WPC& 2fo19d` jCX:x'h$r9:-rt3SQ7jxo MIB˟l{?AC YCـNϔ=]!9U7Jل9.^=npMb"ovxSh_c&䬘?&w Q:"o1c1VģQYIG%`='M#׆¼\DOD`ͨzQ+|?TӞy>? esXb_=_%I,$2sYnG=4i_8{*oZ R>D,B=Ke$ؐ. {ڑroH\,uv0.kQr!;r> 6 gFLh*">| ս\AξCy.~*+i:~]LDG AsS"Mz4^B)R{8nE# UQNU % 0( f a b w 4  UN>( Nf ^ h t mv 0l 0D = 0DE 0U 0 0 0z 03r 0X 0 0 0M 0 0 0r 0 0 0g 0 B 0 0C 0 0 0N 0 0 0: 0 0d 0 1ut 72 0N! 0ci!UH!!N"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" D5b" 0D"""" AS## 0D$ 0D$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ D-B%B%B%B%B%B%B%B%B%B%B%B% 04o%o%o%o% A% 0KB&\\IB01S01\CLERK1NAS,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE APage of &JE1d 3|x\  `&Times New RomanʜF1 U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   (3$ !  *+ (_2623  ..*D+D (_25   ," <DL,23  ..," <DL,   *5+5 (_24  ) <DL)23  ..) <DL)  *2+2 (_23 ` &<<DL&23  ..&<<DL& ` */+/ (_22  #DL#23  ..#DL#   h  \R'3 Letter Landscape\*,+, (_21   DL 23  .. DL  *)+) (_20 h DDL23  ..DDL h *&+& (_19  L23  ..L  *#+# (_18   L23  .. L  *>> (_17  2( 4 <DL223  Ԁ2( 4 <DL2  *DD (_16   ," <DL,23  Ԁ," <DL,   *55 (_15  ) <DL)23  Ԁ) <DL)  *22 (_14 ` &<<DL&23  Ԁ&<<DL& ` *// (_13  #DL#23  Ԁ#DL#  *,, (_12   DL 23  Ԁ DL  *)) (_11 h DDL23  ԀDDL h  d*&& (_10  L23  ԀL  (## &_9   L23  Ԁ L  (>> &_8  2( 4 <DL223  2( 4 <DL2  (DD &_7   ," <DL,23  ," <DL,   (55 &_6  ) <DL)23  ) <DL)  (22 &_5 ` &<<DL&23  &<<DL& ` (// &_4  #DL#23  #DL#  (,, &_3   DL 23   DL  ()) &_2 h DDL23  DDL h (&& &_1  L23  L  &## $_   L23   L  3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)1i)(O$(;3$2#  0  .3  0  2tQ Q`0Microsoft Sans Serif D   8zPXXdXXd8%%%%)!dxdx(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5ab\c[E<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1  )!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRO'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter Landscape3'LetterTXXX, 8oXXdd8760  081810` 8181@*` 81` 81SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE , @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS  @^^+ Monday,October11,2004 x      Ӏ   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd , dd ,dd ,edd , dd +  $ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER '$" 'COUNTY $ TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE $  JUDGE   JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE $ OF  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION '$" ' ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXHomerChancev.KennethW.Mitchell,   etal.   M200201239SCR11CV#XoXX X|# '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoHumphreysChancery   RobertE.Burch   26216#XoXX X# '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoKoch,J.   Affirmed#XoXX X # '  'Rule11 '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofKennethW.   MitchellandMichaelS.Clement#XoXX Xx #. ' ! '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoTammyKayJoinerv.JamesAlden b6" Griffin P$# M200300536SCR11JV#XoXX Xz # '>$ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoMontgomeryJuvenile b6% JohnJ._Hestle_ P$& 98235#XoXX X # '>' '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoClement,J. b6( Affirmedin P$) part,reversed >* inpart,and ,+ remanded#XoXX X # ', 'Rule11 'b6- '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofJamesAlden b6. Griffith#XoXX X# 'P$/ ' <( 4 <DLX< XXXXoHowardE.Buchananv.Stateof p0 Tennessee ^1 M200301815SCR11PC#XoXX X# 'xL2 '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoDicksonCircuit p3 RobertE.Burch ^4 CR6085#XoXX X#<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo#XoXX X# 'xL5 '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoOgle,J. p6 Affirmed#XoXX Xm# '^7 'Rule11 'p8 '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofHowardE. p9 Buchanan#XoXX Xe# '^: '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoMarcusW.Keenerv.StateofTennessee ; M200301521SCR11PC#XoXX XN# '< '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoLawrenceCircuit = RobertL.Jones > 23776#XoXX XC# '? '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoWelles,J. @ Affirmed#XoXX X6# 'A 'Rule11 'B '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofMarcusW. C Keene#XoXX X0#5X^ XXXo5  X5X^r#5X^ X 5##XoX X5X^dz# 'D 'DamienOwesv.StateofTennessee X,E M200203020SCR11PC 'FF 'DavidsonCriminal X,G SteveR.Dozier FH 99C1934 '4I 'Witt,J. X,J Tipton,J. FK Williams,J. 4L Affirmed '"M 'Rule11 'X,N ' Denied ApplicationofDamienOwes. 