WPC  3P+u(g5p>r*Eb`G ..YMx*ȡ6o}@?jL[jLz\%6bE. R9f-\\^rGIAE]6 z{̞'$'TrC\ ~+U; Wq/b䇍R;!2*On\ngmlTP.%D j֣-Ѽ*’0󝶇jU1Yy[B/P&4 ИL̴@CL _-f (:s>|G0񨢃͈L8, WN7wtR?&0XY A|Є&Lv,|Agb?5W/3$ ?s9;B&}[ʛȂgfRb Z U(.#{/ֈt f{B+*q~JR:&nH1nZz„5qb#)xP)# >U NI % 0(4U :U:"b\ 0Ddw@$U:U:N 0l 0D]8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 AQ  0D B 0D D/Q Q B D3 HP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nLh(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($n~<$ @ d3|x>7,cAZ"Arial Regular,rAZ"Arial Regular- -(3$ !   *7+7,7-7.7D/707?e1727Ӏ>7  !"  X?XXXG.XX?   Ad FILEDX?XG.   July9,1998  CecilCrowson,Jr.XX?AppellateCourtClerk ,cAZ"Arial Regular,cAZ"Arial Regular((3$ !      0  (#$  0   S     #Xd#   ! #%C<< CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !   d($$   1  ''' dxdP Pd""""'dxd !  070707074X?XXXTR[A' Legal3'A' Legal3'T  aќ>72727r (<,(j 8` `@E` ttx$, r>7INTHECOURTOFCRIMINALAPPEALSOFTENNESSEE  >7t (>.*jx` `@Eg` ttx$ tߛ>7*,XXXX* @  @  @<  @ ATJACKSONJUNE1998SESSION  `    * 4,XXX* 474STATEOFTENNESSEE#X~XXX?M#X?XXX~, 7 )    4 747  7 )C.C.A.No.0707070702C01070707079707CR00290 Appellee, 7 )     7 )07070707Shelby07070707CountyV. 7 ) n    7 )HonorableJamesC.Beasley,Jr.,Judge  7 ) GREGORYWHITFIELD, #X~XXX?S#X?XXX~ 7 )(AggravatedRobbery,AggravatedAssault)  p Ѐ  7 )  \  Appellant. 7 ) B 4c4 #X~XXX?s#X?XXX~ԀFORTHE#X~XXX?#X?XXX~ԀAPPELLANT:#X~XXX?#X?XXX~ c FORTHEAPPELLEE:#X~XXX?'#X?XXX~ p ACWharton,Jr. c JohnKnoxWalkup < #X~XXX?#X?XXX~07070707Shelby07070707CountyPublicDefender c AttorneyGeneral&Reporter "r TonyN.07070707Brayton07070707 c Georgia07070707Blythe0707070707070707Felner07070707 > AssistantPublicDefender c CounselfortheState $ (OnAppeal) c CriminalJusticeDivision    c 07070707Cordell07070707HullBuilding,SecondFloorMichaelJohnson c 425FifthAvenueNorth "! KevinReed c Nashville,TN372430493 l#" AssistantPublicDefenders201PoplarAvenue,Suite201 c WilliamL.Gibbons 8% $ Memphis,TN38103 c DistrictAttorneyGeneral &n!% (AtTrial) c  'T"&  c DavidB.Shapiro c Chris07070707Marshburn07070707 c AssistantDistrictAttorneysGeneral c 201PoplarAvenue,Suite301 c Memphis,TN38103OPINIONFILED:___________________ AFFIRMED  2.3  PAULG.SUMMERS,  4/5 М17Judge17#X~XXX? # X?XXX~   4 D4c QDD/D "8r39 27a  73XXdXXd7   a     #Xd#    27 Q(DOPINION  ;"7= a  73XXdXXd7   27a     #Xd#    27XXXX  Theappellant,GregoryWhitfield,wasconvictedbyajuryofXXXXaggravated  robbery#XXXXk#ԀandaggravatedassaultintheShelbyCountyCriminalCourt.Thetrial   courtoverruledhismotionforanewtrialandheappeals.Thesoleissueforourreviewiswhethertheevidenceissufficienttosupportthejurysverdict. OnJuly13,1995,YuetLeeandherson,Albert,wereworkingatthefamilybusiness,theB&Gmarket,inMemphis.Alonemanenteredthestore.Hewasnotwearingamask.HepointedagunatYuetLeeanddemandedmoneyandcigarettes.YuetLeecompliedwithhisrequest.Shetestifiedthatshewasafraidofthegunman.Leesson,Albert,wasalsointhestore.ThemanpointedthegunatAlbertandtoldhimtolieonthefloor.Thegunmanfled.YuetLeepressedasilentalarmandthepolicesoonarrived. LieutenantC.G.GordonoftheMemphisPoliceDepartmentinvestigatedtherobbery.HeshowedYuetLeeandAlbertaphotographiclineupseparately.Theybothidentifiedtheappellantastheperpetratoroftherobbery.Attrial,YuetLeeidentifiedtheappellantasthemanwhorobbedheratgunpoint.Shetestifiedtheappellanthadbeenacustomerinthestorebeforetherobbery.YuetLeealsotestifiedthattheappellantsfamilyhadbeencustomersinthestoreforalongtime.Attrial,Albertidentifiedtheappellantastheperpetratoroftherobbery.Alberttestifiedthattheappellanthadbeenacustomerinthestorebeforetherobbery.