WPC< Y"b ABO/Rh2T{ E ޵`ě ]Q8$qج?]Gr7pE瘫ƈoi; 1S7-8.% qu(t8=T?QV9l$qX[G- xto 2JQ5  <4AwǜW㗤J=£h8:<'Z|:2qyJNn"Qᇡ}7# UNM % 0( f a L w+4/CBRN^  m 0l 0D'kkkkfddddddddddddddd B 0D++++++++++++++++++++++++++ D- 04 AR 0KHP LaserJet 4050 Series PCL 6,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A B $    1    _Inadditiontotheissuesraisedintheapplicationforpermissiontoappeal,thepartiesaredirectedtofilesupplementalbriefs X onthefollowingquestion: >    ` Whetherthe madewholedoctrineappliestotheproceedsofasettlementunderthisCourtsholdinginYorkv._Sevier_ $ CountyAmbulanceAuthority,8_S.W._Ԁ3d616(Tenn.1999).,-d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd8'H-s U((3$ !      0  (#$  0    $    2    _OnSeptember6,2002,theproseapplicant,JamesL._McCurry_,filedanapplicationforpermissiontoappealpursuanttoTenn. X R.App.P.11.ThejudgmentoftheCourtofCriminalAppealswasfiledonJuly5,2002.Thetimeforfilinganapplicationfor > permissiontoappealexpiredonSeptember3,2002.SeeTenn.R.App.P.11(b).Theapplication,therefore,wasnottimelyfiled.See $ Tenn.R.App.P.20.Asaresult,thisCourtiswithoutjurisdictiontoconsiderthemeritsoftheapplication.SeeTenn.R.App.P.2   and11(b). \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5)!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3 Letter Landscape3'TXXXX  g 0  @*8181SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS > @  / October7,2002 $   CORRECTEDOCT.8,2002(HealthCost_Controls_Ԁv._Gifford_)    @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,dd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE :  OFAPPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' RaymondMitchell  ( v. f   _Donal_ԀCampbell L  M200100477SCR11CV '2  'DavidsonChancery  ( EllenH.Lyle f   003311II 'L  'Koch,J.  ( Affirmed. 'f   'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRaymond  ( Mitchell. f    'L  ' StevenRayChance T  v. :  TennesseeDepartmentof x  Correction,EtAl. ^  M200200727SCR11CV 'D! 'DavidsonCircuit T " WalterC.Kurtz : # 01C1076 'x $ '_Cantrell_,J. T % Cottrell,J. : & Koch,J. x ' Dismissed. '^( 'Rule11 'T ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStevenRay T * Chance. : +  'x , ' StevenRayChance f- v. L. TennesseeDepartmentof 2/ Correction,EtAl. p0 M200200423SCR11CV 'V1 'DavidsonChancery f2 EllenH.Lyle L3 012830III '24 '_Cantrell_,J. f5 Cottrell,J. L6 Koch.J. 27 Dismissed. 'p8 'Rule11 'f9 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStevenRay f: Chance. L;  '2< ' JohnD.Cooke,III x= v. ^> TennesseeDepartmentof D? Correction,EtAl. *@ M200200242SCR11CV 'hA 'DavidsonCircuit xB WalterC.Kurtz ^C 01C2707 'DD '_Cantrell_,J. xE Dismissed. '^F 'Rule11 'xG ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnD._Cocke_, xH III. ^I  'DJ ' WatsonsCarpetandFloor K Coverings,Inc. pL v. VM RickMcCormick,CarpetDen,Inc.,  <N EtAl. z!"O M200003101SCR11CV '`" P 'WilliamsonCircuit Q Russ_Heldman_ pR II99316 'VS '_Goddard_,J. T Remanded. 