WPCfA  j046sʐ#LnO9REY-k@d`I }IHk ҵOaM4ЬJaU`~p'E];&Qn9]˃5sHĎdבWHO%,P1/@"6Mݰ5fb^hFq=r3+,K.6[.Wh>vT'] 䍲\*g |PhFRv !RLEBK1_/te% ew@[,G-ǫ}yNNyd 1a]Dg -(Y}m@# UNU % 0( f a b w 4  )( NQ^ S_ ma 0lx 0D( 0D0 0Ut 0 0 0e 0" 0 0 0G 0 0 0B 0  0 0a 0 0 B2 0O 0 0e 0! 0 0 07! 0! 0m" 0" 0# 1u$ 72$ 0N$ 0c% 0g% 0&"& 0& 0>' 0' 0( 0) 0* 0+ 0u, 0W- 0. 02. 0/ 0:0 0YK0 0_0 0 1 0 2 03 B*5 D/5 05 D/7 0#8 068 0'9 0:/: 0^i: 0<: 1e;U6h;U>;U*;"<<< D5(< 0D]<E<<"= AS=!> 0D> 0D+?o?o?o?o?"???????????????? D-@@@@@@@@@@@@ 04H@H@H@H@ A|@ 0KA\\IB01S01\CLERK1NAS,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE APage of &Eb0d 3|x  $    1    _ԀFororalargument,theCourtisparticularlyinterestedinthefollowingissues:  0  0` ..(1)IstheCourtofCriminalAppealsholdingthatadmissionofcodefendantBryant_Guartos_statementdidnotviolate r theConfrontationClausecontrarytoCrawfordv.Washington,124_S.Ct_.1354(2004)?`` .` .    ` (2)HasEdwinGomezaffirmativelywaivedtheCrawfordissue? N    ` (3)IsEdwinGomezssentenceexcessiveunder_Blakely_Ԁ_v._ԀWashington,124_S.Ct_.2531(2004)? <    ` (4)Isthe_Blakely_issuewaivedand,ifso,shouldtheCourtreviewtheissueforplainerror?D1 U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   (3$ !  *+ (_2623  ..*D+D (_25   ," <DL,23  ..," <DL,   *5+5 (_24  ) <DL)23  ..) <DL)  *2+2 (_23 ` &<<DL&23  ..&<<DL& ` */+/ (_22  #DL#23  ..#DL#      *,+, (_21   DL 23  .. DL  *)+) (_20 h DDL23  ..DDL h *&+& (_19  L23  ..L  *#+# (_18   L23  .. L  *>> (_17  2( 4 <DL223  Ԁ2( 4 <DL2  *DD (_16   ," <DL,23  Ԁ," <DL,   *55 (_15  ) <DL)23  Ԁ) <DL)  *22 (_14 ` &<<DL&23  Ԁ&<<DL& ` *// (_13  #DL#23  Ԁ#DL#  *,, (_12   DL 23  Ԁ DL  *)) (_11 h DDL23  ԀDDL h  d*&& (_10  L23  ԀL  (## &_9   L23  Ԁ L  (>> &_8  2( 4 <DL223  2( 4 <DL2  (DD &_7   ," <DL,23  ," <DL,   (55 &_6  ) <DL)23  ) <DL)  (22 &_5 ` &<<DL&23  &<<DL& ` (// &_4  #DL#23  #DL#  (,, &_3   DL 23   DL  ()) &_2 h DDL23  DDL h (&& &_1  L23  L  &## $_   L23   L  3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)1i)(O$(;3$2#  0  .3  0  0AA.Normal  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5  <AA:Definition T  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5      <AA:Definition L , 5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 586Definition(hh&H1  5+ ` hp x 5      5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H2  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H3  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H4  5+ ` hp x 5 XXX 5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H5  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H6  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  2DD0Address  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5  8MM6Blockquote , , 5+ ` hp x 5   5+ ` hp x 5,*CITE,dl*CODEKU<6X9`(Courier NewKSV\  `&Times New RomanS42Emphasis64Hyperlink    <:FollowedHype    4go2Keyboard KU<6X9`(Courier NewKSV\  `&Times New RomanS <:Preformatted  /%  ,Kk %#/KU<6X9`(Courier NewKSV\  `&Times New RomanS/%  ,Kk %#/  <:zBottom of 7K(X7    5+ ` hp x 5?W%2A`Arial?  