WPC<  Ԁ4뎵핚IIH Wˀg-q~lQBC='Rn+u>{e{NgHWywPB}r=ÒZؽ&^R3\jqYUq<^2&)#(3|C.3o5’MKє\Rx%Df7r|\m2׭N _^ *634dLryQ(KFJf\v3j8--ߛ|I^}V'P=c[)O;m!~Pw}* '%ܼwi<T8ew{ԦgP-LIC1ou_#2U!N %I 0:O UN ^ w 4   m N# % U> 0U 0> 0! 0 0 0^ 0 0 0e 0 0 0 0O 0 0 0D 0 0t 0 0 0 0A 0 0 0- 0 0W 0 0 0Q! 0>" 0M" 0E# 0'$ 0 % 0% 0& 0' 0i( 02;) 0m) 0:i* 0Y* 0_* 0 [+ 0e, 0- B*/ D/0 D+F0 0q0 D/w2 02 06t3 03 0:4 0^4 0<J5 1e5U65U*!6 1uK6 726 0c6 0NU77i9i9 0~w:E: 0D: B;;X;X;X;X;b?<?<?<:G<\\IB01S02\CLERKJAC,,,,0(@ Z6Times New Roman RegularX($USUS.,("  Z6Times New Roman Regular1 ~/CCA103|x U     ' ib011r90ib011r9 .   \  `&Times New Roman*+ (_2623  ..*G+G (_25   /%` ` hp x /23  ../%` ` hp x /   *8+8 (_24  ," hp x ,23  ..," hp x ,  *5+5 (_23 ` ) hp x )23  ..) hp x ) ` *2+2 (_22  &hhp x &23  ..&hhp x &  */+/ (_21  #p x #23  ..#p x #  *,+, (_20 h  p x 23  .. p x h *)+) (_19  pp x 23  ..pp x   *&+& (_18   x 23  .. x   *AA (_17  5+ ` hp x 523  Ԁ5+ ` hp x 5  *GG (_16   /%` ` hp x /23  Ԁ/%` ` hp x /   *88 (_15  ," hp x ,23  Ԁ," hp x ,  *55 (_14 ` ) hp x )23  Ԁ) hp x ) ` *22 (_13  &hhp x &23  Ԁ&hhp x &  *// (_12  #p x #23  Ԁ#p x #  *,, (_11 h  p x 23  Ԁ p x h *)) (_10  pp x 23  Ԁpp x   (&& &_9   x 23  Ԁ x   (AA &_8  5+ ` hp x 523  5+ ` hp x 5  (GG &_7   /%` ` hp x /23  /%` ` hp x /   (88 &_6  ," hp x ,23  ," hp x ,  (55 &_5 ` ) hp x )23  ) hp x ) ` (22 &_4  &hhp x &23  &hhp x &  (// &_3  #p x #23  #p x #  (,, &_2 h  p x 23   p x h ()) &_1  pp x 23  pp x   &&& $_   x 23   x   0AA.Normal  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5  <AA:Definition T  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5  <AA:Definition L , 5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 586Definition(hh&H1  5+ ` hp x 5      5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H2  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H3  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H4  5+ ` hp x 5 XXX 5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H5  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H6  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  2DD0Address  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5  8MM6Blockquote , , 5+ ` hp x 5   5+ ` hp x 5,*CITE,dl*CODEKJ<6X9`(Courier NewKS\  `&Times New RomanS42Emphasis64Hyperlink    <:FollowedHype    4go2Keyboard KJ<6X9`(Courier NewKS\  `&Times New RomanS <:Preformatted  /%  ,Kk %#/KJ<6X9`(Courier NewKS\  `&Times New RomanS/%  ,Kk %#/  <:zBottom of 7?(X7    5+ ` hp x 5?K%2A`Arial?  S\  `&Times New RomanS7@(X75+ ` hp x 5  &  d d>)1dxd'dxd<:zTop of For7B(X7    5+ ` hp x 5?K%2A`Arial?  S\  `&Times New RomanS7@(X75+ ` hp x 5  >)2dxd0KS.SampleKJ<6X9`(Courier NewKS\  `&Times New RomanS0.Strong 8dl6TypewriterKJ<6X9`(Courier NewKS\  `&Times New RomanS42Variable: 8HTML MarkupB      2 0CommentB   35;AGMSY_11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.<6X9`(Courier New%2A`Arial3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)Li)(;3$2#  0  .3  0  (O$ RONNELLLEBERRYWedemeyerDemetrisLavergne t]hequicklierSummittStalderLatashaGasaway P.J.DunavantBeiber JodiBulleLaverngeLynequiaNishabarrelled Dotyt]heysluffing  S($USUS.,    1    _BXXItisthepolicyofthisCourttorefertovictimsofsexualoffensesbytheirinitialsonly#X0XBe#.(.(3($ !USUS.,      0  (#$  0   d S($USUS.,    2    _BXXSexualbatteryisnota sexualoffenseasdefinedbythissectionofthestatute.