WPC, eMQ 9X۷=W4/ rYwHBPv71',״;Ѧ'n2pke"|f@>_W6NpuAt rV86;9,FU@g5 ^Xcp}UEGfxoBK~ؽSinw&*8-l3W`v+/S~Smѝhlŭ'K4k{.9dI7 _n0\|y{LtÚkwڲ&sH9Ӂ`Hgw>/vmWt#7&HQ9n'F^s⋪-<;UW誈\"Yi97l亂Û |\k5eӮA†c{w;h@"g<F.K]m&\)PA[l Z# UNM % 0( f a 0 w 4 ' B6 Nx ^ z  m 0l 0D OOOOfTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT B 0D D- 04 AB 0KHP LaserJet 4050 Series PCL 6,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A & $    1    _TheapplicationisgrantedforthesolepurposeofremandingthecasetotheCourtofCriminalAppealsfordispositionin X accordancewithRule22oftheTennesseeRuleofAppellateProcedure.,-d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd82Y-s U((3$ !      0  (#$  0    $    2    _Ԁ1.Istheevidenceinsufficienttosupportthejurysfindingthattheaggravatingcircumstancesoutweighthemitigating X circumstancesbeyondareasonabledoubt? >   2.Isthesentenceimposeddisproportionatetothoseinsimilarcases? $   3.DotheotherfactorsformandatoryreviewunderTenn.CodeAnn.3913206(c)(1)requirereversalofthesentence?     4.Didthetrialcourtabuseitsdis;:re:;<cretioninadmit<?<i<?@tingphotographsofthevictimsbodies?  @?<n<<g<<<<p<?=<r<=?>ho>?@  5.Didthetrialcourtcommitreversibleerrorinlimitingthedefen@A@g@ABdantsmitigatingevidence? ~ BA@a@@n@@t@@@@mitigationg@@@AB  6.DidtheadmissionofBCBtheBCDvictimimpactevidenceviolateconstitutionalprovisionsagainstexpostfactolaws?D \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5)!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3 Letter Landscape3'TXXXX  g 0  @*8181SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS > @/ October28,2002 $   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,dd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE :  OFAPPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' JerryWalkerandwifeOpal  ( WalkerandWalker&Assoc. f   Realty,Inc.,f/k/aCentury21 L  Walker&Assoc.,Inc. 2  v.   _Ricky_ԀE.WhiteandCitizensBank   ofLafayette   M200102438SCR11CV 'r 'MaconCircuit  ( JohnD._Wooten_,Jr. f   4276 'L  'Farmer,J.  ( Affirmed& f   Remanded. 'L  'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCitizensBank  ( ofLafayette.PursuanttoSupremeCourt f   Rule4(D),theCourtdirectsthatthe L ! opinionoftheCourtofAppeals,filed 2 " June20,2002,bepublishedinthe  # officialreporter.  $  ' % ' JosephA._Cashia_,EtAl . D&  v. *' BruceA.Hancock,EtAl. ( M199700252SCR11CV ') 'WilliamsonChancery D* HenryD.Bell *+ 23606 ,  '- '_Cantrell_,J. D. Koch,J. */ Cain,J. 0 Reversed& 1 Remanded. '2 'Rule11 'D3 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJosephA.and D4 _Suellyn_Ԁ_Cashia_. *5  '6 ' MarilynAnn_Yount_ V7 v. <8 BruceWayne_Yount_ "9 M200101335SCR11CV ': 'MontgomeryChancery V; Carol_Catalano_ << 9167205 '"= '_Cantrell_,J. V> Affirmedas <? Modified& "@ Remanded. 'A 'Rule11 'VB ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBruceWayne VC _Yount_. <D  '"E ' '*F ' '*G ' '*H ' '*I ' '*J ' StateofTennessee K v. L ThomasW._Gatewood_ pM M200101871SCR11CD 'VN 'DavidsonCriminal O SethNorman P 99C1698 'pQ 'Glenn,J. R Reversed& S Remanded. 