WPC& '[utVs[D3ut35ɘykHw -OvrM8&> L!S ^lY$~'5j;~eD[kE+e؛;`t)NqGh,&{~4$#3[XSHkvQR q5w싪dN:Yt`һ}6gA6 5_|=W|939C;6tδG k`}v^EigUy,s8*097da{NA쀿Ŧִܴ%=)U avz0{iw*F?L.tc\}Z"vߝn aZ.=z$ӞYkw|Y*/:%k0V E>N߭ |"`)CQgͦ<ݠ*W.bIohHr34 ԙe)2$LU8!BlX# UNU % 0( f a b w 4   N( ^ * 6 m8 0lO 0D  0D 0UK 0 0} 0< 0r 0 0 0n 0 0 0i 04 0 0 0) 0 BY 0v 0 0 0H 0 0 0^ 0 0 0& 0 1u6 72 0N 0c+!+!+!N!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! D5! 0D""U"U" AS#n# 0D4$ 0Dx$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$x$ D-$$$$$$$$$$$$ 04$$$$ A% 0K%\\ib01s01\clerk1nas,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE APage of &0d 3|xM1 U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   (3$ !  *+ (_2623  ..*D+D (_25   ," <DL,23  ..," <DL,   *5+5 (_24  ) <DL)23  ..) <DL)  *2+2 (_23 ` &<<DL&23  ..&<<DL& ` */+/ (_22  #DL#23  ..#DL#   h  \R'3 Letter Landscape\*,+, (_21   DL 23  .. DL  *)+) (_20 h DDL23  ..DDL h *&+& (_19  L23  ..L  *#+# (_18   L23  .. L  *>> (_17  2( 4 <DL223  Ԁ2( 4 <DL2  *DD (_16   ," <DL,23  Ԁ," <DL,   *55 (_15  ) <DL)23  Ԁ) <DL)  *22 (_14 ` &<<DL&23  Ԁ&<<DL& ` *// (_13  #DL#23  Ԁ#DL#  *,, (_12   DL 23  Ԁ DL  *)) (_11 h DDL23  ԀDDL h  d*&& (_10  L23  ԀL  (## &_9   L23  Ԁ L  (>> &_8  2( 4 <DL223  2( 4 <DL2  (DD &_7   ," <DL,23  ," <DL,   (55 &_6  ) <DL)23  ) <DL)  (22 &_5 ` &<<DL&23  &<<DL& ` (// &_4  #DL#23  #DL#  (,, &_3   DL 23   DL  ()) &_2 h DDL23  DDL h (&& &_1  L23  L  &## $_   L23   L  3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)1i)(O$(;3$2#  0  .3  0   D   8zPXXdXXd8%%%%)!dxdx(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5ab\c[E<<CLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ($$   1  )!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRO'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter Landscape3'LetterTXXX, 8n8XXdd8760  081810` 8181@*` 81` 81SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE , @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS  @>>+ Monday,December6,2004  (#     Ӏ   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd , dd ,dd ,edd , dd +  $ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER '$" 'COUNTY $ TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE $  JUDGE   JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE $ OF  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION '$" ' ' V  'Ѐ 4XXNASHVILLE #Xn8X4ٷ# ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  ' ' V  ' '>   ' '>   ' '>   ' '>   ' '>   'Dana_Friedenstab_ԀandMichael   _Friedenstab_Ԁv.MarthaShort   M200300603SCR11CV 'p 'WilliamsonCircuit   DonaldP.Harris   II01386 'p! 'Cain,J  " Affirmedand  # Modifies 'p$ 'Rule11 ' % ' Denied ApplicationofDanaand  & Michael_Friedenstab_ ' ' 'Donald_Hargrove_,etalv.Metropolitan ( GovernmentofNashville&Davidson  ) County * M200300289SCR11CV '+ 'DavidsonChancery , EllenH.Lyle  - 02215III '. 