WPC Mn"ET̕TfS [dq;.scYRɏ8|k[2 4 M7o"UVgplV!t)Pv\f;qRj gaUSI0\\D'ajqvhˀIޭ9դÎڀxU ;$ΣgB$^;xrlfPFFR*/ؼWDj9Y8@4AU`W;-(4^MU;/b4vghBLheUD贰 @/ November4,2002 $   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,dd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE :  OFAPPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' KennethL.Warren  ( v. f   Columbia/_HCA_ԀHealthcareCorp., L  EtAl. 2  M200002579SCR11CV '  'DavidsonCircuit  ( BarbaraN.Haynes f   99C1995 'L  '_Lillard_,J.  ( Affirmed. 'f   'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKennethL.  ( Warren. f   _Drowota_,C.J.notparticipating. 2   '  ' _Klosterman_ԀDevelopmentCorp. :  v. x ! OutlawAircraftSales ^" M200102586SCR11CV 'D# 'MontgomeryChancery : $ JamesE.Walton x % 99060044 '^& 'Crawford,J. : ' ReversedinPart; x ( Affirmedas ^) Modified. 'D* 'Rule11 ': + ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofOutlawAircraft : , Sales. x -  '^. ' LindaK.Plunk,EtAl. f/ v. L0 NationalHealthInvestors,Inc. 21 M199901596SCR11CV 'p2 'LawrenceCircuit f3 RobertL.Jones L4 CC38197 '25 'Koch,J. f6 Reversed. 'L7 'Rule11 'f8 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLindaK.Plunk, f9 EtAl. L:  '2; ' SusanGreen < v. x= LeonMoore,_Sholodge_,Inc.,and ^> _Sholodge_ԀFranchiseSystems,Inc. D? M200200889SCR11CV '*@ 'WilliamsonCircuit A R.E.LeeDavies xB I2K393 '^C '_Cantrell_,J. D Koch,J. xE GrantingMotionto ^F Dismiss. 'DG 'Rule11 'H ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofSusanGreen. I  'xJ ' VictoriaL.Henry,EtAl. K v. L TimothyA._Goins_,EtAl. pM M200002663SCR11CV 'VN 'DavidsonCircuit O HamiltonV._Gayden_,Jr. P 97C496(99C1454, pQ 99C1453) VR  ' <S '_Inman_,Sp.J. T Reversed. 'U 'Rule11 'V ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofVictoriaL. W HenryandPeggyHenry. X  'pY ' g  8pXXdd8    Carolyn_Stovall_ d v. J LoisE.Clarke,M.D.,EtAl. 0  M200100810SCR11CV 'n 'WilliamsonCircuit d Russ_Heldman_ J 97652 '0 '_Inman_,Sp.J. d AffirmedinPart, J  ReversedinPart& 0  Remanded. 'n  'Rule11 'd  ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofLoisE.Clarke, d  M.D. J  '0 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' StateofTennessee b  v. H  RandalL._Skelton_ .  M200101266SCR11CD '  'SumnerCriminal b  Jane_Wheatcraft_ H  3752000 '.  'Smith,J. b  Welles,J. H  _Woodall_,J. .  Dismissed. '  'Rule11 'b   ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRandal b ! _L.Skelton_. H "  '. # ' StateofTennessee  6 $ v. t  % Michael_Terrell_ԀThomas,Shawn Z & _Lavell_ԀFore,andGaryDwayne @ ' _Harton_ & ( M200100799SCR11CD ' ) 'MarshallCircuit  6 * WilliamC.Lee t  + 14363,14362,14281 'Z , 'Riley,J.  6 - Reversed& t  . Remanded. 'Z / 'Rule11 ' 6 0 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichael_Terrell_  6 1 Thomas,Shawn_Lavell_ԀFore,andGary t  2 Dwayne_Harton_. Z 3  '@ 4 ' StateofTennessee .5 v. l6 William_Binkley_ R7 M200100404SCR11CD '88 'DavidsonCircuit .9 JamesK.Clayton,Jr. l: F47453 'R; '_Witt_,J. .< Affirmed. 'l= 'Rule11 '.> ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliam .? _Binkley_. l@  'RA ' StateofTennessee ZB v. @C TiffanyMichelleTaylor ~&D M199902358SCR11CD 'd E 'PutnamCriminal ZF LeonBurns @G 970295 '~&H '_Tipton_,J. ZI Affirmed. '@J 'Rule11 'ZK ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTiffany ZL MichelleTaylor. @M  '~&N ' StateofTennessee O v. lP _Kerwin_Ԁ_Dowell_ RQ M200100970SCR11CD '8R 'MontgomeryCircuit S MichaelR.Jones lT 38236,39149 'RU 'Riley,J. V Affirmed. 'lW 'Rule11 'X ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Kerwin_Ԁ_Dowell_. Y  'lZ ' FloydCampbell  [ v. \ StateofTennessee  ~] M200000408SCR11PC '!d^ 'CannonCircuit  _ _J.S._ԀDaniel ` 9942 ' ~a 'Williams,J.  b Affirmed. 