WPC jM0b:!= BKq;e">O7n/$Lsuz~E@_l+TS=l~5ϸçbg&1DtB({E" 23QHy1DŽJn.=/DVC-H>( 1\| k"}.xXP%cu.7~94JP$,f$چX[ơg<~S/my/bh`eOyEMi(-PU~Y 8.jXgKvٹlD,j'Z3gzŌcZĺ:++R,ZaʋGzɓQ;?r=,O FVSV8 ,|+]N4zV{gJ<ڝ5SnB`J=Tݗ5-z?C.NY`]Dr *mZ`# U NM % 0( f a  w 4  B N ^  m 0l 0D.f B??????????????????????????????????????????????????????? 0D\\ D-ffffffffffff 04 A 0KfHP LaserJet 4050 Series PCL 6,,,,0(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A  $    3    _AppellantsMotiontoGranttheRule11ApplicationandConsidertheMeritsorVacatetheCourtofCriminalAppeals X OpinionandRemandforFurtherProceedingsandAppellantsMotiontoVacatetheCourtofCriminalAppealsOrderPreventingUse > oftheDirectAppealRecordaredenied.F+d 3|x 88zPXXdXXd8n+s U((3$ !      0  (#$  0   $ $    4    _TheCourt,havingconsideredallerrorssetoutintheapplication,isparticularlyinterestedinthefollowingissuesatoral X argument:1)WhethertheCourtofCriminalAppealsappliedadilutedconstitutionalharmlesserrorstandardwhenitconcludedthat >  anyerrorwasharmlessbeyondareasonabledoubt,becauseitmoreprobablythannotdidnotaffectthejudgmenttotheprejudiceof $ thedefendant.2)Whetherthefailureofthetrialcourttoinstructthejuryonrecklesshomicideandcriminallynegligenthomicideas   lesserincludedoffensesoffelonymurderwasharmlesserrorunderStatev.Williams,977S.W.2d101(Tenn.1998),becausethejury  hadtheopportunitytoconvictoffacilitationoffelonymurder.3)Whetherthetrialcourterredbyfailingtoinstructanylesser ~ includedoffensesofespeciallyaggravatedrobbery.  $    1    _TheCourtisparticularlyinterestedin,andthepartiesaredirectedtobrief,thefollowingissue:Howdoestheburdenofproof X ontheissueofinsanityaffectthestandardofreviewofthejurysfindingsoninsanity?Thisstatementoftheissuesfororalargument > doesnotpreventthepartiesfromraisingadditionalissuespursuanttoRule13(a),Tenn.R.App.P.  $    2    _TheapplicationisherebygrantedforthesolepurposeofremandingthecasetotheCourtofCriminalAppealsfor X reconsiderationinlightofthisCourtsopinioninStatev.Ely,43S.W.3d710(Tenn.2001).InEly,thisCourtheldthatfailureto > instructonlesserincludedoffensesimplicatestheconstitutionalrighttotrialbyjury.We,therefore,remandthiscasetotheCourtof $ CriminalAppealstoconsiderwhetherthisissueis plainerrorwarrantingreviewdespitethedefendantsfailuretoincludeitinhis   MotionforNewTrial. \\R'3 Letter Landscape\ d(3$ !  ݁Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5)!dxdx&c$""0 ^\x I&mage <=8C HKKKK( $ Figure  1  !  _TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeX3' Letter'3 Letter Landscape3'TXXXX  g @*SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @&SUPREMECOURTDISCRETIONARYAPPEALS > @/ December17,20010 x   (#  %  '  0*  , $x81x81 @7 ,X*%wddd Xdd Xdd X,81,81, dd ,dd ,Sdd ,Fdd , dd +  $~~ $STYLE/APPEALNUMBER ':" 'COUNTY : TRIALJUDGE   TRIALCOURTNO. '  " 'APPELLATE :  JUDGE    JUDGMENT '  " 'NATUREOF :  APPEAL ' " 'ACTION ':" ' JuliaSledgeLeachBryan  ( vs. f   JamesWendellLeach L  M199800922SCR11CV '2  'MauryChancery  ( JimHamilton f   91540 'L  'Cottrell,J.  ( Affirmedas f   modifiedand L  remanded '2  'Rule11 ' ( ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesWendell  ( Leach;publicationoftheCourtof f   Appealsopinionisrecommended. 'L  ' DarrellD.Cannon T  vs. :  &n3%XXDept.ofCorrection,StateofTN,etal#XnX%&n3#  x !  