- - 0#Xd# [ !USUS.,  _XoXXXQXXo^  @@tt#XoXQ\#bXXoINTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @@%ATJACKSON#XoXb#QXXo #  @  @` AssignedonBriefsNovember2,2004 F #XoXQm#QXXo #XoXQ#QXo#yR .Q=#Q .yRSTATEOFTENNESSEEv.#yR Q##X0X yR]#yR XX0Q yRԀRONALDHARRISON #yR QA##X0X yR"#XoXXX0QXXo  f #XoXQ# DirectAppealfromtheCriminalCourtforShelbyCounty 7  @@t t No.0303860ChrisCraft,Judge ! q @@*AVT) ` dE<` A /  @@No.W200300685CCAR3CDFiledDecember2,_2004_ (  AVT) ` dE<` A    TheDefendant,RonaldHarrison,wasindictedforrape,andhepledguiltytothelesserincluded   offenseofsexualbattery.Afterholdingasentencinghearing,thetrialcourtdeniedtheDefendants  requestforjudicialdiversion,suspendedsentenceandprobation,andsentencedtheDefendantto v twoyearsinthecountyworkhouse.TheDefendantappeals,contendingthatthetrialcourterred _ whenit:(1)deniedhisapplicationforjudicialdiversion;and(2)sentencedhimtotwoyears.After H thoroughlyreviewingtherecord,weconcludethatthetrialcourtdidnoterrwhenitdeniedthe 1 Defendantsapplicationforjudicialdiversion.Further,weholdthatthetrialcourtimproperly j enhancedtheDefendantssentencesinlightof_Blakely_Ԁv.Washington,542U.S.__,124S.Ct.2531 S (2004),andwereducetheDefendantssentenceinaccordancewiththisopiniontothepresumptive < minimumofoneyear.Weremandthecasefortheentryofappropriatejudgmentsofconviction.#X0XXXo#XoXXX0 % #X0XXXo #XoXXX0#X0XXXoU #XoXXX0   Tenn.R.App.P.3AppealasofRight;JudgmentoftheCriminalCourtAffirmedinPart,  ReversedinPart,andRemanded.#X0XXXo #XoXXX0   RobertW.Wedemeyer,J.,deliveredtheopinionofthecourt,inwhichJerryL.Smithand_J.C._ d _McLin_,JJ.,joined. M  JefferyL._Stimpson_,_Munford_,Tennessee,fortheappellant. "o! PaulG.Summers,AttorneyGeneralandReporter;JohnH._Bledsoe_,AssistantAttorneyGeneral; #A# WilliamL.Gibbons,DistrictAttorneyGeneral;andMicheleParks,AssistantDistrictAttorney $* $ General#X0XXXo #XoXXX0,fortheappellee,StateofTennessee. %!%     OPINION  '"' #X0XXXo~#XoXXX0@& I.Facts  (#(   #X0XXXoK#XoXXX0  ThiscasearisesoutoftheDefendantsconvictionforsexualbattery,aclassEfelony.On R*%* June5,2003,theDefendantwasindictedbytheShelbyCountyGrandJuryononecountofrape, ;+&+ andhepledguiltytosexualbattery.AttheDefendantssentencinghearing,thefollowingoccurred. $,t',    -](- ^ ^80XXdd8[ ^    Thevictim,_T.T._,Q U#  1      ׀testifiedthat,atthetimeofthehearing,shewasthirtyyearsold.Shesaid   that,inSeptemberof2002,shewasworkingatForestHillFuneralHomeasanapprenticewhile  goingtoschooltobeamortician.ThevictimsaidthattheDefendantwashersupervisor/manager  atthehome.Shesaidthatapproximatelysixorsevenmonthsaftershebeganworkingatthefuneral k home,duringSeptemberof2002,theDefendantsexuallyassaultedher.Shesaid: T 8  Wewereinthechapel.Wehadturnedoffthelightsinthebuildinginordertogo & v home.Andwewereinthechapelwherewewereturningoffthelightsinorderto  _ leave.Anditwasrealdarkinthechapel.AndIhadmadesomecommentsaboutit  H being[sic]spiritsandscaryandspookyinthechapel.And[theDefendant]toldme  1  tocomebacktothebackpartwherethetwodoorsareinthemiddleofthechapel.    Andhetoldmeitsdarkestbackhere.Andsowhenwewentbackthere,westood   backthere.AndIwaslike,Imscaredbeingbackherebecauseitwasdarkandthe   spirits,andhemadeacomment.Hedidntsayitinamannerthatwas,Iguess   supposedtomakemescared,itwasajokingmanner.Theonlythingyouhaveto n  fearisme.Andhedidntsayitinawaytointimidateme.Butthenafterthat,he W  rubbedmybreastareaandmystomach.Hewasbehindme.Andheaskedmeif @ I"ifhecouldkissme.AndIsaidhuhuh.Hekissedmeanyway.Itsthepewsor )y bencheslikethoseoutthereinthechapel.Hetoldmetositdown.Isatdown.And b hetoldmehewantedmetotouchhim.Iwasjustscared.SoItouchedhim...his K genitals.4   ThevictimsaidthatshewasscaredbecausetheDefendantwashersupervisor,andsheasked who  amIgoingtotell?ThevictimsaidthattheDefendantunzippedhispantsandpulledouthispenis.  