SV\  `&Times New RomanS7x(X75+ ` hp x 5  &  d dJ)1dxd<:zTop of For7M(X7    5+ ` hp x 5?W%2A`Arial?  SV\  `&Times New RomanS7x(X75+ ` hp x 5  J)2dxd0KS.SampleKU<6X9`(Courier NewKSV\  `&Times New RomanS0.Strong 8dl6TypewriterKU<6X9`(Courier NewKSV\  `&Times New RomanS42Variable: 8HTML MarkupB      2 0CommentB   !"#$& 35;AGMSY_11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.<6X9`(Courier New\  `&Times New Roman%2A`Arial    %%%%)!dxdx(3$ !   ;   #<2Xd#сLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5    ab\c[E<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1        \R'3 Letter Landscape\    )!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRO'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter Landscape3'LetterTXX, 8pXXdd8]URdV7{Ih{IX{I{I_{I0  081810` 8181@*` 81` 81SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE , @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS  @, Monday,October4,2004 x      Ӏ   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd , dd ,dd ,edd , dd +  $ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER '$" 'COUNTY $ TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE $  JUDGE   JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE $ OF  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION '$" ' ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  'James_Corbin_Ԁv.TomLangeCompany,   Inc.   M200201162SCR11CV '  'DavidsonCircuit   EllenH.Lyle   01532III '  'Kirby,J.   Affirmed '  'Rule11 '  ' Denied ApplicationofTomLange   Company,Inc. ' ! 'StevenD.Elliottv.GingerW.Elliott b6" (_Ecton_) P$# M200300492SCR11CV '>$ 'DavidsonCircuit b6% MurielRobinson P$& 00D2375 '>' 'Koch,P.J., b6( M.S. P$) Affirmedin >* Part,Modified ,+ inPart& , Remanded '- 'Rule11 'b6. ' Denied ApplicationofStevenDale b6/ Elliott. 'P$0 'InRe:_A.M.T._,_Z.T.R._Ԁand_K.W.T._ ^1 M200302926SCR11PT 'xL2 'DavidsonJuvenile ^3 BettyK.Adams xL4 2272605,201957602, f:5 201953684&221970163 'T(6 'Clement,J. ^7 Affirmedin xL8 Part,Reversed f:9 InPart T(: (Separate B; concurringby 0< Cain,J.) '= 'Rule11 '^> ' Denied Applicationof_K.L.T_Ԁ '^? 