'pU 'Rule11 'V ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMohawk W Industries,Inc. pX  'VY ' g  8}XXdXXd8    InTheMatterof_Asbert_ԀJoseph d  M199902795SCR11CV 'J 'WayneChancery d RobertL.Jones J 10247 '0 'Koch,J. d Affirmed. 'J 'Rule11 'd ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Asbert_ԀJoseph. d  PursuanttoSupremeCourtRule4(D), J  theCourtdirectsthattheopinionofthe 0  CourtofAppeals,filedApril30,2002, n  bepublishedintheofficialreporter. 'T  ' Antonio_Sweatt_ v v. \ TennesseeDepartmentof  B Correction  ( M200002983SCR11CV 'f   'DavidsonCircuit v Carol_Soloman_ \ 98C3505 ' B '_Cantrell_,J. v Affirmed& \ Remanded. ' B 'Rule11 'v ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAntonio_Sweatt_. v  '\ ' Dennis_Osa_Ԁ_Osagie_   v.  n  _Peakload_ԀTemporaryServices T  M200100852SCR11CV ':  'DavidsonCircuit   HamiltonV._Gayden_,Jr.  n ! 01C32 'T " '_Cantrell_,J.  # Affirmed&  n $ Remanded. 'T % 'Rule11 ' & ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDennis_Osa_  ' _Osagie_.  n (  'T ) ' DouglasOConnell  * v. + YoungMensChristianAssociation , ofMiddleTennessee f- M200002099SCR11CV 'L. 'DavidsonCircuit  / Carol_Soloman_ 0 99C2294 '1 '_Lillard_,J.  2 Affirmed. '3 'Rule11 ' 4 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDouglas  5 OConnell. 6 _Drowota_,C.J.notparticipating. 7  'L9 ' InRe:EstateofHaroldL.Jenkins : M200101969SCR11CV '; 'SumnerProbate < TomE.Gray = 93P30 '> 'Crawford,J. ? ReversedinPart, @ AffirmedinPart. 'A 'Rule11 'B ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Delores_ԀHenry C Jenkins. D  'E ' AegisInvestigativeGroup d F v. JG TheMetropolitanGovernmentof 0H NashvilleandDavidsonCounty I M200101068SCR11CV 'J 'DavidsonCircuit d K HamiltonV._Gayden_,Jr. JL 98C2980 '0M 'Neal,_Sp.J._ d N Reversed& JO Remanded. '0P 'Rule11 'd Q ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAegis d R InvestigativeGroup. JS  '0T ' C.Noelle_Chaffin_ vU v. \V MarcusC.Ellis B W M200201643SCS10CV '(!X 'WilliamsonChancery vY R.E.LeeDavies \Z 276908 'B [ '_Cantrell_,J. v\ DeniedRule10. '\] 'Rule10 'v^ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMarcusC.Ellis. v_  '\` ' '"J a ' '"J b ' '"J c ' '"J d ' '"J e ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   StateofTennessee d v. J KevinLaneFarrar 0 M200101370SCR11CD 'n 'BedfordCircuit d F.LeeRussell J 14848 '0 'Glenn,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKevinLane d  Farrar. J   '0  ' StateofTennessee  v. v JesseR._Scruggs_ \ M200100518SCR11CD ' B 'WilliamsonCriminal  DonaldP.Harris v I999317 '\ 'Williams,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJesseR.  _Scruggs_. v  '\ ' StateofTennessee   v.   ChristopherD._Neighbours_   M200002594SCR11CD ' n  'DavidsonCriminal   J.RandallWyatt,Jr.   97B1229  !  ' n " 'Ogle,J.  # Affirmed. ' $ 'Rule11 ' % ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofChristopherD.  & _Neighbours_.  '  ' ( ' JohnDavidWhite @ ) v. & * StateofTennessee  + M200100336SCR11CD ', 'RutherfordCircuit @ - L.Terry_Lafferty_ & . 