WPC #n+ Ni1DWbVf= O݇ (:hV9 D{CmˊGg1U70oDl,l_X+K'Fl'J1QZ'I̻ \hLDTh.U8j}<| _3^*iʩG߉!f!9MHd_s8$Rr @R4EzEl n7mi/n`i,rĎ/|uLV\] >AB2j0j=[rfH-G͆zcY6},ocĺ &,> o%AhHũq\Zue՛53ammʷAD>-~/*fؼ2uW-e* i6 z@<}%=H@? ȢM5:TAߙ7d&2'6# UNM % 0( f a  ww 4{  B N ^  m 0l 0Dsssssf B 0D::~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ D-DDDDDDDDDDDD 04qqqq A 0KDHP LaserJet 4050 Series PCL 6,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A  $    1    _ԀItappearsfromtherecordinthiscasethattheapplicationforpermissiontoappealwasnottimelyfiled,andthisCourtis X thereforewithoutjurisdictiontoconsiderthemeritsoftheapplication.SeeRule11(b)andRule2,TennesseeRulesofAppellate > Procedure.,-d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd8C-s U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5)!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3 Letter Landscape3'TXXXX  g 0  @*8181SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS > @. December16,2002 $   @@7,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,dd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATURE :  OFAPPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' Ellen_Hensley_  ( v. f   WilsonSportingGoodsand L  LumbermensMutualCasualtyCo. 2  M200202525SCS09CV '  'FranklinChancery  ( JeffreyF.Stewart f   15,604 'L  ' ' ( 'Rule9 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilsonSporting  ( GoodsCompanyandLumbermens f   MutualCasualtyCompany. L   '2  ' DavidDouglasOConnell :  v. x  MetropolitanGovernmentof ^  Nashville&DavidsonCounty,TN. D! M200100491SCR11CV '*" 'DavidsonCircuit : # WalterC.Kurtz x $ 98C974 '^% '_Cantrell_,J. : & Affirmed& x ' Remanded. '^( 'Rule11 ': ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDavidDouglas : * OConnell. x +  '^, ' _Kymberly_ԀLynneHaas L- v. 2. AlbertJamesHaas p/ M200002850SCR11CV 'V0 'DavidsonCircuit L1 MurielRobinson 22 99D3509 'p3 'Ash,Sp.J. L4 AffirmedinPart; 25 ReversedinPart; p6 RemandedinPart. 'V7 'Rule11 'L8 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Kymberly_ԀLynn L9 AnneHaas. 2:  'p; ' Dexter_McMillan_ x< v. ^= TennesseeBoardofProbationand D> Parole *? M200101843SCR11CV 'h@ 'DavidsonChancery xA EllenH.Lyle ^B 011260I 'DC 'Cottrell,J. xD Affirmed& ^E Remanded. 'DF 'Rule11 'xG ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDexter xH _McMillan_. ^I  'DJ ' InTheMatterOf:TheEstateof K John(_N.M.N._)Marin,Deceased pL M200102292SCR11CV 'VM 'LawrenceProbate N LeeA.England pO 11522 'VP '_Highers_,J. Q Reversed& pR Remanded. 'VS 'Rule11 'T ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAudreyMartin U Marlow. pV  'VW ' g  8aXXdd8    AllenD._Shoffner_ԀandEdnaJ. d _Shoffner_ԀasTrusteeofTheAllenD. J _Shoffner_ԀandEdnaJ._Shoffner_ 0 FamilyLivingTrust,andMichael n  A._Shoffner_ԀandLindaG._Shoffner_ T v. : _CSX_ԀTransportation   M200202323SCS09CV '  '_Beford_ԀCircuit d  FranklinL.Russell J  8345 '0  '_Cantrell_,J. d  Cain,J. J  Cottrell,J. 0 Rule9Denied. 'n 'Rule9 'd ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_CSX_ d Transportation. J  '0 ' RobertW._Chagrasulis_,M.D.  ( V. f   TennesseeBoardofMedical L  Examiners 2  M200101595SCR11CV '  'DavidsonChancery  ( IrvinH._Kilcrease_,Jr. f   001866I 'L  '_Cantrell_,J.  ( Affirmed& f   Remanded. 