Shesaidthathepulledherheadtoitandputherhandsonit.ShesaidtheDefendantwalkedher  aroundthebench,bentherover,andhadsexwithher.Sheagainsaidshewasscared. q   Thevictimtestifiedthatshedidnotimmediatelytellthepoliceabouttheincident,butafew C dayslater,shetoldheruncle,whoisapoliceofficer.Shesaidthatittookafewdaystotellanyone ,| abouttheincidentbecauseshe justthoughthemademedosomethingIdidntwanttodo.Ithought e rapewasgetting_beat[en_]upandbrutal.Thevictimsaidthatshesaid huhuh,beforeshe just N froze.  7   Thevictimtestifiedabouttheimpactthatthisincidenthashadonherlife.Shesaidthatshe " ! goestocounselingandhasbeendiagnosedwithposttraumaticstressdisorder.Shetestifiedthat, #" becauseofthisassault,sheattemptedtokillherselftwice,oncebytakingalotofpillsandanother $# timebycuttingherself.Thevictimsaidsheisstillincounselingandgoesonceaweek.Shesaid t% $ thatsheistakingantidepressantsandtranquilizers.Shetestifiedthatshehastostartherlifeover ]&!% becauseshenolongerwantstobeamortician,eventhoughshegraduatedatthetopofherclass. F'"& ThevictimsaidthattheDefendanthurther,andsheisscaredtobeinaclosedenvironment.She /(#' saidthatshecannottrustanyone. )h$( Ї  Oncrossexamination,thevictimtestifiedthatshetoldtheDefendant huhuhonetime,  andthenshefroze.Thevictimsaidthat huhuhmeans no.Thevictimsaidthattheroomwas  dark,andshedidnotknowiftheDefendantcouldseeherface.    TheDefendanttestifiedthathepledguiltytosexualbattery,andhewasaskingthetrialcourt T forjudicialdiversionorprobation.Hesaidthatwhenthevictimsaid huhuhheunderstoodher =  tosay uhhuh,but lookingback,youknow,maybeIshouldhaverecognizedshedidntmean & v that.Butsheofferednootherresistance.Ihadnoreasontothinkotherwise.Hesaidthat,now  _ thathehasseenwhatthisencounterhasdonetothevictim,heregretshisactions terribly.The  H Defendantapologizedtothevictimandtoherfamily.Hesaidthatheusedpoorjudgment,andhe  1  wasdeeplysorry.Hesaidthatheregrettedhisactionseveryday.      TheDefendanttestifiedthatheunderstoodthatthevictimhadfiledacivilsuitagainsthim   andthathisstatementwouldprovehercase.Hesaidthattherewasalsoanothersexualharassment   lawsuitpendingagainsthiscompany,butthesuitwasstayedbythecompanysbankruptcy.The n  Defendantsaidthathehasneverbeenarrestedbeforeandhasonlyhadafewspeedingticketsinthe W  past.TheDefendantsaidthathejustwantedtogetthisbehindhimandnevergothroughanything @ likethisagain.Hesaidthatheunderstoodthathecouldberequiredtoregisterasasexoffender )y whereverhelivesfortherestofhislife. b   Oncrossexamination,theDefendantstatedthat,severalyearsago,hehadconsensualsexual 4 relationswithtwootherfemaleemployees.TheDefendantsaidthat,whenhewasfirstquestioned  bythepoliceaboutthiscase,hesaidthathehad nevertouchedthevictim.Hesaidthathe had  given[his]employerastatementthatnothinghadhappenedbecause[he]knew[_he]would_Ԁlose[his]  jobif[he]toldthemotherwise.TheDefendantsaidthat,afterhewasarrested,headmittedtohis  wifeandhisattorneythathehadintercoursewiththevictim.TheDefendantsaidthatheunderstood q thevictimtohavesaid uhhuhandthathekissedherandthingsjustprogressedfromthere.He Z saidthatsheofferednootherresistance.Hetestifiedthathedidnotplanto makeamove.Itjust C happened.OnredirectexaminationtheDefendantsaidthattheincidentoccurredina fairlylarge ,| roomthathadseveralexits. e   WhensentencingtheDefendant,thetrialcourtstated:  7 8  Well,lookingatthediversionconsiderationinStatev[.]