WPC BL4@H*7>|{pw3;o'k)e;J=]2e)[>,!~| "Z遟,%/LY%r2ZósH.U;:)(ۖŃBP{Qke 5`)Qߚʻ@ĥZ( <_Рl,h\_'2.*D U9ʻ#9Wpa-뷃 멇K|u JJ4r{Wr PV-.dmcSY,^P-E&V}byl :pgaS-zYI&ۚ c(ڗ@{Br'+6/~B~<1KE<b8nxІ*xU5JKS2^pk`Pv/X!:וϬ._+w£XE?R# UNM % 0( f a  wi 4m  B N ^  m 0l 0De~f''''''''''''''' B 0D D- 04 A 0KHP LaserJet 4050 Series PCL 6,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A  $    1    _TheapplicationisgrantedforthesolepurposeofremandingthecasetotheCourtofCriminalAppealsforreconsiderationin X lightofthisCourtsopinioninStatev._ Peele_ ,___S.W.3d____(Tenn.2001)(Knoxville,filedOctober16,2001).F+d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd8 +s U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   t $    2    _Fororalargument,theCourtisparticularlyinterestedinthefollowingissue:WhethertheCourtofCriminalAppealserredin X affirmingthetrialcourtsrefusaltograntpostconvictionreliefonthepetitionersclaimthathewasdeniedtheeffectiveassistanceof > counselinconnectionwithpretrialstatementsgiventopolice.Thisstatementoftheissuefororalargumentdoesnotpreventthe $ partiesfromraisingadditionalissuespursuanttoRule13(a),Tenn.R.App.P. \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5)!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3 Letter Landscape3'TXXXX  g @*SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS > @/ December10,20010 x   (#  %  '  0*  , $x81x81 @7 ,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,Fdd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATUREOF :  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' Dennis_Armoneit_  ( vs. f   ElliottCraneService,Inc.,etal L  M199800988SCR11CV '2  'DavidsonCircuit  ( HamiltonV._Gayden_,Jr. f   97C232 'L  'Koch,J.  ( Affirmedinpart, f   reversedinpart 'L  'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof Dennis  ( _Armoneit_ 'f   ' BillyandMary_Milliken_ T  vs. :  _Crye_Ԅ_Leike_ԀRealtors,etal x  M199900071SCR11CV '^  'SmithCircuit T ! ClaraW.Byrd : " 4119 'x # 'Cottrell,J. T $ Affirmedinpart, : % vacatedinpart,and x & remanded '^' 'Rule11 'T ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBillyandMary T ) _Milliken_ ': * ' TeresaOverland,etal + vs. f, _Jonee_ԀElizabethOBrien,etal L- M200002192SCR11CV '2. 'WilliamsonCircuit / Russ_Heldman_ f0 I98119 'L1 'Ash,Sp.J. 2 Affirmed 'f3 'Rule11 '4 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTeresa 5 Overland,etal 'f6 ' _Omawali_Ԁ_Ashanti_Ԁ_Shabazz_,a/k/a 7 FredE.Dean 8 vs. x9 _Donal_ԀCampbell,etal ^: M200001780SCR11CV 'D; 'DavidsonChancery < Ellen_Hobbs_ԀLyle = 992160III 'x> 'Cain,J. ? Affirmed '@ 'Rule11 'A ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Omawali_ B _Ashanti_Ԁ_Shabazz_Ԁa/k/aFredE.Dean 'C ' StateDept.ofTransportation D vs. E MedicineBirdEagle,etal F M199900300SCR11CV 'pG 'WilliamsonChancery H Russ_Heldman_ I II26212 'J 'Koch,J. K Reversed 'L 'Rule11 'M ' &f%XXDenied 󀄀#XcX%&f#&f%XXcApplicationofMedicineBird N Eagle,etal;motionsofthe_Toye_Ԁ_Heape_Ԁand O theEasternBandofCherokeeIndians fP seekingleavetoappearasamicuscuriaeare :Q denied.#XcX%&fb# 'fR ' LoisUnderwood  vS vs. !\T _NHC_ԀInsuranceCompany "B U M200102341SCR9CV '#(!V 'MauryCircuit  vW RobertHolloway !