WPC FkHFWVav n'Ͷ8Ĝ-6 YP /M#kV!pkHƥ>3*qxd7|s0Ua, >R>mmIE4װ`( 7#/f ɏ#Hr[ M?5ZA:g'Mkvq( v_Nup3#}^:ZiQ_\?p"{yi# UNM % 0( f a  w 4  B N4^ 6B mD 0l[ 0Df                Bqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq 0D D- 04 A 0KHP LaserJet 4050 Series PCL 6,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A  $    1    _ԀAppellantEdward_Tharpe_sMotiontoProceedasaPoorPersonisgranted.ItappearingtotheCourtthatAppellantEdward X _Tharpe_Ԁisincarceratedandindigent,theCourtherebyappointsBrian_Dunigan_Ԁtorepresenttheappellantforpurposesofthisappeal > only.,-d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd8n-s U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5)!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3 Letter Landscape3'TXXXX  g 0  @*8181SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS > @/ December9,2002 $   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,dd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE :  OFAPPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' Calvin_Tankesly_  ( v. f   Sgt._Pugh_ԀandJames_Bowlen_ L  M200001520SCR11CV '2  'DavidsonChancery  ( 00135III 'f   'Cottrell,J.  ( Affirmed& f   Remanded. L   '2  'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCalvin  ( _Tankesly_. f    'L  ' JerryW.Seymour,EtAl. T  v. :  _Tomisa_ԀSierra,EtAl. x   M200102278SCS09CV '^! 'FranklinCircuit T " BuddyD.Perry : # 10897CV 'x $ '_Cantrell_,J. T % Affirmed& : & Remanded. 'x ' 'Rule11 'T ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofNationwide T ) Insurance.InaccordancewithSupreme : * CourtRule4(D),theCourtrecommends x + thattheopinionoftheCourtofAppeals ^, bepublished. 'D- ' MaryEdithKelley,EtAl. f. v. L/ _Mahlon_ԀJohns 20 M199800912SCR11CV 'p1 'MauryCircuit f2 RobertL.Jones L3 2994 '24 'Koch,J. f5 Affirmed& L6 Remanded. '27 'Rule11 'f8 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Mahlon_ԀJohns. f9  'L: ' RichardLynnNorton ; v. x< JimB.,EtAl. ^= M200201596SCR11CV 'D> 'Unknown '? '_Cantrell_,J. @ PetitionforReview xA Denied. '^B 'Rule11 'C ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRichardLynn D Norton. xE  '^F ' TonyWillis,EtAl. G v. H TennesseeDepartmentof I Correction pJ M200001397SCR11CV 'VK 'DavidsonChancery L EllenH.Lyle M 993332III 'N 'Cottrell,J. O Affirmed& P Remanded. 'Q 'Rule11 'R ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofEdward S _Tharpe_. #  1       T  'U ' g  8cXXdd8    'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' StateofTennessee 6 v.  WilliamTonyWright  M200101418SCR11CD '  'RutherfordCircuit 6  _J.S.Daniel_   M43411&F49336 '  '_Woodall_,J. 6  Affirmed. ' 'Rule11 '6 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliamTony 6 Wright.   ' ' StateofTennessee b  v. H  TimothyTyroneSanders .  M200102128SCR11CD '  'BedfordCircuit b  WilliamC.Lee H  14492 '.  'Ogle,J. b  Affirmed. 'H  'Rule11 'b  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTimothyTyrone b  Sanders. H   '.  ' StateofTennessee  6  v. t  ! FloydEarl_Rayner_,III Z " M200100971SCR11CD '@ # 'DavidsonCriminal  6 $ SethNorman t  % 2000A589 'Z & '_Witt_,J.  6 ' Affirmed. 