_Bonestel_Ԁ..andStatev. " ! Parker.His#X0XXXo#[amenabilityXoXXX0]tocorrection,Ithinkisaquestionmark.Idontknowif #" hellbeabletostopthissexualactivity.Ithinkhellprobablyifhewereplacedon $# probation,probablywouldntviolateoutoffear.Imnotsurehewouldntstartright t% $ backlater.Thecircumstancesoftheoffensesareextremelyaggravatedinmy ]&!% opinion,especiallythe_los[s_]tothiswomanofhercareer.Hehasnocriminalrecord F'"& otherthansmokingdopeinthepastafewtimes.Hissocialhistoryissomewhat /(#' suspectgivenpastsexualharassmentofemployeesandpeoplethatheworkedwith )h$( whichisjustanabsolutelyhorriblething.Hisphysicalandmentalhealthappears *Q%) tobenormal.*:&*   8  +#'+   8   ` Akeyheretodiversionisdeterrentvaluetotheaccused.Ijustdontseehim  doingthisandfeelinglikenothinghappened.Thathecangetawaywithit.And  whetherjudicialdiversionwouldservetheinterestofthepublicaswellasthe  accused,itseemstomethatthismanneedsafelonyrecordbecauseIhaveadistinct k feeling,givenhertestimonyandhistestimony,[theDefendant]islying.Anditsjust T almostasclearasIcanbe,thedifferencebetweenhistestimonyandhers,isthislady =  istellingthetruth.AndIjustcannotgivethismandiversionforviolatingherthe & v wayhedid.Heknewitwaswrongandjustdiditanyway. _   8      8   ` Astrikingthingaboutthiscaseislookingatthe[_D]efendant_sversionof  1  thesefactswhichare,althoughthe[_D]efendant_Ԁtestifiedandactslikewell,you    know,Ithoughtshesaiduhhuh.Andshesaidhuhuh,andreally,wereallyagree   onthesamethings,itwasjustamistake.AndInoticedthe[_D]efendant_stestimony   wherehesaidImadeamistake.Thiswasntamistake.Thiswasapurposeful   violationofanotherhumanbeing.Treatingthemasmeatwhenyouwerecontrolling n  themassupervisor.Andaparticularotherquotehesaid,sheofferednoother W  resistance.Whenaladyisworkingataworkplaceandherbossisincontrolofher @ careerthatshesgonetoschoolfor,whatkindofresistanceisshesupposedtooffer? )y Howintheworldcananybodybejustifiedinputtingsomebodyinthatposition?b   8   ` Supposeoneofmyclerkshere,Iaskedthemtohavesexwithmeaftercourt 4 today?Whataretheygoingtodo?Realizingthatiftheycomplainagainstme,  theyrenotevergoingtogetpromotedintheclerksoffice.Lawsuits,allofthese  politiciansmadatthem,themmadatme.Allofthisstuffgoingon.Itsjust  absolutelyinexcusableintodaysworld.Buthereswhathesays.Heresthestory  hetellsinhis_presentence_Ԁreport.[_T.T._]andI...werethelasttwoemployeesleft q toclosedownthebuildingat5p.m.Afterturningoffthelightsinthechapel,she Z saiditwasscaryinthere.Itoldhertherewasnothingtobeafraidof.Shewalked C overandstoodclosebesideme.IaskedifIcouldkissher.Shesaidunhuh.I ,| kissedherandthenItouchedherbreast.Isatdownononeofthepews.She e straddledmylap.Okay.Noneofthiswasmentionedbythis[_D]efendant_Ԁjusta N minuteago.Shestraddledmylap.Iunbuttonedhershirt,liftedherbra,began  7 touchingherbreast.Afterashorttime,Iaskedifshewouldtouchme.Well, !   obviouslyifshesgoingtogetonhislapandstraddleitandgivehimalittlelap " ! dance,obviouslyhewouldthink,yeah,sure,goforit.Butthatsnotwhathappened. #" No.Thisfellowsjustflatlyingaboutwhathappened.Andheneedstorealizethat $# hesnottellingthetruth.Hiswifeneedstorealizethatheslying.Shegotoffmy t% $ lapandsatonthepew.Istoodinfrontofherandunzippedmypants.Shetookout ]&!