WPC zH]M!5t65xтgJ1rOo(:tasNFb6a>%D ҵyˋK;f7ΩX~I-zcK&~@L9 (?oQ'9* oq(%^PN8Yx0=p}'m\7B3(e|Ld>z ,L$7-`&H@7vR3d=gi/Йн XΥ#Y<PU[Q5Z{J'25zq[#F UN %U 0([ f a - w 4   N ^  m 0l 0D7;{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{ B 04HP LaserJet 4Si,,,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A ##Xd#~(d 3|x  $    1    _Oralargumentshallbelimitedtothefollowingissues:(1)WhethertheCourtofAppealserredinrulingthattherewasagenuineissueofmaterialfactastothequestionof X whetherthereisaconspiracybythedefendantstodefraudtheplaintiffs.(2)Whetherthedefendantscanassertthedefenseoftestimonialprivilege."r(L U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   1 $    2    _Oralargumentshallbelimitedtothefollowingissues:(1)Didthedefendantreceiveineffectiveassistanceofcounsel?(2)Didthetrialcourterrinfailingtoinstructany X lesserincludedoffenses? d&c$""0 !  _XXTR[,'ALegal LandscapeX3' Letter 'ALegal Landscape3'T @9 SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @??5 STATELISTFORPERMISSIONTOAPPEAL > @@  July17,20000 %  '  0*  ,  .  81  3 $%<%< @ F  XX,X*%ddd Xdd Xdd X,H?,H?,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ," dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY ':" 'TRIALJUDGE ':" 'TRIAL :  COURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE/JUDGMENT '  " 'NATUREOF :  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION :"  CharlotteBrown,etal  B vs.  ( _Birman_ԀManagedCare,Inc.,etal f   M199902551SCR11CV  L  PutnamCircuit   B JohnA._Turnbull_   B 97J0266   B _Cantrell_,_P.J._  B Reversedand  ( remanded  f   Rule11   B  Granted 󀄀Applicationof  B _Birman_ԀManagedCare,_Birman_  ( &Associates,Dr.David_Birman_ f   andSueD._Birman_  #  1       L   StephenV.Lyons  n  vs. T  FarmersInsuranceExchange,etal : ! M199900160SCR11CV  x " WilliamsonChancery   n # CorneliaA.Clark   n $ I25499   n % Crawford,_P.J._  n & Reversedinpart, T ' affirmedinpartand : ( remanded  x ) Rule11   n *  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStephen  n + Lyons  T ,  WachoviaBankofNorthCarolina,N.A.,et - al . vs. f/ RuthE.Johnson,CommissionerofRevenue, L0 StateofTennessee  21  M199900166SCR11CV  p2 DavidsonChancery  3 CarolL.McCoy  4 97450II  5 Crawford,_P.J._ 6 Reversedand 7 remanded  f8 Rule11  9  Denied 󀄀Applicationof : WachoviaBankofNorth ; Carolina,N.A.,etal  f<  RonWilliams = vs. x> Berube&AssociatesandEssexInsurance ^? Company D@ M199800802SCR11CV  *A MarionChancery  B JeffreyF.Stewart 7- C :@5946:@75946 6,*D :@5946 :@ 6Highers,J. E Affirmed  xF Rule11  G  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRon H Williams  xI   J   K   L   M   N   O   P  8zXXdd8   StateofTennessee d vs. J StephenJohnAbbott 0  M199700127SCR11CD  n MauryCriminal  d WilliamB.Cain 7- d @9577@79577 6,*d @9577 @ 6Wade,J. d Reversedand J  remanded  0  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStateof d  Tennessee  J   StateofTennessee  vs. v HaroldW.Daniels \ M199900303SCR11CD   B _Cheatham_ԀCriminal   RobertE.Burch 8.  D@12937D@812937 7-+ D@12937 D@ 7Riley,J.  AffirmedRule20 v Order  \ Rule11    Denied 󀄀ApplicationofHarold  W.Daniels  v  StateofTennessee   vs.   Vernon_Elkins_,Jr.   