WPC+  yteTKE2J;>;!rzތ?@*2M6GݰC1:5mF:4Q'QZcO徍W*[^n*cH$J1({]ä6fnjx3 v}*XG*+}7fMl2:h9B$?H#״rSr M0Ն'g<Ɍj]ACª@T 1ed;)R{ @>  December11,20000 %  '  0*  ,  .  81  3 $%<%< @ F  XX,X*%ddd Xdd Xdd X,H?,H?,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ," dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY ':" 'TRIALJUDGE ':" 'TRIAL :  COURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE/JUDGMENT '  " 'NATUREOF :  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' LarryCherry,etal  B vs.  ( JohnE.Williams,Jr.,etal f   M199700216SCR11CV 'L  'DavidsonCircuit ' B 'BarbaraN.Haynes ' B '96C955 ' B 'Koch,J.  B Affirmedand  ( remanded 'f   'Rule11 ' B ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLarry  B CherryandMoneyManagement  ( Services,Inc. 'f   ' _Marcina_ԀClark  n  vs. T  NathanCrow :  M199900916SCS09CV 'x ! 'DavidsonCircuit ' n " 'MariettaM.  n # _Shipley_ 'T $ '98D2049 ' n % 'Cain,J.  n & Affirmedand T ' remanded ': ( 'Rule11 ' n ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofNathan  n * Crow;recommendedthatthe T + CourtofAppealsopinionbe : , published. 'x - ' RonaldCollier,etal . vs. / JackMorgan,etal f0 M199900476SCR11CV 'L1 '_Hickman_ԀCircuit '2 'DonaldP.Harris '3 '995013I '4 'Koch,J. 5 Affirmed '6 'Rule11 '7 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Issac_ԀL. 8 _Herron_ '9 ' PatriciaDavis,etal : vs. ; MikeOHara,actingdirector,ChildSupport < Services,TennesseeDepartmentofHuman x= Services  ^>  M199900066SCR11CV 'D? 'DavidsonChancery '@ 'IrvinH._Kilcrease_, A Jr. 'B '923314I 'C 'Farmer,J. D Affirmedand E remanded 'F 'Rule11 'G ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofPatricia H DavisandJennifer_Aric_ 'I ' TheGalleriaAssociates,L.P. J vs. K William_Mogk_,IIIandMarilyn_Mogk_ L M199900470SCR11CV 'pM 'WilliamsonChancery 'N 'Russ_Heldman_ 'O 'II25638 'P '_Cantrell_,J. Q Reversedand R remanded 'S 'Rule11 'T ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliam U _Mogk_,IIIandMarilyn_Mogk_ 'V ' BobKielbasa,etal B W vs. (!X WilsonCo.BoardofZoningAppeals,etal  "Y  M199901155SCR11CV '" Z 'WilsonChancery 'B [ 'CharlesK.Smith J@B \ `@98134`@J98134 I?4B ] `@98134 `@ IFranks,J. B ^ Affirmed '(!_ 'Rule11 'B ` ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBob& B a VeedaKielbasa '(!b ' 8mXXdd8   EddieBrown_Limbaugh_,executorofthe d  estateofEmmaRuth_Limbaugh_ J vs. 0 CoffeeMedicalCenter,etal n M199901181SCR11CV 'T 'CoffeeCircuit 'd 'JohnW.Rollins J@d B@28936B@J28,936 I?4d B@28936 B@ IFarmer,J. d  Affirmedinpart, J  reversedinpart,and 0  remanded 'n  'Rule11 'd  ' Granted 󀄀Applicationof Eddie d Brown_Limbaugh_ 'J ' _Katrinka_Ԁ_Stalsworth_,etal v vs. \ RobertA._Grummon_,M.D.  B M199900047SCR11CV ' ( 'SumnerCircuit 'v 'Thomas_Goodall_ 'v '17315C 'v 'Cottrell,J. v Affirmedand \ remanded ' B 'Rule11 'v ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof v _Katrinka_Ԁ_Stalsworth_; \ recommendedthattheCourtof  B Appealsopinionbepublished. ' ( ' IntheMatterofT.S.andM.S.:   StateofTNDept.ofChildrensServices   vs.  n ! Tina_Rena_ԀStaceyandMackNealStacey T " M199901286SCR11CV ': # 'RutherfordJuvenile ' $ 'BenH._McFarlin_,  % Jr. ' & '25646J ' ' 'Cottrell,J.  ( Affirmedand  ) remanded ' n * 'Rule11 ' + ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTina  , Stacey ' - ' _Donnie_ԀFranklinWheeler  . vs. / TennesseeDept.ofCorrection 0 M199900569SCR11CV 'f1 'DavidsonChancery ' 2 'CarolL.McCoy ' 3 '962001II ' 4 '_Cantrell_,_P.J._  5 Affirmedand 6 remanded '7 'Rule11 ' 8 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Donnie_  9 Wheeler;recommendedthatthe : CourtofAppealsopinionbe ; published. 'f< ' '8= ' '8> ' '8? ' '8@ ' '8A ' '8B ' '8C ' StateofTennessee ZD vs. @E FrederickBrush ~&F M199900622SCR11CD 'd G 'StewartCriminal 'ZH 'RobertE.Burch 'ZI '41087CR98 'ZJ 'Hayes,J. ZK Vacatedand @L remanded;appeal ~&M dismissed 'd N 'Rule11 'ZO ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof ZP FrederickBrush '@Q ' StateofTennessee R vs. lS _Mell_ԀThomas_Bruton_ RT M199900956SCR11CD '8U 'DavidsonCriminal 'V 'CherylBlackburn 'W '98B1163 'X 'Smith,J. Y Affirmed 'lZ 'Rule11 '[ ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Mell_ \ Thomas_Bruton_ 'l] ' StateofTennessee  ^ vs. _ _Ricky_ԀRaymondBryan  ~` M199900854SCS09CD '!da 'RutherfordCircuit ' b 'JamesK.Clayton ' c 'F32368 ' d 'Williams,J.  e Affirmed 'f 'Rule11 ' g ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Ricky_  h RaymondBryan 'i ' StateofTennessee d  vs. J JosephStarling_Burris_ 0 M199901059SCR11CD 'n 'Rutherford 'd '_J.S._ԀSteveDaniel 'd 'F47015, d F46978 'J '_Woodall_,J. d  Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJoseph d  Starling_Burris_;recommended J  thattheCourtofCriminal 0 Appealsopinionbepublished. 'n ' StateofTennessee  vs. v GregoryCarson,Jr. \ M199900315SCR11CD ' B 'RutherfordCircuit ' '_J.S._ԀSteveDaniel J@  K@43609 K@J43609 I?4  K@43609  K@ I_Lafferty_,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofGregory  Carson,Jr. 'v ' StateofTennessee   vs.   James_Geddings_   M199900333SCR11CD ' n  '_Dickson_ԀCircuit '   'AllenW.Wallace ' ! 'CR4089 ' " 'Smith,J.  # Affirmedasmodified  $ andremanded ' % 'Rule11 ' & ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJames  ' _Geddings_ ' ( ' StateofTennessee @ ) vs. & * JimmyDaleHogan  + M199900013SCR11CD ', 'LawrenceCircuit '@ - 'WilliamB.Cain J@@ . @@18969@@J18,969 I?4@ / @@18969 @@ IOgle,J. @ 0 Affirmed '& 1 'Rule11 '@ 2 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJimmy @ 3 DaleHogan '& 4 ' StateofTennessee l5 vs. R6 SamuelD.Land 87 M199901023SCR11CD '8 'WilliamsonCircuit 'l9 'TimothyL.Easter 'l: 'II1098332 'l; 'Hayes,J. l< Affirmed 'R= 'Rule11 'l> ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSamuel l? D.Land 'R@ ' StateofTennessee @A vs. ~&B DarrenMatthewLee d C M199901625SCR11CD 'JD 'MarshallCircuit '@E 'WilliamC.Lee J@@F @13814@J13814 I?4@G @13814 @ ISmith,J. @H Affirmed '~&I 'Rule11 '@J ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDarren @K MatthewLee '~&L ' StateofTennessee lM vs. RN TerryLucas 8O M199800654SCR11CD 'vP 'RobertsonCriminal 'lQ 'RobertW. lR _Wedemeyer_ 'RS '980024 'lT '_Woodall_,J. lU Affirmed 'RV 'Rule11 'lW ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTerry lX Lucas 'RY ' StateofTennessee Z vs.  ~[ Edward_Pinchon_ !d\ M199900994SCR11CD '"J ] 'DavidsonCriminal '^ 'J.RandallWyatt '_ '98A307 '` '_Witt_,J. a Affirmed ' ~b 'Rule11 'c ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEdward d _Pinchon_ ' ~e ' StateofTennessee d  vs. J Jason_Ingram_ԀStokes 0 M199901892SCR11CD 'n 'GilesCriminal 'd 'JimT.Hamilton I?d  @7949 @I7949 H>3d  @7949  @ HHayes,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJason d  _Ingram_ԀStokes 'J  ' StateofTennessee   vs. v DannyRay_Trull_ \ M199900036SCR11CD ' B '_Hickman_ ' 'DonaldP.Harris ' '985043CRI ' 'Ogle,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDanny  Ray_Trull_ 'v ' StateofTennessee   vs.   _Tarrance_Ԁ_Latroy_ԀTurnerand_Jermaine_   Bradford  n  M199800115SCR11CD 'T  'DavidsonCriminal '  'SethW.Norman '  '97A49 '   '_Woodall_,J.  ! Affirmed ' " 'Rule11 ' # ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof  $ _Terrance_Ԁ_Latroy_ԀTurnerand  % _Jermaine_ԀBradford ' & ' MichaelO.Brown & ' vs.  ( KevinMyers,Warden ) M200000199SCR11PC '* 'WayneCircuit '& + 'JimT.Hamilton J@& , @12151@J12151 I?4& - @12151 @ I_Wedemeyer_,J. & . AffirmedRule20 ' / 'Rule11 '& 0 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMichael & 1 O.Brown ' 2 ' BillyMerle_Meeks_ R3 vs. 84 StateofTennessee 5 M199800791SCR11PC '6 '_Grundy_ԀCircuit 'R7 'J.CurtisSmith I?R8 @5649@I5649 H>3R9 @5649 @ HOgle,J. R: Affirmed '8; 'Rule11 'R< ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBilly R= Merle_Meeks_ '8> ' '~&? ' '~&@ ' '~&A ' '~&B ' '~&C ' '~&D ' '~&E ' Dorothy_Inman_ԀEngland F vs. G DavidLeonard_Clendenin_Ԁandwife,Teresa lH Ann_Clendenin_ RI W199900625SCR11CV '8J 'BentonChancery 'K 'RonE.Harmon I?L @9724@I9724 H>3M @9724 @ HCrawford,J. N Affirmedasmodified 'O 'Rule11 'P ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDavid Q andTeresa_Clendenin_ 'R ' StephenPatterson  S vs. T SusanPatterson(_Yonavich_)  ~U W199901544SCR11CV '!dV 'ShelbyChancery ' W 'WalterL.Evans ' X 'D256221 ' Y 'Highers,J.  Z Reversed '[ 'Rule11 ' \ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSusan  ] Patterson '^ ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' StateofTennessee 6 vs.   _Damion_ԀCarrick   W199800655SCR11CD '  'ShelbyCriminal '6  'W.Fred_Axley_ '6  '9809360 '6 'Williams,J. 6 Affirmedasmodified ' 'Rule11 '6 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Damion_ 6 Carrick;opinionoftheCourtof  CriminalAppealsisdesignated   NotForCitationinaccordance  withSupremeCourtRule4,F 'v ' StateofTennessee H  vs. .  TerryLeeClifton   W199901745SCR11PC '  'MadisonCircuit 'H  'RoyB.Morgan, H  Jr. '.  'C99254 'H  'Hayes,J. H  DeniedRule28 .   Application ' ! 'Rule11 'H " ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTerry H # LeeClifton '. $ ' StateofTennessee t  % vs. Z & JoeMitchell @ ' W199901160SCR11CD '& ( '_Haywood_ԀCircuit 't  ) 'MarkAgee I?t  * 6@29716@I2971 H>3t  + 6@2971 6@ H_Woodall_,J. t  , Affirmed 'Z - 'Rule11 't  . ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJoe t  / Mitchell 'Z 0 ' StateofTennessee H1 vs. .2 EverettDaleRobinson l3 W199901348SCR11CD 'R4 'HenryCircuit 'H5 'JulianP._Guinn_ J@H6 &@12876&@J12876 I?4H7 &@12876 &@ IWelles,J. H8 Affirmedand .9 remanded 'l: 'Rule11 'H; ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEverett H< DaleRobinson '.= ' StateofTennessee t> vs. Z? AntonioSmith @@ W199901096SCR11CD '~&A 'ShelbyCriminal 'tB 'W.Fred_Axley_ 'tC '9704418 'tD 'Williams,J. tE Modifiedandaffirmed 'ZF 'Rule11 'tG ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAntonio tH Smith 'ZI ' EarnestC._Woodley_ J vs. K StateofTennessee lL W200001689SCR11PC 'RM 'ShelbyCriminal 'N ' 'O 'P13038 'P 'Riley,J. Q Deniedmotionfor R delayedappeal 'lS 'Rule11 'T ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofEarnest U C._Woodley_ 'V ' '$W ' '$X ' '$Y ' '$Z ' '$[ ' '$\ ' '$] ' AnnMarieRutherford_Keck_ F^ vs.  ,_ RichardLen_Keck_ j!