% mypenisand_beg[an]giving_Ԁmeoralsex.AfterashorttimeItoldherweshouldstop F'"& becauseDub_Nance_Ԁand_Wendel_ԀSmithshouldberight"inotherwords,hestheone /(#' thatsaidletsstop,nother.[We][_w]ent_Ԁtothefuneraldirectorsworkofficeafterwe )h$( fixedourclothes.Duband_Wendel_Ԁarrivedatthattime.Andthen20minuteswent *Q%) bywithotherpeoplearoundthem.Andthentheyclockedoutandleft.Andwewent *:&* backinthechapel.Itookoffmypantsandshebegangivingmeoralsexagain.I +#'+ removedherpantsandgaveheroralsex.   8   ` Now,somehowthevictim_forg[ot_]toleaveoutthefactthatshetookoffher  clothesandhegaveheroralsexforawhile.Thatjust"itjustflatdidnthappen. k Thismanisaliar.Istoodupandwalkedaroundbehindthepewandmotionedfor T hertofollowme.Shewalkedaroundandstoodinfrontofme.Shebentoverand =  Ipenetratedhervaginafrombehind.Afterwewerefinished,Ipickedupmyclothes & v andwenttothemensroomtocleanup.Shewenttotheladiesroomtocleanupand  _ getdressed.Afterweweredressed,sheclockedoutandweleft. H   8   ` Thisisjust"theresjustnowaythisisatrueversion.Thismanwantstoget    hereandsay,Judge,Imgoingtocommitperjuryinfrontofyouandcommita   felonyrightinfrontofyoureyes.AndIwantprobation,diversion.Itsjustnot   goingtohappen,[Defendant].Ifyoudtakenthestandandyoudtoldthetruth   _ab[o]ut_Ԁwhatwasgoingon,thenmaybewewoulddosomethingforyou.Butyoure n  stilllying.Yourestillpersecutingthisyounglady.Andthatstheproblem.You W  stillcangetajobsomewhere,butallthoseyearsofworkshe_ha[s_]havecometono @ avail.Sheofferednootherresistance.ThatsthequotethatIwrotedown. )y Absolutelynodiversion,notonlybecauseofthepastepisodeswhichwerentcrimes, b butbecauseyourelyingtodayonthestand,absolutelackofcandor.Youwantto K sayjustenoughtowhereeverybodywillbelievethatitwasanhonestmistake.This 4 wasnotamistake.Itwasacrime.Andwhenyouwereincharge!oneofour  enhancementfactorsandIlljustreaditfromthestatuethatIcanusetoapply.   8   ` Iabsolutelyfindinthiscasethatthe[_D]efendant_Ԁabusedapositionofprivate  trustinthiscase.Lookingattheprobationconsiderations,theresapresumptionof q analternativesentence.Iveconsideredthe_presentence_Ԁreport;hisphysicaland Z mentalcondition,hissocialhistoryasIvedescribed.Thefactsandcircumstances C surroundingtheoffense;thenatureandcircumstancesofthecriminalconductwhich ,| wereaggravatedforasexualbatterycase.Thiswasntjustacasewheresomebody e walkeduptosomebodystandingatastopsignandgrabbedtheirbreast.Thiswas N acalculated,intimidationofsomeoneelsethatwasunderyourcare.Totake  7 advantageofherandbasicallybeapredatorofherbody.!     8   ` Iveconsideredyourlackofcriminalhistoryotherthanthismarijuana #" smoking.Thepreviousactionsofthe[_D]efendant_.Thefactthattheother $# complaintsweregoingon.Thatyouweredoingthistopeoplewhowereworking t% $ foryouremployeraswellasbeingtheirsupervisor.Whetherornotyoumight ]&!% reasonablyexpecttoberehabilitated.Ijust,becauseofthelies,Idontreallythink F'"& thatthismanisrehabilitated.AndIthinkthatthismanwillprobablyreoffendagain /(#' somedayassoonashesinapositionofpoweroverwomen.Whetherornotyoull )h$( abidebythetermsofprobation,andIthinkhewill.Ithinkhesscared.AndIthink *Q%) hellabidebythetermsofprobation.Whetherornottheinterestofsocietyand *:&* beingprotectedfrompossiblefuturecriminalconductfromthe[_D]efend[ant_]are +#'+ great.Iwouldsayyes,theyare.Nomeasureslessrestrictivethanconfinementhave  beenappliedbecausehesneverbeenprosecutedbefore.   