WPC& RgK]HɎ:)?-X-PaK]Hէ!A qdph #G UwCjJUd!VP{I9̨lfb]FK}Vk%łZv 1W W"aȆµNãێb_p26tZ.{( VNT6Ҋz+euvK)Ԏ?'in- d98cc꺡[w2;z{2&vik]\B} 4)wq8Scx0G(BzZִZe )fZmBaզv+PawJt¶w֪"a>ꯆwK*d7b'AIےz䯸irUNj#L<`&k (Gp]hj*1<<::Iw(랮*gCDZO׸d# U NU % 0( f a b w 4   N( ^ * 6 m8 0lO 0D  0D 0UK 0 0} 0< 0r 0 0 0n 0 0 0i 04 0 0 0) 0 BY 0v 0 0 0H 0 0 0^ 0 0 0& 0 1u6 72 0N 0c+!+!+!N!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! D5! 0D""U"U" AS#n# 0D4$ 0Dx$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$ D-$$$$$$$$$$$$ 04$$$$ A% 0K%\\ib01s01\clerk1nas,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE APage of &0d 3|xdo1 U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   (3$ !  *+ (_2623  ..*D+D (_25   ," <DL,23  ..," <DL,   *5+5 (_24  ) <DL)23  ..) <DL)  *2+2 (_23 ` &<<DL&23  ..&<<DL& ` */+/ (_22  #DL#23  ..#DL#   h  \R'3 Letter Landscape\*,+, (_21   DL 23  .. DL  *)+) (_20 h DDL23  ..DDL h *&+& (_19  L23  ..L  *#+# (_18   L23  .. L  *>> (_17  2( 4 <DL223  Ԁ2( 4 <DL2  *DD (_16   ," <DL,23  Ԁ," <DL,   *55 (_15  ) <DL)23  Ԁ) <DL)  *22 (_14 ` &<<DL&23  Ԁ&<<DL& ` *// (_13  #DL#23  Ԁ#DL#  *,, (_12   DL 23  Ԁ DL  *)) (_11 h DDL23  ԀDDL h  d*&& (_10  L23  ԀL  (## &_9   L23  Ԁ L  (>> &_8  2( 4 <DL223  2( 4 <DL2  (DD &_7   ," <DL,23  ," <DL,   (55 &_6  ) <DL)23  ) <DL)  (22 &_5 ` &<<DL&23  &<<DL& ` (// &_4  #DL#23  #DL#  (,, &_3   DL 23   DL  ()) &_2 h DDL23  DDL h (&& &_1  L23  L  &## $_   L23   L  3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)1i)(O$(;3$2#  0  .3  0   D   8zPXXdXXd8%%%%)!dxdx(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5ab\c[E<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1  )!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRO'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter Landscape3'LetterTXXX, 8zXXdd8760  081810` 8181@*` 81` 81SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE , @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS  @+ Monday,November15,2004  (#     Ӏ   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd , dd ,dd ,edd , dd +  $ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER '$" 'COUNTY $ TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE $  JUDGE   JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE $ OF  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION '$" ' ' V  'Ѐ .XXNASHVILLE #XzX.Ѹ# ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  ' '>   ' '>   ' '>   ' '>   ' '>   'BoardofProfessionalResponsibilityof   theSupremeCourtofTennesseev.H.   Owen_Maddux_ p M200301136SCR3BP '^ 'HamiltonChancery   William_Dender_  ! 021061 'p" ' ' # ' ' $ ' Denied 󀄀PetitionforRehearingofThe  % BoardofProfessional_Resposibility_ ' & 'FrankChesterBrightv.Stateof  ' Tennessee ( M200300239SCR11PC ') 'DavidsonCriminal  * J.RandallWyatt,Jr. + 97A597 ', '_Wedemeyer_,J  - Affirmed '. 'Rule11 ' / ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFrankChester  0 Bright '1 'MariaL.Caldwellv. j>2 Bridgestone/Firestone,Inc.,etal. X,3 M200101067SCR11CV 'F4 'CannonChancery j>5 Robert_Corlew_,III X,6 9851 'F7 '_Hagler_,J j>8 Affirmedand X,9 Remanded 'F: 'Rule11 'j>; ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMariaL. j>< Caldwell 'X,= 'MikeCampbellv.ChubbGroupof > InsuranceCompanies,a/k/aChubb ? IndemnityVigilantInsuranceCompany, x@ _Servpro_ fA M200301623SCR11CV 'TB 'DavidsonCircuit D ThomasW.Brothers xE 02C3005 'fF 'Koch,Cain, G