WPC Ġ0u%yG>54c2d9B0v)сۻ$~ e))F;yIdg(~~ɁT5C8ox|ziyqes}iATlX2GSVO"q~;-.kRòy?QMG#YT<惨q| c50iG9Ҳqt5݇HG^90mDHvRHoʤ@:ϐ}a?qP"Ζ+j ,ݏ4VU=^ʘ5=XO񧈛&Wx^* ū[u_htsD>۶o~:a/ٞo-?dlso,x*kT"ч2%/JZJ#9>#|\{%0#I_"wToB ?E-YY7؄7UklwZe^k`IC]8Mnez# UNU % 0( f a b w 4  B( Nj ^ l x mz 0l 0D 1uA 72 0cfKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK B D5 0DGG AS ` 0D& 0Djjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj D- 04 A 0K\\IB01S01\CLERK1NAS,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE APage of &o=/d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd8W/ U((3$ !      0  (#$  0  3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)i)(;3$2#  0  .3  0   \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d%%%%)!dxdx(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5ab\c[E<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1  )!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRO'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter Landscape3'LetterTXXX,  g 8cXXdd80  081810` 81810 ` 81` 81@* 81 81SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE , @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS  @^^+ Monday,October27,2003 x         `     h       @@7*%wddd Xdd Xdd XX81X81, dd ,dd ,dd ,dd , dd +  $ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER '6 " 'COUNTY 6  TRIALJUDGE $ TRIALCOURTNO. ' " 'APPELLATE 6   JUDGE $  JUDGMENT ' " 'NATURE 6   OF $ APPEAL '" 'ACTION '6 " ' ' h ' ' h ' ' h ' ' h ' ' h 'JacksonTennesseeHospitalCompany,   LLCv.JacksonMadisonCounty   GeneralHospitalDistrict,etal   M200201655SCR11CV '  'DavidsonChancery   IrvinH._Kilcrease_,Jr.   013364I '  'Crawford,_P.J_,   W.S.   Vacatedand   Remanded '  'Rule11 ' ! ' Denied ApplicationofJackson  " TennesseeHospitalCompany,LLC. ' # 'SammyMillerv.TennesseeBoardof b6$ ProbationandParoles P$% M200200426SCR11CV '>& 'DavidsonChancery b6' Ellen_Hobbs_ԀLyle P$( 012807III '>) 'Cantrell,P.J.,M.S. b6* Affirmedand P$+ Remanded '>, 'Rule11 'b6- ' Denied ApplicationofSammyMiller. 'b6. 'RutherfordCountyBoardofEducation / v.Alexander&_Shankle_,Inc. 0 M200301460SCS09CV 'p1 'RutherfordChancery 2 RobertE._Corlew_,III 3 012930CV 'p4 'Cantrell,P.J.,M.S. 5 Rule9Denied '6 'Rule9 '7 ' Denied ApplicationofRutherford 8 CountyBoardofEducation. '9 'StateofTennesseeexrel.Moore& : Associates,Inc.v.TerenceL.Cobb,  ; DirectorofCodesAdministrationofthe < MetropolitanGovernmentofNashville = andDavidsonCounty > M200200504SCR11CV '? 'DavidsonChancery @ IrvinH._Kilcrease_,Jr.  A 02113I 'B '_Highers_,J. C Reversedand  D Remanded 'E 'Rule11 'F ' Denied ApplicationofTerrenceL. G Cobb,DirectorofCodesAdministration  H oftheMetropolitanGovernmentof I NashvilleandDavidson_County. 'J 'JeffUtleyv.TennesseeDepartmentof FK Correction,etal 4L M199901412SCR11CV '"M 'DavidsonChancery FN CarolMcCoy 4O 982578II '"P 'Koch,J. FQ Affirmed '4R 'Rule11 'FS ' Denied ApplicationofJeffUtley.Itis FT therecommendationoftheCourtof 4U AppealsthattheOpinionbePublished._ '"V 'JohnE.Carterv.StateofTennessee xW M200300750SCR11CO ' fX 'WhiteCircuit xY LeonC.Burns,Jr.  fZ 6734 '!T [ '_Woodall_,J. x\ Smith,J.  f] Wedemeyer,J. !T ^ Dismissed 'n"B!