8   ` Whetherornotasentenceoffullprobationwouldundulydepreciatethe k seriousnessoftheoffense.Absolutelyyes.Itwouldmakehimfeellikehesnota T criminal,andwhathedidisreallynotrightandthathestheonethatsbeing =  misunderstood.Whetherornotconfinementisparticularlysuitedprovidingeffective & v deterrenttoothers.Itmaybe.Ireallycantfindthatfromtherecord,butitvery  _ wellmaybeifthisgetsaroundinthefuneralhomebusiness.Ithoughtinthiscase  H becauseof[the]presumptionofanalternativesentence,thatmaybehewoulddeserve  1  somekindofalternativesentenceandnotfullprobation.     8  TheproblemIseeinthis,though,iswiththismanactuallyhavingthegalltogeton   thestandandsay,yes,shetoldthetruth.Wejusthadamisunderstanding,   completelymitigatesagainstgivingthismananyprobationwhatsoever.n      ThetrialcourtthensentencedtheDefendanttotwoyearsintheworkhouse. @ #X0XXXo0#X0XXX0@$ II.Analysis #X0XXX0_#X0XXX0Ԉ K   TheDefendantpresentstwoissuesforreview,bothofwhichinvolvehissentence.First,he  contendsthatthetrialcourterredwhenitdeniedhisrequestforjudicialdiversion.Next,heasserts  thatthetrialcourterredwhenitorderedenhancedhissentence.#X0XXX0_#Whenadefendantchallengesthe  lengthormannerofserviceofasentence,itisthedutyofthisCourttoconductadenovoreview  oftherecordwithapresumptionthat thedeterminationsmadebythecourtfromwhichtheappeal r istakenarecorrect.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035401(d)(2003).Thispresumptionis conditioned [ upontheaffirmativeshowingintherecordthatthetrialcourtconsideredthesentencingprinciples D andallrelevantfactsandcircumstances.Statev.Ross,49S.W.3d833,847(Tenn.2001)(quoting -} Statev._Pettus_,986S.W.2d540,543(Tenn.1999));Statev._Ashby_,823S.W.2d166,169(Tenn. f 1991).Thepresumptiondoesnotapplytothelegalconclusionsreachedbythetrialcourtin O sentencingadefendantortothedeterminationsmadebythetrialcourtthatarepredicatedupon  8 _uncontroverted_Ԁfacts.Statev.Dean,76S.W.3d352,377(Tenn._Crim_.App.2001);Statev.Butler, !!  900S.W.2d305,311(Tenn._Crim_.App.1994);Statev.Smith891S.W.2d922,929(Tenn._Crim_. " ! App.1994).Inconductingadenovoreviewofasentence,wemustconsider:(a)anyevidence #" receivedatthetrialand/orsentencinghearing;(b)the_presentence_Ԁreport;_(c_)theprinciplesof $# sentencing;(d)theargumentsofcounselrelativetosentencingalternatives;(e)thenatureand u% $ characteristicsoftheoffense;(f)anymitigatingorstatutoryenhancementfactors;(g)anystatements ^&!% madebythedefendantonhisorherownbehalf;and(h)thedefendantspotentialorlackofpotential G'"& forrehabilitationortreatment.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035210(2003);Statev.Taylor,63S.W.3d 0(#' 400,411(Tenn._Crim_.App.2001).Thepartychallengingasentenceimposedbythetrialcourthas )i$( theburdenofestablishingthatthesentenceiserroneous.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035401(d), *R%) Sentencing_Commn_Ԁ_Cmts_. *;&*  X0XXX0 +$'+ #X0XXX0k#  Inthecaseundersubmission,weconcludethatthereisampleevidencethatthetrialcourt  consideredthesentencingprinciplesandallrelevantfactsandcircumstances.Therefore,wereview  itsdecisiondenovowithapresumptionofcorrectness.Accordingly,solongasthetrialcourt  compliedwiththepurposesandproceduresofthe1989SentencingActanditsfindingsare k supportedbythefactualrecord,thisCourtmaynotdisturbthissentenceevenifwewouldhave T preferredadifferentresult.SeeTenn.CodeAnn.4035210,Sentencing_Commn_Ԁ_Cmts_;Statev. =  Fletcher,805S.W.2d785,789(Tenn._Crim_.App.1991).Wenotethatthedefendantbearsthe & v burdenofshowingthatthesentenceisimproper.