WPC trٱIr:J| mV4@f#!;D "v(dqLBcѩ,pl2Lj\M3iWa'YOg46lr'Dj菋oAɭe F* cwplNY%U"0ӁXئʊ6 mu\ٯe'x?So'THgYI[;^0x,ρhxK>,X(kg7,]jxPx֮sS @>  October11,1999  %  '  0*  ,  .  81  $ XX*%Xddd Xdd Xdd XXH?XH?,<dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ," dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY ':" 'TRIALJUDGE ':" 'TRIAL :  COURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE/JUDGMENT '  " 'NATUREOF :  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION :"  _BVT_ԀLebanonShoppingCenter,Ltd.,a  B TennesseeLimitedPartnership,  ( vs. f   WalMartStores,Inc.,aCorporation,and L  KuhnsBigKStoresCorporation,a 2  TennesseeCorporation   01A019710CV00607    WilsonCircuit   B BobbyH.Capers 7-  B @9113@79113 6,* B @9113 @ 6Cain,J.  B AffirmedasModified  ( andRemanded f     L  Rule11   B  Granted 󀄀ApplicationofWal  B MartStores,Inc.andKuhns  (  BigKStoresCorp. f  !   L "  FrederickWayne_Cavitt_ x # vs. ^$ TennesseeDepartmentofCorrection D% 01A019712CH00713  *& DavidsonChancery  x ' Ellen_Hobbs_ԀLyle  x ( 972994III  x ) Cottrell,J. x * Affirmedand ^+ Remanded  D, Rule11  x -  Denied 󀄀Applicationof x . FrederickWayne_Cavitt_ ^/   D0  Giles_Damron_Ԁ L1 vs. 22 MediaGeneral,Inc.,_NES_,II,Inc.,d/b/a p3 _Onduline_ԀSalesandService,andGarden V4 StatePaperCompany,Inc.,awholly <5 ownedsubsidiaryofMediaGeneral,Inc. "6 01A019805CV00251  7 LincolnCircuit  L8 F.LeeRussell  L9 C9600043  L: _Cantrell_,_P.J._ L; Reversedand 2< Remanded  p= Rule11  L>  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGiles L? _Damron_;recommendedthatthe 2@ CourtofAppealsopinionbe pA published. VB   <C  DanielB.Taylor *D vs. hE StateofTennessee,etal NF 01A019707CH00338  4G DavidsonChancery  *H CarolMcCoy  *I 96859II  *J _Cantrell_,_P.J._ *K Affirmedand hL Remanded  NM Rule11  *N  Dismissed 󀄀Applicationof *O DanielB.Taylor;application hP wasnottimelyfiled.  NQ  UnitedSteelworkersofAmerica VR vs.  <S TennesseeAirPollutionControlBoard z!"T 01A019605CH00235  `" U DavidsonChancery  VV Irvin_Kilcrease_  VW 953724I  VX Koch,J. VY Reversedand  <Z Remanded  z!"[ Rule11  V\  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTNAir V] PollutionControlBoard  <^   z!"_   #!`   #!a   #!b   #!c   #!d   #!e   #!f  8vXXdd8   StateofTennessee d vs. J LeslieHereford 0 01C019803CR00100  n DavidsonCriminal  d SethNorman  d 95C2206& d 96C1232  J Riley,J. d  Affirmed  J  Rule11  d   Denied,concurringinresults d  only ApplicationofLeslie J  Hereford 0   n  StateofTennessee  vs. v DarylHooper \ 01C019711CC00507   B _Humphreys_ԀCriminal   AllenW.Wallace 7-  @8995@78995 6,* @8995 @ 6Smith,J.  Affirmed  v Rule11    Granted 󀄀ApplicationofState  ofTennessee v   \  StateofTennessee   vs.   _Ricky_ԀHill_Krantz_   01C019406CR00207   n  DavidsonCriminal   ! RandallWyatt   " 94A21   # _Tipton_,J.  $ Affirmed   % Rule11   &  Granted 󀄀Applicationof_Ricky_  ' Hill_Krantz_;forthesolepurpose  ( ofremandingthecasetothe  ) CourtofCriminalAppealsfor  n * reconsiderationinlightofthis T + CourtsopinioninStatev. : , MarvinK.Ferguson. x -   ^.  