49031 ' / '_Tipton_,J. @ 0 Affirmed. '& 1 'Rule11 '@ 2 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnDavid @ 3 White.TheopinionoftheCourtof & 4 Appealsisdesignated NotForCitation  5 inaccordancewithSupremeCourtRule 6 4F. '7 ' StateofTennessee R8 v. 89 JohnR.Black : M200001286SCR11CD '; 'DavidsonCriminal R< SteveDozier 8= 99A396 '> 'Smith,J. R? Affirmed& 8@ Remanded. 'A 'Rule11 'RB ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnR.Black. RC  '8D ' StateofTennessee ~&E v. d F AnthonyL.Rogers JG M200101729SCR11CD '0H 'CoffeeCircuit ~&I JohnW.Rollins d J 29,592 'JK 'Glenn,J. ~&L Affirmed. 'd M 'Rule11 '~&N ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAnthonyL. ~&O Rogers. d P  'JQ ' StateofTennessee RR v. 8S Mario_Pendegrass_ vT M199902532SCR11CD '\U 'DavidsonCriminal RV SethNorman 8W 93C1345 'vX 'Wade,J. RY Affirmed. '8Z 'Rule11 'R[ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMario R\ _Pendegrass_. 8]  'v^ ' ' ~_ ' ' ~` ' ' ~a ' ' ~b ' ' ~c ' UnionPlantersNationalBank d  v. J AmericanHomeAssurance 0 Company n W200101124SCR11CV 'T 'ShelbyCircuit d KarenR.Williams J 321263T.D. '0 '_Lillard_,J. d  ReversedinPart, J  AffirmedinPartand 0  Remanded. 'n  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAmericanHome d AssuranceCompany. J  '0 ' MelvinBonds,Jr.,EtAl. v v. \ EricaEmerson,EtAl.And  B EricaEmerson,EtAl.  ( v. f   MelvinBonds,Jr.,EtAl. L  W200100812SCR11CV '2  'HowardCircuit v _Clayburn_ԀL._Peeples_ \ 3296and3305 ' B 'Crawford,J. v Modified,Vacated \ &Remanded. ' B 'Rule11 'v ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMelvinbonds, v Jr. \   ' B! ' Larry_Littles_ T " v. : # _Donal_ԀCampbell,EtAl. x $ W200200265SCR11CV '^% 'LauderdaleChancery T & MarthaB._Brasfield_ : ' 11,781 'x ( 'Crawford,J. T ) Affirmed& : * Remanded. 'x + 'Rule11 'T , ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLarry_Littles_. T -  ': . ' MechanicsLaundryService / v. f0 AutoGlassCompanyofMemphis, L1 Inc.d/b/aJackMorrisAutoGlass 22 W200101113SCR11CV 'p3 'ShelbyCircuit 4 GeorgeH.Brown,Jr. f5 306057 'L6 'Crawford,J. 7 Vacated,Rendered f8 &Remanded. 'L9 'Rule11 ': ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMechanics ; LaundryService. f<  'L= ' HealthCostControls,Inc. > v. x? Ronald_Gifford_ ^@ W200102267SCR11CV 'DA '_Weakley_ԀChancery B W.Michael_Maloan_ xC 15726 '^D '_Lillard_,J. E Affirmed. 'xF 'Rule11 'G ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofRonald H _Gifford_. #  1       xI  '^J ' _Lydell_ԀGreenRussell,EtAl. d v. J  CityofMemphis,Tennessee 0 W200101307SCR11CV 'n 'ShelbyCircuit d GeorgeH.Brown,Jr. J 80147 '0 'Farmer,J. d Affirmed& J  Remanded. '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Lydell_ԀGreen d  Russell,etal. J   '0 ' RoseConstruction,Inc.  v. v _Raintree_ԀDevelopmentCompany, \ LLC.  B W200001388SCR11CV ' ( 'ShelbyChancery  WalterL.Evans v 1101621 '\ '_Lillard_,J.  