'pT 'Rule11 'U ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStateof V Tennessee. W  'pX ' StateofTennessee (!Y v. "Z _Haskel_ԀD.Finch " [ M200100340SCR11CD '#!\ '_Humphreys_ԀCounty (!] AllenW.Wallace "^ 9751 '" _ 'Glenn,J. (!` Affirmed. '"a 'Rule11 '(!b ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Haskel_ԀD. (!c Finch. "d  '" e ' g  8n`XXdd8    TravisJones,Jr. d  v. J StateofTennessee 0 M200101852SCR11PC 'n 'DavidsonCriminal d J.RandallWyatt,Jr. J 99C1774 '0 'Hayes,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTravisJones,Jr. d   'J  ' TedRay_Brannan_   v. v StateofTennessee \ M200001668SCR11PC ' B 'FranklinCircuit  BuddyD.Perry v 9332B '\ 'Smith,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTedRay  _Brannan_. v  '\ ' '  ' '  ' '  ' '  ' '  ' StateofTennessee  6  v. t   WillieJ._Cowan_,Jr. Z ! W200003140SCR11CD '@ " 'ShelbyCriminal  6 # ChrisCraft t  $ 9912175 'Z % '_Wedemeyer_,J.  6 & Affirmed. 't  ' 'Rule11 ' 6 ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWillieJ._Cowan_,  6 ) Jr. t  *  'Z + ' StateofTennessee b, v. H- StephenMurrayMitchell .. W200201574SCR11CD 'l/ 'ShelbyCriminal b0 JosephB.Dailey H1 99139667,0013207 .2 9,0001544 'l3 'Riley,J. b4 Rule9Denied. 'H5 'Rule9 'b6 ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofStephen b7 MurrayMitchell. #  1       H8  '.9 ' StateofTennessee : v. t; PercyPerezFarris Z< W200101787SCR11CD '@= '_McNairy_ԀCircuit > JonKerryBlackwood t? 1339A 'Z@ 'Welles,J. A Affirmed. 'tB 'Rule11 'C ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPercyPerez D Farris. tE  'ZF ' StateofTennessee G v. H RonaldEugene_Rickman_Ԁand I WilliamEdward_Groseclose_ lJ W199901744SCR11CD 'RK 'ShelbyCriminal L JamesC._Beasley_,Jr. M B59341 'N 'Ogle,J. O Remandedfor P Correctionand Q OtherwiseAffirmed. 'lR 'Rule11 'S ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRonald T _Rickman_ԀandWilliam_Groseclose_. U  'V ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   EddieF._Depriest_ d v. J  StateofTennessee 0 W200103103SCR11PC 'n 'ShelbyCriminal d Carolyn_Blacklett_ J _M_25794 '0 'Williams,J. d AffirmedRule20 J  Order. '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEddieF. d  _Depriest_. J   '0 ' _Lacorrick_Ԁc.Williams  v. v StateofTennessee \ W200200156SCR11PC ' B 'ShelbyCriminal  _J.C._Ԁ_McLin_ v P22070 '\ 'Williams,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Lacorrick_ԀC.  Williams. v  '\ ' StateofTennessee   v.   PrestonCarter   W200002204SCDDTDD ' n  'ShelbyCriminal    JonKerryBlackwood  ! 9309760,9309761 ' " 'Williams,J.  # Affirmed. ' $ ' ' % 'Uponconsiderationofthebriefsfiledby  & thedefendantandtheStateofTennessee,  ' andpursuanttoTenn.CodeAnn.39  ( 13206(a)(1),theCourt,atoralargument,  n ) isparticularlyinterestedinthese_issues: #  2      _ 'T * ' '& + ' '& , ' '& - ' '& . ' '& / ' InRe:TheAdoptionof_D.P.M._ H0 E200100958SCR11CV '.1 'KnoxChancery H2 JohnF.Weaver .3 1431981 'l4 '_Swiney_,J. H5 Affirmed& .6 Remanded. 