Cottrell H DeniedMotion xI toreinstate fJ appeal 'TK 'Rule11 'L ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMike_Campbell_ 'M '_JamesEdward_Dicken_Ԁv.Stateof N Tennessee O M200301455SCR11PC 'P 'SumnerCriminal Q JaneW._Wheatcraft_ R 3412002 'S 'Wade,J T Affirmed 'U 'Rule11 'V ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesEdward W _Dicken_ 'X '76 7 ,8zXXdXXd8 7  RobertL.Drewv.StateofTennessee qd M200300593SCR11PC '_R 'DavidsonCriminal qd SteveDozier _R  95D2559 'M@ 'Wade,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertL.Drew 'qd  'FirstNationalofNorthAmerica,LLCv.   MichaelMarks   M200203104SCR11CV '  'DavidsonChancery   IrvinH._Kilcrease_,Jr.  01778I ' 'Clement,J  Affirmedand  Remanded ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichaelMarks ' 'CharlesWilliamJonesv.Stateof -  Tennessee   M200301851SCR11PC '  'DavidsonCriminal -  SteveR.Dozier   99D2321 '  'Riley,J -  Affirmed '  'Rule11 '-  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharlesWilliam -  Jones '  'JohnnyMcGowan,Jr.v.Stateof  ~  Tennessee y l ! M200300268SCR11CO 'gZ " 'DavidsonCircuit  ~ # ThomasW.Brothers y l $ 00C3729 'gZ % 'Williams,J  ~ & Reversedand y l ' Remanded 'gZ ( 'Rule11 ' ~ ) ' Denied ApplicationoftheStateof  ~ * Tennessee 'y l + 'NissanNorthAmerica,Inc.,Successor  , byMergertoNissanMotor - ManufacturingCompanyv.LindaJ. . _Haislip_,MarshallCountyAssessorof / Property,etal. 0 M200300813SCR11CV '1 'DavidsonChancery  2 EllenH.Lyle 3 021614III '4 'Farmer,J  5 Reversedand 6 Remanded '7 'Rule11 ' 8 ' Denied ApplicationofNissanNorth  9 America,Inc. ': '_Mandrall_ԀPorterv.StateofTennessee ; M2003025250SCR11_HC_ '< 'WayneCircuit = RobertHolloway > 13153 '? '_Wedemeyer_,J @ Affirmed 'A 'Rule11 'B ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Mandrall_ԀPorter 'C '_Skyla_Ԁ_Sepeda_ԀSmithv.Stateof obD Tennessee ]PE M200301872SCR11_HC_ 'K>F 'DavidsonCriminal obG J.RandallWyatt ]PH 3377 'K>I 'Smith,J obJ Affirmed ']PK 'Rule11 'obL ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Skyla_Ԁ_Sepeda_ obM Smith ']PN 'StateofTennesseev.Jonathan O Abernathy,Jr. P M200301452SCR11CD 'Q 'GilesCircuit R JimT.Hamilton S 10552 'T 'Welles,J U Affirmed 'V 'Rule11 'W ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJonathan X Abernathy,Jr. 'Y 'StateofTennesseev.EricT.Armstrong + Z M200300762SCR11CD '! [ 'WilliamsonCircuit + \ DonaldP.Harris ! ] 1901265 '"^ 'Ogle,J + _ Affirmed '! ` 'Rule11 '+ a ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEricT. + b Armstrong '! c ' TRO'3 Letter LandscapeO'3 Letter Landscape'3Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeT   _StateofTennesseev.JamesRayBartlett qd  M200201868SCR11CD '_R 'LincolnCircuit qd WilliamCharlesLee _R 28390,28490,28690 'M@ 'Wade,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesRay qd  Bartlett '_R  'StateofTennesseev.BenThomas   Dowlen   M200300508SCR11CD '  'MontgomeryCircuit  JohnH.Gasaway  40000231 ' 'Witt,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofBenThomas  Dowlen ' 'StateofTennesseev.TerryAnn -  Hawkins   M200201819SCR11CD '  'WilsonCircuit -  JohnD.Wootten,Jr.   001387    '  'Hayes,J -  Dismissed '  'Rule11 '-  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTerryAnn -   Hawkins ' ! 