WPC  0_^H;^ hLJ(K1LQ,K̢>ƅP/\7 Ocd(L_Ր\_J\? 4P0IP؏GCY:,dJ"t4_ 8aAcE8k=ADT*$JW٢M5(*$=#<2 mߒ0̎"4*w j#zBO\Z^_n+Rk֪S^Ei!džboY MudLUڑ43>0 }&#"w ҹ>^pG& x|a Ӯ> y!2x>syk*w:XW#U : % 0:UNU@K UN N - ^  w 4 , ; m= -T T T T T T E B HP LaserJet 4000 Series PCL 60,cAZ"Arial RegularX($USUS.,("  Z6Times New Roman Regular(9 Z(Times New Roman (9 Z6Times New Roman Regular ##CXd#"T) J~'bk1\3|xU ##mXd# d !USUS.,  _X.$XXX]XXX.$8A"XXdd8 b;@tt#X.$X]X\#rXX.$INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  @kk$ATNASHVILLE#X.$Xr #]XXX.$Ԉ      @  @` September19,2000Session @ #X.$X]X# ]XXX.$STATEOFTENNESSEEv.BOBBIEJOEROLLINS#X.$X]X\#  4 @@ AppealfromtheCriminalCourtforMarshallCounty  ( @@No.13789CharlesLee,Judge   @@*AV) ` dE<o` A p  @@TTNo.M199902457CCAR3CDFiledOctober20,_2000_ e  AV) ` dE<0` A 1     ThedefendantwasconvictedbyaMarshallCountyjuryofrecklessaggravatedassaultandsentenced &v  bythetrialcourttotenyearsimprisonmentasaRangeIIIoffender.Inthisappealasamatterof  \ right,thedefendantclaimstheconflictbetweenthetrialcourtserroneouswrittenjuryinstruction B requiringproofofvenuein LincolnCounty,andtheoralinstructionrequiringproofofvenuein (  MarshallCounty,requiresreversal.Afterathroughreviewoftherecord,weconcludethatthe  issuehasbeenwaived.Furthermore,regardlessofwaiver,anyerrorinthewrittenjuryinstruction  wasclearlyharmless.Therefore,weaffirmthejudgmentofthetrialcourt.   Tenn.R.App.P.3AppealasofRight;JudgmentoftheCriminalCourtAffirmed  V   JoeG.Riley,J.,deliveredtheopinionofthecourt,inwhichDavidH.WellesandNormaMcGee "r Ogle,JJ.,joined. X DonnaLeigh_Hargrove_,DistrictPublicDefender;AndrewJackson_Dearing_,III,AssistantDistrict $ PublicDefender,Fayetteville,Tennessee(attrial);andJohnE._Herbison_,Nashville,Tennessee(on   appeal),fortheappellant,BobbyJoeRollins.  PaulG.Summers,AttorneyGeneralandReporter;MarvinE.Clements,Jr.,AssistantAttorney l!! General;WilliamMichael_McCown_,DistrictAttorneyGeneral;and_Weakley_ԀE.Barnard,Assistant R"" DistrictAttorneyGeneral,fortheappellee,StateofTennessee. 8## @@OO& OPINION  %:!&     Thedefendantwasconvictedofrecklessaggravatedassaultandsentencedtotenyears '#( incarcerationasaRangeIIIoffender.Defendantcontendsthatthetrialcourtcommittedreversible (#) errorwhenitsubmittedanerroneouswrittenjuryinstructiononvenuethatwasdifferentfromthe )$* oraljuryinstruction.Uponreviewoftherecord,weaffirmthejudgmentofthetrialcourt. h*%+ @22& I.FACTS  -j(. ; 8.$XXdXXd8     Thedefendantwasmarriedtothevictim,ConnieSueAdams,fromAprilof1998,to  Novemberof1998.Theydivorcedfivedayspriortothisincident.OnNovember11,1998,the | defendant,withoutprovocation,stabbedthevictim. b @@@# II.ANALYSIS   d   Onappeal,defendantcontendsthatthetrialcourtswrittenjuryinstructioncontaininga  0 referenceto LincolnCountywasprejudicialerror.Theinstructionread, [_t]he_Ԁstatemustprove    beyondareasonabledoubt...thatthecrime,ifinfactcommitted,wascommittedbythisdefendant    inLincolnCounty,Tennessee.#XA"XXX.$=#X.$XXXA"However,thedefendantfailedtoincludethisissueinthemotion   fornewtrial.Therefore,thisissueiswaived.Tenn.R.App.P.3(e);seeStatev._Spadafina_,952 x  S.W.2d444,451(Tenn._Crim_.App.1996).#XA"XXX.$w#X.$XXXA"Ԁ ^    Regardlessofwaiver,theerroneousjuryinstructionwasclearlyharmless.Ajurychargeis *z  prejudiciallyerroneousifitfailstofairlysubmitthelegalissuesormisleadsthejury.Statev._Vann_, ` 976S.W.2d93,101(Tenn.1998).Contradictorystatementsinajurychargearesubjecttoa F harmlesserroranalysis.SeeStatev._Dulsworth_,781S.W.2d277,285(Tenn._Crim_.App.1989) , (findingcontradictoryinstructionsastowhetherawitnesswasanaccomplicetobeharmlesserror).  ThiscrimeoccurredinMarshallCounty;allevidencepresentedattrialconcernedMarshallCounty;  thecasewastriedinMarshallCounty;andtheoraljuryinstructionproperlyinstructedthatthestate  mustprovethatthecrimeoccurredinMarshallCounty.Infact,theonlyreferencetoLincoln t Countywaswithintheparticularwrittenjuryinstructionnowatissue.Thereisnoindicationthat Z thejurywasmisledbytheclericalerrorcontainedinthewrittencharge.Thus,weconcludetheerror @ washarmless.SeeTenn.R.App.P.36(b).  &v   Accordingly,thejudgmentofthetrialcourtisaffirmed. B    `     h        `     h     ___________________________________ V"!    `     h     JOEG.RILEY,JUDGE <#" ]XXX.$@tt#X.$X]Xl#rXX.$INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE R+&+  b  8A"XXdXXd8    _@kk$ATNASHVILLE#X.$Xr#]XXX.$Ԉ  @September19,2000Session   #X.$X]X# ]XXX.$  ӀSTATEOFTENNESSEEv.BOBBIEJOEROLLINS#X.$X]X#   @  CriminalCourtforMarshallCounty   @FF&No.13789   @*AV) ` dE<O ` A߈ P   @No.M199902457CCAR3CD E  AV) ` dE<` A a   @& JUDGMENT  V    Cametheappellant,BOBBIEJOEROLLINS,bycounsel,andthestate,bytheAttorney  General,andthiscasewasheardontherecordonappealfromtheCriminalCourtofMarshall  County;anduponconsiderationthereof,thisCourtisoftheopinionthatthereisnoreversibleerror  inthejudgmentofthetrialcourt. j   Itis,therefore,orderedandadjudgedbythisCourtthatthejudgmentofthetrialcourtis 6 affirmed,andthecaseisremandedtotheCriminalCourtof Marshall Countyforexecutionofthe l judgmentofthatcourtandforcollectionofcostsaccruedbelow. R   Itappearsthatappellantisindigent.CostsofappealwillbepaidbytheStateofTennessee.  Ѐ   `     h     PerCuriam     `     h     JoeG.Riley,Judge L      `     h     DavidH.Welles,Judge 2!!    `     h     NormaMcGeeOgle,Judge#XA"XXX.$#X.$XXXA" "h" #XA"XXX.$]%#X.$XXXA"#XA"XXX.$%#