Reversed& v Remanded. '\ 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Raintree_  DevelopmentCompany,LLC. v  '\ ' InRe:EstateofSamVires,   Deceased,Shirley_Schulze_Ԁa/k/a   Shirley_Schulze_ԀVires  n  v. T ! _Jere_ԀStevenVires,RandallK.Vires, : " JosephS.Vires,andMarilynVires x # W200002953SCR11CV '^$ 'ShelbyProbate  % RobertS._Benham_  & B29543 ' n ' '_Lillard_,J.  ( Affirmed. ' ) 'Rule11 ' * ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofShirley_Schulze_  + Vires.  ,  ' n - ' AnitaJoyceOwen,EtAl. . v. f/ GeorgeD.Summers L0 W200100727SCR11CV '21 '_Fayette_ԀChancery 2 Dewey_Whitenton_ f3 11797 'L4 'Crawford,J. 5 Affirmed& f6 Remanded. 'L7 'Rule11 '8 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGeorgeD. 9 Summers. f:  'L; ' '< ' '= ' '> ' '? ' '@ ' StateofTennessee ~&A v. d B RobinDavis JC W200003137SCR11CD '0D 'ShelbyCriminal ~&E JohnP._Colton_,Jr. d F 9905481,00752 'JG 'Glenn,J. ~&H Affirmed. 'd I 'Rule11 '~&J ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobinDavis. ~&K  'd L ' MickeyP._Hadden_ RM v. 8N Fred_Raney_,Warden vO W200102949SCR11CD '\P 'LakeCircuit RQ R.LeeMoore,Jr. 8R 018196 'vS 'Hayes,J. RT AffirmedbyRule20 8U Order. 'vV 'Rule11 'RW ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMickeyP. RX _Hadden_. 8Y  'vZ ' StateofTennessee d v. J _Kardius_Ԁ_Wilks_ 0  W200102172SCR11CD 'n 'ShelbyCriminal d ChrisCraft J 0008070 '0 'Hayes,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Kardius_Ԁ_Wilks_. d   'J  ' StateofTennessee   v. v RodneyM.Butler \ W200101084SCR11CD ' B 'MadisonCircuit  DonaldAllen v 00543 '\ 'Welles,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofRodneyM.  Butler. v  '\ ' StateofTennessee   v.   Robert_Tait_   W200102157SCR11CD ' n  'ShelbyCriminal   JosephB.Dailey   0012820 '  'Wade,J.  ! Reversed&  " Remanded. ' # 'Rule11 ' $ ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofRobert_Tait_.  %  ' & ' AndreWilson @ ' v. & ( StateofTennessee  ) W200102442SCR11PC '* 'ShelbyCriminal @ + ChrisCraft & , P25387 ' - '_Wedemeyer_,J. @ . Affirmed. '& / 'Rule11 '@ 0 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAndreWilson. @ 1  '& 2 ' MauricePierre_Teague_ l3 v. R4 StateofTennessee 85 W200100533SCR11PC '6 'CarrollCircuit l7 JulianP._Guinn_ R8 98CR1212 '89 'Glenn,J. l: Affirmed. 'R; 'Rule11 'l< ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMauricePierre l= _Teague_. R>  '8? ' '@@ ' '@A ' '@B ' '@C ' '@D ' PatriciaD.Parks E v. F JulieNelson,EtAl. G E200002943SCR11CV 'lH '_Blount_ԀCircuit I WilliamD.Young J L10961 'K '_Goddard_,J. L Affirmed& M Remanded. 'N 'Rule11 'O ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPatriciaD. P Parks. Q  'R ' BarbaraA._Willoughby_ >S v. $T MontgomeryElevatorCompany  U E200002521SCR11CV 'V 'AndersonCircuit >W JamesB.Scott,Jr. $X 981A0271 ' Y '_Swiney_,J. >Z Affirmed& $[ Remanded. ' \ 'Rule11 '>] ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof BarbaraA. >^ _Willoughby_ . $_   'a ' _Effie_ԀLouiseHayes d v. J  Roger_Strutton_,EtAl. 0 E200101765SCR11CV 'n 'HamiltonCircuit d Jackie_Schulten_ J 01C700 '0 '_Goddard_,J. d Affirmed& J  Remanded. '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Effie_ԀLouise d  Hayes. J   '0 ' StateofTennessee,exrel.Wanda  Moody v v. \ Timothy_Hutchison_  B E200200743SCS09CV ' ( 'KnoxChancery  Thomas_Frierson_,II v 1508211 '\ '_Goddard_,J.  