M199700107SCDAPCD   n  CannonCriminal    JamesK.Clayton,    Jr.   ! F2494   " Riley,J.  # Affirmed   $ Rule11   %  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofVernon  & _Elkins_,Jr.   '  StateofTennessee @ ( vs. & ) DeborahLeigh_Goins_  * M199800758SCR11CD  + DavidsonCriminal  @ , FrankClement,Jr.  @ - 97T930  @ . Ogle,J. @ / Affirmedasmodified  & 0 Rule11  @ 1  Denied 󀄀Applicationof @ 2 DeborahLeigh_Goins_  & 3  StateofTennessee l4 vs. R5 ShirleyR.Hastings 86 M199800466SCR11CD  7 DavidsonCriminal  l8 FrankClement,Jr.  l9 98T502and l: 98T915  R; _Woodall_,J. l< Affirmed  R= Rule11  l>  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofShirley l? R.Hastings  R@  StateofTennessee @A vs. ~&B MichaelShane_Honeycutt_ d C M199800245SCR11CD  JD DavidsonCriminal  @E CherylA. @F Blackburn  ~&G 96B820  @H _Woodall_,J. @I Affirmed  ~&J Rule11  @K  Granted 󀄀Applicationof @L MichaelShane_Honeycutt_ #  2       ~&M  StateofTennessee lN vs. RO _Donielle_ԀHouse 8P M199800403SCR11CD  vQ DavidsonCriminal  lR SethW.Norman  lS 98C1603  lT _Witt_,J. lU AffirmedRule20  RV Rule11  lW  Denied 󀄀Applicationof lX DonielleHouse  RY  Stateof_Tennessee_ d  vs. J BruceEdwardLittle 0 M199902111SCR11PC  n DavidsonCriminal  d WalterC.Kurtz  d 90W326  d Per_ Curiam_  d Order/vacate& J  reinstate  0  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBruce d  EdwardLittle  J   Stateof_Tennessee_  vs. v DonaldRay_ Pannell_  \ M199900178SCR11CD   B MarshallCriminal   WilliamC.Lee 8.  @13697@813697 7-+ @13697 @ 7Riley,J.  Affirmed  v Rule11    Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonald  Ray_ Pannell_   v  Stateof_Tennessee_   vs.   JamesThomas_ Tyree_    M199800401SCR11CD   n  MarshallCircuit    WilliamC.Lee 8.   U@13483U@813483 7-+   U@13483 U@ 7Riley,J.  ! Affirmed   " Rule11   #  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJames  $ Thomas_ Tyree_    %  Stateof_Tennessee_ @ & vs. & ' BobbyJ.Young  ( M199800402SCR11CD  ) _ Dickson_ ԀCircuit  @ * RobertE.Burch  @ + CR3380  @ , Smith,J. @ - Affirmedinpart, & . vacatedandremanded  / inpart  0 Rule11  @ 1  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBobby @ 2 J.Young  & 3  DannyHouse l4 vs. R5 Stateof_Tennessee_ 86 M199800464SCR11CD  7 DavidsonCriminal  l8 SethNorman  l9 96A70  l: Riley,J. l; Reversedand R< remanded  8= Rule11  l>  Granted 󀄀ApplicationofState l? ofTennessee  R@  DannyJeromeJones @A vs. ~&B Stateof_Tennessee_ d C M199901949SCR11CD  JD DavidsonCriminal  @E J.RandallWyatt, @F Jr.  ~&G 92B738  @H Welles,J. @I Rule10denied  ~&J Rule11  @K  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDanny @L JeromeJones  ~&M   lN   lO   lP   lQ   lR   lS   lT  PatriciaB.Beck >U vs. $V HenryCountyMedicalCenter  W W199900457SCR11CV  X HenryCircuit     >Y  P  $Z JulianP._ Guinn_  7- >[ @1028@71028 6,*>\ @1028 @ 6Farmer,J. >] Highers,J. $^ Deniedrehearmotion   _ Rule11  >`  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPatricia >a B.Beck  $b  PatriciaB.Beck d vs. J  JoyceHudson,etal 0 W199902247SCR11CV  n HenryCircuit  d JulianP._Guinn_ 7- d @1029@71029 6,*d @1029 @ 6Farmer,J. d _Highers_,J. J  Deniedrehearmotion  0  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPatricia d  B.Beck  J   RobertEugeneLamb,etal  vs. v _Megaflight_,Inc.,etal \ W199800797SCR11CV   B _McNairy_ԀChancery   Judge_Whitenton_ 7-  @7310@77310 6,* @7310 @ 6_Highers_,J.  