WPC NTg6fRH>=GbYiXgstƅ)ʀ(9cad4N`,z'jw>eh^i+h#ⅉ"ӘUXǹ7j ܒ("y{zFM]smČU锡Rtz9Z>RBF?֟7lBMdX>(w7E @#86]c9l Vk^> y\D~v`GH?(tgaP`nV">C+xQriwi:-aew)BYN(K:\vO=@J09* 8+w&T a8NEJ.mEB sr?\Fe.S7qL0garBRc"# UNM % 0( f a w 4  B NH ^ J V mX 0lo 0D f               B 0D  D- 04 A  0KHP LaserJet 4050 Series PCL 6,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE AWF]+d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd8gze+s U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5)!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3 Letter Landscape3'TXXXX  g @*SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS > @/ November5,20010 x   (#  %  '  0*  , $x81x81 @7 ,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,Fdd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATUREOF :  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' CarlE._Saine_  ( vs. f   StateofTennessee  L  W200002179SCR11PC '2  'ShelbyCriminal  ( JosephB.Brown,Jr. f   P21055 'L  'Williams,Hayes,  ( Riley,JJ. f   _Dismissed_ 'L  'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCarlE._Saine_. ' ( ' PhilipR.Workman T  vs. :  StateofTennessee x  W200101920SCR10_PD_ '^ 'ShelbyCriminal T  JohnP._Colton_,Jr. : ! B81209 'x " ' 'T # 'Rule10 'T $ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPhilipR. T % Workman ': & ' '' ' '( ' ') ' '* ' '+ ' _Brennco_ԀIncorporated R, vs. 8- CityofChattanoogaBetter . HousingCommission / E200001508SCR11CV '0 'HamiltonChancery R1 W.FrankBrown,III 82 990847 '3 'Franks,J. R4 Affirmed '85 'Rule11 'R6 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Brennco_,Inc. 'R7 ' BlancheBunch d 8 vs. J9 RobertSharp 0: E199902524SCR11CV '; 'ClaiborneCircuit d < Conrad_Troutman_ J= 7791 '0> 'Franks,J. d ? Affirmed 'J@ 'Rule11 'd A ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBlancheBunch 'd B ' _Kristin_ԀB.Huntley 8C vs. vD WilliamSidneyHuntley \E E200001718SCR11CV 'B F 'HamiltonCircuit 8G W.NeilThomas,III vH 94DR2179 '\I '_Swiney_,J. 8J Affirmed 'vK 'Rule11 '8L ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliamSidney 8M Huntley 'vN ' g  8vHXXdd8    _g CityofKnoxville,etal d vs. J RobertJ.Taylor,etal 0  E200002329SCR11CV 'n 'KnoxChancery d SharonJ.Bell J 1393333 '0 'Goddard,J. d Reversedinpart, J  affirmedinpartand 0  remanded 'n  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCityof d  Knoxville 'J ' JoanneLett  vs. v CollisFoods,Inc.,etal \ E200002776SCR11CV ' B 'KnoxCircuit  HaroldWimberly v 260098 '\ 'Susano,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJoanneLett;  recommendedthattheCourtofAppeals v opinionbepublished. '\ ' DanielEdLowe   vs.   FaytellaD.Lowe   E200001456SCR11CV ' n  'BradleyCircuit    LawrenceH.Puckett  ! V99300 ' " 'Susano,J.  # Affirmedand  $ remanded ' % 'Rule11 ' & ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDanielEdLowe ' ' ' PearlLynellPotts,etal @ ( vs. & ) MaryPottsMayforth,etal  * E200003116SCS10CV '+ 'CarterChancery @ , G.RichardJohnson & - 124432 ' . 