̀  h0`).  Theappellantchallengesthesufficiencyoftheevidence.XXXXInasufficiency 42,+0 oftheevidencechallenge,therelevantquestiononappellatereviewiswhether,afterviewingtheevidenceinthelightmostfavorabletotheprosecution,anyrationaltrieroffactcouldhavefoundtheessentialelementsofthecrimeor 706 crimesbeyondareasonabledoubt.Jacksonv.Virginia,443U.S.307,99S.Ct.  2781,61L.Ed.2d560(1979);07070707T.R.A.P.070713(e);#XXXX#XXXXԀState0707v.Duncan,698S.W.2d63  0707(Tenn.1985).0707070707070707 InTennessee,greatweightisgiventotheresultreachedbythejuryinacriminaltrial.Ajuryverdictaccreditsthetestimonyofthestate'switnessesandresolvesallconflictsinfavorofthestate.Statev.Williams,657S.W.2d405  0707(Tenn.'7'71983).07070707Moreover,aguiltyverdictreplacesthepresumptionofinnocenceenjoyedattrialwiththepresumptionofguiltonappeal.Statev.Grace,493  S.W.2d4740707(Tenn.)7(7(71)7*71*7973).07070707Theappellanthastheburdenofovercomingthepresumptionofguilt.Id.Onappeal,thestateisentitledtothestrongest  legitimateviewoftheevidenceandallreasonableinferenceswhichmaybedrawntherefrom.Statev.Cabbage,571S.W.2d8320707(Tenn.+7+71978).#XI(XXXI(#07070707 H!@ Ѐ Theappellantssufficiencyoftheevidenceissuechallengestheidentificationoftheappellantastheperpetratoroftheoffenses.Heconcedesthattheeyewitnesstestimonyissufficientevidencetosupporttheappellantsconvictions.Heargues,however,thattheeyewitnesstestimonyis untrustworthy.TheappellantpointsoutthattherobberyoccurredquicklyandthatYuetLeehasgreatdifficultyseeingwithoutherglasses.Healsopointsoutthatthereisnophysicalevidencelinkingtheappellanttothecrime.HecontendsthattheYuetLeeandAlbertdidnotgivethepoliceadescriptionoftheperpetrator0707-7before-7.7,7BEFO,7priorto.7/7/7identifying07070707theappellantinthephotographiclineup.NeitherpartyaskedYuetLeewhethershewaswearingherglassesonthedayoftherobbery.NeitherpartyaskedYuetLee,herson,orLieutenantGordonwhether 704 theLeesgaveadescriptionoftheperpetrator.Theappellantsrelianceonthosefactorstochallengethesufficiencyoftheevidenceisunconvincing. Thereissufficientevidencefromwhichthejurycouldhaveidentifiedtheappellantastheperpetratoroftheoffensesbeyondareasonabledoubt.YuetLeeandAlbertidentifiedtheappellantastheperpetratorinaphotographiclineup.Bothtestifiedthattheappellanthadbeeninthestorebeforetherobbery.Attrial,YuetLeeandAlbertidentifiedtheappellantastheperpetrator.See (  XI(XXXI(Statev.Johnson#XI(XXXI("#,XI(XXXI(910S.W.2d897(Tenn.Crim.App.1995)#XI(XXXI("#   Thejudgmentofthetrialcourtisaffirmed. 704 Ї! 4 Dp4 D! QDD/D p _____________________________   QDD/D p PAULG.SUMMERS,Judge  CONCUR:___________________________DAVIDH.07070707WELLES07070707,Judge___________________________JOEG.07070707RILEY07070707,Judge