StateofTennessee / vs. f0 DonaldK.Moore,Jr. L1 01C019801CR00032  22 DavidsonCriminal  3 RandallWyatt  4 96C1428  5 Ogle,J. 6 Affirmed  f7 Rule11  8  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonald 9 K.Moore,Jr. f:   L;  StateofTennessee < vs. = JefferyL.Perry x> 01C019710CC00467  ^? _Dickson_ԀCriminal  @ RobertE.Burch  A CR2141  B Wade,_P.J._ C Affirmed  D Rule11  E  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJeffery F L.Perry G   xH  StateofTennessee 0I vs. J JeffreyEdward_Pitts_ K 01C019701CC00003  L WayneCriminal  0M James 0N _Weatherford_ 8. O @10551@810551 7-+0P @10551 @ 7Smith,J. 0Q AffirmedinPart, R ReversedinPart  S Rule11  0T  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJeffrey 0U Edward_Pitts_ V   W  StateofTennessee d vs. J _Eldred_ԀReid 0 01C019511CC00390  n RutherfordCriminal  d JosephS.Daniel  d F24217  d _Peay_,J. d OrderDenyingProSe J   NoticeofClaimof 0  Exemptionof n   Garnishmentand T  DenialofProSe :  Motionto   Reconsider/Rehearin    BancandMotion   forAppointmentof  z Counsel   `  Rule11  d  Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Eldred_ d Reid J   0  StateofTennessee 2  vs.   KarlShields   01C019707CR00239    DavidsonCriminal  2  SethNorman  2  96C1340  2  Wade,_P.J._ 2  Affirmed    Rule11  2   Denied,concurringinresults 2 ! only ApplicationofKarl  " Shields  #    $  StateofTennessee ^% vs. D& _Lon_ԀS.Walker *' 01C019711CR00535  ( PutnamCriminal  ^) LeonC.Burns,Jr.  ^* 960087  ^+ Hayes,J. ^, Affirmed  D- Rule11  ^.  Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Lon_ ^/ Walker D0   *1  RockyLee_Coker_Ԁ 22 vs. p3 StateofTennessee V4 01C019804CC00152  <5 _Sequatchie_ԀCriminal  26 WilliamS.Russell 7- 27 @4778@74778 6,*28 @4778 @ 6_Peay_,J. 29 AppealDismissed  p: Rule11  2;  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRocky 2< Lee_Coker_ p=   <?  GeneCrank ^@ vs. DA KevinMyers,Warden *B 01C019903CC00106  hC WayneCircuit  ^D  8. ^E @11824@811824 7-+^F @11824 @ 7Smith,J. ^G OrderDenying DH PetitionforWritof *I HabeasCorpus  hJ Rule11  ^K  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGene ^L Crank DM   *N  GrantC._Ivey_ O vs. pP StateofTennessee VQ 01C019801CC00052   <R RutherfordCriminal  S JosephS.Daniel  T F42148  U _Tipton_,J. V Affirmed  pW Rule11  X  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGrant Y C._Ivey_ pZ   V[ _ CharlesEdwardMeeks d  vs. J StateofTennessee 0 01C019807CC00295  n GrundyCriminal  d ThomasW. d Graham 7- J 7@59437@75943 6,*d 7@5943 7@ 6Witt,J. d  Affirmed  J  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharles d  EdwardMeeks J    n  DerrickS.Sams  vs. v StateofTennessee \ 01C019712CC00592   B WilliamsonCriminal   HenryD.Bell   397112   Ogle,J.  Affirmed  v Rule11    Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDerrick  S.Sams v   \  DerrickSawyers   vs.   StateofTennessee   01C019806CR00254   n  DavidsonCriminal   ! RandallWyatt   " 96B825,96  # A360,96B  $ 1044   % Peay,J.  & Affirmed   ' Rule11   (  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDerrick  ) Sawyers  *    +  AntonioL.Sweatt @ , vs. & - StateofTennessee  . 