Reversedand v remanded  \ Rule11    Denied 󀄀Applicationof  _Megaflight_,Inc.,etal  v  Stateof_Tennessee_   vs.   EddieWilliams,Jr.   W200000190SCR11CV   n  TNClaimsCommission    RandyCamp 9/    F.A992102F.A9992102 8., ! F.A992102 F.A 8Farmer,J.  " _Highers_,J.  # Dismissedappeal   $ Rule11   %  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEddie  & Williams,Jr.   '   @ (   @ )   @ *   @ +   @ ,   @ -   @ .  StateofTennessee b/ vs. H0 WalterBlair .1 W199902157SCR11PC  l2 _Haywood_ԀCircuit  b3 Dick_Jerman_,Jr. 7- b4 X@1942X@71942 6,*b5 X@1942 X@ 6_Peay_,J. b6 Affirmed  H7 Rule11  b8  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWalter b9 Blair  H:  StateofTennessee ; vs. t< Leon_Goins_ Z= W199901681SCR11CD  @> DyerCircuit  ? R.LeeMoore,Jr.  @ C9895  A _Woodall_,J. B Affirmed  tC Rule11  D  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLeon E _Goins_  tF  StateofTennessee G vs. H CollierHarris I W199902144SCR11CD  lJ ShelbyCriminal  K W.Fred_Axley_  L 9504114  M _Woodall_,J. N Affirmed  O Rule11  P  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCollier Q V.Harris  R  StateofTennessee >S vs. $T Leslie_Mauro_ԀHudson  U W199900429SCR11PC  V _Haywood_ԀCircuit  >W Dick_Jerman_,Jr. 7- >X @1896@71896 6,*>Y @1896 @ 6Smith,J. >Z Affirmed  $[ Rule11  >\  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLeslie >] _Mauro_ԀHudson  $^  StateofTennessee d vs. J  DavidScott_Humphries_ 0 W199901785SCR11CD  n LauderdaleCircuit  d JoeH.Walker,III 7- d c@6499c@76499 6,*d c@6499 c@ 6Welles,J. d Affirmed  J  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDavid d  Scott_Humphries_  J   StateofTennessee   vs. v Marcus_Mabon_ \ W199901696SCR11CD   B ShelbyCriminal   Judge_Weinman_   9204709   Glenn,J.  Affirmed  v Rule11    Dismissed 󀄀Applicationof  Marcus_Mabon_;applicationfor v permissiontoappealwasnot \ timelyfiled,andthisCourtis  B thereforewithoutjurisdictionto  ( considersame.  f    StateofTennessee   vs.  n  RoyL.Morris T  W199901628SCR11CO    6  :  LakeCircuit/Criminal   ! R.LeeMoore,Jr.   " 997912   # Glenn,J.  $ Affirmed   n % Rule11   &  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRoyL.  ' Morris   n (  StateofTennessee  ) vs. * SamuelEarlPerry + W199901472SCR11CD  f, ShelbyCriminal   - ChrisCraft   . 9805024   / Riley,J.  0 Affirmed  1 Rule11   2  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSamuel  3 Perry  4  AlvinG.Taylor 85 vs. 6 StateofTennessee 7 W199901736SCR11PC  8 ShelbyCriminal  89 Fred_Axley_  8: P2152224  8; Hayes,J. 8< Affirmedpursuantto = Rule20  > Rule11  8?  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAlvin 8@ G.Taylor  A   d B   d C   d D   d E   d F   d G   d H  Charlene_Colvin_ԀLadd I vs. lJ DouglasEvan_Colvin_ RK E199902447SCR11CD  8L RheaCircuit  M BuddyD.Perry 8. N @19215@819215 7-+O @19215 @ 7_Goddard_,J. P Reversedand lQ remanded  RR Rule11  S  Denied 󀄀Applicationof T Charlene_Colvin_ԀLadd  lU  GloriaGeiger_Neuenschwander_  V vs. W RoyPatrick_Neuenschwander_  ~X E199901752SCR11CV  !dY KnoxChancery   Z WilliamM.  [ _Dender_  \ 1374261   ] Franks,J.  ^ Affirmedand _ remanded   ~` Rule11   a  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRoy  b Patrick_Neuenschwander_  c  _Pero_sSteak&SpaghettiHouse,etal d  vs. J ElizabethJeanHinkleLee,etal 0 E200000430SCR11CV  n KnoxCircuit  d WheelerA. d _Rosenbalm_  J 354196and d 354496  J  _Goddard_,J. d  _Swiney_,J. J  Rule9denied  0  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀ApplicationsofFirst d TennesseeBankand_Pero_s J Steak&SpaghettiHouse& 0 LouisInn  n  GeraldW.Smith  vs. v HarrimanUtilityBoard,etal \ E199902456SCR11CV   B _Roane_ԀCircuit   RussellE.  Simmons 8. v N@11420N@811420 7-+ N@11420 N@ 7_Swiney_,J.  Affirmed& v Remanded  \ Rule11    Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGerald  W.Smith  v  Mildred_Whaley_Ԁ    vs.  ! ScottGriffin_Wolfenbarger_  " E199902518SCR11CV   n # KnoxCircuit   $ Harold_Wimberly_   % 263294   & Susano,J.  ' Affirmedand  ( remanded   ) Rule11   *  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofScott  + Griffin_Wolfenbarger_   ,   @ -   @ .   @ /   @ 0   @ 1   @ 2   @ 3  StateofTennessee b4 vs. H5 StephenCraigDillard .6 E199900020SCR11CD  l7 SullivanCriminal  b8 PhyllisH.Miller  b9 S40,226  b: Sullivan,J. b; Affirmed  H< Rule11  b=  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStephen b> CraigDillard  H?  StateofTennessee  @ vs. tA BobbyG._Godsey_ԀandAllenHoyle ZB E199800127SCR11CD  @C SullivanCircuit  D R.JerryBeck  E S39,521  F Wade,J. G Affirmed  tH Rule11  I  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBobby J _Godsey_ԀandAllenHoyle  tK  StateofTennessee L vs. M JimmyD.Johnson N E199900146SCR11CD  lO _Blount_ԀCircuit  P D.KellyThomas, Q Jr.  R C8758  S _Tipton_,J. T Affirmed  U Rule11  V  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJimmy W D.Johnson  X  StateofTennessee >Y vs. $Z JohnGeorge_Kain_  [ E199800595SCR11CD  \ HamiltonCriminal  >] DouglasA.Meyer 9/ >^  A213620 A9213620 8.,>_  A213620  A 8Glenn,J. >` Affirmedasmodified  $a Rule11  >b  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohn >c George_Kain_  $d  _Arzolia_ԀC._Goines_ d vs. J  StateofTennessee 0 E199901199SCR11CD  n JohnsonCriminal  d RobertE._Cupp_ 7- d @3395@73395 6,*d @3395 @ 6_Tipton_,J. d Affirmed  J  Rule11  d   Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Arzolia_ d  Charles_Goines_  J   GregoryJamesHarper   vs. v StateofTennessee \ E199900798SCR11PC   B SullivanCriminal   R.JerryBeck   C41,705   Welles,J.  Affirmed  v Rule11    Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGregory  JamesHarper  v  WilliamL.Howell   vs.   StateofTennessee   E199901502SCR11PC   n  KnoxCriminal    MaryBeth   _Leibowitz_ 8.   @35016@835016 7-+   @35016 @ 7Riley,J.  ! Affirmed   " Rule11   #  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliam  $ LewisHowell   %  BrettRae @ & vs. & ' StateofTennessee   ( E199902080SCR11PC  ) _Sevier_ԀCircuit  @ * RexH.Ogle  @ + 97272  @ , Hayes,J. @ - Affirmed  & . Rule11  @ /  Denied 󀄀Application_of_ԀBrett @ 0 Rae;opinionoftheCourtof & 1 CriminalAppealsisdesignated  2  NotFor_Citation_ 3 0 X,