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035401,Sentencing  _ _Commn_Ԁ_Cmts_.;_Ashby_,823S.W.2dat169.  H   A.JudicialDiversion    p  TheDefendantarguesthatthetrialcourtabuseditsdiscretionindecliningtoimposea   sentencepursuanttoTennesseeCodeAnnotatedsection40-35-313(2003),commonlyreferredto o  as judicialdiversion.Accordingtothisstatute,thetrialcourtmay,atitsdiscretion,followinga X  determinationofguilt,deferfurtherproceedingsandplaceaqualifieddefendantonprobation A withoutenteringajudgmentofguilt.Tenn.CodeAnn.40-35-313(a)(1)(A).Aqualifieddefendant *z isonewho: c 8  (a)Isfoundguiltyoforpleadsguiltyornolocontenderetotheoffenseforwhich 5 deferraloffurtherproceedingsissought;   8  (b)IsnotseekingdeferraloffurtherproceedingsforasexualoffenseW U#  2      ׀oraClassA  orClassBfelony;and   8  _(c_)HasnotpreviouslybeenconvictedofafelonyoraClassAmisdemeanor.   Tenn.CodeAnn.40-35-313(a)(1)(B)(_i_)(a),(b),_(c_)(footnoteinserted).Whenadefendant [ contendsthatthetrialcourtcommittederrorinrefusingtograntjudicialdiversion,wemust D determinewhetherthetrialcourtabuseditsdiscretionbydenyingthedefendantsrequestforjudicial -} diversion.Statev.Electroplating,Inc.,990S.W.2d211,229(Tenn._Crim_.App.1998);Statev. f _Cutshaw_,967S.W.2d332,344(Tenn._Crim_.App.1997).Judicialdiversionissimilartopretrial O diversion;however,judicialdiversionfollowsadeterminationofguilt,andthedecisiontogrant  8 judicialdiversionisinitiatedbythetrialcourt,nottheprosecutor.Statev.Anderson,857S.W.2d !!  571,572(Tenn._Crim_.App.1992).Whenadefendantchallengesthetrialcourtsdenialofjudicial " ! diversion,wemaynotrevisittheissueiftherecordcontainsanysubstantialevidencesupportingthe #" trialcourtsdecision._Cutshaw_,967S.W.2dat344;Statev.Parker,932S.W.2d945,958(Tenn. $# _Crim_.App.1996).InAnderson,thisCourtstated: u% $ 8  Weconcludethatjudicialdiversionissimilarinpurposetopretrialdiversionandis G'"& tobeimposedwithinthediscretionofthetrialcourtsubjectonlytothesame 0(#' constraintsapplicabletoprosecutorsinapplyingpretrialdiversionunderTennessee )i$( CodeAnnotated40-15-105.Therefore,uponreview,if anysubstantialevidence  tosupporttherefusalexistsintherecord,wewillgivethetrialcourtthebenefitof  itsdiscretion.Onlyanabuseofthatdiscretionwillallowustooverturnthetrial  court.k   Anderson,857S.W.2dat572(citationomitted). =    Thecriteriathatthetrialcourtmustconsiderindeterminingwhetheraqualifieddefendant  _ shouldbegrantedjudicialdiversionincludethefollowing:(1)thedefendantsamenabilityto  H correction;(2)thecircumstancesoftheoffense;(3)thedefendantscriminalrecord;(4)the  1  defendantssocialhistory;(5)thedefendantsphysicalandmentalhealth;and(6)thedeterrence    valuetothedefendantandothers._Cutshaw_,967S.W.2dat343-44;Parker,932S.W.2dat958.An   additionalconsiderationiswhetherjudicialdiversionwillservetheendsofjustice,i.e.,theinterests   ofthepublicaswellasthedefendant._Cutshaw_,967S.W.2dat344;Parker,932S.W.2dat958;   Statev._Bonestel_,871S.W.2d163,168(Tenn._Crim_.App.1993),overruledonothergroundsby n  Statev.Hooper,29S.W.3d1,9(Tenn.2000). W    Inthecaseundersubmission,thetrialcourtfoundthattheDefendantsamenabilityto )y correctionwasa questionmark,becauseitdidnot knowifhellbeabletostopthissexual b activity.Thetrialcourtalsofoundthatthecircumstancesofthisoffensewere extremely K aggravatedconsideringthevictimslossofhercareer.ThetrialcourtstatedthattheDefendants 4 socialhistorywas