\X 8910 '"B Y ' ' vZ 'Rule9 ' v[ ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_NHC_ԀInsurance ' v\ ' g  8cXXdd8    'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' StateofTennessee 6 vs.  JamesDavidAlder  M200001825SCR11CD '  'FranklinCircuit 6  BuddyD.Perry   12715 '  '_Woodall_,J. 6  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 '6 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesDavid 6 Alder ' ' StateofTennessee b  vs. H  DamienJackson .  M200000763SCR11CD '  'DavidsonCriminal b  CherylBlackburn H  98C2159 '.  'Welles,J. b  Affirmed 'H  'Rule11 'b  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDamienJackson 'b  ' StateofTennessee  6  vs. t   RaymondO.Jackson Z  M199902106SCR11PC '@  'DavidsonCriminal  6 ! SteveR.Dozier t  " C3599 'Z # 'Williams,J.  6 $ Affirmed 't  % 'Rule11 ' 6 & ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRaymondO.  6 ' Jackson 't  ( ' StateofTennessee b) vs. H* AaronJames .+ M200000495SCR11CD 'l, 'DavidsonCriminal b- J.RandallWyatt,Jr. H. 98C2345 './ 'Hayes,J. b0 Reversed 'H1 'Rule11 'b2 ' Granted ApplicationofStateof b3 Tennessee 'H4 ' StateofTennessee 5 vs. t6 _Lonnie_ԀTurner Z7 M199901127SCR11CD '@8 'RutherfordCircuit 9 JamesK.Clayton,Jr. t: 33793 'Z; '_Tipton_,J. < Affirmed 't= 'Rule11 '> ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Lonnie_ԀTurner '? ' QuintonA.Cage @ vs. A StateofTennessee B M200001989SCR11PC 'lC 'MontgomeryCircuit D J.Walton E 40000140 'F '_Lafferty_,J. G Affirmed 'H 'Rule11 'I ' Denied 󀄀Application_of_ԀQuinton_Cage_ 'J ' JonathanDavis >K vs. $L StateofTennessee  M M200001158SCR11PC 'N 'MauryCircuit >O RobertL.Jones $P 8,455 ' Q 'Ogle,J. >R Affirmed '$S 'Rule11 '>T ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJonathanDavis '>U ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   _  JohnnyWayneGarnerand d RichardDarrellMiller J  vs. 0 StateofTennessee n M200001258SCR11PC 'T 'GilesCircuit d StellaL.Hargrove J 9155,9171 0  'n  'Williams,J. d  Reversedand J  remanded '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofStateof d Tennessee;opinionoftheCourtof J CriminalAppealsisdesignated Notfor 0 CitationinaccordancewithSupreme n CourtRule4,F 'T ' JoeyLeeSmith v vs. \ StateofTennessee  B M199901896SCR11PC ' ( 'BedfordCircuit v WilliamC.Lee \ 8062 ' B 'Smith,J. v Affirmed '\ 'Rule11 'v ' &f%XXcDenied 󀄀ApplicationofJoeyLeeSmith; v opinionoftheCourtofCriminalAppealsis J designated NotforCitationinaccordance v  withSupremeCourtRule4,F#XcX%&fM-# 'J   ' ' ! ' ' " ' ' # ' ' $ ' ' % ' AndreBeason,etal t  & vs. Z ' JamesDukes,etal @ ( W200002908SCR11CV '& ) 'LauderdaleChancery t  * 11439 '@ , 'Farmer,Highers,JJ. t  - Dismissed 'Z . 'Rule11 't  / ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAndreBeason, t  0 etal 'Z 1 ' WilmaLucchesi H2 vs. .3 AlcoholandLicensingCommission l4 ofTheCityofMemphis,TN R5 W200002911SCR11CV '86 'ShelbyChancery H7 FloydPeete,Jr. .8 CH0013683 'l9 'Crawford,J. H: Vacatedand .; remanded 'l< 'Rule11 'H= ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilmaS. H> Lucchesi '.? ' DuncanRagsdale,etal Z@ vs. @A TheCityofMemphis,etal ~&B W200101652SCR11CV 'd C 'ShelbyChancery ZD