'c 'Rule11 ' d ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFloydCampbell.  e  'f ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   Brian_Roberson_ d  v. J State_ofTennessee_ 0 M200100459SCR11PC 'n 'WilliamsonCircuit d DonaldP.Harris J 500172 '0 'Williams,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBrian_Roberson_. d   'J  ' _Ricky_Ԁ_Garrett_   v. v StateofTennessee \ M200100312SCR11PC ' B 'DavidsonCriminal  SteveR.Dozier v 98A448 '\ 'Glenn,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Ricky_Ԁ_Garrett_.   'v ' RichardLynnNorton   v.   _Ricky_ԀBell,Warden   M200102516SCR11CO ' n  'DavidsonCriminal   SethNorman   3150 '  '_Tipton_,J.    Affirmed. ' ! 'Rule11 ' " ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRichardLynn  # Norton.  $  ' % ' AntonioL._Sweatt_ @ & v. & ' TennesseeDepartmentof  ( Correction ) M200102141SCR11CO '* 'DavidsonCriminal @ + CherylA.Blackburn & , 3131III ' - '_Woodall_,J. @ . Affirmed. '& / 'Rule11 '@ 0 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAntonioL. @ 1 _Sweatt_. & 2  ' 3 ' 'R4 ' 'R5 ' 'R6 ' 'R7 ' 'R8 ' Kevin_Stumpenhorst_ t9 v. Z: Jerry_Blurton_,Jr.,EtAl. @; W200002977SCR11CV '~&< 'MadisonCircuit t= RoyB.Morgan Z> C97305 '@? '_Highers_,J. t@ Reversed& ZA Remanded. '@B 'Rule11 'tC ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKevin tD _Stumpenhorst_. ZE  '@F ' _Natalya_Ԁ_Mazor_ G v. H Kenneth_Isaacman_,D.D.S. lI W200001485SCR11CV 'RJ 'ShelbyCircuit K Kay_Robilio_ L 3062085 'lM '_Lillard_,J. N Reversed. 'O 'Rule11 'P ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKenneth Q _Isaacman_,D.D.S. R  'lS ' _Marlena_Ԁ_Tilley_,EtAl. $T v.  U _Gurpal_ԀS._Bindra_,M.D. V W200101157SCR11CV ' ~W 'DyerCircuit $X LeeMoore  Y 99189 'Z '_Highers_,J. $[ Affirmed. ' \ 'Rule11 '$] ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Marlena_Ԁ_Tilley_ $^ andhusband,Fred_Tilley_.  _  '` ' JudyBurroughs,Individually,and d  assurvivingspouseandpersonal J representativeoftheEstateof 0 HaroldL.Burroughs,deceased n v. T RobertW._Magee_,M.D. : W200100238SCR11CV '  'LauderdaleCircuit d JosephH.Walker J  5005 '0  '_Lillard_,J. d  AffirmedinPart; J  ReversedinPartand 0  Remanded. 'n 'Rule11 'd ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofJudy d Burroughs. J  '0 ' RobertLewisDavidson,EtAl.  B v.  ( CharlesR.Lindsey,EtAl. f   W200002891SCR11CV 'L  'HenryCircuit  B JulianP._Guinn_  ( 1365 'f   '_Highers_,J.  B Reversed&  ( Remanded. 'f   'Rule11 ' B ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofCharlesR.  B Lindsey,etal.  (  'f   ' ' n ! ' ' n " ' ' n # ' ' n $ ' ' n % ' StateofTennessee @ & v. & ' _Shanta_Ԁ_Lavett_Ԁ_McKinney_  ( W200101832SCR11CD ') '_Tipton_ԀCircuit @ * JosephH.Walker & + 4122 ' , 'Welles,J. @ - Affirmed. '& . 'Rule11 '@ / ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Shanta_Ԁ_Lavett_ @ 0 _McKinney_. & 1  ' 2 ' StateofTennessee l3 v. R4 JoelKeithRussell 85 W200100587SCR11CD '6 '_Hardin_ԀCircuit l7 C.Creed_McGinley_ R8 7966 '89 'Ogle,J. l: Affirmed. 'R; 'Rule11 'l< ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJoelKeith l= Russell. R>  '8? ' StateofTennessee @@ v. ~&A _Montea_ԀWilson d B W200000748SCR11CD 'JC 'ShelbyCriminal @D ChrisCraft ~&E 9903924,25 'd F 'Wade,J. @G Affirmed. '~&H 'Rule11 '@I ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Montea_ԀWilson. @J  'd L ' StateofTennessee lM v. RN ErnestLee_Littles_ 8O W200101706SCR11CD 'vP '_Obion_ԀCircuit lQ WilliamB._Acree_,Jr. RR 0207 '8S 'Glenn,J. lT Affirmed& RU Remanded. '8V 'Rule11 'lW ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofErnestLee lX _Littles_. RY  '8Z ' StateofTennessee [ v.  ~\ TerryNorris !d] W200000707SCR11CD '"J ^ 'ShelbyCriminal _ JamesC._Beasley_,Jr.  ~` 9708293 '!da '_Wedemeyer_,J. b Affirmed. ' ~c 'Rule11 'd ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTerryNorris. e  ' ~f ' StateofTennessee d  v. J JessieNelsonHodges 0 W200100871SCR11CD 'n 'LauderdaleCircuit d JosephH.Walker,III J 6952 '0 '_Wedemeyer_,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJessieNelson d  Hodges. J   '0  ' StateofTennessee  v. v ChristopherFlake \ W200100568SCR11CD ' B 'ShelbyCriminal  Bernie_Weinman_ v 9709254,9709255 '\ 'Wade,J.  Reversed& v Remanded. '\ 'Rule11 ' ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofStateof  Tennessee. v  ' B ' StateofTennessee   v.   JamesSmith   W200002315SCR11CD ' n  'ShelbyCriminal  ! W.Otis_Higgs_,Jr.  " 0002772 ' # 'Wade,J.  $ Affirmed. ' % 'Rule11 ' & ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesSmith.  '  ' ) ' StateofTennessee @ * v. & + LarryBrooks  , W200102478SCR11CD '- '_Crockett_ԀCircuit @ . L.T._Lafferty_ & / 3216 ' 0 'Welles,J. @ 1 AffirmedinPart; & 2 ReversedinPart. ' 3 'Rule11 '@ 4 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLarryBrooks. @ 5  '& 6 ' StateofTennessee l7 v. R8 _Terrance_ԀBurke 89 W200101462SCR11CD ': 'ShelbyCriminal l; ChrisCraft R< 9807582 '8= '_Witt_,J. l> Affirmed. 'R? 'Rule11 'l@ ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Terrance_ԀBurke. lA  'RB ' Frederick_Beauregard_ @C v. ~&D StateofTennessee d E W200102546SCR11PC 'JF '_Hardeman_ԀCircuit @G JonKerryBlackwood ~&H 5990 'd I 'Hayes,J. @J Affirmed. '~&K 'Rule11 '@L ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFrederick @M _Beauregard_. ~&N  'd O ' 'lP ' 'lQ ' 'lR ' 'lS ' 'lT ' Randy_Arnwine_ >U v. $V UnionCountyBoardofEducation  W andDavidF._Cuppock_ X E200102719SCR11CV ' ~Y 'UnionChancery >Z BillyJ.White $[ 3884 ' \ 'Susano,J. >] Reversed& $^ Remanded. ' _ 'Rule11 '>` ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofRandy >a _Arnwine_. $b  ' c ' MagdaleneA.MillerandRobert d  Miller J v. 0 Mt.Laurel,EtAl. n E200100863SCR11CV 'T '_Sevier_ԀCounty d RichardA.Vance J 981124II '0 'Susano,J. d  Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMagdaleneA. d  andRobertMiller. J  __ '0 ' _Kaila_ԀB.WilliamsSanders, v IndividuallyandasNextofKinto \ CathyD.Williams,Deceased  B v.  ( TracieA._Traver_,M.D.,EtAl. f   E200102926SCR11CV 'L  '_Blount_ԀCircuit v WilliamD.Young \ L12401  B  ' ( 'Franks,J. v Reversed. '\ 'Rule11 'v ' Granted 󀄀Applicationof_Blount_ v MemorialHospital. \  ' B ' Jessie_Bullington_  n  v. T  GreeneCounty,EtAl. : ! E200101917SCR11CV 'x " 'GreeneChancery  n # ThomasR._Frierson_,II T $ 9800166 ': % 'Susano,J.  n & Reversed& T ' Remanded. ': ( 'Rule11 ' n ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGreeneCounty.  n *  'T + ' ', ' '- ' '. ' '/ ' '0 ' StateofTennessee l1 v. R2 CharlesLeonardGoldenand 83 DonaldHarmon 4 E200101506SCR11CD '5 'GreeneCriminal l6 JamesE._Beckner_ R7 00CR106 '88 'Wade,J. l9 Affirmed; R: Remandedfor 8; Considerationof < Alternative = Sentencing. '> 'Rule11 'l? ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharlesLeonard l@ Golden. RA  '8B ' StateofTennessee d C v. JD Teresa_Dockery_ 0E E200101493SCR11CD 'F '_Loudon_ԀCircuit d G E.Eugene_Eblen_ JH 10078 '0I 'Wade,J. d J Dismissed. 'JK 'Rule11 'd L ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTeresa_Dockery_. d M  'JN ' JohnPaulSeals 8O v. vP StateofTennessee \Q E200101756SCR11PC 'B R '_Hamblen_ԀCircuit 8S JamesE._Beckner_ vT 98CR001 '\U '_Tipton_,J. 8V Affirmed. 'vW 'Rule11 '8X ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnPaulSeals. 8Y  'vZ ' RoyLane d v. J  StateofTennessee 0 E200000310SCR11PC 'n '_Cocke_Ԁ_Circuit_ d BenHooper,II J 21,315 '0 '_Tipton_,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRoyLane. d  "J  - "X,