M200001950SCR11CV 'L" 'DavidsonChancery T # IrvinH._Kilcrease_,Jr. : $ 991076I 'x % 'Farmer,J. T & Affirmedand : ' remanded 'x ( 'Rule11 'T ) ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDarrellD. T * Cannon ': + ' _Tarrance_ԀRobinson n, vs. T- Cpl.NeilClement,etal :. M200100365SCR11CV 'x / 'DavidsonChancery n0 EllenH.Lyle T1 002928III ':2 'Koch,J. n3 Affirmed 'T4 'Rule11 'n5 ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Tarrance_ n6 Robinson 'T7 ' &n3%XXnStateofTNDept.ofChildrens_Svcs_.#XnX%&n3 # 8 Vs. n9 _Niki_ԀLynnCrawfordThomas T: M200001655SCR11JV ':; 'CannonJuvenile < JohnB._Melton_,III = 847 'f> '_Highers_,J. ? Affirmed '@ 'Rule11 'A ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Niki_ԀLynn B CrawfordThomas 'C ' ChristinaMae_Stroud_Ԁ(Read)  D vs. E JimmyRay_Stroud_ F M199902239SCR11CV 'fG 'DavidsonCircuit  H MurielRobinson I 90D2910 'J 'Cottrell,J.  K Affirmedand L remanded 'M 'Rule11 ' N ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofChristinaMae  O _Stroud_;&n3%XXnopinionoftheCourtofAppealsis P designated NotforCitationinaccordance Q withSupremeCourtRule4,F#XnX%&n3# 'TR ' _Warbington_ԀConstruction,Inc. 8S vs.  T FranklinLandmark,LLC !U M200000676SCR11CV '!V 'DavidsonChancery 8W IrvinH._Kilcrease_,Jr.  X 993459I '!Y 'Highers,J. 8Z Reversedand  [ remanded '!\ 'Rule11 '8] ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofFranklin 8^ LandmarkLLC ' _ ' 'd# !` ' 'd# !a ' 'd# !b ' 'd# !c '_ 'd# !d ' g  8nXXdd8    StateofTennessee  d  vs. J RussellAllen 0 M200001656SCR11CD 'n 'MauryCircuit d RobertJones J 11192 '0 'Ogle,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRussellAllen 'd  ' StateofTennessee    vs. v  NicholasWilliams \ M199900780SCR11CD ' B 'GilesCircuit  JimHamilton v 96498652 '\ '_Wedemeyer_,J.  Affirmedinpartand v reversedinpart '\ 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofNicholas  Williams 'v ' AllanPrestonBrooks   vs.   StateofTennessee    M200000909SCR11PC ' n  'DavidsonCriminal   WalterKurtz   90W80 '  'Smith,J.    Affirmed ' ! 'Rule11 ' " ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAllanPreston  # Brooks ' $ ' DeborahLouiseReese @ % vs. & & StateofTennessee   ' M200002553SCR11PC '( 'RutherfordCircuit @ ) _J.S._ԀSteveDaniel & * 48592 ' + 'Ogle,J. @ , Affirmed '& - 'Rule11 '@ . ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofDeborahLouise @ / Reese '& 0 ' 'l1 ' 'l2 ' 'l3 ' 'l4 ' 'l5 ' Rick_Roelke_ 6 vs. t7 William_Hickerson_,etal Z8 W200000455SCR11CV '@9 'ShelbyCircuit : KarenR.Williams t; 3034153T.D. 'Z< '_Lillard_,J. = Affirmed 't> 'Rule11 '? ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofRick_Roelke_ '@ ' BarbaraWhite A vs. B John_Albritton_,etal C W200003068SCR11CV 'lD 'ShelbyCircuit E JamesF.Russell F 624142 'G 'Highers,J. H Affirmed 'I 'Rule11 'J ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBarbaraWhite'K ' TRP$'3 Letter LandscapeP$'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter Landscape'3 Letter LandscapeT   StateofTennessee d vs. J ChristopherM.Flake 0 W200001131SCR11CD 'n 'ShelbyCriminal d Bernie_Weinman_ J 9709256 '0 'Riley,J. d XXnReversedandremanded; J  modifiedsentencetonot b   guiltybyreasonof "  insanity#XnX(# '  'Rule11 'd  ' Granted ApplicationofStateof d Tennessee #  1      'J ' StateofTennessee 6 vs.  JamesR._Hankins_   W199900529SCR11PC '  'ShelbyCriminal 6 W.Fred_Axley_  P19859 '  '_Witt_,J. 6 Affirmedinpart;  reversedinpart '  'Rule11 '6 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJamesR. 