WPCA < ~Y>1:$!AJD#E /(hp%uUUQ8@4{IAu/,I"m?8 N\ YuUcfŃ>EBW<:+_N8;`QzeOQؼOrgL.(p Vi y˃0zzQWȞg; =ƚ3%Mu 1jϓT"@\&2KiZ ךy5=wYcixeg))qͿxҎDݿdWѕ0]n(ǺK# % 9Us!Rv6fUZ|@(D͙# F UNQ % 0( w@ 4 ! 0 U :8 U :r U:  U: B     D3% % % 0DX X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X AO  0D D/ B$HP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nLh(hH  Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($ DDDEEDӀuM%3|x, AZ"Arial Regular, AZ"Arial Regular,cAZ"Arial Regular  X;XXX X X;   Ad FILED X;X   December7,1998CecilW.CrowsonAppellateCourtClerkdAM ,cAZ"Arial Regular d%%%%'dxd(3$ !  -C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5($$   1  ' dxdP Pd !  XTR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T XsXXX  r *<,(j 8` `@E ` 8ttxPX  rߛINTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  ATNASHVILLENOVEMBER1998SESSION  JIMMYJONES,JR., h   )    p  'XXDpXX' `     h   ) D C.C.A.No.01C019804CR00162 `   ` Appellant,   h   ) P   `     h   ) D SumnerCounty @  v. `     h   ) D  p  0   `     h   ) D HonorableJaneWheatcraft,Judge   STATEOFTENNESSEE, h   )   `     h   ) D (MotiontoReopenPostConvictionPetition)   ` Appellee.   h   )   FORTHEAPPELLANT: h    D FORTHEAPPELLEE: @ JimmyJones,Jr.,prose h    D JohnKnoxWalkup  p D.S.N.F.Unit15B   h    D AttorneyGeneral&Reporter ` 7575CockrillBendIndustrialRoad D 425FifthAvenueNorth P Nashville,TN372091057   D Nashville,TN372430493 @  `     h    D KimR.Helper `     h    D AssistantAttorneyGeneral `     h    D 425FifthAvenueNorth `     h    D Nashville,TN372430493 `     h    D LawrenceRayWhitley `     h    D DistrictAttorneyGeneral `     h    D 113WestMainStreet `     h    D Gallatin,TN370662803 `     h    D DeeD.Gay `     h    D AssistantDistrictAttorneyGeneral `     h    D 113WestMainStreet `     h    D Gallatin,TN370662803  -P(+  OPINIONFILED:________________________________ 2-1 AFFIRMEDL.T.LAFFERTY,SENIORJUDGE  `  ;`6:  XsXX Xs RX Xs   7<XXdXXd7OPINION# R R # # XsX R #    ` Theappellant,JimmyJones,Jr.,appealsthedismissalofhisprosemotionto   reopenpostconvictionpetitionorinthealternativeapetitionforhabeascorpusreliefbytheSumnerCountyCriminalCourt.InDecember,1987,theappellantwasconvictedbyaSumnerCountyjuryontwocountsofarmedrobberyandonecountofburglary.TheappellantreceivedconcurrentRangeIIsentencesoffortyfiveyearsforthearmedrobberyconvictionsandfourteenyearsfortheburglaryconvictiontorunconsecutively.Ondirectappeal,theappellantallegedtrialerrorsasto(1)thesufficiencyoftheevidencetosustaintheverdicts,(2)whetherthetrialcourterredinlimitingproductionofpolicereports,and(3)whetherhiseffectivesentenceoffiftynine59yearswasexcessive.InJanuary,1989,thiscourtaffirmedthejudgmentsofthetrialcourtinStatev.JimmyJones,Jr.,SumnerCounty,  No.8858III(Tenn.Crim.App.,Nashville,January11,1989)per.app.denied(Tenn. | 1989). ` OnNovember29,1990,theappellantfiledapetitionforpostconvictionreliefandafteranevidentiaryhearing,thetrialcourtdeniedthepetition.Ondirectappeal,tThiscourtaffirmedthetrialcourtsdecisioninJimmyJones,Jr.v.State,SumnerCountyNo.01C019205CC00162, $, " МSumner $, " County $, " (Tenn.Crim.App.,Nashville,April15,1993)per.app.denied(Tenn.1993). & "$  ` OnFebruary20,1998,theappellantfiledamotiontoreopenpostconvictionpetitionorinthealternativeapetitionforhabeascorpusrelief.OnMarch24,1998,thepostconvictioncourt,inapreliminaryorder,dismissedthemotiontoreopen/petition. ` Weaffirmthedecisionofthepostconvictioncourt.  