8Tenn.Code   Ann.40-30-206(f)and(h)#X8XX X8#Ԁ(1997)( Agroundforreliefispreviouslydeterminedifacourtof   competentjurisdictionhasruledonthemeritsafterafullandfairhearing.).     Inhissecondgroundforrelief,Petitionerallegesthathisguiltypleastothetwochargesof p theftwereinvoluntarilyenteredwithoutunderstandingthenatureandconsequencesoftheplea.In \ Statev.JohnClarkGarrison,1998WL300587,at*23,thiscourtheldthatapreviouspanelofthis H court(Statev.JohnGarrison,No.03C019305CR00169,1994WL9388,at*1,KnoxCounty 4 (Tenn.Crim.App.,Knoxville,Jan.10,1995)perm.toapp.denied(Tenn.1995), implicitlyfound  p the[Petitioners]guiltypleatobevoluntarilyandknowinglyentered.Again,inPetitionerslast  \ appeal,Statev.JohnClarkGarrison,2000WL1661491at*4,thiscourtheldthattheissueof H whetherthePetitionerspleawasknowinglyandvoluntarilyenteredhadbeenpreviouslydetermined. 4 Wethusarecompelledtoholdthatthisallegedgroundforpostconvictionreliefhasbeenpreviously   determined.     Inhisthirdgroundforpostconvictionrelief,Petitionerallegesthathisconvictionswere  basedonapleaenteredintowithineffectiveassistanceofcounsel.Inhispetition,Petitioneralleges  thatattorneyCharlesBurksrenderedineffectiveassistanceofcounselinhisoriginalproceedings l leadinguptotheguiltyplea.Fromourreviewoftherecord,Mr.BurkswasneverPetitioners X  attorneyofrecord.Priortotheguiltypleas,Mr.BurkswasapproachedbythePetitionersfather D! aboutpossiblybeingretainedtorepresentthePetitioner.ThePetitioneralreadyhadanotherattorney 0"  ofrecord.However,therecorddoessuggestthatMr.Burksdiddiscussthepotentialpleaagreement #l! withPetitionerandPetitionersfather.Inessence,itappearsthatthemoneythatwouldhavebeen $X" spentbyPetitionersfathertoretainMr.Burks,wasusedtowardadownpaymentontherestitution. $D # SinceMr.BurkswasneverPetitionersattorneyofrecord,thenfromalegalstandpoint,itwouldnot %0!$ matterwhetherornotMr.Burksrendered effectiveassistanceofcounsel.Therefore,the &"% allegationsofthepetitionwerenotsufficienttoraiseanissueofineffectiveassistanceofcounsel. '#&   Inhisfourthgroundforpostconvictionrelief,Petitionerallegesthathisdueprocessrights )$( wereviolatedbytheStateofTennesseeathisresentencinghearinginJune1995,whentheState |*%) failedtohonorapleabargainagreementcontrarytothiscourtsrulinginStatev.JohnGarrison, h+&* 1994WL9388,at*1.ThispreciseissuewasraisedandaddressedinthePetitionersdirectappeal  ofthesentencehereceivedattheresentencinghearing,inStatev.JohnClarkGarrison,1998WL  300587,at*3.Therefore,thisissuehasalsobeenpreviouslydetermined.    Inhisfinalgroundforpostconvictionrelief,Petitionerallegesthathisrightstodueprocess ` weredeniedbythetrialcourtwhenaggravatingfactors X8XXX8Ԁweremisappliedandmitigatingfactorswere L  notconsidered,resultingin incorrectlysentencingthepetitioner.Itiswellsettledlawthat 8  sentencingisnotanappropriateissuetobeaddressedinpostconvictionrelief. SeeTenn.CodeAnn. $ t 40-35-401(a)(1997)( #X8XX X8 '# X8XXX8[t]hereisnoappellatereviewofthesentenceinapost-conviction...  ` proceeding)#X8XX X8(# X8XXX8 .ThePetitionercannotcircumventthiswellestablishedruleoflawbymerelyalleging  L  inapostconvictionpetitionthathisrightstodueprocesswereviolatedbyincorrectsentencing.  8  Further,thePetitionerhasfailedtochallengethatthesentenceisvoidorvoidablebecauseofthe $  abridgementofarightguaranteedbytheTennesseeorUnitedStatesConstitutions.Tenn.CodeAnn.   40-30-203(1997).#X8XX X8a)# X8XXX8Therefore,thelastgroundallegedbyPetitionerisnotappropriateforpost   convictionrelief.   @FF% CONCLUSION  p   Havingfullyreviewedtheentirerecordandthebriefsoftheparties,weconcludethatthetrial H courtdidnoterrbydismissingthepetition,andthereforeaffirmthejudgmentofthetrialcourt. 4 #X8XX X8+#X8XXX8   `     h     ___________________________________  \    `     h     THOMAST.WOODALL,JUDGE#X8XXX8-#Ԁ H     XX8    INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  ATKNOXVILLE#X8X.#XX8 & May22,2001Session L #X8X/#XX8#X8X(0# XX8JOHNCLARKGARRISONV.STATEOFTENNESSEE#X8Xn0# XX8 4  #X8X0#XX8#X8X:1# AppealfromtheCriminalCourtforKnoxCounty n  No.69737JulianGuinn,JudgebyDesignation Z  AV) ` dE<` A n  No.E200000858CCAR3PC i  AV) ` dE<` A A   /   JUDGMENT  <     CametheAppellant,JohnClarkGarrison,byandthroughcounsel,andalsocamethe  AttorneyGeneralonbehalfoftheState,andthiscasewasheardontherecordonappealfromthe  CriminalCourtofKnoxCounty;anduponconsiderationthereof,thiscourtisoftheopinionthat  thereisnoreversibleerrorinthejudgmentofthetrialcourt.     `   Itis,therefore,orderedandadjudgedbythisCourtthatthejudgmentofthetrialcourtis ` affirmed,andthecaseisremandedtotheCriminalCourtofKnoxCountyforexecutionofthe L judgmentofthatcourtandforcollectionofcostsaccruedbelow. 8 0   (#(#   X8XXX8CostsofappealaretaxedtotheStateofTennessee. ` #X8XXX8v6#   `     h   PERCURIAM $    `     h   ThomasT.Woodall      `     h   GaryR.Wade,PresidingJudge !     `     h   RobertW.Wedemeyer