_ 'Rule11 'x` ' Denied ApplicationofJohnE.Carter. 'xa ' g  8cXXdXXd8    RobertI._Gwin_Ԁv.StateofTennessee d  M200202061SCR11PC '~R 'DavidsonCriminal d CherylBlackburn ~R CC3211 'l@ 'Wade,J. d Affirmed '~R 'Rule11 'd ' Denied ApplicationofRobertI._Gwin_. 'd  '_OudonPanyanouvongv.Stateof   Tennessee   M200201567SCR11PC '  'RutherfordCircuit   J.SteveDaniel  F49500 ' 'Welles,J.  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofOudon  Panyanouvong. ' 'FloydW.Smith,IIv.StateofTennessee L  M200201933SCR11PC ':  'WilsonCriminal L  DonAsh :  95407 '(  'Wedemeyer,J. L  Affirmed. ':  'Rule11 'L  ' Denied ApplicationofFloydW.Smith, L  II. ':  'StateofTennesseev.JohnKunle  ~  Awokoya  l  M200200870SCR11CD ' Z ! 'RutherfordCircuit  ~ " DonAsh  l # M51720 ' Z $ 'Welles,J.  ~ % Smith,J.  l & Wedemeyer,J.  Z ' Rule20Order tH ( Affirming b6) Judgment 'P$* 'Rule11 ' ~ + ' Denied ApplicationofJohnKunle  ~ , Awokoya. ' l - 'StateofTennesseev.DerickBailey . M200102411SCR11CD '/ 'DavidsonCriminal 0 SethW.Norman 1 99B1017 '2 'Ogle,J. 3 Affirmed '4 'Rule11 '5 ' Denied ApplicationofDerickBailey. '6 'StateofTennesseev.MichaelRayBates 07 M200201803SCR11CD '8 'HickmanCriminal 09 RussHeldman : 975202CRI ' ; 'Wade,J. 0< Affirmed '= 'Rule11 '0> ' Denied ApplicationofMichaelRay 0? Bates. '@ 'StateofTennesseev.ChristinaB.Jones bA M2002!02428SCR11CD '|PB 'WilliamsonCircuit bC DonaldP.Harris |PD I1101357A 'j>E 'Woodall,J. bF Affirmed '|PG 'Rule11 'bH ' Denied ApplicationofChristinaB. bI Jones. '|PJ 'StateofTennesseev.RalphJoseph K Gonnella L M200300726SCS10CO 'M 'DavidsonCriminal N SteveR.Dozier O 2002B1083 'P 'Wedemeyer,J. Q Rule10Denied 'R 'Rule11 'S ' Denied ApplicationofRalphJoseph T Gonnella. 'U 'StateofTennesseev.PattyFrancine JV Grissom 8 W M200200279SCR11CD '&!X 'WarrenCircuit JY CharlesHaston 8 Z M8690 '&![ 'Ogle,J. J\ Affirmed '8 ] 'Rule11 'J^ ' Denied ApplicationofPattyFrancine J_ __Grissom_. '8 ` ' TRO'3 Letter LandscapeO'3 Letter Landscape'3Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeT   StateofTennesseev.GregoryLance d  M200102507SCR11CD '~R 'PutnamCriminal d CharlesLee ~R 990054 'l@ '_Woodall_,J. d Affirmed '~R 'Rule11 'd ' Denied ApplicationofGregoryLance. 'd  'StateofTennesseev._Brigitte_ԀPauli   M200201607SCR11CD '  'WilliamsonCircuit   DonaldP.Harris   I20010136 ' 'Riley,J.  AffirmedinPart;  ReversedinPart;  Remanded ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied Applicationof_Brigitte_ԀPauli. ' 'StateofTennesseev._Terrance_ԀW.Price :  M200200991SCR11CD '(  'DavidsonCriminal :  CherylBlackburn (  2002A56&2001B   1022 '  '_Woodall_,J. :  Affirmed '(  'Rule11 ':  ' Denied Applicationof_Terrance_ԀW. :  Price. (  **PursuanttoSupremeCourtRule4   (D),theCourtdirectsthepublicationof  ! theopinionoftheCourtofCriminal  " AppealsfiledMay9,2003. ' # 'StateofTennesseev.Dennis_Pylant_ b6$ M200102335SCR11CD 'P$% '_Cheatham_ԀCircuit b6& AllenW.Wallace P$' 13469 '>( 'Ogle,J. b6) Affirmed 'P$* 'Rule11 'b6+ ' Denied ApplicationofDennis_Pylant_. 