'IntheMatterof:S.M. t@ TheAssociationforGuidance,Aid, bA PlacementandEmpathy(AGAPE)v. |PB RicardoLara j>C M200300422SCR11PT 'X ,D 'DavidsonJuvenile tE BettyK.Adams bF 221967013 '|PG 'Koch,P.J., tH M.S. bI Reversed '|PJ 'Rule11 'tK ' Denied ApplicationofThe tL AssociationforGuidance,Aid, bM PlacementandEmpathy(AGAPE). '|PN ']UR ],8pXXdXXd8 ]  _KennethW.Martinv.MarthaMartin d  M200202350SCR11CV 'R 'SumnerChancery d TomE.Gray R 2001D364 '@ 'Cottrell,J. d Affirmed 'R 'Rule11 'd ' Denied ApplicationofKennethW. d  Martin. 'R  'DominicP.Pellicanov.Metropolitan F  GovernmentofNashvilleandDavidson 4  County "   M200300292SCR11CV '  'DavidsonCircuit F CarolSoloman 4 00C3678 '"  'Clement,J. F Reversed, 4 Modifiedand "  Remanded '  'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicationofDominicP. F Pellicano. '4 'JosephSpiveyv.TerryPage,etal   M200200674SCR11CV '  'DavidsonChancery   IrvinH.Kilcrease,Jr.   992690I 'n  'Cottrell,J.   Reversedand   Remanded 'n  'Rule11 ' ! ' Denied ApplicationofTerryPageand  " Page&Associated,P.C. ' # 'BernadetteTinneyv.RosebudRecord& l $ Productions,etal Z % M200302550SCR11CV 'H & 'DavidsonCircuit l ' CarolSoloman Z ( 02C1691 'H ) 'Cain,J. l * Cottrell,J. Z + Clement,J. H , Dismissed '6- 'Rule11 'l . ' Denied ApplicationofVeraCavet l / Vanderpoold/b/aRosebudRecords& Z 0 Productions. 'H 1 'WilliamW.Yorkv.TennesseeBoardof <2 ProbationandParole *3 M200300822SCR11CV '4 'DavidsonChancery <5 IrvinH.Kilcrease,Jr. *6 013349I '7 'Cain,J. <8 Reversedand *9 Remanded ': 'Rule11 '<; ' Denied ApplicationofWilliamW. << York. '*= 'JamesRayBartlettv.StateofTennessee > M200300571SCR11HC '? 'WayneCircuit @ StellaHargrove A 28390,28490,28590, vB 28690 'dC 'Ogle,J. D Affirmed 'E 'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicatioofJamesRay G Bartlett. 'H 'JohnE.Carterv.StateofTennessee bI M200401178SCR11CO 'PJ 'WhiteCriminal bK 6734 'PL 'Welles,J. bM Woodall,J. PN Wedemeyer,J. >O Denied ',P 'Rule11 'bQ ' Denied ApplicationofJohnE.Carter. 'bR 'MonoletoD.Greenv.StateofTennessee 2S M200300998SCR11PC ' T 'RutherfordCircuit 2U DonAsh  V F52471 '!W 'Witt,J. 2X Affirmed ' Y 'Rule11 '2Z ' Denied ApplicationofMonoletoD. 2[ Green. ' \ 'dV dTRO'3 Letter LandscapeO'3 Letter Landscape'3Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeT d  WilliamLewisHoustonv.Stateof d  Tennessee R M200300304SCR11PC '@ 'GilesCircuit d RobertHolloway R 10265 '@ 'Smith,J. d Affirmed 'R 'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofWilliamLewis d  Houston. 'R  'MichaelD.Hughesv.StateofTennessee F  M200300819SCR11PC '4  'DavidsonCriminal F CherylBlackburn 4 92A184 '"  'Smith,J. F Affirmed '4 'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicationofMichaelD. F Hughes. '4 'DonWesleyMcMillanv.Stateof   Tennessee   M200300879SCR11PC '  'CoffeeCircuit   JohnW.Rollins   29,712 '  'Smith,J.   