WPC& I|qczB"Xc"2 _^smO7/f̋j]1w77?FSwk/*=A0Y~{!2J2{`J!qaehICE=z mejq5N<Suq!e6kbMy:kG{ l[Ihy1ο9?2pj|v?4XK=ڞu ĎQ?+{a.Ǹɐ)V><>0>igd6ʯOjU"T"U! `t=Zj:I> (_17  2( 4 <DL223  Ԁ2( 4 <DL2  *DD (_16   ," <DL,23  Ԁ," <DL,   *55 (_15  ) <DL)23  Ԁ) <DL)  *22 (_14 ` &<<DL&23  Ԁ&<<DL& ` *// (_13  #DL#23  Ԁ#DL#  *,, (_12   DL 23  Ԁ DL  *)) (_11 h DDL23  ԀDDL h  d*&& (_10  L23  ԀL  (## &_9   L23  Ԁ L  (>> &_8  2( 4 <DL223  2( 4 <DL2  (DD &_7   ," <DL,23  ," <DL,   (55 &_6  ) <DL)23  ) <DL)  (22 &_5 ` &<<DL&23  &<<DL& ` (// &_4  #DL#23  #DL#  (,, &_3   DL 23   DL  ()) &_2 h DDL23  DDL h (&& &_1  L23  L  &## $_   L23   L  3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)1i)(O$(;3$2#  0  .3  0   D   8zPXXdXXd8%%%%)!dxdx(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5ab\c[E<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1  )!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRO'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter Landscape3'LetterTXXX, 8gdXXdd8760  081810` 8181@*` 81` 81SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE , @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS  @22+ Monday,November8,2004  (#     Ӏ   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd , dd ,dd ,edd , dd +  $ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER '$" 'COUNTY $ TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE $  JUDGE   JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE $ OF  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION '$" 'Vanessa_Baston_Ԁv.StateofTennessee  V  E200302471SCR11PC 'p D  'MorganCircuit  V  E.Eugene_Eblen_ p D  8773B '^ 2  'Riley,J  V  Affirmed 'p D  'Rule11 ' V  ' Denied ApplicationofVanessa_Baston_ ' V  'CityofChattanoogav.Cinema1,Inc   andDavidFranklin   E200301038SCR11CV ' 'HamiltonChancery   HowellN.Peoples   021229 '  '_Swiney_,J  ! Affirmed ' " 'Rule11 ' # ' Denied ApplicationofCinema1,Inc.  $ AndDavidFranklin  %  '& 'IntheMatterof:_C.T.S._ >' W200301679SCR11PT ',( '_Tipton_ԀJuvenile >) WilliamA.Peeler ,* J10677 '+ 'Farmer,J >, Affirmedand ,- Remanded '. 'Rule11 '>/ ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_W.N.S._ >0  ',1 'Patricia_Archard_ԀDell,_Administratix_Ԁv. p2 _Cecelia_ԀPayneWright ^3 W200300461SCR11CV 'xL4 'ShelbyCircuit p5 KarenWilliams ^6 713123 'xL7 '_Highers_,J p8 Affirmed '^9 'Rule11 'p: ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPatricia_Archard_ p; Dell '^< '_Joann_Ԁ_Mallinak_Ԁ_Glassell_Ԁv.RichardLee = _Glassell_ > E200301602SCR11CV '? 'KnoxChancery @ SharonJ.Bell A 1503973 'B '_Swiney_,J C Affirmedas D Modified& E Remanded 'F 'Rule11 'G ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesM._Crain_Ԁ 'H 'GreatRiverInsuranceCo.V.Edison FI Automation,Inc. 4J M200101635SCR11CV '"K 'DavidsonChancery FL EllenH.Lyle 4M 001638III '"N '_Corlew_,J FO Affirmed '4P 'Rule11 'FQ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEdison FR Automation,Inc. '4S 'StevenGriffinv.StateofTennessee xT M200300557SCR11PC ' fU 'DavidsonCriminal xV SteveDozier  fW 93C1154 '!T X '_Witt_,J xY Affirmed ' fZ 'Rule11 'x[ ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofStevenGriffin 'x\ '76 7 ,8gdXXdXXd8 7  ThomasEugene_Hargis_Ԁv.Stateof qd  Tennessee _R E200302682SCR11_HC_ 'M@ '_Bledsoe_ԀCircuit qd BuddyPerry _R 322003 'M@ '_Witt_,J qd Affirmed _R Rule20 'M@  'Rule11 'qd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofThomasEugene qd  Harris '_R  'Inre:EstateofHarrySanders,Deceased,   RosalynVine,Executrix  M200300280SCR11CV ' 'BedfordChancery  _J.B._ԀCox  24,032 ' 'Cottrell,J  Affirmedand  Remanded ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofInre:Estatefo  HarrySanders,Deceased,RosalynVine,  Executrix ' 'Inre:_T.H._Ԁand_J.H._ -  M200302265SCR11PT '  'CannonCircuit -  RoyceTaylor   220 '  'Clement,J -  Affirmedand    Remanded ' ! 