WPC =Yy8Yq*zia_[l9ĪTU$s8\KG 2HbAr{M0l16`{&ɩxTl9eXvWDfLJ5Oe%ZiMdC2&Ø]v8z<=x#E(n79+vl`_ QwuAU $6G͆ΨGJ,YIӬOfՈm; u]# UNM % 0( f a w 4  B NH ^ J V mX 0lo 0D f a! ! 5 f B....................................................... 0VKK D-gggggggggggg 04 A 0KgHP LaserJet 4050 Series PCL 5e,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE Aj5+d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd8*'C+s U((3$ !      0  (#$  0  TABLE B  $    1    _TheapplicationisgrantedforthepurposeofremandingthecasetotheCourtofCriminalAppealsforproceedingsconsistent X withthisCourtsopinioninStateofTennesseev.LarryAllenHicks,No.E199900957SCR11CD,filedSeptember11,2001,at > Knoxville. \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d(.3$ !USUS.,  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5)!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3 Letter Landscape3'TXXXX  g @*SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS > @&&0 October8,20010 x   (#  %  '  0*  , $x81x81 @7 ,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,Fdd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATUREOF :  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' LesterHillDoyle,etal  ( vs. f   WilliamHunt L  M199700179SCR11CV '2  'DavidsonProbate  ( FrankClement,Jr. f   93P211 'L  'Farmer,J.  ( Affirmedand f   remanded 'L  'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLesterHill  ( Doyle,etal 'f   ' FirstAmericanTrustCompany T  vs. :  FranklinMurrayDevelopment x  Company,L.P.  ^   M199800984SCR11CV 'D! 'WilliamsonChancery T " HenryD.Bell : # 22922R5 'x $ 'Koch,J. T % Affirmed ': & 'Rule11 'T ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFirstAmerican T ( Trust ': ) ' JaniceCaroline_Hillyer_ f* vs. L+ CharlesLee_Hillyer_ 2, M199800942SCR11CV 'p- 'MontgomeryCircuit f. JamesE.Walton L/ C3805 '20 'Cottrell,J. f1 Reversedand L2 remanded '23 'Rule11 'f4 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharlesLee f5 _Hillyer_;recommendedthattheCourtof L6 Appealsopinionbepublished. '27 ' RandallE.Jordan 8 vs. x9 _CSX_ԀTransportation,Inc. ^: M199901415SCR11CV 'D; 'DavidsonCircuit < HamiltonV._Gayden_,Jr. x= 95C3216 '^> '_Lillard_,J. ? Affirmed 'x@ 'Rule11 'A ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRandallE. B Jordan 'xC ' PamelaLynnLewis D vs. E AndrewRobertFrances F M199800946SCR11CV 'pG 'WilliamsonChancery H HenryD.Bell I 23448 'J 'Cottrell,J. K Affirmedinpart, L reversedinpartand M remanded 'pN 'Rule11 'O ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAndrewFrances 'P ' g  8n@XXdd8    &m#%XXCharlesDavid_Sigler_Ԁd/b/a_Laverte_s d Market 8 vs. d  MetropolitanBeerPermitBd.ofthe 8 Metropolitan_Govt_ԀofNashvilleand   DavidsonCo.,TN#Xn@X%&m##     M200001728SCR11CV '\ 'DavidsonChancery d CarolL.McCoy J  993148II '0  'Farmer,J. d  Affirmedand J  remanded '0  'Rule11 'd ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Chrles_Ԁ_Sigler_,et d al 'J ' '.  ' '.  ' '.  ' '.  ' '.  ' StateofTennessee  P vs.  6  JacobLeeDavis t   M199902496SCR11CD 'Z   'LincolnCircuit  P W.C.Lee  6  S9800087 't   '_Woodall_,J.  P Affirmed ' 6  'Rule11 ' P ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJacobLeeDavis ' P  ' StateofTennessee | ! vs. b " RobertA.Hayden H# M200000901SCR11CD '.$ 'WilliamsonCircuit | % TimothyL.Easter b & II699211 'H' 'Wade,J. | ( Affirmed 'b ) 'Rule11 '| * ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertA. | + Hayden 'b , ' StateofTennessee - vs. . _Zonnell_ԀS.Hogan t/ M20001998SCR11CO 'Z0 'DavidsonCriminal 1 J.R.Wyatt,Jr. 2 C2876 't3 'Smith,J. 4 Rule20Motion 5 granted 't6 'Rule11 '7 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Zonnell_ԀS. 8 Hogan 9  't: ' StateofTennessee ,; vs. < _Alkita_ԀM._Odom_ = M200002676SCR11CD '> 'Sumner ,? Jane_Wheatcraft_ @ 3082000 'A 'Welles,J. ,B Reversed 'C 'Rule11 ',D ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Alkita_ԀM. ,E _Odom_;recommendedthattheCourtof F CriminalAppealsopinionbepublished. 'G ' StateofTennessee XH vs. >I RobertLee_Pattee_ $J M200000257SCR11CD ' K 'SumnerCriminal XL Jane_Wheatcraft_ >M 2391999 '$N '_Woodall_,J. XO Affirmed '>P 'Rule11 'XQ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertLee XR _Pattee_ '>S ' StateofTennessee ,T vs. j U MichaelWaynePerry P!V M199901832SCR11CD '6"W 'WilsonCriminal ,X _J.O._ԀBond j Y 9711731173A 'P!Z '_Woodall_,J. ,[ Affirmed 'j \ 'Rule11 ',] ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichaelWayne ,^ Perry 'j _ ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   StateofTennessee d  vs. J JoeW.Steward 0 M199901284SCR11CD 'n 'Lewis d CorneliaA.Clark J 6004 '0 'Wade,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofJoeW. d  Steward #  1      'J  ' StateofTennessee   vs. v JosephM.Stone \ M200001321SCR11CD ' B 'DavidsonCriminal  CherylBlackburn v 99D3028 '\ 'Wade,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJosephM.Stone ' ' Stateof_XXTennessee_XX   vs.   JosephD.Taylor   M200000525SCR11CD ' n  'MarshallCircuit   W.C.Lee   13945 '  'Woodall,J.   Affirmedinpartand   reversedinpart ' ! 'Rule11 ' " ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJosephD.  # Taylor ' $ ' DannyRayMeeks @ % vs. & & Stateof_XXTennessee_XX  ' M200001988SCR11CO '( 'Grundy @ ) JohnWileyRollins & * 6491 ' + 'Williams,J. @ , Rule20Affirmed '& - 'Rule11 '@ . ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDannyRay @ / Meeks '& 0 ' WilliamGlennWiley l1 vs. R2 Stateof_XXTennessee_XX 83 M199902487SCR11CD '4 'Davidson l5 WalterKurtz R6 95C1918 '87 'Hayes,J. l8 Affirmed 'R9 'Rule11 'l: ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliamGlenn l; Wiley 'R< ' '@= ' '@> ' '@? ' '@@ ' '@A ' CooperManagement,LLC B vs. C PerformaEntertainment,Inc. D W200100195SCR10CV 'lE 'ShelbyChancery F RobertA.Lanier G 9906122 'H 'Crawfordand I Lillard,JJ. J Denied 'K 'Rule10 'L ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCooper M Management,LLC 'N ' TerenceP.Fennessy d vs. J  WallyHuggins,etal 0 W200101080SCR10CV 'n 'ShelbyCircuit d JamesF.Russell J 973422&3015288 '0 'Crawfordand d Farmer,JJ. J  Rule10denied '0  'Rule10 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWallyHuggins, d  etal 'J  ' IntheMatterofKristinLynn  Bridges,aminor v W200001919SCR11CV '\ 'ShelbyJuvenile  GeorgeE.Blancett v B6450C3176 '\ 'Crawford,J.  