Affirmed '  'Rule11 '  ' Denied ApplicationofDonWesley   McMillan. '   'DonaldTerryMoorev.Stateof ~ ! Tennessee l " M200202417SCR11PC 'Z # 'DavidsonCriminal ~ $ CherylBlackburn l % 94B1017 'Z & 'Wade,J. ~ ' Affirmed 'l ( 'Rule11 '~ ) ' Denied ApplicationofDonaldTerry ~ * Moore. 'l + 'RobertDallisPaynev.Stateof ` , Tennessee N- M200301828SCR11CO '<. 'HickmanCircuit ` / R.E.LeeDavies N0 015078CI '<1 'Wedemeyer,J. ` 2 Welles,J. N3 Smith,J. <4 Motionto *5 Reopen 6 Dismissed '7 'Rule11 '` 8 ' Denied ApplicationofRobertDallis ` 9 Payne. 'N: 'PaulDennisReid,Jr.v.Stateof ; Tennessee v< M200401453SCR10PD 'd= 'DavidsonCriminal > CherylBlackburn v? 97C1834 'd@ 'Smith,J. A Welles,J. vB Woodall,J. dC Denied 'RD 'Rule10 'E ' Denied ApplicationofPaulDennis F Reid,Jr. 'vG 'JamesR.W.Reynoldsv.Stateof PH Tennessee >I M200300112SCR11HC ',J 'CoffeeCircuit PK L.CraigJohnson >L 31,019 ',M 'Glenn,J. PN Affirmed '>O 'Rule11 'PP ' Denied ApplicationofJamesR.W. PQ Reynolds. '>R 'JohnW.Smithv.StateofTennessee 2S M200300729SCR11PC ' T 'DavidsonCriminal 2U CherylBlackburn  V 99!C2088 '!W 'Wade,J. 2X Affirmed ' Y 'Rule11 '2Z ' Denied ApplicationofJohnW.Smith. '2[ '7{I 7 7  StateofTennesseev.TyrieBrown d  M200300556SCR11CD 'R 'FranklinCircuit d ThomasW.Graham R 13637 '@ 'Wedemeyer,J. d Affirmed 'R 'Rule11 'd ' Denied ApplicationofTyrieBrown. 'd  'StateofTennesseev.RafaelA.Bush F  M200202390SCR11CD '4  'RutherfordCircuit F  JamesK.Clayton 4  F50300B '"  'Tipton,J. F Affirmed '4 'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicationofRafaelA.Bush. 'F 'StateofTennesseev.JacobEdward   Campbell   M200300597SCR11CD '  'DavidsonCriminal   J.RandallWyatt   2001B896 '  'Wedemeyer,J.   Affirmed '  'Rule11 '  ' Denied ApplicationofJacobEdward   Campbell. ,"  `,StateofTennesseev.KimberlyJeannine ~  Cox l  M200201849SCR11CD 'Z  'MontgomeryCircuit ~ ! MichaelJones l " 40200158 'Z # 'Smith,J. ~ $ Affirmed 'l % 'Rule11 '~ & ' Granted ApplicationofKimberly ~ ' JeannineCox. 1'l ( ` `1StateofTennesseev.BobbyR.Dyer b ) M200203140SCR11CD 'P* 'WilliamsonCircuit b + CarolSoloman P, I302085 '>- 'Witt,J. b . Affirmed 'P/ 'Rule11 'b 0 ' Denied ApplicationofBobbyR.Dyer. ,"b 1 ` ,StateofTennesseev.EdwinGomezand >2 JonathanS.Londono ,3 M200201209SCR11CD '4 'DavidsonCriminal >5 CherylBlackburn ,6 2001A280 '7 'Hayes,J. >8 Affirmed ',9 'Rule11 '>: ' Granted ApplicationsofEdwin >; GomezandJonathanS.Londono.  #  1      ',< 'StateofTennesseev.PaulEdwin  = Graham > M200300331SCR11CD 'x? 'MontgomeryCircuit  @ MichaelR.Jones A 40100270 'xB 'Williams,J.  C Affirmed 'D 'Rule11 ' E ' Denied ApplicationofPaulEdwin  F Graham. 