suspectgivenpastsexualharassmentofemployeesandpeoplethatheworked  with....Finally,thetrialcourtconsideredthedeterrencevaluetotheDefendantandothersand  found, Ijustdontseehimdoingthisandfeelinglikenothinghappened.Thathecangetawaywith  it.Further,thecourtfoundthattheDefendantneededafelonyrecordinordertoappreciatethe  seriousnessofhisactions,becauseitwasapparentthattheDefendantliedtothecourt.After q consideringthesefactorsandfindings,thetrialcourtdeniedtheDefendantsrequestfordiversion. Z Weconcludethatthereisevidenceintherecordtosupportthesefindingsbythetrialcourtandthat C itdidnotabuseitsdiscretionbydenyingtheDefendantsrequestforjudicialdiversion. ,| @    B.EnhancedSentence  N X0XXX0  TheDefendantnextassertsthatthetrialcourterredwhenitorderedthattheDefendantbe !!  sentencedtotheenhancedsentenceoftwoyears.IncalculatingthesentenceforaClassEfelony " ! conviction,thepresumptivesentenceisthestatutoryminimumforaRangeIoffenderifthereare #" noenhancementormitigatingfactors.SeeTenn.CodeAnn.4035210_(c_).Ifthereare $# enhancementbutnomitigatingfactors,thetrialcourtmaysetthesentenceabovetheminimum,but u% $ stillwithintherange.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035210(d).Asentenceinvolvingbothenhancement ^&!% andmitigatingfactorsrequiresanassignmentofrelativeweightfortheenhancementfactorsasa G'"& meansofincreasingthesentence.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035210(e).Thesentencemustthenbe 0(#' reducedwithintherangebyanyweightassignedtothemitigatingfactorspresent.Tenn.CodeAnn. )i$( 4035210(e).ThesentencerangeforaRangeIoffenderforaclassEfelonyisnotlessthanone *R%) (1)normorethantwo(2)years.Tenn.CodeAnn.4035112(2003). *;&*  +$'+   TheUnitedStatesSupremeCourtsrecentopinionin_Blakely_Ԁv.Washington,542U.S.__,  124S.Ct.2531(2004),callsintoquestionthecontinuingvalidityofourcurrentsentencingscheme.  Inthatcase,theCourt,applyingtherulein_Apprendi_Ԁv.NewJersey,566U.S.466,490(2000),  struckdownaprovisionoftheWashingtonsentencingguidelinesthatpermittedatrialjudgeto k imposean exceptionalsentenceuponthefindingofcertainstatutorilyenumeratedenhancement T factors.124S.Ct.at2537.TheCourtobservedthat thestatutorymaximumfor_Apprendi_ =  purposesisthemaximumsentenceajudgemayimposesolelyonthebasisofthefactsreflectedin & v thejuryverdictoradmittedbythedefendant.124S.Ct.at2537.#X0XXX0#X0XXX0Finally,theCourtconcludedthat  _  everydefendanthasarighttoinsistthattheprosecutorprovetoajury[beyondareasonabledoubt]  H allfactslegallyessentialtothepunishment.Id.at2539.  1      #X0XXX0E#X0XXX0Inthecaseundersubmission,thetrialcourtenhancedtheDefendantssentencebasedupon   itsfindingthatoneenhancementfactorapplied,thattheDefendantabusedapositionoftrust.See   Tenn.CodeAnn.4035114(16).Thisenhancementfactorwasnotsubmittedtoajuryor   admittedbytheDefendant.Therefore,therulein_Blakely_precludestheapplicationthisfactor. n  Becausetherearenoenhancementfactorsthatwereprovedtoajurybeyondareasonabledoubtor W  admittedbytheDefendant,thesentencemustbemodifiedtothepresumptiveminimumofoneyear.#X0XXX0#X0XXX0 @ @NN" III.Conclusion b Ѐ   Inaccordancewiththeforegoingreasoningandauthorities,#X0XXX0ԗ#XoXXX0weaffirmthetrialcourts 6 judgmentinpart,reverseinpart,andremandforentryofajudgmentmodifyingthesentencetothe  presumptiveminimumofoneyear.#X0XXXo#X0XXX0  #X0XXX0#XoXXX0   `     h     ___________________________________     `     h     ROBERTW.WEDEMEYER,JUDGE#X0XXXo#X0XXX0Ԁ#X0XXX0V#