'Rule11 '- " ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_S.H._Ԁ '- # 'IntheMatterof:M.E.,M.E.,_R.B._,_M.B._  ~ $ andS.B.,v.Dawn_Brogden_Ԁ&Lewis y l % _Brogden_ gZ & M200300859SCR11PT 'UH ' 'DavidsonJuvenile  ~ ( BettyK.Adams y l ) 961930417,961930418, gZ * 961930419 'UH + 'Clement,J  ~ , Reversed 'y l - 'Rule11 ' ~ . ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationoftheStateof  ~ / Tennessee 'y l 0 'IntheMatterof:_J.W.P._ 1 M200302859SCR11PT '2 'DavidsonJuvenile 3 BettyK.Adams 4 221962772 '5 'Lee,J '6 'Rule11 '7 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTennessee 8 DepartmentofChildrensServices '9 'DeborahKinter&CamelotRealty,Inc. 5(: V.MemphisAreaAssociationof #; Realtors,Inc.,etal < W200401010SCR9CV '= 'ShelbyChancery 5(> Unknown #? CH0111501 '@ 'Farmer,J& 5(A Highers,J #B Rule9Denied 'C 'Rule9 '5(D ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMemphisArea 5(E AssociationofRealtors,Inc.,et_al_ '#F 'AaronMcFarlandv.StateofTennessee tG W200301797SCR11PC 'obH 'ShelbyCriminal tI JamesC.Beasley,Jr. obJ P26220 ']PK 'Ogle,J tL Affirmed 'obM 'Rule11 'tN ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAaron tO McFarland 'obP 'MatthewL.Moatesv.StateofTennessee Q E200301926SCR11PC 'R 'MonroeCriminal S CarrollL.Ross T 98251 'U 'Tipton,J V Affirmed 'W 'Rule11 'X ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMatthewL. Y Moates 'Z ' TRO'3 Letter LandscapeO'3 Letter Landscape'3Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeT   _OverniteTransportationCompanyv. qd TeamstersLocalUnionNo.480,etal. _R M200202116SCR11CV 'M@ 'DavidsonChancery qd EllenH.Lyle _R 993105III 'M@ 'Kirby,J qd Affirmedin _R Part& M@  Reversedin ;.   Partand )  Remanded '   'Rule11 'qd  ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofTeamsters qd LocalUnion480,andBillyD.Cullen, _R EddieMims,KennieGeorge,andIsom M@ Folso ';. ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 'BryanPearsonv.StateofTennessee   E200302597SCR11CD '  'KnoxCriminal   MaryBethLeibowitz   77694,38234 '  'Wade,J   Affirmed   Rule20 '  'Rule11 '  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBryanPearson '   'R.D.T.,etal.v.F.A.J.InRE:E.D.J. y l ! E200301835SCR11PT 'gZ " 'GreeneCircuit y l # ThomasR.Frierson,II gZ $ 20010291 UH %  'C6& 'Swiney,J y l ' Affirmed& gZ ( Remanded 'UH ) 'Rule11 'y l * ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofF.A.J. 'y l + 'JerryLouRogersv.DavidStanleyDavis , andVenitaDavis - E200301240ScR11CV '. 'PolkChancery / JerriS.Bryant 0 6921 '1 'Franks,J 2 Reversedin 3 Part;Modified 4 inPartand 5 Remanded '}p6 'Rule11 '7 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJerryLou 8 Rogers '9 'EdwinEarlSanbornv.CarlottaJoan : Sanborn ; M200300418ScR11CV '< 'DavidsonCircuit = MariettaM.Shipley > 00D1616 '? 