'L  'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertW.  (  _Chagrasulis_. f  !  'L " ' ': # ' ': $ ' ': % ' ': & ' ': ' ' TerryW.Smith  ( v. ) StateofTennessee * M200103062SCR11CD 'f+ '_Cheatham_ԀCircuit  , RobertE.Burch - 12158,12158A '. 'Riley,J.  / Affirmed. '0 'Rule11 ' 1 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTerryW.Smith.  2  '3 ' StateofTennessee 84 v. 5 TracyF.Leonard 6 M200100368SCR11CD '7 'MontgomeryCircuit 88 RobertW._Wedemeyer_ 9 40494 ': 'Williams,J. 8; AffirmedinPart; < ReversedinPartand = RemandedinPart. '> 'Rule11 '8? ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTracyF. 8@ Leonard. A  'C ' SteveMurphy d D v. JE StateofTennessee 0F M200100886SCR11PC 'G 'DavidsonCriminal d H J.RandallWyatt,Jr. JI 95B856 '0J 'Smith,J. d K Affirmed. 'JL 'Rule11 'd M ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSteveMurphy. d N  'JO ' BlakeE._Hallum_ 8P v. vQ StateofTennessee \R M200100569SCR11PC 'B S 'DavidsonCriminal 8T J.RandallWyatt,Jr. vU 94D2286 '\V 'Smith,J. 8W Affirmed. 'vX 'Rule11 '8Y ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBlakeE. 8Z _Hallum_.TheCourtisalsodenyingthe v[ requesttoholdtheRule11inabeyance \\ pendingawritoferrorcoram_nobis_ B ] proceeding. '(!^ ' '"J _ ' '"J ` ' '"J a ' '"J b ' '"J c ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   StateofTennessee d v. J _Kristopher_ԀRoberts 0 W200101702SCR11JV 'n '_Tipton_ԀJuvenile d JosephH.Walker J 5401 '0 'Farmer,J. d Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Kristopher_ d  Roberts. J   '0  ' InTheMatterOf_D.L.B._,AMinor  W200102245SCR11CV 'v 'ShelbyChancery  KennyArmstrong v Ch0102002 '\ '_Highers_,J.  Affirmed. 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofDavidMoore.   'v ' TrentWrightMarcus .  v.   LorraineBurton_Spiers_Ԁ(Marcus)   W200100906SCR11CV '  'ShelbyCircuit .  GeorgeH.Brown,Jr.   3057816T.D. '  '_Lillard_,J. .  Affirmed. '   'Rule11 '. ! ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLorraine_Spiers_. . "  ' # ' ConstanceCherryandMarcus Z $ Cherry,asNextofKinofSteven @ % Cherry,Deceased & & v.  ' StateofTennessee ( W200100038SCR11CV ') 'TennesseeClaims Z * Commission @ + RandyC.Camp & , 98001883 ' - '_Lillard_,J. Z . Affirmed. '@ / 'Rule11 'Z 0 ' Dismissed 󀄀ApplicationofConstance Z 1 andMarcusCherry. #  1      '@ 2 ' MachinerySalesCo.,Inc. R3 v. 84 _Diamondcut_ԀForestryProducts, 5 LLC,ColumbiaTrading,Inc.,and 6 ChampionInternationalCorp. 7 W200102244SCR11CV 'x8 'ShelbyChancery R9 WalterEvans 8: CH0006591 ;  '< 'Crawford,J. R= Affirmed& 8> Remanded. '? 'Rule11 'R@ ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMachinerySales RA Company,Inc. 8B  'C ' _Lillard_ԀAnthonyWatts JD v. 0E TheKrogerCompany F W200101834SCR11CV 'G 'ShelbyCircuit JH Rita_Stotts_ 0I CT00708400 'J 'Crawford,J. JK Affirmed& 0L Remanded. 'M 'Rule11 'JN ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Lillard_ԀAnthony JO Watts. 0P  'Q ' Nora_Eddings_ԀandSylvester d  _Eddings_Ԁ J v. 0 SearsRoebuck&Co. n W200101107SCR11CV 'T 'ShelbyCircuit d RobertA.Lanier J 3003827T.D. '0 '_Highers_,J. d  Affirmed. 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofNoraand d  Sylvester_Eddings_. J   'n ' 'v ' 'v ' 'v ' 'v ' 'v ' StateofTennessee H  v. .  