` E199900371SCR11CV 'P"a 'Washington 'Fb 'JeanA.Stanley J@Fc @\@32113@\@J32113 I?4Fd @\@32113 @\@ IFranks,J. Fe Affirmedand  ,f remanded 'j!g 'Rule11 'Fh ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRichard Fi Len_Keck_ ' ,j ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' 'd ' StateofTennessee 6 vs.   _Shelia_ԀKayCooper   E199900220SCR11CD    'v  'AndersonCriminal '6  'JamesB.Scott,Jr. '6 '98CR0049 '6 '_Woodall_,J. 6 Affirmed ' 'Rule11 '6 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSheila 6 KayCooper;opinionofthe  CourtofCriminalAppealsis  designated NotForCitationin  accordancewithSupremeCourt v Rule4,F '\ ' StateofTennessee .  vs.   LutherRay_Dotson_,Jr.   E199900640SCR11CD '  'RheaCircuit '.  'J.CurtisSmith J@.  @14146@J14146 I?4.  @14146 @ I_Tipton_,J. .   Affirmed ' ! 'Rule11 '. " ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLuther . # Ray_Dotson_,Jr. ' $ ' StateofTennessee Z % vs. @ & HarveyPhillipHester & ' E200000647SCR11CD ' ( 'HamiltonCriminal 'Z ) 'StephenM._Bevil_ 'Z * '203252, Z + 203253, @ , 204200 '& - 'Wade,J. Z . Affirmed '@ / 'Rule11 'Z 0 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofHarvey Z 1 PhillipHester '@ 2 ' StateofTennessee .3 vs. l4 LarryAllenHicks R5 E199900957SCR11CD '86 'HamiltonCriminal '.7 'DouglasA.Meyer KA.8  A221717 AK221717 J@5.9  A221717  A JWelles,J. .: Reversedand l; remanded 'R< 'Rule11 '.= ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofLarry .> AllenHicks 'l? ' StateofTennessee Z@ vs. @A ThomasDee_Huskey_ ~&B E199900480SCS09CD 'd C 'KnoxCriminal 'ZD 'RichardR. ZE _Baumgartner_ J@@F W@51903W@J51903 I?4ZG W@51903 W@ I_Tipton_,J. ZH Rule9denied '@I 'Rule9 'ZJ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofThomas ZK Dee_Huskey_ '@L ' StateofTennessee M vs. lN JosephJohnHenry_Morrell_ RO E199900924SCR11CD '8P 'Sullivan 'Q 'PhyllisH.Miller 'R 'S41,018 'S 'Smith,J. T Affirmed 'lU 'Rule11 'V ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJoseph W JohnHenry_Morrell_ 'lX ' StateofTennessee  Y vs. Z RickieAlanOsborne  ~[ E199902278SCR11CD '!d\ 'SullivanCriminal ' ] 'PhyllisH.Miller J@ ^ @40366@J40366 I?4 _ @40366 @ I_Woodall_,J.  ` Affirmed 'a 'Rule11 ' b ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRickie  c A.Osborne 'd ' StateofTennessee d  vs. J MarkEdwardTaylor 0 E199901994SCR11CD 'n 'KnoxCriminal 'd 'RexHenryOgle 'd '62207A 'd '_Woodall_,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMark d  EdwardTaylor 'J  ' BrentAllen_Blye_Ԁ   vs. v StateofTennessee \ E199901141SCR11PC ' B 'SullivanCriminal ' 'R.JerryBeck ' 'C40,364 ' '_Woodall_,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBrent  Allen_Blye_ 'v ' '  ' '  ' '  ' '  ' '  ' '  '"  2 "X, ThefollowingRule11DismissalswerefiledtheweekofDecember4thDecember8th,2000    kX*%d3ddd dd dd dd dd dd " dd " %kH?kH?,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ," dd +  $j #j  $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER '& $" 'COUNTY '& %" 'TRIALJUDGE '& &" 'TRIAL & ' COURTNO. ' (" 'APPELLATE & ) JUDGE/JUDGMENT ' *" 'NATUREOF & + APPEAL ' ," 'ACTION '& -" '  RonaldL.Davis .. vs. l/ _Donal_ԀCampbell,Commissioner,etal R0 M199902294SCR11CV '81 'DavidsonChancery '.2 'IrvinH._Kilcrease_, .3 _Jr._ 'l4 '991243I '.5 '_Cantrell_,J. .6 Affirmedand l7 remanded 'R8 'Rule11 '.9 ' Dismissed 󀄀Applicationof .: RonaldL.Davis,onhismotion."l;  "