'l7 'Rule11 'H8 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonnaRaeand H9 PaulEd_Mickles_. .:  'l; ' WilliamR._Lindgren_ < v. t= CityofJohnsonCity Z> E200101676SCR11CV '@? 'WashingtonCircuit @ JeanStanley tA 19720 'ZB 'Franks,J. C AffirmedinPart; tD VacatedinPart& ZE Remanded. '@F 'Rule11 'G ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCityofJohnson H City. tI  'ZJ ' 'K ' 'L ' 'M ' 'N ' 'O ' HowardWalterThomas d  v. J StateofTennessee 0 E200201692SCS09CD 'n 'KnoxCriminal d RichardR._Baumgartner_ J 71670 '0 '_Tipton_,J. d Wade,J. J  Ogle,J 0  Rule9Denied. 'n  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofHowardWalter d  Thomas. J  '0 ' StateofTennessee  v. v JacobDyck \ E200100476SCR11CD ' B 'MonroeCircuit  CarrollL.Ross v 99045 '\ 'Welles,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJacobDyck.   'v ' WilliamBrian_Belser_   v.   StateofTennessee     E200101541SCR11CD ' n  'KnoxCriminal    RayJenkins  ! 70981 ' " 'Wade,J.  # Affirmed. ' $ 'Rule11 ' % ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliamBrian  & _Belser_.  '  ' ( ' StateofTennessee @ ) v. & * DonaldKing,Jr.  + E200100836SCR11CD ', '_Blount_ԀCircuit @ - D.KellyThomas,Jr. & . C12150,51,12568,  / 12868,1293537 '0 'Welles,J. @ 1 Affirmed. '& 2 'Rule11 '@ 3 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonaldKing,Jr. @ 4  '& 5 ' StateofTennessee l6 v. R7 JamesC._McFall_ 88 E200102712SCR11CD '9 'HawkinsCriminal l: JamesE._Beckner_ R; 7865 '8< 'Welles,J. l= Affirmed. 'R> 'Rule11 'l? ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesC. l@ _McFall_. RA  '8B ' StateofTennessee @C v. ~&D _Fredrick_Ԁ_Devill_ԀRice d E E200002389SCR11CD 'JF 'HamiltonCriminal @G StephenM._Bevil_ ~&H 225992 'd I '_Tipton_,J. @J Affirmed. '~&K 'Rule11 '@L ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Fredrick_Ԁ_Devill_ @M Rice. ~&N  'd O ' StateofTennessee lP v. RQ CharlesH.Martin 8R E200100565SCR11CD 'vS '_Sevier_ԀCircuit lT RexH.Ogle RU 8099 '8V 'Welles,J. lW Affirmed. 'RX 'Rule11 'lY ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharlesH. lZ Martin. R[  '8\ ' StateofTennessee ] v.  ~^ GloriaHouse !d_ E200200439SCR11PC '"J ` 'HamiltonCriminal a DouglasMeyer  ~b 211691 '!dc 'Wade,J. d _Witt_,J.  ~e Ogle,J. !df Rule28Denied. '"J g 'Rule11 'h ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGloriaHouse. i  ' ~j ' DonaldWayne_Strouth_ d  v. J StateofTennessee 0 E200102083SCR11PC 'n 'SullivanCircuit d LynnW.Brown J S35,090 '0 'Wade,J. d _Witt_,J. J  Ogle,J. 0  Rule28Denied. 'n  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonaldWayne d  _Strouth_. J  '0 ' JosephHough  v. v StateofTennessee \ E200101792SCR11PC ' B 'GreeneCircuit  LynnW.Brown v 01CR035 '\ 'Wade,J.  _Witt_,J. v Ogle,J. \ AffirmedPursuant  B toRule20. ' ( 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJosephHough."  "X,