'b6, 'StateofTennesseev.JeffreyWayne - Robertson . M200102131SCR11CD 'p/ 'LawrenceCircuit 0 JimT.Hamilton 1 19338 'p2 'Glenn,J. 3 Affirmed '4 'Rule11 '5 ' Denied ApplicationofJeffreyWayne 6 Robertson. '7 'StateofTennesseev._Carvin_ԀLamont 8 Thomas  9 M200201716SCR11CD ': 'DavidsonCriminal ; SteveDozier  < 2000D2269 '= '_Woodall_,J. > Affirmed ' ? 'Rule11 '@ ' Denied Applicationof_Carvin_ԀLamont A Thomas. ' B 'StateofTennesseev.JerryW._Yancy_,Jr. |PC M200201640SCR11CD 'j>D 'WilliamsonCircuit |PE TimothyL.Easter j>F II499120 'X,G '_Woodall_,J. |PH Affirmed 'j>I 'Rule11 '|PJ ' Denied ApplicationofJerryw._Yancy_, |PK Jr. 'j>L 'StevenE.Toddv.StateofTennessee M M200103080SCR11PC 'N 'DavidsonCriminal O SethNorman P 93B901 'Q 'Glenn,J. R Reversedand S Remanded 'T 'Rule11 'U ' Denied ApplicationofStevenE.Todd. 'V ' '8 W ' '8 X ' '8 Y ' '8 Z ' '8 [ 'AnthonyJ._Doty_,etalv._HCCF_,etal d W200203023SCS10CV '~R '_Hardeman_ԀCircuit d RobertL.Childers ~R  8908 'l@ 'Farmer,J. d _Highers_,J. ~R Denied 'l@ 'Rule10 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofAnthony_Doty_ d  andBeth_Doty_. '~R  'HaroldLeeJacksonv.JimRout,Mayor   ofShelbyCounty,etal   W200301702SCS10CV ' 'ShelbyChancery  D.J._Alissandratos_  CH00_Ԅ0776_3 ' '_Highers_,J.  Farmer,J.   ' 'Rule10 ' ' Denied ApplicationofHaroldLee  Jackson. ' 'BillyJoeLambert,etalv.JonDouglas L  Hall :  W200202511SCR11CV '(  'CarrollChancery L  RonE.Harmon :  01AA0084 '(  '_Highers_,J. L  Farmer,J. :  Dismissed '(   'Rule11 'L ! ' Denied ApplicationofJonDouglas L " Hall. ': # 'ChristopherNashPowellv.Patsy_Conley_  ~ $ Powell  l % W200200421SCR11CV ' Z & '_Haywood_ԀChancery  ~ ' GeorgeR.Ellis  l ( 11937 ' Z ) 'Farmer,J.  ~ * AffirmedinPart;  l + ReversedinPart;  Z , andRemanded 'tH - 'Rule11 ' ~ . ' Denied ApplicationofChristopher  ~ / NashPowellandPatsy_Conley_ԀPowell. ' l 0 ' '1 ' '2 ' '3 ' '4 ' '5 'VictorR._Wingo_Ԁv.Tennessee xL6 DepartmentofCorrection f:7 W200200312SCR11CV 'T(8 'LauderdaleChancery xL9 MarthaB._Brasfield_ f:: 11,925 'T(; 'Farmer,J. xL< Affirmedand f:= Remanded 'T(> 'Rule11 'xL? ' Denied ApplicationofVictorR. xL@ _Wingo_. 'f:A '_Terrell_ԀBurgessv.StateofTennessee B W200200826SCR11PC 'C 'ShelbyCircuit D ChrisCraft E P22629 'F 'Tipton,J. G Affirmed 'H 'Rule11 'I ' Denied Applicationof_Terrell_ԀBurgess. 'J 'JeffreyA.Caseyv.StateofTennessee 4K W200201027SCR11PC '"L 'DecaturCircuit 4M JulianP._Guinn_ "N 1275 'O 'Glenn,J. 4P Affirmed '"Q 'Rule11 '4R ' Denied ApplicationofJeffreyA. 4S Casey. '"T 'MichaelWayneHowellv.Stateof fU Tennessee TV W200301056SCR11_PD_ nBW  '\0X 'ShelbyCircuit fY W.Otis_Higgs_,Jr. TZ P14334 'nB[ 'Hayes,J. f\ Denied 'T] 'Rule11 'f^ ' Granted ApplicationofMichael f_ WayneHowell. 'T` 'CorneliusRobinsv.GlenTurner d W200301535SCR11CD '~R '_Hardeman_ԀCircuit d JonK.Blackwood ~R 9600 'l@ 'Hayes,J. d Riley,J. ~R Williams,J. l@ DeniedMotionfor Z.   