't  ( 'Rule11 ' 6 ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFloydEarl  6 * _Rayner_,III. t  +  'Z , ' Adrian_Wilkerson_ b- v. H. StateofTennessee ./ M200102295SCR11CD 'l0 'DavidsonCriminal b1 J.RandallWyatt H2 95B856 '.3 'Riley,J. b4 Affirmed. 'H5 'Rule11 'b6 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAdrian b7 _Wilkerson_. H8  '.9 ' StateofTennessee : v. t; DarylLeeMaddenandMartyDale Z< Williams @= M200002227SCR11CD '~&> 'DavidsonCriminal ? CherylBlackburn t@ 98A627 'ZA 'Riley,J. B Affirmed. 'tC 'Rule11 'D ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationsofDarylLee E MaddenandMartyDaleWilliams. tF  'ZG ' MarioHawkins H v. I StateofTennessee lJ M200002901SCR11PC 'RK 'DavidsonCriminal L SteveR.Dozier M 95D2368 'lN 'Smith,J. O Affirmed. 'P 'Rule11 'Q ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMarioHawkins. R  'S ' _Clessie_Ԁ_Jaco_ $T v.  U StateofTennessee V M200102150SCR11PC ' ~W 'MauryCircuit $X RobertL.Jones  Y 9854 'Z 'Hayes,J. $[ Affirmed. ' \ 'Rule11 '$] ' Granted 󀄀Applicationof_Clessie_Ԁ_Jaco_. $^  ' _ ' 'P"` ' 'P"a ' 'P"b ' 'P"c ' 'P"d ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   AmyWilson,EtAl. d v. J WoodlandPresbyterianSchool 0 W200100054SCR11CV 'n 'ShelbyChancery d WalterL.Evans J CH0014551 '0 '_Lillard_,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWoodland d  PresbyterianSchool.Pursuantto J  SupremeCourtRule4(D),theCourt 0  directsthepublicationoftheopinionof n theCourtofAppealsfiledJune25,2002. 'T ' StevenCase v v. \ ShelbyCountyCivilServiceMerit  B Board,EtAl.  ( W200102058SCR11CV 'f   'ShelbyChancery v D.J._Alissandratos_ \ CH0018863 ' B 'Farmer,J. v Affirmed& \ Remanded. ' B 'Rule11 'v ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStevenCase. v  '\ ' Lorenzo_Childress_,Jr.,d/b/a   _Southgate_ԀMedicalGroup  n  v. T  UnionRealtyCompany,Ltd. : ! W200101742SCR11CV 'x " 'ShelbyCircuit  # GeorgeH.Brown,Jr.  n $ 37267 'T % 'Farmer,J.  & Affirmed&  n ' Remanded. 'T ( 'Rule11 ' ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofUnionRealty  * Company,Ltd.  n +  ': - ' '. ' '/ ' '0 ' '1 ' '2 ' StateofTennessee l3 v. R4 NathanielHenderson 85 W200200605SCR11CD '6 'ShelbyCriminal l7 Carolyn_Blackett_ R8 9302824 '89 'Riley,J. l: Rule20Order R; Affirming. '8< 'Rule11 'l= ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofNathaniel l> Henderson. R?  '8@ ' StateofTennessee @A v. ~&B _Laquenton_ԀMonger d C W200200321SCR11CD 'JD 'ShelbyCriminal @E JohnP._Colton_,Jr. ~&F 9801601;9801602 'd G 'Ogle,J. @H AffirmedinPart, ~&I ReversedinPart& d J RemandedinPart. 'JK 'Rule11 '@L ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Laquenton_ @M Monger. ~&N  'd O ' StateofTennessee lP v. RQ _Matrin_Ԁ_Becton_ԀandAntonioSykes 8R W199900581SCR11CD 'vS 'ShelbyCriminal lT JosephB.Dailey RU 980226770 '8V 'Welles,J. lW Affirmed. 'RX 'Rule11 'lY ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Matrin_Ԁ_Becton_ lZ andAntonioSykes. R[  '8\ ' StateofTennessee ] v.  ~^ Maurice_Lashaun_ԀNash !d_ W200101703SCR11CD '"J ` '_Tipton_ԀCircuit a JosephH.Walker  ~b 3933 '!dc 'Hayes,J. d Reversed&  ~e Remanded. '!df 'Rule11 'g ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationoftheStateof h TennesseeandMaurice_Lashaun_ԀNash.  ~i  '!dj ' JasonW._Kimberland_ d  v. J StateofTennessee 0 W200102597SCR11PC 'n '_Hardin_ԀCircuit d CharlesC._McGinley_ J PC7447 '0 'Williams,J. d AffirmedRule20 J  Order. '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJasonW. d  _Kimberland_. J   '0 ' _Ricky_ԀD.Turner  v. v StateofTennessee \ W200201198SCR11CO ' B 'LauderdaleCircuit  JoeH.Walker,III v 5584 '\ 'Hayes,J.  DenyingMotionto v LateFileNoticeof \ Appeal. ' B 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Ricky_ԀD.  Turner. v  '\ ' MarcA.Bland   v.   JamesM.Dukes,Warden,EtAl.   W200200579SCR11CO ' n ! 'LauderdaleCircuit  " JosephH.Walker  # 5570 ' $ '_Tipton_,J.  % Affirmed. ' & 'Rule11 ' ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMarcA.Bland.  (  ' ) ' '@ * ' '@ + ' '@ , ' '@ - ' '@ . ' JonathanH. b/ v. H0 JamesStewart,Director,Anderson .1 CountySchools,EtAl. l2 E200102485SCR11CV 'R3 'AndersonChancery b4 WilliamEverett_Lantrip_ H5 00CH0424 '.6 '_Goddard_,J. b7 Vacated& H8 Dismissed. '.9 'Rule11 'b: ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLisaS. b;  'H< ' 't= ' 't> ' 't? ' 't@ ' 'tA ' StateofTennessee FB v. ,C MichaelShanePowell D E200101544SCR11CD 'E 'HamiltonCriminal FF StephenM._Bevil_ ,G 226355&226437 'H 'Welles,J. FI Affirmed. ',J 'Rule11 'FK ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichaelShane FL Powell. ,M  'N ' StateofTennessee rO v. XP ElmerW.Cross >Q E200102724SCR11CD '$R 'Hamilton_Criminal_ rS RebeccaStern XT 226046&226047 '>U 'Wade,J. rV Affirmed. 'XW 'Rule11 'rX ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofElmerW.Cross. rY PursuanttoSupremeCourtRule4(D), XZ theCourtdirectsthepublicationofthe >[ opinionoftheCourtofCriminalAppeals $\ filedAugust12,2002. ' ] ' StateofTennessee d v. J PerryRayDavis 0  E200101432SCR11CD 'n 'HamiltonCriminal d DouglasA.Meyer J 228151,229610 '0 'Wade,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPerryRay d  Davis. J   '0  ' StateofTennessee  v. v TerryStewartMoore \ E200100153SCR11CD ' B '_Blount_ԀCircuit  D.KellyThomas,Jr. v C12303 '\ 'Wade,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTerryStewart  Moore. v  '\ ' StateofTennessee   v.   BrendaLeeHicks   E200100990SCR11CD ' n  'HamiltonCriminal   DouglasA.Meyer   231179,231952 ' ! 'Wade,J.  " Affirmed. ' # 'Rule11 ' $ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBrendaLee  % Hicks.  &  ' ' ' StateofTennessee @ ( v. & ) _Demetrius_ԀK.Holmes  * E200100660SCR11CD '+ 'KnoxCriminal @ , RichardR._Baumgartner_ & - 68714 ' . 'Wade,J. @ / Affirmed. '& 0 'Rule11 '@ 1 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Demetrius_ @ 2 Holmes. & 3  ' 4 ' StateofTennessee l5 v. R6 JosephHough 87 E200102728SCR11CD '8 '_Hamblen_ԀCircuit l9 _Kindall_ԀT.Lawson R: 98CR113 '8; 'Ogle,J. l< Affirmed. 'R= 'Rule11 'l> ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJosephHough. l?  'R@ ' RichardLynnNorton @A v. ~&B StateofTennessee d C E200200305SCR11PC 'JD 'GreeneCircuit @E JamesE._Beckner_ ~&F 01_ԄCR_080 'd G 'Ogle,J. @H OrderdenyingPro ~&I SefilingsasNorton d J hadcounsel. 'JK 'Rule11 '@L ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRichardLynn @M Norton. ~&N "d O $ "X,