'StateofTennesseev.RandyJames y l " M200301599SCR11CD 'gZ # 'HumphreysCircuit y l $ AllenW.Wallace gZ % 10251 'UH & 'Welles,J y l ' Affirmed 'gZ ( 'Rule11 'y l ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRandyJames 'y l * 'StateofTennesseev.JefferyLeeMason + M200201709SCR11CD ', 'GilesCircuit - StellaHargrove . 10123 '/ 'Wade,J 0 Affirmed '1 'Rule11 '2 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJefferyLee 3 Mason '4 'StateofTennesseev.CarterMasters 5(5 M200300305SCR11CD '#6 'OvertonCriminal 5(7 LeonBurns,Jr. #8 5,000 '9 'Wade,J 5(: Affirmed '#; 'Rule11 '5(< ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCarterMasters '5(= 'StateofTennesseev.FrederickD. > Morrow t? M199801045SCDATCD 'ob@ 'RobertsonCircuit A RobertWedemeyer tB 3621 'obC 'Smith,J D Affirmed 'tE 'Rule11 'F ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFrederickD. G Morrow 'tH 'StateofTennesseev.AlonzoMaurice I Rogan J M20021603SCR11CD 'K 'SumnerCriminal L JaneWheatcraft M CR2301999 'N 'Williams,J O Affirmed 'P 'Rule11 'Q ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAlonzoMaurice R Rogan 'S 'StateofTennesseev.JamesDennis OBT Rowland =0U M200300878SCR11CD '+ V 'RutherfordCircuit OBW JamesK.Clayton,Jr. =0X M53098 '+ Y 'Hayes,J OBZ Dismissed '=0[ 'Rule11 'OB\ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesDennis OB] Rowland '=0^ 'KarenThomasv.RobertD.Mayfield, qd M.D.,etal. _R  M200002533SCR11CV 'M@ 'MontgomeryCircuit qd JamesE.Walton _R C13175 'M@ 'Cain,J qd Affirmedas _R Modified 'M@  'Rule11 'qd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKarenThomas 'qd  ' '  ' '  ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 'QD '.XXz 򀀀JACKSON 'QD ' 'QD ' 'QD ' 'QD 'XzX. '  ' '  ' '  ' '  ' '  'C.VinsonAlexander,Jr.,M.D.v.   JacksonRadiologyAssociates,P.A.,et } p  al. k ^  W200202702SCR11CV 'Y L  'MadisonCircuit   C01101 } p  C.ReedMcGinley 'k ^ ! 'Farmer,J  " Affirmedand } p # Remanded 'k ^ $ 'Rule11 ' % ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofC.Vinson  & Alexander,Jr.,M.D. '} p ' 'SamuelHumphreysv.RichardSelvey  ( W200202788SCR11CV ' ) 'ShelbyCircuit  * GeorgeH.Brown  + CT000891 ', 'Crawford,J  - Reversedand  . Remanded '/ 'Rule11 ' 0 ' Denied ApplicationofRichardSelvey ' 1 'BeverleyMiller,etal.V.United 9,2 Automax '3 W200301394SCR11CV '4 'ShelbyCircuit 9,5 RobertA.Lanier '6 3066197 '7 'Crawford,J 9,8 Affirmed ''9 'Rule11 '9,: ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofBeverley 9,; MillerandCassandraMeyer ''< 'MackA.OBanerv.StateofTennessee = W200301945SCR11PC 'x> 'ShelbyCriminal ? ArthurT.Bennett x@ P27087 'sfA 'Smith,J B Affirmed 'xC 'Rule11 'D ' Denied ApplicationofMackA. E OBaner 'xF 'JeanneL.Schuettv.EgonHorstSchuett, G Jr. H W200300337SCR11CV 'I 'ShelbyCircuit J RitaStotts K CT001433002 'L 'Highers,J M Affirmedin N Part,Reversed O inPart, P Remanded 'Q 'Rule11 'R ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJeanneL. S Schuett 'T 'RonnieSimpsonv.StateofTennessee /"U W200302400SCR11PC 'V 'ShelbyCriminal /"W JosephB.Dailey X P24994 ' Y 'Hayes,J. /"Z Affirmed '[ 'Rule11 '/"\ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRonnieSimpson '/"] 'StateofTennesseev.KewanJackson !^ W200301917SCR11CD '{"n _ 'ShelbyCriminal !` J.C.Mclin {"n a 0207016 'i#\!b 'Ogle,J !c Affirmed '{"n d 'Rule11 '!e ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKewanJackson '!f 'StateofTennesseev.DonaldKeel qd  W200300638SCR11CD '_R 'Gibson qd ClayburnPeeples _R 16089 'M@ 'Hayes,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd ' Denied ApplicationofDonaldKeel 'qd  'StateofTennesseev.BarryRayLong   W200301198SCR11CD '  'WeakleyCircuit   WilliamB.Acree,Jr.   