WalterL.Evans @E CH010780 '~&F 'Crawford,J. ZG Affirmedinpart, @H reversedand ~&I remanded 'd J 'Rule11 'ZK ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDuncan ZL Ragsdale,etal '@M ' PatriciaWilliams N vs. lO JamesNelsonWilliams,etal  RP  W200003096SCR11CV '8Q 'DyerChancery R J.StevenStafford lS 97C492 'RT 'Glenn,J. U Affirmed 'lV 'Rule11 'W ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesNelson X Williams,etal 'lY ' MaryLindaWinkler  Z vs. [ TiptonCo.Bd.ofEducation,etal   ~\  W200002996SCR11CV '!d] 'TiptonChancery  ^ JonK.Blackwood _ 16961 ' ~` 'Glenn,J.  a Affirmedinpart, b reversedinpart,and  ~c remanded '!dd 'Rule11 ' e ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationsofTiptonCo.Bd.  f ofEducation,etal,andMaryLinda g Winkler ' ~h ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' StateofTennessee 6 vs.  AnthonyBrasfield  W200100169SCR11PC '  'WeakleyCircuit 6  WilliamB.Acree   CR632000 '  'Hayes,J. 6  Affirmed ' 'Rule11 '6 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAnthony 6 Brasfield ' ' StateofTennessee b  vs. H  DarrinBryant .  W200001136SCR11CD '  'ShelbyCriminal b  CarolynW.Blackett H  9803828 '.  'Lafferty,J. b  Affirmed 'H  'Rule11 'b  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDarrinBryant 'b  ' StateofTennessee  6  vs. t   CliffordRogers Z  W200100889SCR11CD '@  'ShelbyCriminal  6 ! BernieWeinman t  " 8505976 'Z # 'Riley,J.  6 $ Affirmedpursuant t  % toRule20 'Z & 'Rule11 ' 6 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCliffordRogers ' 6 ( ' StateofTennessee b) vs. H* CharlesEdwardTaylor .+ W200002167SCR11PC 'l, 'DyerCircuit b- R.LeeMoore,Jr. H. C9753A './ 'Glenn,J. b0 Affirmed 'H1 'Rule11 'b2 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharlesEdward b3 Taylor 'H4 ' ElmerFritts,Sr. 5 vs. t6 StateofTennessee Z7 W200100833SCR11CO '@8 'LauderdaleCircuit 9 JoeH.Walker,III t: 5468 'Z; 'Glenn,J. < Affirmed 't= 'Rule11 '> ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofElmerL.Fritts '? ' DonaldWayneHopper @ vs. A StateofTennessee B W200101758SCR11PC 'lC 'ShelbyCriminal D JudgeDailey E 98076;P06991 'F 'Williams,J. G DeniedWritof H Mandamus 'I 'Rule11 'J ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDonaldWayne K Hopper 'L ' DonaldD.Naughton,Sr. >M vs. $N StateofTennessee  O W200003006SCR11PC 'P 'ShelbyCriminal >Q W.FredAxley $R P22147 ' S 'Riley,J. >T Affirmedpursuant $U toRule20 ' V 'Rule11 '>W ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDanielD. >X Naughton,Sr. '$Y ' 'j!Z ' 'j![ ' 'j!\ ' 'j!] ' 'j!^ ' ThomasD.Fulbright d  vs. J BevansRamseyFulbright 0 E200002040SCR11CV 'n 'HamiltonCircuit d L.MarieWilliams J 98D2292 '0 'Swiney,J. d Affirmedas J  modified '0  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBevansRamsey d  Fulbright 'J  ' GatlinburgAirportAuthority,Inc.  vs. v RossB.Summitt,etal \ E200002646SCR11CV ' B 'SevierCircuit  WilliamDaleYoung v 991096II,991094II, \ 991095II,991096II ' B 'Goddard,J.  Vacatedand v remanded '\ 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRossB.  Summitt,etal 'v ' EllisPerlberg   vs.   BrencorAssetManagement,Inc.   E200002272SCR11CV ' n  'HamiltonChancery    W.FrankBrown,III  ! 