Reversed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMarkBridges ' ' CherylOliver,etal  .   vs.   EarlHardinQuinby,etal   W200002158SCR11CV '  'ShelbyCircuit .  KarenR.Williams   3027523T.D. '  'Highers,J. .  Affirmed '   'Rule11 '. ! ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCherylOliver . " andEdwinOliver ' # ' RonaldSchnider Z $ vs. @ % CarlisleCorporation & & W200001695SCR11CV ' ' 'ShelbyChancery Z ( FloydPeete,Jr. @ ) 9811492 '& * 'Crawford,J. Z + Vacatedand @ , remanded '& - 'Rule11 'Z . ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCarlisle Z / Corporation '@ 0 ' &m#%XXn@DanaHopeDavisThurmon(Scott), .1 indiv.andassurvivingnaturalparent Z2 ofDaltonThurmon,aminor,etal#Xn@X%&m#D=# .3 vs. 4 EdwardSellers,etal 5 W200000422SCR11CV 'v6 'ShelbyCircuit .7 GeorgeH.Brown,Jr. l8 830126 'R9 'Farmer,J. .: Affirmedinpart, l; reversedinpartand R< remanded '8= 'Rule11 '.> ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationsofEdwardand .? DonaldSellersandDanaHopeDavis l@ Thurman,ShaneThurmon,andTiffany RA Thurmon;recommendedthattheCourt 8B ofAppealsopinionbepublished. 'C ' MyronZimmerman,etal HD vs. .E CityofMemphis,etal F W200001369SCR11CV 'G 'ShelbyChancery HH D.J.Alissandratos .I 10024&980795 'J 'Highers,J. HK Affirmed '.L 'Rule11 'HM ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMyron HN ZimmermanandJ.F.Canepari '.O ' 'tP ' 'tQ ' 'tR ' 'tS ' 'tT ' StateofTennessee  U  vs. |V CurtisCleggins bW W199900647SCR11CD ' HX 'ShelbyCriminal Y BernieWeinman |Z 9900723 'b[ 'Glenn,J. \ Affirmed '|] 'Rule11 '^ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCurtisCleggins '_ ' StateofTennessee d  vs. J DarrellJennings 0 W199901036SCR11CD 'n 'ShelbyCriminal d ChrisCraft J 9813866 '0 'Hayes,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDarrellJennings 'd  ' StateofTennessee   vs. v  _XXPrentiss_XXԀPhillips \ W200000245SCR11CD ' B 'ShelbyCriminal  JamesC._XXBeasley_XX,Jr. v 9713179;80 '\ 'Glenn,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_XXPrentiss_XX  Phillips;recommendedthattheCourtof v CriminalAppealsopinionbepublished. '\ ' StateofTennessee   vs.   MichaelDale_XXRimmer_XX   W199900637SCR11DD ' n  'ShelbyCriminal   W.Fred_XXAxley_XX   980103334;9702817 '  'Williams,J.    &m#%XXn@Affirmed,reversedin  ! part;remandedforre  v " sentencing.