'G 'h{I h h  StateofTennesseev.JarretA.Guy d  M200202473SCR11CD 'R 'DavidsonCriminal d J.RandallWyatt R 2001B896 '@ 'Wade,J. d Affirmed 'R 'Rule11 'd ' Denied ApplicationofJarretA.Guy. 'd  'StateofTennesseev.MarcoPoloPatten F  M200300760SCR11CD '4  'WilsonCriminal F  J.O.Bond 4  010010 '"  'Welles,J. F Affirmed '4 'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicationofMarcoPolo F Patten. '4 'StateofTennesseev.CoreyLamont   Radley   M200301466SCR11CD '  'DavidsonCriminal   SteveDozier   2001B1114 '  'Woodall,J.   Affirmed '  'Rule11 '  ' Denied ApplicationofCoreyLamont   Radley. '  'StateofTennesseev.WilliamBurt ~  Smith l  M200202988SCR11CD 'Z ! 'FranklinCircuit ~ " BuddyD.Perry l # 12,226 'Z $ 'Williams,J. ~ % Affirmed 'l & 'Rule11 '~ ' ' Denied ApplicationofWilliamBurt ~ ( Smith. l ) **TheopinionoftheCourtofCriminal Z * Appealsisdesignated NotforCitation H + inaccordancewithSupremeCourtRule 6, 4,F. '$- 'StateofTennesseev.WilliamC. *. Tomlin,Jr. / M200301746SCR11CD '0 'WilliamsonCircuit *1 TimothyL.Easter 2 II1101360 '3 'Welles,J. *4 Affirmedas 5 Modified '6 'Rule11 '*7 ' Denied ApplicationofWilliamC. *8 Tomlin,Jr. '9 ' ': ' '; ' '< ' '= ' '> 'CharlesBrown,etalv.Crown  ? EquipmentCorporation t@ W200202228SCR11CV 'bA 'ShelbyCircuit  B RobertL.Childers tC 975289 'bD 'Farmer,J.  E Affirmedand tF Remanded 'bG 'Rule11 ' H ' Granted ApplicationofCharles  I Brown,BarbaraSueReynoldsand tJ HowardReynolds. 'bK 'TommyMurrayv.ChristianMethodist hL EpiscopalChurch VM W200200448SCR11CV 'DN 'ShelbyChancery hO FloydPeete,Jr. VP CH0009392 'DQ 'Kirby,J. hR Reversedand VS Remanded 'DT 'Rule11 'hU ' Denied ApplicationofTommyMurray. 'hV 'HelaineRichbergerv.TheWestClinic, BW P.C.,etal  0X W200300141SCR11CV '!Y 'ShelbyCircuit BZ JohnR.McCarrol  0[ 81970 '!\ 'Crawford,P.J., B] W.S.  0^ Affirmed '!_ 'Rule11 'B` ' Denied ApplicationofHelaine Ba __Richberger_. ' 0b 'X{I X X  RoyV.Smith,IIv.Grace_Hutchison_ d  (Blair) R W200300214SCR11JV '@ 'DyerJuvenile d CharlesV.Moore R 3134 '@ 'Farmer,J. d Affirmedand R Remanded '@  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofRoyV.Smith, d  II. 'R  'Guy_Varnadoe_Ԁv._Shelton_Ԁ_McGhee_,Jr.,et F  al 4 W200301341SCR11CV '"  'ShelbyChancery F Arnold_Goldin_ 4 9806672 '"  'Farmer,J. F Affirmedand 4 Remanded '"  'Rule11 'F ' Denied Applicationof_Shelton_ F _McGhee_,Jr.AndSandraT._McGhee_. '4 '_Wincor_,Inc.v.John_Dunlap_   W200202522SCR11CV '  'ShelbyCircuit   _DArmy_ԀBailey   CT00062802 '  'Highers,J.   Affirmed '  'Rule11 '   ' Denied Applicationof_Wincor_,Inc. ' ! 