PermissiontoFile H  aLateAppeal '6   'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofCornelius d  Robins. '~R 'StateofTennesseev.DonaldClark  W200101549SCR11CD 'z 'ShelbyCriminal  JosephB.Dailey z 0003417 ' h 'Smith,J.  Affirmed 'z 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofDonaldClark. ' 'StateofTennesseev.RobertClark   W200200940SCR11CD '  'ShelbyCriminal   JohnP._Colton_,Jr.   0105153 '  'Glenn,J.   Affirmed '  'Rule11 '  ' Denied ApplicationofRobertClark. '  'StateofTennesseev.HenryDaniels tH ! W200200193SCR11CD 'b6" 'ShelbyCriminal tH # JosephB.Dailey b6$ 0005606,07 'P$% 'Glenn,J. tH & AffirmedinPart b6' andRemanded 'P$( 'Rule11 'tH ) ' Denied ApplicationofHenryDaniels. 'tH * 'StateofTennesseev.JamieLou + _Haneline_ , W200201773SCR11CD '- 'DecaturCircuit . C.Creed_McGinley_ / 01CR013 '0 'Welles,J. 1 Affirmed '2 'Rule11 '3 ' Denied ApplicationofJamieLou 4 _Haneline_. '5 'StateofTennesseev.CarltonLee 06 _McAlister_ 7 W200200454SCR11CD ' 8 'CarrollCircuit 09 C.Creed_McGinley_ : 20CR1620 ' ; 'Williams,J. 0< Affirmed '= 'Rule11 '0> ' Denied ApplicationofCarltonLee 0? _McAlister_. '@ 'StateofTennesseev._Delbert_ԀEugene bA _Orey_ |PB W200200482SCR11CD 'j>C 'CarrollCircuit bD RoyMorgan |PE 01CR1769 'j>F 'Glenn,J. bG Affirmed '|PH 'Rule11 'bI ' Denied Applicationof_Delbert_ԀEugene bJ _Orey_. '|PK 'StateofTennesseev.SteveA.White L W20000148SCR11CD 'M 'ShelbyCriminal N JosephB.Dailey O 9810427 'P 'Tipton,J. Q Affirmed 'R 'Rule11 'S ' Denied ApplicationofSteveA.White. 'T ' 'JU ' 'JV ' 'JW ' 'JX ' 'JY '_NicoleMarieLuschinBussFlinnv. d JamesMichaelFlinn ~R E200201598SCR11CV 'l@ 'CampbellGeneral d Sessions ~R JosephM.Ayers l@  2363 'Z. 'Swiney,J. d Affirmed& ~R  Remanded 'l@  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofJamesMichael d  Flinn. '~R  'CarrollClabo,etalv.GreatAmerican  Resorts,Inc.  E200201008SCR11CV ' 'SevierCircuit  RexH.Ogle  96204III ' 'Swiney,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofGreatAmerican  Resorts,Inc. ' 'BobbyGeneGoodsonv.MaryLou :  Duncan (  E200301137SCR11CV '  'SullivanCircuit :  C11820 '(  'Goddard,P.J.,E.S. :  Susano,J. (  Swiney,J.   AppealDismissed ' ! 'Rule11 ': " ' Denied ApplicationofBobbyGene : # Goodson. '( $ 'IntheMatterof:TheEstateofJ.C.  Z % Queener,Deceased,JeffW.Powelland tH & EdwinH.Arnoldv.ElaineHelton,etal b6' E200202311SCR11CV 'P$( 'LoudonProbate  Z ) WilliamH.Russell tH * 2363 'b6+ 'Franks,J.  Z , AffirmedinPart; tH - ReversedinPart 'b6. 'Rule11 ' Z / ' Denied ApplicationofElaineHelton  Z 0 andKennyStevens. 'tH 1 'FernKeatonv.HancockCountyBoard 2 ofEducation 3 E200201778SCR11CV '4 'HancockCircuit 5 BenK.Wexler 6 3012 '7 'Susano,J. 8 Affirmedas 9 Modified& : Remanded 'p; 'Rule11 '< ' Denied ApplicationofHancockCounty = BoardofEducation. '> 'ByronA.Looperv.NewsChannel5 ? Network,L.P.,etal  @ E200202295SCR11CV 'A 'MorganCircuit B RussellE.Simmons,Jr.  C 6197C 'D 'Franks,J. E Susano,J.  