#Xn@X%&m#JL# ' J # 'Rule11 ' $ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichaelDale  % _XXRimmer_XX ' & ' StateofTennessee @ ' vs. & ( AnthonyRobinson  ) W200002248SCR11CO '* 'ShelbyCriminal @ + W.Otis_XXHiggs_XX,Jr. & , P23457 ' - 'Riley,J. @ . Affirmed '& / 'Rule11 '@ 0 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAnthony @ 1 Robinson '& 2 ' StateofTennessee l3 vs. R4 Ernest_XXSoloman_XX 85 W200001176SCR11CD '6 'ShelbyCriminal l7 CarolynW._XXBlackett_XX R8 980026466,69 '89 'Glenn,J. l: Affirmedand R; remandedfor 8< _XXresentencing_XX '= 'Rule11 'l> ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEarnest l? Solomon 'R@ ' Ronnie_XXBradfield_XXԀ @A vs. ~&B StateofTennessee d C W199902344SCR11PC 'JD 'ShelbyCriminal @E JamesC._XXBeasley_XX,Jr. ~&F P18580 'd G '_XXWoodall_XX,J. @H Affirmed '~&I 'Rule11 '@J ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRonnie @K _XXBradfield_XX '~&L ' _XXTerrance_XXԀN.Burnett lM vs. RN StateofTennessee 8O W200001954SCR11PC 'vP 'LauderdaleCircuit lQ JoeH.Walker,III RR 6484 '8S 'Glenn,J. lT Affirmed 'RU 'Rule11 'lV ' Granted 󀄀Applicationof_XXTerrance_XXԀB. lW Burnett 'RX ' DannyRayLacy Y vs.  ~Z StateofTennessee !d[ W200001898SCR11PC '"J \ 'MadisonCircuit ] JudgeMorris  ~^ C99144 '!d_ 'Williams,J. ` Affirmed ' ~a 'Rule11 'b ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDannyRayLacy 'c ' RudolphPowers d  vs. J Fred_XXRaney_XX,Warden 0 W200100410SCR11CO 'n 'LakeCircuit d R.LeeMoore,Jr. J 00CR8098 '0 'Glenn,J. d Deniedmotionfor J  judgmentsofdefault '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Dismissed 󀄀ApplicationofRudolph d  Powers;applicationwaspremature. 'J  ' WardenFred_XXRaney_XXԀ  vs. v GeorgeTodd \ W200002347SCR11CO ' B 'LakeCircuit  R.LeeMoore,Jr. v 00CR8060 '\ 'Williams,J.  Affirmedpursuant v toRule20 '\ 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGeorgeTodd ' ' _XXVeldora_XXԀL.Trout   vs.   StateofTennessee   W200000857SCR11PC ' n  '_XXHardin_XXԀCircuit   CharlesC._XXMcGinley_XX   PC7706 '  'Williams,J.  ! Affirmed ' " 'Rule11 ' # ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_XXVeldora_XXԀL.  $ Trout ' % ' '@ & ' '@ ' ' '@ ( ' '@ ) ' '@ * ' RobertBurden,etal b+ vs. H, NobleSharp,etal .- E200002548SCR11CV 'l. 'Campbell b/ _XXJerri_XXԀBryant H0 14,671 '.1 '_XXGoddard_XXԀand b2 _XXSwiney_XX,JJ. H3 Appealdismissed '.4 'Rule11 'b5 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofNobleand b6 DorothySharp 'H7 ' BobbyJ.Everett,indiv.andas 8 executoroftheestateofEdithMae t9 Everett Z: vs. @; B.GordonMcCall,M.D.  ~&<  E200002012SCR11CV 'd = '_XXBlount_XXԀCircuit > WilliamD.Young t? L11466 'Z@ '_XXInman_XX,Sr.J. A Reversed 'tB 'Rule11 'C ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofB.Gordon D McCall,M.D. 'tE ' FirstCitizensBankofCleveland F vs. lG CarolCross RH E200001325SCR11CV '8I 'BradleyCircuit J _XXJerri_XXԀS.Bryant lK 96266 'RL 'Susano,J. M Vacatedand lN remanded 'RO 'Rule11 'P ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFirstCitizens Q BankofCleveland;recommendedthat lR theopinionoftheCourtofAppealsbe RS published. '8T ' Jack_XXHutter_XXԀv.RobertM.Cohen  U and V Jack_XXHutter_XXԀv.H.AllenBray  ~W E199901859SCR11CV '!dX '_XXBlount_XXԀCircuit  Y JamesB.Scott,Jr. Z L11709 ' ~[ 'Franks,J.  \ Affirmed '] 'Rule11 ' ^ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJack_XXHutter_XX_XX ' _ ' Inre:TheEstateofConstantine d  _XXAnagnost_XXԀ(deceased) J vs. 0 George_XXAnagnost_XX n E200002321SCR11CV 'T 'KnoxChancery d DarylR._XXFansler_XX J 554841 '0 'Susano,J. d  Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGeorge d  _XXAnagnost_XX 'J  ' MartinE.Walker v vs. \ HowardCarlton,etal  B E200100171SCR11CV ' ( 'Johnson v ThomasJ._XXSeely_XX \ 1885 ' B '_XXGoddard_XX,J. v Affirmed '\ 'Rule11 'v ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMartinWalker 'v ' RobertPaulWilson,Jr.   vs.   MarthaRuthWilson  n  E200001181SCR11CV 'T  '_XXBlount_XXԀGeneralSessions   WilliamR.Brewer,Jr.   S4587 ' n  'Susano,J.   Vacatedinpart;  ! affirmedinpart;and  n " remanded 'T # 'Rule11 ' $ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertPaul  % Wilson ' & ' '& ' ' '& ( ' '& ) ' '& * ' '& + ' StateofTennessee  H, vs. .- CarlPrestonDurham l. E199902640SCR11CD 'R/ 'HamiltonCriminal H0 StephenM._XXBevcil_XX .1 214467,214469,and l2 214471 'R3 'Wade,J. H4 Affirmedas .5 modified 'l6 'Rule11 'H7 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCarlPreston H8 Durham '.9 ' StateofTennessee  t: vs. Z; MichaelShawn_XXShoffner_XX @< E200000993SCR11CD '~&= 'Knox t> MaryBeth_XXLeibowitz_XX Z? 60057 '@@ '_XXWitt_XX,J. tA Affirmed 'ZB 'Rule11 'tC ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichaelShawn tD _XXShoffner_XX 'ZE ' StateofTennessee  F vs. G JohnCalvinSmith lH E200001109SCR11CD 'RI 'HamiltonCriminal J DouglasA.Meyer K 229720&229866 'lL 'Riley,J. M Affirmed 'N 'ЀRule11 'O ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnCalvin P Smith 'Q ' JohnBates $R vs.  S StateofTennessee  T E200002354SCR11PC ' ~U 'HamiltonCriminal $V StephenM._XXBevil_XX  W 231663 'X 'Williams,J. $Y Affirmed ' Z 'Rule11 '$[ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnBates '$\ ' RichardLeeFranklin d  vs. J StateofTennessee  0 E200001398SCR11PC 'n 'CumberlandCircuit d LeonC.Burns,Jr. J 3354 '0 '_XXWoodall_XX,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRichardLee d  Franklin 'J  ' JosephA.Hough   vs. v StateofTennessee  \ E200000945SCR11PC ' B 'Greene  _XXKindall_XXԀT.Lawson v 00CR017 '\ 'Glenn,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJosephA.  Hough 'v ' JimmyWayneWilson   vs.   StateofTennessee    E200101407SCR11CO ' n  'Sullivan   LynnBrown   18,745 '  '_XXWitt_XX,J.    MotiontoStay  ! denied ' " 'Rule11 ' # ' Denied 󀄀Application_XXof_XXԀJimmyWayne  $ _XXWilson_XX" % 7 "X,# ThefollowingRule11DismissalswerefiledtheweeksofOctober1stOctober5th,2001  6( kX*%d8wd dd dd Sdd SFdd F dd %k81k81,N dd ,dd ,4dd ,Fdd ,z dd +  $@+@ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER 'L," 'COUNTY L- TRIALJUDGE 2. TRIALCOURTNO. 'p/" 'APPELLATEJUDGE L0 JUDGMENT '21" 'NATUREOF L2 APPEAL '23" 'ACTION 'L4" ' '5 ' '6 ' '7 ' '8 '"9  "Xk