'SedleyAlleyv.StateofTennessee ~ " W200401204SCR11_PD_ 'l # 'ShelbyCriminal ~ $ W.Otis_Higgs_,Jr. l % P8040 'Z & 'Hayes,J. ~ ' Affirmed 'l ( 'Rule11 '~ ) ' Denied ApplicationofSedleyAlley. '~ * '_Odean_ԀCooperv.StateofTennessee ` + W200301518SCR11PC 'N, 'LauderdaleCircuit ` - JosephH.Walker N. 7176 '</ 'Riley,J. ` 0 Affirmed 'N1 'Rule11 '` 2 ' Denied Applicationof_Odean_ԀCooper. '` 3 'MarioPerryv.StateofTennessee :4 W200302220SCR11PC '(5 'ShelbyCriminal :6 JosephB.Dailey (7 P26622 '8 'Tipton,J. :9 Affirmed '(: 'Rule11 ':; ' Denied ApplicationofMarioPerry. ':< 'Henry_Rankins_,ProSev.Stateof = Tennessee  > W200301749SCR11PC 't? 'ShelbyCriminal @ J.C._McLin_  A P25228 'tB 'Riley,J. C Rule20  D Affirmed 'tE 'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicationofHenry_Rankins_. 'G 'StateofTennesseev.Anthony_Crowe_ zH W200300800SCR11CD 'hI '_McNairy_ԀCircuit zJ JonKerryBlackwood hK 1465A 'VL 'Williams,J. zM Affirmed 'hN 'Rule11 'zO ' Granted ApplicationofAnthony zP _Crowe__._ 'hQ 'StateofTennesseev._Thelisa_ԀEmeryand TR MauriceEmery BS W200202698SCR11CD ' 0T 'Gibson_Humbolt_ԀLawCourt TU _Clayburn_ԀPeebles BV H6980&H6981 ' 0W 'Witt,J. TX Affirmed 'BY 'Rule11 'TZ ' Denied Applicationof_Thelisa_ԀEmery. 'T[ '{I    StateofTennesseev.GaryJohnson d  W200300220SCR11CD 'R 'TiptonCircuit d JoeH.Walker R 4062 '@ 'Smith,J. d Affirmed 'R 'Rule11 'd ' Denied ApplicationofGaryJohnson. d  **TheopinionoftheCourtofCriminal R  Appealsisdesignated NotforCitation @  inaccordancewithSupremeCourtRule .  4,F. '  'StateofTennesseev.DavidPlunk "  W200000526SCR11CD '  'CrockettCircuit "  L.T.Lafferty   2939 ' z 'Riley,J. "  Affirmed '  'Rule11 '"  ' Dismissed ApplicationofDavid "  Plunk. '  'StateofTennesseev.Cornelius   Richmond n  W200300683SCR11CD '\  'ShelbyCriminal   JosephB.Dailey n  000674346 '\  'Riley,J.   Affirmed 'n  'Rule11 '   ' Denied ApplicationofCornelius  ! Richmond. 'n " 'StateofTennesseev.CliffordRogers Z # W200301375SCR11CD 'H $ 'ShelbyCriminal Z % JosephB.Dailey H & 020186970 '6' '_Woodall_,J. Z ( Affirmedin H ) Part, 6* Convictions $+ forFirst , DegreeMurder - Merged 'r. 'Rule11 'Z / ' Denied ApplicationofClifford Z 0 Rogers. 'H 1 'StateofTennesseev._Lenzo_Ԁ_Sherron_Ԁ_aka_ p2 Salaam_Shabazz_,prose ^3 W200301222SCR11CD 'L4 'DyerCircuit p5 LeeMoore ^6 C02393 'L7 'Williams,J. p8 Affirmed '^9 'Rule11 'p: ' Denied Applicationof_Lenzo_Ԁ_Sherron_ p; _aka_ԀSalaam_Shabazz_. '^< ' 'R= ' 'R> ' 'R? ' 'R@ ' 'RA 'PeggyBailey,etalv.Dr.John_Tasker_ PB E200300844SCR11CV '>C 'SullivanCircuit PD JohnS._McLellan_,III >E C34264 ',F 'Susano,J. PG Affirmed& >H Remanded ',I 'Rule11 'PJ ' Denied ApplicationofPeggyandGary PK Bailey. '>L '_JudithChristenberryv.StanleyF. 