CR202003   ' 'Smith,J  Dismissed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBarryRayLong ' 'StateofTennesseev.BenMills   W199901175SCR11CD '  'ShelbyCriminal   JohnP.Colton   9506195,9506196,   9506198,95061200 '  'Wade,J   Affirmedas   Modifiedand   Remanded '  'Rule11 '  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBenMills '  'StateofTennesseev.BillyGeneRich gZ  W200301495SCR11CD 'UH ! 'ChesterCircuit gZ " RogerA.Page UH # 02180 C6$  '1$% 'Hayes,J gZ & Affirmed 'UH ' 'Rule11 'gZ ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBillyGeneRich 'gZ ) 'LottieFayeTaylor,etal.V.JohnnyC. * Carlin,etal. + W200300640SCR11CV ', 'McNairyChancery - DeweyC.Whitenton . 7563 '/ 'Highers,J 0 Affirmed '1 'Rule11 '2 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnnyC. 3 CarlinandJoyceB.Carlin '4 ' '5 ' '6 ' '7 ' '8 ' '9 '.XXzCORRECTEDFROM11/08/04 ': 'WESTERNLIST: '; '#XzX.W#W '< ' '= ' '> 'BrendaJ.Sneedv.ThomasG.Stovall, OB? M.D. =0@ W200300779SCR11CV '+A 'ShelbyCircuit OBB KarenWilliams =0C 57955 '+D 'Farmer,J OBE Affirmedand =0F Remanded '+G 'Rule11 'OBH ' Denied ApplicationofBrendaJ.Sneed 'OBI ' 'J ' 'K ' 'L ' 'M ' 'N ' '/"O ' '/"P ' '/"Q ' '/"R ' '/"S ' 'T ' 'U ' 'V ' 'W ' 'X ' '3!&Y ' '3!&Z ' '3!&[ ' '3!&\ ' '3!&] ' '" ^ ' '" _ ' '" ` ' '" a ' '" b ' 'qd 'Ѐ .XXzKNOXVILLE #XzX._# 'qd ' 'qd ' 'qd ' 'qd ' '-  ' '-  ' '-  ' '-   ' 1(#331 '-   'YasmondFendersonv.Stateof   Tennessee   E200302995ScR11PC '~  'KnoxCriminal  RichardBaumgartner  77793 '~ 'Williams,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofYasmond  Fenderson ' 'AnnaFayeFloyd,etal.V.JohnnyTesar,   etal.   E200400025SCR11CV '  'SevierChancery   TelfordE.Forgerty,Jr.   01265 '  'Swiney,J   Affirmedand   Remanded '  'Rule11 '  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnnyTesar '   'StaceyG.Hillv.DonnaElizabeth k ^ ! FrazierHill Y L " E200302173SCR11CV 'G: # 'HamiltonCircuit k ^ $ 99D2412 Y L % W.NeilThomas,III 'G: & 'Susano,J k ^ ' Vacatedin Y L ( Part;Affirmed G: ) inPartand 5( * Remanded '#+ 'Rule11 k ^ , Barker,J., Y L - not G: . participat 5( / ing '#0 ' '#XJ.D/XX'Denied ApplicationofDonnaElizabeth k ^ 1 FrazierHill 'Y L 2 'RandyD.Hurleyv.HowardCarlton, 3 Warden 4 E200400381SCR11HC 't5 'JohnsonCriminal 6 LynnW.Brown 7 4303 't8 'Williams,J 9 Affirmed ': 'Rule11 '; ' Denied ApplicationofRandyD. < Hurley '= 'ArthurMcRae,etal.v.KnoxCounty,et > al. ? E200301990SCR11CV '@ 'KnoxCircuit A DaleWorkman B 170800 'C 'Inman,J D Affirmed 'E 'Rule11 'F ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofOutdoor G Displays,Inc. 'H 'StevenOtisNicelyv.StateofTennessee aTI E200302113SCR11PC 'OBJ 'KnoxCriminal aTK RichardBaumgartner OBL 70791 '=0M 'Tipton,J aTN Affirmed 'OBO 'Rule11 'aTP ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStevenOtis aTQ Nicely 'OBR 'HarryNimmonsv.StateofTennessee S E200302513SCR11PC 'T 'KnoxCriminal U RichardBaumgartner V 77656,78103 'W 'Tipton,J X Affirmed 'Y 'Rule11 'Z ' Denied ApplicationofHarryM. [ Nimmons '\ 'RichardLynnNortonv.Stateof ] Tennessee  ^ E200202145SCR11CO  _ E200300857SCR11PC !