WilliamJ.Ford   W200001205SCR11CD '  'ShelbyCriminal H  ChrisCraft .  9911016 '  'Smith,J. H  Affirmed. '.  'Rule11 'H  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilliamJ.Ford. H   '.   ' StateofTennessee t  ! v. Z " ReginaldD.Terry @ # W200103027SCR11CD '& $ 'ShelbyCriminal t  % W.Fred_Axley_ Z & 9803934 '@ ' '_Wedemeyer_,J. t  ( Affirmedon Z ) Remand. '@ * 'Rule11 't  + ' Granted 󀄀ApplicationofReginaldD. t  , Terry. Z -  '@ . ' StateofTennessee H/ v. .0 RobertS.Clark l1 W200100921SCR11CD 'R2 'ShelbyCriminal H3 W.Otis_Higgs_,Jr. .4 9906263;9906264 'l5 'Wade,J. H6 Affirmed. '.7 'Rule11 'H8 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRobertS.Clark. H9  '.: ' StateofTennessee t; v. Z< Wilson_Neely_ @= W200101327SCR11CD '~&> 'ShelbyCriminal t? ChrisCraft Z@ 9810092 '@A '_Witt_,J. tB Affirmed. 'ZC 'Rule11 'tD ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofWilson_Neely_. tE  'ZF ' Joe_Hibbler_,III G v. H StateofTennessee lI W200100449SCR11PC 'RJ 'ShelbyCriminal K JohnP._Colton_,Jr. L P10318,P13805,P lM 16922 'RN '_Witt_,J. O Affirmed. 'P 'Rule11 'Q ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJoe_Hibbler_,III. R  'S ' _Darron_ԀClayton $T v.  U StateofTennessee V W200200707SCR11CO ' ~W 'ShelbyCriminal $X JosephP.Dailey  Y P26055 Z  ' ~[ 'Glenn,J. $\ Rule20Affirmed. ' ] 'Rule11 '$^ ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Darron_ԀClayton. $_  ' ` ' 'P"a ' 'P"b ' 'P"c ' 'P"d ' 'P"e ' _Kasiea_Ԁ_Delawn_ԀChance,EtAl. d v. J CarlDennisGibson,Jr. 0 E200102836SCR11JV 'n '_Sevier_ԀJuvenile d JeffreyD._Rader_ J 01M6469 '0 '_Goddard_,J. d AffirmedinPart; J  VacatedinPart; 0  Remanded. 'n  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCarlDennis d  Gibson,Jr. J  '0 ' Cityof_Sevierville_  v. v BillGreen,EtAl. \ E200102467SCR11CV ' B '_Sevier_ԀCircuit  RichardR.Vance v 0719411&9719511 '\ '_Goddard_,J.  Affirmed& v Remanded. '\ 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationoftheCityof  _Sevierville_. v  '\ ' CoryJacobRose,EtAl.   v.   ParkRidgeHospital,Inc.,d/b/a   EastRidgeHospital  n ! E200201743SCS09CV 'T " 'HamiltonCircuit  # SamuelH.Payne  $ 98C0825 ' % '_Goddard_,J.  & Rule9Denied. ' ' 'Rule9 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCoryJacob  ) Rose.  *  ' + ' '& , ' '& - ' '& . ' '& / ' '& 0 ' StateofTennessee H1 v. .2 JackDeforest_Bolden_ l3 E200102846SCR11CD 'R4 'KnoxCriminal H5 RichardR._Baumgartner_ .6 68293,71538 'l7 'Riley,J. H8 Affirmed. '.9 'Rule11 'H: ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJackDeforest H; _Bolden_. .< __ 'l= ' StateofTennessee t> v. Z? DavidMichaelLong @@ E200103086SCR11PC '~&A '_McMinn_ԀCircuit tB CarrollL.Ross ZC 01268 '@D 'Wade,J. tE Affirmed. 'ZF 'Rule11 'tG ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDavidMichael tH Long. ZI  '@J ' Henry_Cephus_ԀBond K v. L StateofTennessee lM E200101948SCR11PC 'RN 'KnoxCircuit O RayJenkins P 72489 'lQ '_Witt_,J. R AffirmedPursuant S toRule20. 'lT 'Rule11 'U ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofHenry_Cephus_ V Bond. W  'lX '_ DavidMcNish $Y v.  Z StateofTennessee [ E200102633SCR11PC ' ~\ 'CarterCircuit $] RobertE.Cupp  ^ 9612 '_ 'Wade,J. $` Rule28Denied. ' a 'Rule11 '$b ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDavidMcNish. $c "e $ "X,