Susano,J. v _Swiney_,J. \ Rule9Denied. ' B 'Rule9 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTimothy  _Hutchison_. v  '\ ' JamesA.CollinsandGarySmith   v.   SummersHardwareandSupply  n ! Company T " E200100578SCR11CV ': # 'WashingtonCircuit  $ ThomasJ._Seeley_,Jr.  % 20085 ' n & '_Goddard_,J.  ' Affirmed. ' ( 'Rule11 ' ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSummers  * HardwareandSupply.  +  ' n , ' Carol_Hankins_,EtAl.  - v. . _Chevco_,Inc.,d/b/aCurtisProducts / So.Central,Inc.,EtAl. f0 E200100608SCR11CV 'L1 '_Bledsoe_ԀCircuit  2 ThomasW.Graham 3 1865 '4 '_Swiney_,J.  5 Vacated& 6 Remanded. '7 'Rule11 ' 8 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Checvo_ԀInc.,Et  9 Al. :  '; ' FortSandersWestOutpatient < SurgeryCenter,L.P.,EtAl. = v. > PaulS.Ambrose,EtAl. x? E200201544SCS09CV '^@ 'KnoxChancery A SharonJ.Bell B 1525033 'C '_Goddard_,J. D Franks,J. E Rule9Denied. 'F 'Rule9 'G ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPaulS. H Ambrose. I  'J ' '0K ' '0L ' '0M ' '0N ' '0O ' StateofTennessee RP v. 8Q RogerEdwards vR E200100705SCR11CD '\S 'ClaiborneCircuit RT E._Shayne_ԀSexton 8U 11,263 'vV 'Williams,J. RW Affirmed. '8X 'Rule11 'RY ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRogerEdwards. RZ  '8[ ' StateofTennessee d v. J MichaelWayne_Belcher_ 0  E200100515SCR11CD 'n 'CarterCircuit d RobertE._Cupp_ J S15009 0  'n 'Williams,J. d  AffirmedinPart; J  ReversedinPart. '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichaelWayne d  _Belcher_. J  '0 ' StateofTennessee  v. v JamesL._McCurry_ \ E200101900SCR11CD ' B '_Roane_ԀCircuit  E.Eugene_Eblen_ v 12057 '\ 'Hayes,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Dismissed ApplicationofJamesL.  _McCurry_._ #  2      _ 'v ' StateofTennessee   v.   StephenGreene   E200002616SCR11CD ' n  '_Blount_ԀCircuit    D.KellyThomas,Jr.  ! C10844 ' " 'Williams,J.  # AffirmedinPart;  $ ReversedinPart&  % Remanded. ' n & 'Rule11 ' ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStephenGreene.  (  ' ) ' _Yasmond_Ԁ_Fenderson_ @ * v. & + StateofTennessee  , E200101088SCR11PC '- 'KnoxCriminal @ . RichardR._Baumgartner_ & / 68806 ' 0 '_Witt_,J. @ 1 Affirmed. '& 2 'Rule11 '@ 3 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Yasmond_ @ 4 _Fenderson_. & 5  ' 6 ' Darrell_Lunsford_ l7 v. R8 HowardCarlton,Warden,EtAl. 89 E200102409SCR11PC ': 'JohnsonCircuit l; LynnW.Brown R< 3829 '8= '_Witt_,J. l> _Tipton_,J. R? Ogle,J. 8@ AppealDismissed. 'A 'Rule11 'lB ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDarrell lC _Lunsford_. RD "8E 5 "X,q