WPC  };kEܱtZuA;:`W1`ʨoEѱo o94sQ(i] ĵpFa8Rb\.(>T7ry}u'xZ{k92-WMukr &뎝D[vFcrgPF!ޢ =Roq-UD.Ý!ϸZ2']{wi* G`-u/_ntz1EI/\bZr{ q|] XLmC?9DoqEh2F<4k@ܹ D@H7`fUFpgc t*,@ hdM_9 ,oB+*Y P/g%WBb#\ %% ^ + 07 UN w 4 z%  q  m   g -N 0DEb 0     B 0 D3 D- 0K AS` 0y 0D AaHP LaserJet 4000 Series PCL6V,,,,V0p1 (`$.8dd8    ("  Z6Times New Roman Regularh_B0.bk C:\PROGRA~1\COREL\WORDPE~1\TEMPLATE\CUSTOM~1\REVISE~1.WPTC:\Program Files\Corel\WordPerfect Office 2000\Template\Custom WP Templates\revised standard opinion.wpt3|xU Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(#$  0  - -(|G2o $ !.8Qdd8         0   d(|3$ !.8Qdd8     VVVV'dxd)!dxdx( $ Figure  1  ^_X`YE<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(|3$ !.8Qdd8     ($$   1  X[Z&OLE 2.0 Box <=8C HKKKK !.8Qdd8     _   Q8ǿXXdd8@hhaQINTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @gg$ATNASHVILLE#Qa #Ԉ #    @  @` XǿXQ #QXXǿ#_RICKY_ԀH._KRANTZ_v.STATEOFTENNESSEEXǿXQ  ? @@ AppealfromtheCircuitCourtforWayneCounty  9 @@No.94A21RobertHolloway,Judge  # @@*AV) ` dE<` A   @@TTNo.M200302819CCAR3_HC_ԀFiledNovember12,_2004_   AV) ` dE<]` A ^     ThePetitioner,_Ricky_ԀH._Krantz_,appealsfromthedismissalofhispetitionforthewritofhabeas V  corpus.TheStatehasfiledamotionrequestingthattheCourtaffirmthetrialcourtsdenialofrelief ? pursuanttoRule20,RulesoftheCourtofCriminalAppeals.WefindtheStatesmotionhasmerit. (x Accordingly,themotionisgrantedandtheappealisaffirmedpursuanttoRule20,Rulesofthe a CourtofCriminalAppeals. J #QXXǿ#XǿXQ Tenn.R.App.P.3;JudgmentoftheTrialCourtAffirmedPursuanttoRule20,Rulesof  theCourtofCriminalAppeals   #QXXǿu#XǿXQ   #QXǿ[#XǿX.QRobertW._Wedemeyer_,J.,deliveredtheopinionofthecourt,inwhichDavidH.Welles,and r JerryL.Smith,JJ,joined. [ _Ricky_ԀH._Krantz_,prose,Nashville,Tennessee. -} PaulG.Summers,AttorneyGeneralandReporter;HelenaW._Yarbrough_,AssistantAttorney O General,fortheappellee,StateofTennessee.  8   MEMORANDUM @@OO& OPINION " "     OnFebruary24,1994,aDavidsonCountyjuryconvictedthePetitioneroffelonymurderand $$ aggravatedassaultasalesserincludedoffenseofattemptedfirstdegreemurder.ThePetitionerwas w% % sentencedtolifeimprisonmentforthefelonymurderconvictionandsevenyearsfortheaggravated `&!& assaultconviction,tobeservedconsecutively.ThisCourtaffirmedtheconvictionsonappeal.State I'"' v._Ricky_ԀHill_Krantz_,No.01C019406CR00207,1998WL3621(Tenn._Crim_.App.,atNashville, 2(#( Jan.7,1998),perm.toappealgranted(Tenn.Oct.11,1999),seeStatev._Krantz_,No.M1999 )k$) 02437CCARMCD,2000WL59915(Tenn._Crim_.App.,atNashville,Jan.20,2000)(remanded *T%* onothergrounds),perm.toapp.denied(Tenn.Sept.18,2000).ThePetitionerfiledapetitionfor *=&+ postconvictionrelief,allegingthathereceivedineffectiveassistanceofcounsel.Thetrialcourt, +&',  afteranevidentiaryhearing,deniedrelief,andthisCourtaffirmedthejudgmentonappeal.See ,(- __Krantz_Ԁv.State,No.M200202978CCAR3PC,2004WL367723,(Tenn._Crim_.App.,atNashville,  Feb.27,2004),perm.toapp.denied(Tenn.June1,2004).     