F Swiney,J. G AppealDismissed 'H 'Rule11 'I ' Denied ApplicationofByronA. J Looper. ' K 'WandaShadwick,Individually,andas j>L ExecutrixoftheEstateofKennethLee X,M Phillipsv.F.H.ShoemakerDistributors, FN Inc.,etal 4O E200201525SCR11CV '"P 'ScottChancery j>Q BillyJ.White X,R 8282 'FS 'Goddard,P.J.,E.S. j>T Affirmed& X,U Remanded 'FV 'Rule11 'j>W ' Denied ApplicationofWanda j>X Shadwick. 'X,Y 'CharlesWestonElseav.Stateof xZ Tennessee  f[ E200300091SCR11PC ; '!T \ 'HamiltonCriminal x] StephenM.Bevil  f^ 23692 '!T _ 'Wade,J. x` Affirmed ' fa 'Rule11 'xb ' Denied ApplicationofCharlesW. xc Elsea. ' fd 'ChristopherDavidHodgev.Stateof d  Tennessee ~R E200201149SCR11PC 'l@ 'KnoxCriminal d RayJenkins ~R 72957 'l@ 'Smith,J. d Affirmed '~R 'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofChristopher d  DavidHodge. '~R  'RichardHoustonv.StateofTennessee   E200201590SCR11PC '  'KnoxCriminal  RayJenkins  74831 ' 'Ogle,J.  Wade,J.  Witt,J.  AffirmedPursuant  toRule20 'z 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofRichard  Houston. ' 'StateofTennesseev.DewayneR.Cross (  E199902026SCR11CD '  'BlountCircuit (  D.KellyThomas,Jr.   C10542 '  'Glenn,J. (  Affirmed '  'Rule11 '(   ' Denied ApplicationofDwayneR. ( ! Cross. ' " 'StateofTennesseev.RobertLeeFox  Z # E200201585SCR11CD 'tH $ 'HamiltonCriminal  Z % StephenM.Bevil tH & 234538 'b6' 'Hayes,J.  Z ( Affirmed 'tH ) 'Rule11 ' Z * ' Denied ApplicationofRobertLeeFox. ' Z + 'StateofTennesseev.TracyLorenzo , Goodwin - E200101978SCR11CD '. 'HamiltonCriminal / StephenM.Bevil 0 228289,228290,22891, 1 228292 '2 'Tipton,J. 3 Affirmed '4 'Rule11 '5 ' Granted ApplicationofTracyLorenzo 6 Goodwin. '7 'StateofTennesseev.DebiasiSirnard 08 King 9 E200200634SCR11CD ' : 'HamiltonCriminal 0; DouglasA.Meyer < 207729 ' = 'Williams,J. 0> Affirmed '? 'Rule11 '0@ ' Denied ApplicationofDebiasiSirnard 0A King. 'B 'StateofTennesseev.SusanSophia bC McDaniel |PD E200202469SCR11CD 'j>E 'CumberlandCircuit bF LeonC.Burns,Jr. |PG 6513 'j>H 'Riley,J. bI Affirmed '|PJ 'Rule11 'bK ' Denied ApplicationofSusanSophia bL McDaniel. '|PM 'StateofTennesseev.JosephLance N Risner O E200201112SCR11PC 'P 'GreeneCircuit Q JamesE.Beckner R 01CR155 'S 'Hayes,J. T Affirmed 'U 'Rule11 'V ' Denied ApplicationofJosephLance W Risner. 'X 'StateofTennesseev.RobertF.Smythers JY E200102806SCR11CD '8 Z 'MonroeCircuit J[ R.StevenBebb 8 \ 98202 '&!] 'Wedemeyer,J. J^ Reversed& 8 _ Remanded '&!` 'Rule11 'Ja ' Denied ApplicationofStateof Jb Tennessee. '8 c 'StateofTennesseev.KennethRay d  Stewart ~R E200102117SCR11CD 'l@ 'HamiltonCriminal d DouglasA.Meyer ~R 232733 'l@ 'Wedemeyer,J. d Affirmed '~R 'Rule11 'd  ' Denied ApplicationofKennethRay d  Stewart. '~R  'StateofTennesseev.RomeyStone   E200202570SCR11CD '  'GraingerCircuit  O.DuaneSlone  3401&3617 ' 'Hayes,J.  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofRomeyStone. ' 'StateofTennesseev.RaymondWriter L  E200101062SCR11CD ':  'SullivanCircuit L  PhyllisH.Miller :  S42,614 '(  'Smith,J. L  Affirmed ':  'Rule11 'L  ' Denied ApplicationofRaymond L  Writer. ':  ' ' ~  ' ' ~  ' ' ~ ! ' ' ~ " '" ~ # @ "