6 _Hankins_ ' ' StateofTennessee b  vs. H  AlbertJohnson .  W200001694SCR11CD '  'ShelbyCriminal b ! W.Fred_Axley_ H " 9806889 '. # 'Riley,J. b $ Affirmed 'H % 'Rule11 'b & ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofAlbertJohnson 'b ' ' StateofTennessee 6 ( vs. t) MarcusPolk Z* W200001057SCR11PC '@+ 'ShelbyCriminal 6 , JosephB.Dailey t- P20491 'Z. 'Ogle,J. 6 / Affirmed 't0 'Rule11 '6 1 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofMarcusPolk '6 2 ' StateofTennessee b3 vs. H4 ReginaldD.Terry .5 W200000090SCR11CD 'l6 'ShelbyCriminal b7 W.Fred_Axley_ H8 9803934 '.9 '_Wedemeyer_,J. b: Affirmed 'H; 'Rule11 'b< ' Granted ApplicationofReginald b= TerryB #  2       'H> ' StateofTennessee d vs. J  Shawn_Tolliver_ 0 W200000834SCR11PC 'n 'ShelbyCriminal d ChrisCraft J P20924 '0 'Williams,J. d Affirmed 'J  'Rule11 'd  ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofShawn_Tolliver_ 'd  ' BobbyJ.Armstrong   vs. v  StateofTennessee  \ W200002598SCR11PC ' B 'MadisonCircuit  RoyB.Morgan,Jr. v C00237 '\ 'Hayes,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofBobbyJ.  Armstrong 'v ' Teresa_Deion_ԀSmithHarris   vs.   StateofTennessee    W200002611SCR11PC ' n  'HenryCircuit   JulianP._Guinn_   13023 '  'Riley,J.   Affirmed '  'Rule11 ' ! ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofTeresa_Deion_  " SmithHarris #  3      ' # ' _Tarran_Ԁ_Kyles_ @ $ vs. & % StateofTennessee   & W200002152SCR11PC '' 'MadisonCircuit @ ( RoyB.Morgan,Jr. & ) C00247 ' * 'Hayes,J. @ + Affirmed '& , 'Rule11 '@ - ' Denied 󀄀Applicationof_Tarran_Ԁ_Kyles_ '@ . ' JerryL.Luster l/ vs. R0 J.LarryCraven 81 W200002217SCR11CO '2 'MadisonCircuit l3 RoyB.Morgan,Jr. R4 C00238I '85 'Clark,J. l6 Affirmed 'R7 'Rule11 'l8 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJerryL.Luster 'l9 ' '@: ' '@; ' '@< ' '@= ' '@> ' &n3%XXnStateofTNDept.ofChildrensSvcs.#XnX%&n3?# ? vs. @ JacquelineDiana_Rucker_ tA Inre:_S.D.R._,d/o/b10/1/97  ZB  E200101163SCR11JV '@C '_Roane_ԀJuvenile D ThomasA.Austin E DennisW.Humphrey F 10117 'lG 'Franks,J. H Affirmed 'I 'Rule11 'J ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJacqueline K Diana_Rucker_ 'L ' 'M ' 'N ' 'O ' 'P ' 'Q ' StateofTennessee  d vs. J HaroldGreen 0 E200000616SCR11CD 'n 'AndersonCriminal d JamesB.Scott,Jr. J 99CR0068 '0 '_Tipton_,J. d Reversed 'J  'Rule10 'd  ' Granted ApplicationofHaroldGreen 'd  ' StateofTennessee    vs. v  Steve_Hilliard_ \ E200002819SCS09CD ' B 'HamiltonCriminal  DouglasA.Meyer v 224113&224114 '\ '_Wedemeyer_,J.  Affirmed 'v 'Rule11 ' ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofSteve_Hilliard_ ' ' StateofTennessee    vs.   _Takeita_ԀM.Locke   E200000923SCR11CD ' n  'KnoxCriminal   RichardR._Baumgartner_   67739 '  'Glenn,J.   Affirmed '  'Rule11 '   ' Granted Applicationof _Takeita_ԀM.  ! Locke #  4      ' " ' StateofTennessee  @ # vs. & $ CharlesE.Mitchell  % E200100373SCR11PC '& 'KnoxCriminal @ ' RayJenkins & ( 71076 ' ) 'Glenn,J. @ * Affirmed '& + 'Rule11 '@ , ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofCharlesE. @ - Mitchell '& . ' StateofTennessee l/ vs. R0 LarryD._Upshaw_ 81 E200002262SCR11CD '2 'KnoxCriminal l3 RayL.Jenkins R4 67242 '85 'Wade,J. l6 Affirmed 'R7 'Rule11 'l8 ' Denied 󀄀ApplicationofLarryD. l9 _Upshaw_"R: "X,%