'Clement,J @ Affirmed 'A 'Rule11 'B ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEdwinEarl C Sanborn 'D 'JohnEarlScalesv.StateofTennessee ]PE M200301753SCR11PC 'K>F 'DavidsonCriminal ]PG SteveR.Dozier K>H 96A339 '9,I 'Riley,J ]PJ Affirmed 'K>K 'Rule11 ']PL ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnEarlScales ']PM 'DonnaJeanSextonv.StateofTennessee N E2002023130SCR11PC 'O 'CarterCircuit P LynnW.Brown Q S12429 'R 'Tipton,J S Affirmed 'T 'Rule11 'U ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonnaJean V Sexton 'W 'BrendaJ.Sneedv.ThomasG.Stovall, ! X M.D.,etal "Y W200301222SCR11CV '" Z 'ShelbyCircuit ! [ KarenWilliams "\ 57955 '" ] 'Farmer,J ! ^ Reversedand "_ Remanded '" ` 'Rule11 '! a ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBrendaJ.Sneed '! b 'StateofTennesseev.RandyAnderson qd  W200301472SCR11CD '_R 'HenryCircuit qd JulianP.Guinn _R 13191 'M@ 'Ogle,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRandyAnderson 'qd  'StateofTennesseev.RonaldDotson   W200300259SCR11CD '  'ShelbyCriminal   JosephB.Dailey   991226465 ' 'Hayes,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRonaldDotson ' 'StateofTennesseev.CornellM.Hyder -  M200300833SCR11CD '  'TrousdaleCriminal -  J.O.Bond   0183ABCD '  'Smith,J -  Affirmed '  'Rule11 '-  ' Denied ApplicationofCornellM. -  Hyder   **TheopinionoftheCourtofCriminal   Appealsisdesignated NotforCitation   inaccordancewithSupremeCourtRule   4,F. '  'StateofTennesseev.JoyKennedy UH ! M200301745SCR11CD 'C6" 'FranklinCircuit UH # ThomasW.Graham C6$ 14176 '1$% 'Welles,J UH & Affirmed 'C6' 'Rule11 'UH ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStateof UH ) Tennessee 'C6* 'StateofTennesseev.RandallMills + M200301770SCR11PC ', 'MarshallCircuit - CharlesLee . 14007/PC#15471 '/ 'Wade,J 0 Affirmed '1 'Rule11 '2 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRandallMills '3 'StateofTennesseev.LatishaLee 4 Morgan 5 W200302174SCR11CD '6 'LauderdaleCircuit 7 JosephH.Walker,III 8 7412 '9 'Welles,J : Affirmed '; 'Rule11 '< ' Denied ApplicationofLatishaLee = Morgan >  '? 'StateofTennesseev.RaymondDouglas ob@ Myers,Sr. ]PA M200301099SCR11CD 'K>B 'PutnamCircuit obC JohnTurnbull ]PD 010401A 'K>E 'Welles,J obF Affirmed ']PG 'Rule11 'obH ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRaymond obI DouglasMyers,Sr. ']PJ 'StateofTennesseev.StevenAllen K Meyer L M200302297SCR11CD 'M 'MontgomeryCircuit N MichaelR.Jones O 40970 'P 'Glenn,J Q Affirmed 'R 'Rule11 'S ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStevenAllen T Meyer 'U 'StateofTennesseev.FredAllenOwens + V E200302003SCR11CD '! W 'KnoxCriminal + X RichardBaumgartner ! Y 73949 '"Z 'Welles,J + [ Affirmed '! \ 'Rule11 '+ ] ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFredAllen + ^ Owens '! _ 'StateofTennesseev.EricPendleton qd  M200301762SCR11CD '_R 'DavidsonCriminal qd J.RandallWyatt,Jr. _R 87S777 'M@ 'Williams,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEricPendleton 'qd  'StateofTennesseev.DarrellSanderlin   W200301546SCR11CD '  'HaywoodCircuit   ClayburnL.Peeples   4900B ' 'Hayes,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDarrell  Sanderlin ' ' '-  ' '-  ' '-  ' '-  ' '-  'StateofTennesseev.ReginaldStacy   Sudderth   E200300333SCS09CD ' ~  'KnoxCriminal   JamesL.Weatherford   74386 ' ~  'Glenn,J   Affirmedand   Remanded ' ~ ! 'Rule11 ' " ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofReginaldStacy  # Sudderth ' $ 'LatroyWilliamsv.AbleTowing   % Services  & W200301023SCR11CV ' ' 'ShelbyCircuit   ( JohnR.McCarroll,Jr.  ) 00259600 ' * 'Farmer,J   + Highers,J  , Order  - Dismissing '. 'Rule11 '  / ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLatroyWilliams"  0 & "X,