` E200301114SCR11PC '" a 'GreeneCircuit b JamesBeckner  c 02CR040 ' d 'Tipton,Witt& e Ogle  f Dismissed ' g 'Rule11 'h ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRichardLynn i Norton ' j 'KevinShoughrue,etal.v.St.Marys qd  MedicalCenter,Inc.,etal. '_R 'KnoxCircuit qd HaroldWimberly _R 240897 'M@ 'Swiney,J qd Affirmed& _R Remanded 'M@ 'Rule11 'qd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJ.D.Leeandthe qd  TheLawFirmofLee,Lee&Lee '_R  'StateofTennesseev.JamesAllenBates   E200301475SCR11CD '  'SullivanCriminal  PhyllisH.Miller  S45667 ' 'Welles,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesAllen  Bates ' 'StateofTennesseev.AnthonyLebron -  Carter   E200302172SCR11CD '  'HamiltonCriminal -  RebeccaStern   237672&239201 '  'Welles,J -  Affirmed '  'Rule11 '-  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAnthonyLebron -  Carter '   'StateofTennesseev.MarioHernandez  ~ ! Castillo y l " E200301250SCR11CD 'gZ # 'GraingerCircuit  ~ $ O.DuaneSlone y l % 3621 'gZ & 'Riley,J  ~ ' Affirmedand y l ( Modified 'gZ ) 'Rule11 ' ~ * ' Denied ApplicationofMario  ~ + HernandezCastillo 'y l , 'StateofTennesseev.BobbyJoeGentry  - E200301069SCR11CD '. 'KnoxCriminal  / 72766 0 RichardR.Baumgartner '1 'Wedemeyer,J  2 Affirmed '3 'Rule11 ' 4 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBobbyJoe  5 Gentry '6 'StateofTennesseev.BillyDavidGrubb G:7 E20032189SCR11PC '5(8 'KnoxCriminal G:9 RayL.Jenkins 5(: 75249 '#; 'Glenn, G:< Affirmed '5(= 'Rule11 'G:> ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBillyDavid G:? Grubb '5(@ 'StateofTennesseev.BrianKeith A Jackson B E200300606SCR11CD 'tC 'HamiltonCriminal D RebeccaStern E 238096 'tF 'Welles,J G Affirmed 'H 'Rule11 'I ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBrianKeith J Jackson 'K 'StateofTennesseev.RobertWayne L Marler M E200302179SCR11CD 'N 'SullivanCriminal O LynnW.Brown P S46,143 'Q 'Williams,J R Affirmed 'S 'Rule11 'T ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertW. U Marler 'V 'StateofTennesseev.LatoshaS.Martin, aTW aliasLatoshaS.Johnson OBX E200302663SCR11CD '=0Y 'KnoxCriminal aTZ MaryBethLeibowitz OB[ 69879 '=0\ 'Williams,J aT] Affirmed 'OB^ 'Rule11 'aT_ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLatoshaS. aT` Martin,aliasLatoshaS.Johnson 'OBa 'StateofTennesseev.DarianNigel  b Sparks !c E200302021SCR11CD '" d 'KnoxCriminal  e RichardBaumgartner !f 75820,77714 '" g 'Tipton,J  h Affirmed '!i 'Rule11 ' j ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDarianNigel  k Sparks '!l 'StateofTennesseev.DavidL.Taylor qd  E200302117SCR11CD '_R 'CampbellCircuit qd RichardBaumgartner _R 11389 'M@ 'Riley,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDavidL.Taylor 'qd  'StateofTennesseev.GeorgeA.Vance   andVincentVance   E200300110SCR11CD '  'SullivanCircuit   PhyllisH.Miller  S43074andS43075 ' 'Wedemeyer,J  Affirmed ' ' ' ' Denied 󀄀MotiontoReconsiderDenialof  ApplicationofGeorgeA.Vanceand  VincentVance ' 'ClaytonEugeneTurnerv.Stateof -  Tennessee   E200202895SCR11PC '  'SullivanCriminal -  PhyllisH.Miller   C46,354 '  'Glenn,J -  Affirmed '  'Rule11 '-  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofClaytonEugene -  Turner '   'DonnaS.Youngv.FredC.Hartley,  ~ ! M.D.,etal. y l " E200202925SCR11CV 'gZ # 'WashingtonCircuit  ~ $ ThomasJ.Seeley,Jr. y l % 20477 'gZ & 'Swiney,J.  ~ ' Affirmed 'y l ( 'Rule11 ' ~ ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonnaS.Young ' ~ * ' ' + ' ' , ' ' - ' ' . '" / J "X,