981133 ' " 'Susano,J.  # Reversedand  $ remanded ' % 'Rule11 ' & ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBrencorAsset  ' Management,Inc. ' ( ' TheBank/FirstCitizensBank @ ) vs. & * CitizensandAssociates,etal  + E200002545SCR11CV ', 'BradleyCircuit @ - RussellE.Simmons,Jr. & . V97922 ' / 'Franks,J. @ 0 Affirmedas & 1 modified ' 2 'Rule11 '@ 3 ' Granted ApplicationofCitizensand @ 4 Associates '& 5 ' VulcanMaterialsCompany l6 vs. R7 TranscontinentalInsuranceCo. 88 E200002528SCR11CV '9 'HamiltonCircuit l: W.NeilThomas,III R; 95CV371 '8< 'Franks,J. l= Affirmed 'R> 'Rule11 'l? ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTranscontinental l@ Insurance 'RA ' '@B ' '@C ' '@D ' '@E ' '@F ' StateofTennessee G vs. H LatroyW.Askew I E200002010SCR11CD 'lJ 'KnoxCriminal K RayJenkins L 66726A&67088B 'M 'Woodall,J. N Affirmed 'O 'Rule11 'P ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLatroyAskew 'Q ' StateofTennessee  >R  vs. $S JohnM.Bachelor  T E200001004SCR11CD 'U 'HamiltonCriminal >V DouglasA.Meyer $W 223381 ' X 'Williams,J. >Y Affirmed '$Z 'Rule11 '>[ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJohnM. >\ _ Bachelor '$] ' StateofTennessee d vs. J  NelsonKeithFoster 0 E199902778SCR11CD 'n 'SullivanCriminal d R.JerryBeck J S41,054;S41,055; 0 S41,056 'n 'Williams,J. d  Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Granted Applicationof NelsonKeith d  Foster_  #  1      _  'J  ' StateofTennessee  vs. v ThomasDee_ Huskey_  \ E199900524SCS09CD ' B 'KnoxCriminal  RichardR._ Baumgartner_  v 51903 '\ '_ Tipton_ ,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofThomasDee  _ Huskey_  'v ' StateofTennessee   vs.   SteveA.Jackson   E199902013SCR11CD ' n  'KnoxCriminal   MaryB._ Leibowitz_    61760 '  'Smith,J.  ! Affirmed ' " 'Rule11 ' # ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSteveA.  $ Jackson ' % ' ChristopherStacyLong @ & vs. & ' StateofTennessee  ( E200001909SCR11PC ') '_ Hamblen_ ԀCriminal @ * JamesE._ Beckner_  & + 99CR219 ' , '_ Wedemeyer_ ,J. @ - Affirmed '& . 'Rule11 '@ / ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofChristopher @ 0 StacyLong '& 1 ' Randy_ Overbay_ Ԁ l2 vs. R3 HowardCarlton,Warden,Stateof 84 Tennessee 5 E200100784SCR11CO '6 'JohnsonCircuit l7 RobertE._ Cupp_  R8 3598 '89 '_ Witt_ ,J. l: Affirmedpursuant R; toRule20 '8< 'Rule11 'l= ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRandy_ Overbay_  'l> ' Charles_ Shelton_  ~&? vs. d @ HowardCarlton,Warden JA E200002805SCR11PC '0B 'JohnsonCriminal ~&C LynnW.Brown d D 361 'JE 'Smith,J. ~&F Affirmed 'd G 'Rule11 '~&H ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharles_ Shelton_  '~&I ' Kenneth_ Stomm_  RJ vs. 8K StateofTennessee vL E199900392SCR11PC '\M 'MorganCriminal RN E.Eugene_ Eblen_  8O 8532 'vP 'Wade,J. RQ Affirmed '8R 'Rule11 'RS ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofKenneth_ Stomm_  'RT ' J.Y._ Sepulveda_  d  vs. J StateofTennessee 0 E199902766SCR11PC 'n 'JeffersonCircuit d RexHenryOgle J 15,954 '0 'Smith,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Granted Applicationof _ J.Y._  d  _ Sepulveda_  #  2      "J  / "X,%