2M Tipton,etal  N E200301971SCR11CV '!O 'KnoxCircuit 2P DaleC.Workman  Q 151001 '!R 'Susano,J. 2S Affirmed ' T 'Rule11 '2U ' Granted ApplicationofJudith 2V Christenberry. ' W '_{I _ _  EstateofCarrollArchParkerv.Jackson d  NationalLifeInsurance,etal R E200301604SCR11CV '@ 'KnoxChancery d JohnF.Weaver R 1542291 '@ 'Susano,J. d Swiney,J. R Dismissed '@  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofDonandJanet d  Cameron. 'R  'FarmersMutualofTennesseev.Athens F  InsuranceAgency,CharlesW.Spurling 4 andCarolynSpurling "  E200301258SCR11CV '  'BradleyCircuit F JohnB.Hagler 4 V00172 '"  'Franks,J. F Affirmedin 4 Part;Reversed "  inPart '  'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicationofFarmersMutual F ofTennessee. '4 'FifthThirdBankv.BonnieS.Vaughn   E200400513*SCS10CV '  'BlountCircuit   WilliamD.Young   V0011167 'n  'Franks,J.    Susano,J.  ! Swiney,J. n " Rule10 \ # Denied 'J $ 'Rule10 ' % ' Dismissed ApplicationofBonnieS.  & Vaughn. ' ' 'NelsonKeithFosterv.SullivanCounty H ( DistrictAttorneyGeneral 6) E200302740SCR11CV '$* 'SullivanChancery H + RichardE.Ladd 6, C0016445 '$- 'Franks,J. H . Affirmed '6/ 'Rule11 'H 0 ' Denied ApplicationofNelsonKeith H 1 Foster. '62 'FreemanIndustries,LLCv.Eastman *3 ChemicalCompany,etal 4 E200300527SCS09CV '5 'SullivanCircuit *6 RichardLadd 7 C34355L '8 'Susano,J. *9 Affirmedas : Modifiedand ; Remanded 'p< 'Rule11 '*= ' Granted ApplicationofFreeman *> Industries,LLC. ?  Granted ApplicationofEastman @ ChemicalCompany,etal. 'pA 'RonaldHart,etalv.JosephDecosimo vB andCompany,LLP,etal dC E200202825SCR11CV 'RD 'HamiltonCircuit vE JackeSchulten dF 99C1250 'RG 'Susano,J. vH Vacated& dI Remanded 'RJ 'Rule11 'vK ' Denied ApplicationofJoseph vL DecosimoandCompany,LLP;Hendry dM &Decosimo,LLP;andWilliamAcuff. 'RN 'AussieLeeHumphrey,etalv.Stateof PO Tennessee >P E200300617SCR11CV ',Q 'TennesseeClaims PR Commission >S VanceW.Cheek,Jr. ',T 'Susano,J. PU Reversed '>V 'Rule11 'PW ' Denied ApplicationoftheStateof PX Tennessee. '>Y 'DeborahL.Jordanv.WalterB.Jordan 2Z E200300826SCR11CV ' [ 'HamiltonChancery 2\ W.FrankBrown,III  ]  '!^ 'Susano,J. 2_ Reversed&  ` Remanded '!a 'Rule11 '2b ' Denied ApplicationofWalterB. 2c Jordan. ' d 'FredM.Leonard,Jr.,etalv.Knox d  County,Tennessee,etal R E200302255SCR11CV '@ 'KnoxCircuit d WheelerA.Rosebalm R 379203 '@ 'Swiney,J. d Affirmedin R Part;Reversed @  inPart '.  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofFredM. d  Leonard,Jr. 'R  'TennesseeEnvironmentalCouncil,Inc., 4 etalv.BrightPar3Associates,L.P.,et "  al   E200301982SCR11CV ' z 'HamiltonChancery 4 HowellN.Peoples "  030775 '  'Inman,Sr.J. 4 Reversed& "  Remanded '  'Rule11 '4 ' Denied ApplicationofBrightPar3 4 Associates,L.P.,CorkerGroup,Inc., "  OsborneBuildingCorporation,andDBS   Corporation. ' z 'EddieDeanHallv.StateofTennessee   E200201986SCR11PC 'n  'CockeCircuit   BenHooper,II n  27782I '\ ! 