'X,O 'StateofTennesseev.AmyJo xP _Blankenship_  fQ M200201878SCR11CD '!T R 'CoffeeCircuit xS JohnW.Rollins  fT 31,689 '!T U 'Smith,J. xV Affirmed ' fW 'Rule11 'xX ' Denied ApplicationofAmyJo xY _Blankenship_. ' fZ '76 7 ,8oXXdXXd8 7  <( 4 <DLX< XXXXoStateofTennesseev._Ricky_ԀAllenDavis qd  M200202264SCR11CD#XoXX XA# '_R '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoFranklinCircuit qd J.CurtisSmith _R 13950#XoXX Xa# 'M@ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoOgle,J. qd Affirmed#XoXX XT# '_R 'Rule11 'qd '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied Applicationof_Ricky_ԀAllen qd  Davis#XoXX XL # '_R  'StateofTennesseev.RonaldFielding   M200301055SCR11CD '  'DavidsonCriminal   CherylBlackburn  2001D2358 ' 'Wedemeyer,J.  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofRonaldFielding. ' '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoStateofTennesseev.AndreEdward -  Hicks   M200300818SCR11CD#XoXX X## '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoDavidsonCriminal -  CherylBlackburn   2002B641#XoXX X&$# '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoHayes,J. -  Affirmed#XoXX X %# '  'Rule11 '-  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofAndreEdward -  Hicks#XoXX X&# '  'StateofTennesseev.JohnA.Lee  ~  M200301801SCR11CD 'y l  'WilliamsonCircuit  ~ ! TimothyL.Easter y l " II402146 'gZ # 'Welles,J.  ~ $ Affirmed 'y l % 'Rule11 ' ~ & ' Denied ApplicationofJohnA.Lee. ' ~ ' 'StateofTennesseev._Macin_Ԁ_Piotr_  ( _Makolajczak_ ) M200301764SCR11CD '* 'CheathamCircuit  + RobertE.Burch , 14046 '- 'Smith,J.  . Affirmed '/ 'Rule11 ' 0 ' Denied Applicationof_Macin_Ԁ_Piotr_  1 _Mikolajczak_. '2 'StateofTennesseev.DouglasMarshall G:3 _Mathis_ 5(4 M200202291SCR11CD '#5 'HoustonCircuit G:6 RobertE.Burch 5(7 CR4532 '#8 'Smith,J. G:9 Affirmed '5(: 'Rule11 'G:; ' Denied ApplicationofDouglas G:< Marshall_Mathis_. '5(= '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoStateofTennesseev._Stevan_ԀCraig > Mullen ? M200301123SCR11CD#XoXX X-# 't@ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoFranklinCircuit A BuddyD.Perry B 13972#XoXX X.# 'tC '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo_Woodall_,J. D Affirmed#XoXX X/# 'E 'Rule11 'F '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied Applicationof_Stevan_ԀCraig G Mullen#XoXX X0# 'H 'StateofTennesseev.PaulE.Orr,Jr. I M200202332SCR11CD 'J 'MarshallCircuit K CharlesLee L 14474 'M 'Tipton,J. N Reversed, O Case P Remanded 'Q 'Rule11 'R ' Denied ApplicationofPaulE.Orr,Jr. 'S '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoStateofTennesseev.CarlaJuanita OBT Prince =0U M200301098SCR11CD#XoXX X3# '+ V '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoFranklinCircuit OBW BuddyD.Perry =0X 13983#XoXX X4# '+ Y '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoGlenn,J. OBZ Affirmed#XoXX X5# '=0[ 'Rule11 'OB\ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofCarlaJuanita OB] Prince#XoXX X6# '=0^ ' TRO'3 Letter LandscapeO'3 Letter Landscape'3Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeT   StateofTennesseev.RoxanneVance qd M200301748SCR11CD '_R 'DavidsonCriminal qd J.RandallWyatt,Jr. _R  2002T475 'M@ 'Glenn,J. qd Affirmed _R  'M@ 'Rule11 'qd  ' Denied ApplicationofRoxanneVance. 'qd  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoGaryLynnVernonv.Jim_Dickman_Ԁand   StateofTennessee   M200302268SCR11_HC_#XoXX XG;# '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoHickmanCircuit  RussHeldman  035047CI#XoXX X<# ' '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoSmith,J.  Affirmed#XoXX X=# ' 'Rule11 ' '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofGaryLynn  Vernon#XoXX X># ' ' '-  ' '-  ' '-  ' '-  ' '-  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo_Cindi_ԀCarey,etal.v.DonaldMerritt,   d/b/aMerrittResidentialand   CommercialInspections  ~  W200300771SCR11CV#XoXX X7@# 'y l  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoShelbyChancery   D.J._Alissandratos_   #XoXX XA#<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoCH0214703#XoXX XB# ' ~ ! '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoHighers,J.  " Reversedin  # partand  ~ $ remanded#XoXX XCC# 'y l % 'Rule11 ' & '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofDonaldMerritt  ' d/b/aMerrittResidentialand  ( CommercialInspections#XoXX X{D#. ' ~ ) 'StateofTennesseev.CaryRayDavis  * W200301202SCR11CD ' + 'TiptonCircuit  , JosephH.Walker,III  - 4519 '. 'Smith,J.  / Affirmed ' 0 'Rule11 ' 1 ' Denied ApplicationofCaryRay  2 Davis. ' 3 '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoStateofTennesseev.VincentJackson YL4 W200301212SCR11CD#XoXX X{G# 'G:5 '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoShelbyCriminal YL6 JohnP._Colton_,Jr. G:7 9612127#XoXX XoH# '5(8 '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoRiley,J. YL9 Judgmentof G:: conviction 5(; reducedto #< seconddegree = murder; > remandedfor ? sentencing#XoXX XI# '@ 'Rule11 'YLA '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Granted ApplicationofStateof YLB Tennessee#XoXX X@K# 'G:C '_<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoStateofTennesseev.JohnDavidSmith ]PD W200301200SCR11CD#XoXX X:L# 'K>E '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoTiptonCircuit ]PF JosephH.Walker K>G 4565#XoXX X/M# '9,H '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoWitt,J. ]PI Affirmed#XoXX X N# 'K>J 'Rule11 ']PK '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofJohnDavid ]PL Smith.#XoXX XO# 'K>M ' 'N ' 'O ' 'P ' 'Q ' 'R '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoDanny_Blalock_Ԁv.Carolyn_Blalock_ =0S E200301151SCR11CV#XoXX XP# '+ T '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoSevierCircuit =0U RexH.Ogle + V 2001458III#XoXX XQ# '! W '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo_Inman_,J. =0X Affirmedas + Y modified#XoXX XR# '! Z 'Rule11 '=0[ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofCarolyn_Blalock_ =0\ #XoXX XT# '+ ] '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoCharlesC.Phillips,Jr.o/b/oHimselfv. qd  UnitedServicesAutomobileAssociation _R E200300850SCR11CV#XoXX X0U# 'M@ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoKnoxChancery qd DarylR._Fansler_ _R 1509302#XoXX XmV# 'M@ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoSusano,J. qd Affirmed#XoXX XW# '_R 'Rule11 'qd  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofUnitedServices qd  AutomobileAssociation#XoXX X{X#. '_R  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoErnestB._Eady_Ԁv.StateofTennessee   E200203111SCR11PC#XoXX XyY# '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoKnoxCriminal  RichardR.Baumgartner  73105#XoXX XZ# ' '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoGlenn,J.  Reversedand  Remanded#XoXX X[# ' 'Rule11 ' ' <( 4 <DLX< XXXXoDenied ApplicationofErnestB._Eady_#XoXX X\#. ' '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoRaymond_Kennebrew_Ԁv.Stateof -  Tennessee   E200301896SCR11PC#XoXX X]# '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoHamiltonCriminal -  RebeccaStern   241836#XoXX X^# '  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoWade,J. -  Affirmed#XoXX X_# '  'Rule11 '-  '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofRaymond -  _Kennebrew_.    #XoXX X`# ' ! '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoStateofTennesseev.Christopher_Kevan_  ~ " _Hein_ y l # E200301793SCR11CD#XoXX Xa# 'gZ $ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoKnoxCriminal  ~ % RichardBaumgartner y l & 68318#XoXX Xc# 'gZ ' '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoGlenn,J.  ~ ( Affirmed#XoXX Xd# 'y l ) 'Rule11 ' ~ * '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofChristopher  ~ + _Kevan_Ԁ_Hein_. y l , #XoXX Xd# 'gZ - 'StateofTennesseev.DavidWilliam  . _Sonnemaker_ / E200301402SCR11CD '0 'HamiltonCriminal  1 RebeccaStern 2 227582 '3 'Wedemeyer,J.  4 Affirmed '5 'Rule11 ' 6 ' Denied ApplicationofDavidWilliam  7 _Sonnemaker_. '8 '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoStateofTennesseev._Sedrick_ԀWilliams G:9 E200300659SCR11CD#XoXX Xzh# '5(: '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoKnoxCriminal G:; MaryBeth_Leibowitz_ 5(< 69597#XoXX Xi# '#= '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo_Woodall_,J. G:> Affirmed#XoXX Xj# '5(? 'Rule11 'G:@ '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied Applicationof_Sedrick_ G:A Williams#XoXX Xk#. '5(B '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoAnthonyJeromeStokesv.Stateof C Tennessee D E200202597SCR11PC#XoXX Xl# 'tE '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoHamiltonCriminal F DouglasA.Meyer G 211043#XoXX Xm# 'tH '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXoWade,P.J. I Vacatedand J ReEntered; tK TrialCourt obL Affirmed#XoXX Xn# ']PM 'Rule11 'N '<( 4 <DLX< XXXXo Denied ApplicationofAnthonyJerome O Stokes#XoXX X%p# 'P ' 'Q ' 'R ' 'S ' 'T '"U ! "X,