OnAugust6,2003,thePetitionerfiled,prose,apetitionforwritofhabeascorpusreliefin k theWayneCountyCircuitCourt.Hecontendsthatthejudgmententeredisvoidasthetrialcourt T waswithoutjurisdictiontoenterjudgmentagainstthePetitioner.Insupportofthisallegation,the =  Petitionerassertsthathisfelonymurderconvictionisvoidbecausehewasacquittedofthe & v underlyingfelonyofattemptedfirstdegreemurder.Further,thePetitionerassertsthathis  _ convictionsarevoidbecausethetrialjudgefailedtosignthecourtminutes.OnSeptember11,  H 2003,thetrialcourtissuedanorderdismissingthePetitionerswritofhabeascorpus.ThePetitioner  1  filedhisnoticeofappealinthetrialcourtonSeptember30,2003.      Thegroundsuponwhichawritofhabeascorpusmaybeissuedareverynarrow._McLaney_   v.Bell,59S.W.3d90,92(Tenn.2001).Awritofhabeascorpusisavailableonlywhenitappears   fromthefaceofthejudgmentorrecordthateithertheconvictingcourtwaswithoutjurisdictionto n  convictorsentencethepetitioner,orthepetitionerssentencehasexpired.Archerv.State,851 W  S.W.2d157,164(Tenn.1993);_Potts_Ԁv.State,833S.W.2d60,62(Tenn.1992).Inotherwords, @ habeascorpusreliefmayonlybesoughtwhenthejudgmentisvoid,notmerelyvoidable.Taylor )y v.State,995S.W.2d78,83(Tenn.1999). b   ThePetitionerhasfailedtosetforthanyallegationsthatwouldindicatethatthetrialcourt 4 lackedjurisdictiontoconvictorsentencehimorthatheisunlawfully restrainedforasentencethat  hasexpired.ThePetitionerassertsthatinorderforhisfelonymurderconvictiontostand,hemust  havebeenconvictedoftheunderlyingfelony.Further,thePetitionercontendsthathecouldnot  havebeenconvictedoffelonymurderbecauseaggravatedassaultisnotanenumeratedfelonyinthe  felonymurderstatute.OurSupremeCourthasheld [_c]onsistency_Ԁinverdictsformultiplecount q indictmentsisunnecessaryaseachcountisaseparateindictment.Wigginsv.State,498S.W.2d Z 92,9394(Tenn.1973).Aconvictionwillbeupheldif theevidenceestablishesguiltoftheoffense C uponwhichtheconvictionwasreturned.Id.Therefore,thePetitionersconvictionforfelony ,| murderisnotvoidbecausehewasseparatelyconvictedofaggravatedassaultasalesserincluded e offenseofattemptedfirstdegreemurder. N   ThePetitionerfurtherassertsthathisjudgmentisvoidbecausethejudgedidnotsignthe !   courtminutesasrequiredbyTennesseeCodeAnnotatedsection161106(a).Althoughthereisno " ! evidencethatthejudgesignedtheminutes,therecordshowsthat,onthedatetheverdictwas #" returned,thejudgesmarkisthelastentryoftheminutes.Further,thisCourthasheldthatthe $# requirementsofTennesseeCodeAnnotatesection161106(a)aredirectoryandnotmandatory. t% $ SeeJohnsv.State,No.E199900260CCAR3CD,2000WL262901at*2(Tenn._Crim_.App.,at ]&!% Nashville,March9,2000),perm.toapp.denied(Tenn.Sept.11,2000).ThisCourthasconsistently F'"& heldthatthefailureofajudgetosignthecourtminutesdoesnotvoidtheunderlyingjudgments. /(#' SeeJohns,2000WL262901at*2;seealso_Duboise_Ԁv.State,290S.W.2d646,647(Tenn.1956). )h$( TherecorddoesnotcontainanyevidencetosupportthePetitionerscontentionand,baseduponthe *Q%)  recordbeforeus,thereisnoproofthatPetitionerssentencehasexpired.Petitionerhasfailedto *:&* establishbyapreponderanceoftheevidencethathisconvictionisvoidorhistermofimprisonment  hasexpired.     Accordingly,theStatesmotionisgranted.Thejudgmentofthetrialcourtisaffirmedin k accordancewithRule20,RulesoftheCourtofCriminalAppeals. T      `     h   ___________________________________ & v    `     h     ROBERTW._WEDEMEYER_,JUDGE