'Franks,J. @ / Affirmed '& 0 'Rule11 '@ 1 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMaryMayforth @ 2 andGordonPotts '& 3 ' LarryRobbins l4 vs. R5 CityofJohnsonCity,Tennessee 86 E200002952SCR11CV '7 'WashingtonChancery l8 JeanA.Stanley R9 33154 '8: 'Susano,J. l; Reversedand R< remanded '8= 'Rule11 'l> ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLarryRobbins 'l? ' StateofTN,exrelCountyof @@ HamblenandCityofMorristown ~&A vs. d B KnoxvilleCollege JC E200002507SCR11CV '0D 'HamblenChancery @E ThomasR.Frierson,II ~&F 99227&99372 'd G 'Franks,J. @H Affirmed '~&I 'Rule11 '@J ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKnoxville @K College '~&L ' KarenStempa,etal RM vs. 8N WalgreenCo.d/b/aWalgreen vO DrugStores,etalandDonnie \P Dean,D.D.S.,etal B Q E200002223SCR11CV '(!R 'KnoxCircuit RS DaleC.Workman 8T 128198 'vU 'Swiney,J. RV Reversed '8W 'Rule11 'RX ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationsofWalgreenCo. RY andDonnieDean,D.D.S. '8Z ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   TNFarmersMutualIns.Co. d  vs. J &kk%XXRobertandElizabethWestmoreland#XvHX%&kk^$#  0  E200002693SCR11CV '\ 'RheaChancery d JeffreyF.Stewart J 9317 '0 'Swiney,J. d Affirmedand J  remanded '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertand d  ElizabethWestmoreland 'J  ' 3 '~ ' '~ ' '~ ' '~ ' '~ ' StateofTennessee  P  vs. 6  ShannaAlder   E200101425SCR11CD '  'KnoxCircuit P MaryBethLeibowitz 6  64064 '  'Witt,Tipton& P Wade,JJ. 6  Rule9Denied '  'Rule9 'P ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofShannaAlder 'P ' StateofTennessee | $  vs. b  JackieF.Curry H ! E200002475SCR11CD '. " 'KnoxCriminal | $ # RayJenkins b $ 64212 'H % 'Woodall,J. | $ & Affirmed 'b ' 'Rule11 '| $ ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJackieCurry '| $ ) ' StateofTennessee P* vs. 6+ DonnieWayneFoulks t, E199700310SCR11CD 'Z- 'GreeneCircuit P. JamesBeckner 6/ 96CR085 't0 'Tipton,J. P1 Affirmed '62 'Rule11 'P3 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonnieWayne P4 Foulks '65 ' StateofTennessee |6 vs. b7 ThomasGagne,Jr. H8 E200003073SCR11PC '.9 'KnoxCriminal |: RayJenkins b; 67654 'H< 'Witt,J. |= Affirmed 'b> 'Rule11 '|? ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofThomasGagne, |@ Jr. 'bA ' StateofTennessee B vs. C DennisJacks tD E200000643SCR11CD 'ZE 'AndersonCircuit F JamesB.Scott G 96CR0017 'tH 'Tipton,J. I Affirmedand J remanded 'tK 'Rule11 'L ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDennisJacks 'M ' StateofTennessee ,N vs. O WilliamMakransky P E200000048SCR11CD 'Q 'BradleyCriminal ,R CarrollL.Ross S 98479 'T 'Tipton,J. ,U Affirmedinpartand V modifiedinpart 'W 'Rule11 ',X ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliam ,Y Makransky 'Z ' StateofTennessee d vs. J  MichaelA.Miller 0 E200000930SCR11CD 'n 'CumberlandCriminal d LillieAnnSells J 5417 '0 'Glenn,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichaelA. d  Miller 'J  ' StateofTennessee   vs. v JamesWesleyOsborne \ E199901071SCR11CD ' B 'JeffersonCircuit  O.DuaneSlonei v 3792 '\ 'Wedemeyer,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesWesley  Osborne 'v ' StateofTennessee   vs.   MitchellPresnell   E200101318SCS09CD ' n  'CockeCircuit   RexOgle   6413 '  'Witt,Wade&    Tipton  ! Rule9Denied ' " 'Rule9 ' # ' Dismissed 󀄀ApplicationofMitchell  $ Presnell ' % ' StateofTennessee @ & vs. & ' OnealSanford  ( E199902089SCR11CD ') 'BradleyCriminal @ * CarrollL.Ross & + 98280 ' , 'Ogle,J. @ - Affirmedand & . remanded ' / 'Rule11 '@ 0 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofOnealSanford '@ 1 ' StephenLeonWilliams l2 vs. R3 StateofTennessee 84 E200000935SCR11PC '5 'HawkinsCircuit l6 JamesE.Beckner R7 5314 '88 'Witt,Wade&Ogle l9 Rule28denied 'R: 'Rule11 'l; ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStephenLeon l< Williams"R=  "X,$