LEGALANALYSIS 5 14     ` Inhismotiontoreopenthepetitionforpostconvictionrelief,theappellantcontends |948 thattheindictmentsforarmedrobberyandburglarywerevoidforduplicityandthetrialcourtlackedjurisdictiontotrythesematters. ` Thepostconvictioncourtdismissedthemotiontoreopenbasedonthefollowing:(1)pursuanttoTenn.CodeAnn. X?fXX X?f# X?fXX X?f#Ԁ4030202(c),thepriorpetitionwasresolvedbyacourt 0  ofcompetentjurisdictionand,therefore,anysecondorsubsequentpetition(motion)shouldbedismissed;(2)pursuanttoTenn.CodeAnn. X?fXX X?f# X?fXX X?f#Ԁ4030202(a)and(b),thepetition @  (motion)istimebarred;and(3)thatthemotiontoreopenmeetsnoneoftherequirementsofTenn.CodeAnn. X?fXX X?f# X?fXX X?f#Ԁ4030217.   ` Onceapetitionforpostconvictionreliefhasbeendeterminedonitsmeritsbyacourtofcompetentjurisdictionanddenied,apetitionermayfileamotiontoreopenthepetitionundercertaincircumstances.TennesseeCodeAnnotated X?fXX X?f# X?fXX X?f^#Ԁ4030217(a)(1)and 0 (2),MotionstoReopen,states:8 ` 8 ` (#` (#Apetitionermayfileamotioninthetrialcourttoreopenthefirstpostconvictionpetitiononlyifthefollowingapplies:   8 ` 8 ` (#` (#Theclaiminthemotionisbaseduponafinalrulingofanappellatecourtestablishingaconstitutionalrightthatwasnotrecognizedasexistingatthetimeoftrial,ifretrospectiveapplicationofthatrightisrequired.Suchmotionmustbefiledwithinone(1)yearoftherulingofthehigheststateappellatecourtortheUnitedStatessupremecourtestablishingaconstitutionalrightthatwasnotrecognizedasexistingatthetimeoftrial;or   8 ` 8 ` (#` (#Theclaiminthemotionisbaseduponnewscientificevidenceestablishingthatsuchpetitionerisactuallyinnocentoftheoffenseofoffensesforwhichthepetitionerwasconvicted.   8 ` 8 ` (#` (#    ` TheappellantsnewclaimsdonotfallwithinanyoftheconditionsofTenn.CodeAnn. X?fXX X?f# X?fXX X?fS #Ԁ4030217(a)inthattheclaimsarenotbasedonanewconstitutionalrightornew 1-0 scientificevidence.Also,themotionwasnotfiledwithinone(1)yearoftherulingofthiscourtin1993.Thepostconvictioncourtsorderdismissingthemotionisaffirmed. ` Initsdismissalorder,thepostconvictioncourtdidnotaddressthealternative 0948 requestoftheappellanttoconsiderthemeritsofapetitionforhabeascorpusrelief.Habeascorpusreliefisavailableonly whenitappearsuponthefaceofthejudgmentortherecordoftheproceedingsuponwhichthejudgmentisrenderedthattheconvictingcourtwaswithoutjurisdictionorauthoritytosentenceadefendant,orthatthedefendantssentencehasexpired. XGXX XGArcherv.StateStatev.Archer,851S.W.2d157,164(Tenn.1993).Seealso,; 0  Passarellav.State,891S.W.2d619,62728(Tenn.Crim.App.),per.app.denied(Tenn. `  1994).;# XGXX XGg%# XGXX XGԀ# XGXX XG&#ԀFromareviewoftheindictmentinthisrecord,theappellantsargumentastothe @  offensesbeingduplicitousisnotvalid.ThefivecountindictmentindictmentinfivecountsallegedtheappellantandtwocodefendantsrobbedthreepersonsatgunpointwithashotgunandforcedthemanagerofShoneysRestauranttoopenalockedsafeonJune2,1987. ` TheappellantsrequestforhabeascorpusreliefissubjecttodismissalpursuanttoTenn.CodeAnn. XGXX XG# XGXX XGJ)#Ԁ2921105whichstates: 0 8 ` 8 ` (#` (#Theapplicationshouldbemadetothecourtorjudgemostconvenientinpointofdistancetotheapplicant,unlessasufficientreasonbegiveninthepetitionfornotapplyingtosuchcourtorjudge.   ) ` TherecordestablishestheappellantisaninmateintheDepartmentofCorrectioninDavidsonCounty. ` Thejudgmentofthepostconvictioncourtisaffirmed. XXX XG `     h    D _____________________________________ ,`'*  `     h    D L.T.LAFFERTY,SENIORJUDGECONCUR:___________________________________PAULG.SUMMERS,JUDGE___________________________________# XGXX X+# XGXX XG 737 JOEG.RILEY,JUDGE# XGXX XGR-# 838  838  838  838  838  838  838  838