'Koch,J / Affirmed ' 0 'Rule11 '1 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonald 2 _Hargrove_,Richard_Hughey_,Scott  3 _Sulfridge_,_Jimmie_ԀKnight,andJerry 4 _Pinkleton_ '5 'HowardandSuzanneLevyv.James j>6 C.D.andRhondaFranks,etal. X,7 M200202730SCR11CV 'F8 'WilliamsonChancery j>9 R.E.LeeDavies X,: I25613 'F; 'Kirby,J j>< Affirmedin X,= Part,Reversed F> inPart,and 4? Remanded '"@ 'Rule11 'j>A ' Denied 󀄀Applicationonbehalfof j>B HowardLevyandSuzanneLevyandon X,C behalfofJamesC.D.andRhondaFranks 'FD 'JamesLeePerryv.StateofTennessee xE M200301939SCR11_HC_ 'fF 'WayneCircuit xG RobertHolloway fH 14005 'TI '_Wedemeyer_,J xJ Affirmed 'fK 'Rule11 'xL ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesLeePerry 'xM 'InRe:EstateofNellieElizabeth_Crowell_ N (Deceased) O M200202285SCR11CV 'P 'DavidsonCircuit Q FrankClement,Jr. R 00P1427 'S 'Farmer,J T Reversedand U Remanded 'V 'Rule11 'W ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationonbehalfofFree X WillMinistries,Inc.,etal. 'Y '76 7 ,8n8XXdXXd8 7  _InRe:EstateofErinMurrayJones qd M200203073SCR11CV '_R 'DavidsonProbate qd FrankClement,Jr. _R  98P1344 'M@ 'Farmer,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationonbehalfofEvie qd  Moore '_R  'NationalInsuranceAssociationv.   KatherineMichelleSimpson,David   Franklin,RogerPerryandCreteCarrier   Corporation  M200203109SCR11CV ' z 'RutherfordChancery  RobertE.Corlew,III  013395CV ' 'Koch,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKatherine  MichelleSimpsonandDavidFranklin ' 'CherylOBrienv.RheemManufacturing   Co.   M200300530SCR11CV '  'MontgomeryCircuit   JohnH.Gasaway   C10695 '  'Cain,J   Affirmedand   Remanded '  'Rule11 ' ! ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCherylOBrien ' " 'WilliamOsepczukv.StateofTennessee gZ # M200301601SCR11PC 'UH $ 'LawrenceCriminal gZ % StellaL.Hargrove UH & 23648 'C6' 'Glenn,J gZ ( Affirmed 'UH ) 'Rule11 'gZ * ' Denied ApplicationofWilliam gZ + Osepczuk 'UH , 'StateofTennesseev.RogerDaleBryan - M200301366SCR11CD '. 'BedfordCircuit / LeeRussell 0 15202 '1 'Hayes,J 2 Affirmed '3 'Rule11 '4 ' Denied- ApplicationofRogerDale 5 Bryan '6 'StateofTennesseev.AndrewNeal #7 Davis 8 M200202375SCR11CD '9 'DavidsonCriminal #: CherylBlackburn ; 2001A391 '< 'Woodall,J #= Affirmed '> 'Rule11 '#? ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAndrewNeal #@ Davis 'A 'StateofTennesseev.Anthony tB Henderson obC M200302145SCR11CD ']PD 'WhiteCircuit tE LeonBurns,Jr. obF CR762,CR730 ']PG 'Woodall,J tH Affirmed 'obI 'Rule11 'tJ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAnthony tK CharlesHenderson 'obL 'StateofTennesseev.BryanK.Miller M M200301434SCR11CD 'N 'FranklinCircuit O J.CurtisSmith P 14539 'Q 'Hayes,J R Affirmed 'S 'Rule11 'T ' Denied ApplicationofBryanK.Miller 'U 'StateofTennesseev.BrandonScott =0V Watson + W M200301814SCR11CD '! X 'DavidsonCriminal =0Y SethNorman + Z 2002I1329 '! [ 'Hayes,J =0\ Affirmed + ]  '! ^ 'Rule11 '=0_ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBrandonScott =0` Watson '+ a ' TRO'3 Letter LandscapeO'3 Letter Landscape'3Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3Letter LandscapeT   StateofTennesseev.JosephChiChoi qd  Wong _R M200300504SCR11CD 'M@ 'DavidsonCriminal qd CherylBlackburn _R 2000D1879 'M@ 'Smith,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJosephChiChoi qd  Wong '_R  ' '  ' '  ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 'QD ' 'QD ' 'QD ' 'QD ' 'QD ' ' '4XXn8 򀀀JACKSON ' ' ' ' ' ' ' 'Xn8X4TeresaCaldwell,etalv.CanadaTrace,   Inc. } p  W200300264SCR11CV 'k ^  'ShelbyCircuit   KarenWilliams } p  90025and90029 'k ^  'Highers,J.  ! Affirmedin } p " Part,Reversed k ^ # inPart 'Y L $ 'Rule11 ' % ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTeresa  & Caldwell,etal. '} p ' 'EdwardJohnsonv.Fox13News,  ( WHBQTV  ) W200400992SCR11CV '* 'ShelbyChancery  + CH0401282 ' , 'Farmer,J  - Highers,J  . Dismissed / appeal '0 'Rule11 ' 1 ' Denied ApplicationofEdwardJohnson ' 2 'BernardKeysv.StateofTennessee '3 W200301846SCR11PC '4 'ShelbyCriminal '5 BernieWeinman 6 P26734 '7 'Wedemeyer,J '8 Affirmed '9 'Rule11 '': ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBernardKeys ''; 'RhodneyRobersonv.StateofTennessee x< W200301236SCR11PC 'sf= 'GibsonCircuit x> JosephH.Walker,III sf? 148881 'aT@ 'Tipton,J xA Affirmed 'sfB 'Rule11 'xC ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRhodney xD Roberson 'sfE 'StateofTennesseev.AndreBaldwin F W200302253SCR11CD 'G 'ShelbyCriminal H W.OtisHiggs,Jr. I 0013691 'J 'Welles,J K Affirmed 'L 'Rule11 'M ' Denied ApplicationofAndreBaldwin 'N 'StateofTennesseev.StephenKeith A4O Frazier /"P W200301612SCR11CD 'Q 'HardinCircuit A4R C.CreedMcGinley /"S 8198 'T 'Wedemeyer,J A4U Affirmedin /"V Part;Reversed W inPartand  X Remanded ' Y 'Rule11 'A4Z ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStephenKeith A4[ Frazier '/"\ 'StateofTennesseev.RobertL. qd Stevenson _R  W200302097SCR11CD 'M@ 'ShelbyCriminal qd ChrisCraft _R 0207247 'M@ 'Tipton,J qd Affirmed '_R 'Rule11 'qd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertL. qd  Stevenson '_R  'StateofTennesseev.AnthonyTony   Woods   W200302785SCR11CD ' 'HardemanCircuit  JonKerryBlackwood  6755 ' 'Smith,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAnthonyTony  Woods ' 'EarleyStoryv.StateofTennessee -  W200401586SCR10PC '  'ShelbyCriminal -  ChrisCraft   P27176 '  'Hayes,J -  Denied '  'Rule10 '-  ' Denied ApplicationofEarleyStory '-  'MikeWilson,d/b/aM&MAutoSales  ~  v.ShaneChapman y l ! W200302130SCR11CV 'gZ " 'ShelbyChancery  ~ # ArnoldGoldin y l $ CH0012492 'gZ % 'Crawford,J  ~ & Affirmed 'y l ' 'Rule11 ' ~ ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofShaneChapman ' ~ ) ' ' * ' ' + ' ' , ' ' - ' ' . ' 'k^/ ' 'k^0 ' 'k^1 ' 'k^2 ' 'k^3 ' '4 'Ѐ 4XXn8KNOXVILLE #Xn8X4ٴB# '5 ' '6 ' '7 ' '8 ' '9 ' ': ' '; ' '< ' 1(#331 '= 'WaynellC.Burnettev.TeddySundeen, +> etal.  ? E200301404SCR11CV '@ 'BlountCircuit +A WilliamD.Young  B L1331 'C 'Susan,J +D Vacatedin  E Part,Affirmed F inPartand G Remanded 'H 'Rule11 '+I ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWaynellC. +J Burnette ' K 'RobertL. LarryCarrierv.Speedway eXL Motorsports,Inc.,etal. SFM E200202724SCR11CV 'A4N 'SullivanChancery eXO ThomasR.Frierson,II SFP 17294(L) 'A4Q 'Susano,J eXR Affirmedin SFS Partand A4T Reversedin /"U Part 'V 'Rule11 'eXW ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationonbehalfofRobert eXX L. LarryCarrier 'SFY 'ElisaCochranv.StateofTennessee qd E200401778SCR11PC '_R 'McMinnCircuit qd R.StevenBebb _R 00296 'M@ 'Witt,J qd Wade,Jand _R Ogle,J M@ Rule28 ;.   Denied ')  'Rule11 'qd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofElisaCochran 'qd  'Dr.KennethF.Freels,DDS,PCetal.v.   JosephC.Taylor&Associates,Inc.,etal  E200301788ScR11CV ' z 'KnoxChancery  DarylR.Fansier  1283681 ' z 'Franks,J  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 ' ' Denied ApplicationofDr.KennethF.  Freels,KennethF.Freels,D.D.S.,P.C.,  andKennethF.Freels,D.D.S.,P.C. ' z 'TerranceLowdermilkv.Stateof   Tennessee   E200400282SCR11HC '  'HamiltonCriminal   RebeccaStern   246750 '  'Tipton,J   Affirmed   Rule20 ' ! 'Rule11 ' " ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof__Terrance_  # _Lowdermilk_ ' $ 'WandaMoodyv.Timothy_Hutchison_, gZ % SheriffofKnoxCounty UH & E200301325SCR11CV 'C6' 'KnoxChancery gZ ( DarylR._Fansier_ UH ) 1533152 'C6* '_Swiney_,J gZ + Affirmedand UH , Remanded 'C6- 'Rule11 'gZ . ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationsofWandaMoody gZ / andofTimothy_Hutchison_ 'UH 0 '_Onvil_ԀRobinson,etal.V.DorothyR. 1 Currey,etux.,etal. 2 E200301847SCR11CV '3 'HamiltonCircuit 4 W.NeilThomas,III 5 01C1677 '6 'Swiney,J 7 Affirmed 8  '9 'Rule11 ': ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofOnvilRobinson ; andLaraFyfe '< 'StateofTennesseev.LarryArnell #= Adams > E200203046ScR11CD '? 'KnoxCriminal #@ RichardBaumgartner A 70670and75581 'B 'Ogle,J #C Affirmed 'D 'Rule11 '#E ' Denied ApplicationofLarryArnell #F Adams 'G 'StateofTennesseev.RussellDavid tH Farmer obI E199500055SCDATCD ']PJ 'McMinnCircuit tK R.StevenBebb obL 901015;901016;901017; ]PM 901018 'K>N 'Hayes,J tO Affirmed 'obP 'Rule11 'tQ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRussellDavid tR Farmer 'obS 'StateofTennesseev.J.D.Jones T E20031565SCR11CD 'U 'ClaiborneCircuit V E.ShayneSexton W 11,977 'X 'Woodall,J Y Affirmed 'Z 'Rule11 '[ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJ.D.Jones '\ 'StateofTennesseev.ChadKilgore + ] E200301112SCR11CD '! ^ 'GreeneCircuit + _ JamesBeckner ! ` 98CR287 '"a 'Wade,J + b Appeal ! c Dismissed '"d 'Rule11 '+ e ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofChadKilgore"+ f - "X,