01C019811CR00454  / DavidsonCriminal  @ 0 SteveDozier  @ 1 90S1362  @ 2 Woodall,J. @ 3 OrderGranting & 4 MotiontoAffirm  5 Rule20  6 Rule11  @ 7  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAntonio @ 8 L.Sweatt & 9    :   l;   l<   l=   l>   l?   l@   lA  RichardandPatriciaWarmath B vs. tC RogerD.Payne,etal ZD 02A019803CH00084  @E TiptonChancery  F Chancellor G Whitenton 8. tH @16384@816,384 7-+I @16384 @ 7Highers,J. J Affirmed  tK Rule11  L  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDr. M RogerD.Payne tN   ZO   P   Q   R   S   T   U   V  StateofTennessee 4W vs. rX CharlesG.Bledsoe XY 02C019809CC00269  >Z MadisonCriminal  4[ RoyMorgan  4\ 966  4] Peay,J. 4^ Affirmed  r_ Rule11  4`  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharles 4a GwynneBledsoe rb   Xc  StateofTennessee  `d  vs. Fe ThomasBrandonBooker  ,f 02C019810CC00323  j!g HardinCriminal  `h CreedMcGinley 7- `i @7674@77674 6,*`j @7674 @ 6Hayes,J. `k Affirmed  Fl Rule11  `m  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofThomas `n BrandonBooker Fo    ,p  StateofTennessee  d  vs. J IvoryDubose 0 02C019808CR00237  n ShelbyCriminal  d W.FredAxley  d 9711259  d Peay,J. d Affirmed  J  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀ApplicationofIvory d  Dubose J    0   StateofTennessee  vs. v JohnGreer \ 02C019806CR00167   B ShelbyCriminal   ChrisB.Craft   9708635   Peay,J.  Affirmed  v Rule11    Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohn  Greer v   \  StateofTennessee   vs.   MelvinHenning   02C019804CC00099   n  MadisonCriminal    Franklin    Murchison   ! 95391   " Beasley,Sp.J.  # Affirmedand  $ ModifiedAppellants  % Sentence   n & Rule11   '  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMelvin  ( Henning  )    *  StateofTennessee @ + vs. & , ClemHenry  - 02C019803CR00063  . ShelbyCriminal  @ / JosephDailey  @ 0 9704015,97 @ 1 08220  & 2 Riley,J. @ 3 Affirmed  & 4 Rule11  @ 5  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofClem @ 6 Henry & 7    8  StateofTennessee l9 vs. R: VernonLove(akaVernaleLove) 8; 02C019801CC00011  < CarrollCriminal  l= JulianP.Guinn  l> 97CR1063  l? Peay,J. l@ Affirmed  RA Rule11  lB  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofVernon lC Love  RD  StateofTennessee @E vs. ~&F RonaldL.McCray d G 02C019809CC00292 JH   0I FayetteCriminal  @J JonKerry @K Blackwood 7- ~&L B@3873B@73873 6,*@M B@3873 B@ 6Peay,J. @N AffirmedPursuantto ~&O Rule20  d P Rule11  @Q  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRonald @R LatureMcCray ~&S   d T  StateofTennessee RU vs. 8V DonaldTallie vW 02C019807CC00229  \X CarrollCriminal  RY CreedMcGinley  RZ 97CR1080  R[ Hayes,J. R\ Affirmed  8] Rule11  R^  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonald R_ Tallie  8`  StateofTennessee d vs. J JamesYoung 0  02C019805CR00144  n ShelbyCriminal  d ChrisB.Craft  d 9606641  d Tipton,J. d Affirmed  J  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJames d  Young J    0   TyroneClay  vs. v StateofTennessee \ 02C019611CC00410   B LakeCriminal   R.LeeMoore   95CR7178   Summers,J.  Affirmed  v Rule11    Dismissed forthereasonthatthe  petitionseekingpostconviction v reliefwasnottimelyfiled \ ApplicationofTyroneClay   B  JamesG.Wingard   vs.   FredRaney,Warden   02C019809CC00293   n  LakeCriminal     R.LeeMoore   ! 987835   " Woodall,J.  # AffirmedPursuantto  $ Rule20   % Rule11   &  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJames  ' G.Wingard  (    )   @ *   @ +   @ ,   @ -   @ .   @ /   @ 0  BettyJeanStreet b1 vs. H2 RobertL.Waddell,etal .3 03A019710CV00488  l4 WashingtonCircuit  b5 ThomasJ.Selley, b6 Jr. 7- H7 @7419@77419 6,*b8 @7419 @ 6Franks,J. b9 Affirmedand H: Remanded  .; Rule11  b<  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBetty b= JeanStreet H>   .?   @   A   B   C   D   E   F  StateofTennessee `G vs. FH DustinDwayneDavis ,I 03C019712CR00543  J KnoxCriminal  `K RayL.Jenkins 8. `L  @46233 @846233 7-+`M  @46233  @ 7Witt,J. `N Affirmed  FO Rule11  `P  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDustin `Q D.Davis FR   ,S  StateofTennessee 4T vs. rU MarkDunlap XV 03C019702CC00070  >W SevierCriminal  4X RexHenryOgle 7- 4Y @6287@76287 6,*4Z @6287 @ 6Wade,J. 4[ Affirmed  r\ Rule11  4]  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMark 4^ Dunlap r_   X`  StateofTennessee `a vs. Fb TyrisHarvey  ,c 03C019710CC00447  j!d BlountCriminal  `e D.KellyThomas  `f C10213  `g Wade,J. `h Affirmed  Fi Rule11  `j  Granted&Remandedtothe `k CourtofCriminalAppealsfor Fl reconsiderationinlightof  ,m Statev.DavidKeithLane  j!n ApplicationofTyrisL.Harvey  P"o  StateofTennessee d vs. J ReginaldJohnson 0 03C019801CC00006  n BlountCriminal  d D.KellyThomas, d Jr.  J C9886  d Witt,J. d  Affirmed  J  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀Applicationof d  ReginaldJohnson J    0  StateofTennessee  vs. v JohnnyMartin \ 03C019711CR00520   B McMinnCriminal   R.StevenBebb   84443   Woodall,J.  Affirmed  v Rule11    Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnny  Martin v   \  StateofTennessee   vs.   SharonMarieShell   03C019803CR00119   n  HamiltonCriminal     StephenM.Beil 9/  !  A210066 A9210066 8., "  A210066  A 8Lafferty,J.  # Affirmed   $ Rule11   %  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSharon  & M.Shell  '    (  StateofTennessee @ ) vs. & * PhillipToddSwords  + 03C019807CR00239  , HamiltonCriminal  @ - DouglasA.Meyer 9/ @ . X A212683X A9212683 8.,@ / X A212683 X A 8Wells,J. @ 0 Affirmed  & 1 Rule11  @ 2  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPhillip @ 3 T.Swords  & 4  GregL.Baine l5 vs. R6 StateofTennessee 87 03C019806CR00201  8 PolkCriminal  l9 CarrollRoss 7- l: @4372@74372 6,*l; @4372 @ 6Smith,J. l< Affirmed  R= ЀRule11  l>  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGregL. l? Baine  R@  GlennThomasCollins @A vs. ~&B StateofTennessee d C 03C019806CR00209  JD KnoxCriminal  @E RayL.Jenkins 8. @F @59582@859582 7-+@G @59582 @ 7Smith,J. @H Affirmed  ~&I Rule11  @J  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGlenn @K ThomasCollins  ~&L  BobbyAllenJoyner lM vs. RN StateofTennessee 8O 03C019807CR00260  vP SullivanCriminal  lQ LynnW.Brown  lR C40,290  lS Woodall,J. lT Affirmed  RU Rule11  lV  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBobby lW AllenJoyner(Barker,J.not RX participating) 8Y   vZ  GaryWayneLowe [ vs.  ~\ StateofTennessee !d] 03C019806CR00222  "J ^ AndersonCriminal  _ JamesB.Scott,Jr.  ` C88161  a Lafferty,J. b Affirmed   ~c Rule11  d  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGary e WayneLowe   ~f  TimothyMorris d  vs. J StateofTennessee 0 03C019906CR00234  n GreeneCriminal  d JamesE.Beckner  d 8297C  d Witt,J. d Rule10  J  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀Applicationof d  TimothyMorris J    0                      5