'Woodall,J.  " Affirmed 'n # 'Rule11 ' $ ' Denied ApplicationofEddieDean  % Hall. 'n & 'DavidJohnsonHartsellv.Stateof Z ' Tennessee H ( E200303080SCR11PC '6) 'WashingtonCircuit Z * LynnBrown H + 29257 '6, 'Ogle,J. Z - Affirmed H . Pursuantto 6/ Rule20 '$0 'Rule11 'Z 1 ' Denied ApplicationofDavidJohnson Z 2 Hartsell. 'H 3 'JackJayShuttlev.StateofTennessee *4 E200300131SCR11PC '5 'SullivanCriminal *6 LynnW.Brown 7 S35,010 '8 'Riley,J. *9 Reversed ': 'Rule11 '*; ' Denied ApplicationoftheStateof *< Tennessee. '= 'StateofTennesseev.JonBrewbaker > E200302706SCR11CD 'v? 'BradleyCircuit @ CarrollL.Ross vA 02888 'dB 'Welles,J. C Affirmed 'vD 'Rule11 'E ' Denied ApplicationofJonBrewbaker. 'F 'StateofTennesseev.TerryLynn bG Byington PH E200302814SCR11CD '>I 'SullivanCircuit bJ PhyllisMiller PK S45,791 '>L 'Riley,J. bM Affirmed 'PN 'Rule11 'bO ' Denied ApplicationofTerryLynn bP Byington. 'PQ 'StateofTennesseev.RobertAllen DR Crawford 2S E200300627SCR11CD ' T 'WashingtonCircuit DU RobertE.Cupp 2V 25661 ' W 'Glenn,J. DX Affirmed '2Y 'Rule11 'DZ ' Denied ApplicationofRobertAllen D[ Crawford. '2\ 'StateofTennesseev.JamaElainePenley d  E200300820SCR11CD 'R 'GreeneCircuit d JamesBeckner R 01CR043A '@ 'Ogle,J. d Affirmedas R Modified '@ 'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofJamaElaine d  Penley. 'R  'StateofTennesseev.RobertSimerly F  E200202626SCR11CD '4  'JohnsonCriminal F RobertE.Cupp 4 3855A '"  'Witt,J. F Affirmed '4 'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicationofRobertSimerly. 'F 'StateofTennesseev.DarrellGlenn   Smith   E200201988SCR11CD '  'CockeCircuit   BenHooper,II   7923 '  'Tipton,J.   Wade,J.   Ogle,J.   Affirmed 'n  'Rule11 '  ' Denied ApplicationofDarrellGlenn    Smith. ' ! 'StateofTennesseev.RichardLafayette l " Sumner Z # E200300570SCR11CD 'H $ 'CockeCircuit l % BenW.Hooper,II Z & 8285 'H ' 'Tipton,J. l ( Affirmedin Z ) Part;Vacated H * inPart; 6+ Remanded '$, 'Rule11 'l - ' Denied ApplicationofRichard l . LafayetteSumner. 'Z / 'StateofTennesseev.GeorgeA.Vance *0 andVincentVance 1 E200300110SCR11CD '2 'SullivanCircuit *3 PhyllisMiller 4 S43074&S43075 '5 'Wedemeyer,J. *6 Affirmed '7 'Rule11 '*8 ' Denied ApplicationofGeorgeA. *9 Vance. ': 'EdwardThompsonv.StateofTennessee ; E200301089SCR11PC 'v< 'CockeCriminal = BenHooper,II v> 27,453I 'd? 'Tipton,J. @ Affirmed 'vA 'Rule11 'B ' Denied ApplicationofEdward C Thompson. 'vD ' 'bE ' 'bF ' 'bG ' 'bH '"bI M "X,