WPC#, d0{k&.\PӋS䏊7_Z4G?r]Xc[{u Ro<y [p ʌGiŨ37:ɐ/b ,.ft^ DcFy=!\i8E~f#pJx"o5e˦.B%r[l};93SUp\v$j7I %Ix䠸TS6!~Th wx! ,s@ hyRk1uT K3_fœ=Wt$<}o|ϥ_k RN.B !;6='u(BT+gX|š˄8$G&AG|h>D$$&# UN %m 0(sfa-w@42 h%AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA B,HP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nLh(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A ##Xd# [H$d 3|x?X@&@?@&@?X@&@?X@&@?@T@&@?W@&@?&@?~@&@ ?   w@  &@  ?   @W@  &@  ?   D@  &@  ?   W@  &@  ?   @W@  &@ ?W@&@?X@&@?X@&@?؈&@?R@&@@1@&@@@4@&@@X@&@@X@&@@@&@@@&@@X@&@@@W@&@@t&@@W@&@@W@&@@W@4@&@ @   @X@ 4@ &@ !@!!!W@!!&@!"@"""X@""&@"#@###W@##&@#$@$$$$$&@$%@%%%W@%%&@%&@&&&@X&4@&&@&'@'''W@''&@'(@(((W@((&@()@)))W@))&@)*@***[@**&@*,@,,,X@,,&@,-@---@--&@-.@...W@..&@./@///7@//&@/0@000Ԧ@00&@01@111@11&@12@222X22&@23@333 @33&@34@444pA44&@45@555b@55&@56@666@66&@67@777@77&@78@888) A88&@89@999@W99&@9:@::: @::&@:;@;;;@;;&@;TABLE A d !  XXTRZ'ALegal Landscape3''ALegal Landscape3'T@9 SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @??5 STATELISTFORPERMISSIONTOAPPEAL@> November2,1998 %  '  0*  ,  .  81  3  5  @8  0 XX*w%Xddd Xdd Xdd XXH?XH?w,<dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ," dd +    STYLE/APPEALNUMBER 'X" 'COUNTY 'X" 'TRIALJUDGE 'X" 'TRIALCOURTNO. 'D " 'APPELLATEJUDGE/JUDGMENT 'D " 'NATUREOFAPPEAL 'D" 'ACTION X" DannyCardvs.TennesseeCivilServiceCommission,etal.  D  (01A019709CH00496)   0  DavidsonChancery   l IrvinH.Kilcrease,Jr.   X 96734I   l BenH.Cantrell,P.J.AffirmedandRemanded   D  Rule11   l  Denied ApplicationofDanny  l Card   \ OlanEnglandandRobertWhitleyvs.SelectSires,Inc.,etal.   (01A019705CV00204)  t! GilesCircuit   " WilliamB.Cain 7-  # @2142@72142 7-+ $ @2142 @ 7AlanE.HighersReversedandRemanded   ' Rule11   (  Denied Applicationof  ) TennesseeArtificialBreedingandApplicationofOlanEngland   + DwayneHawkinsandAlGossettvs.PatrickA.Hart,etal. $. (01A019707CV00294)  / DavidsonCircuit  L0 BarbaraN.Haynes  L1 96C2528  L2 HenryF.ToddModifiedandRemanded  $5 Rule11  L6  Granted Applicationof L7 SuperiorMotors,Inc.AndPatrickA.Hart  (9 RobertL.Ogburnvs.TennesseeDepartmentofCorrection,etal. h< (01A019707CH00284)  T= DavidsonChancery  8> CarolMcCoy  8? 961806I(II)  8@ BenH.Cantrell,P.J.AffirmedandRemanded  hC Rule11  8D  Denied ApplicationofRogert 8E L.Ogburn  (F VirginiaGrafWaddeyvs.IraClintonWaddey,Jr.(01A019708CV00374)  @J DavidsonCircuit  |K RobertCorlew,III  |L 81D2266  |M HenryF.ToddAffirmedandRemanded  TP Rule11  |Q  Granted Applicationof |R VirginiaGrafWaddey  lS WilliamWare,etal. T vs.MichaelC.Greene,Commissioner(01A019604CH00170)  !W DavidsonChancery  X RobertS.Brandt  Y 952493III  Z WilliamC.Koch,Jr.AffirmedandRemanded   ] Rule11  ^  Denied ApplicationofWilliam _ Ware   ` 7nXXdXXd7  DavidCarney d vs. StateofTennessee(01C019612CR00518)  ( DavidsonCriminal  d AnnLacyJohns  d C7303  d JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofDavid d  Carney  T  ChadSwatzellvs.StateofTennessee(01C019604CC00154)   l WilliamsonCriminal   HenryDenmarkBell   495138   JerryL.SmithAffirmed   Rule11    Denied ApplicationofChad  Swatzell   JamesYatesvs.StateofTennessee(01C019707CC00299)    HickmanCriminal  D  DonaldP.Harris  D  955100C  D   DavidG.HayesAffirmed  0 " Rule11  D #  Denied ApplicationofJames D $ Yates   StateofTennesseevs.RalphCedricallen(01C019612CC00538)    RobertsonCriminal  D  JohnGasaway,III 7- D  w@9455w@79455 7-+D   w@9455 w@ 7WilliamM.BarkerAffirmed  0 " Rule11  D #  Denied ApplicationofRalph D $ CedricAllen(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)   & StateofTennesseevs.TimothyLeronBrown(01C019701CR00032)  L* DavidsonCriminal  0 + RandallWyatt  0 , 93A155  0 - JosephM.TiptonAffirmed  t/ Rule11  0 0  Denied,concurringindecision 0 1 ofCourtofCriminalAppealsinresultsonly Applicationof `3 TimothyL.Brown  P4 StateofTennesseevs.TommyGeneClinton(01C019608CR00381)  <8 PutnamCriminal  x9 LeonC.Burns,Jr.  x: 94381  x; DavidH.WellesAffirmed  d= Rule11  x>  Denied ApplicationofTommy x? GeneClinton  P4 StateofTennesseevs.JerryRayCooper(01C019604CC00150)  <8 LincolnCriminal  x9 WilliamCharlesLee  d; 04095  x< PaulG.SummersReversedandRemanded  P? Rule11  x@  GrantedandRemanded  xA ApplicationofStateofTennessee  TC StateofTennesseevs.JamesFernandez(01C019609CR00394)  G DavidsonCriminal  H AnnLacyJohns  I 94B896  J ThomasT.WoodallAffirmed  L Rule11  M  Denied 󀄀ApplicationofJames N Fernandez  O StateofTennesseevs.SamuelPaulFields(01C019512CR00414)  S DavidsonCriminal  XT AnnLacyJohns  XU 93D1628  XV JerryL.SmithAffirmed  DX Rule11  XY  Denied ApplicationofSamuel XZ PaulFields  H[ StateofTennesseevs.CharlesGasaway (01C019703CR00101)  ( DavidsonCriminal  d ThomasH.Shriver  P 95A128  d JohnH.PeayConvictionsAffirmed/SentencesModified  (  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofRayC. d Gasaway  T StateofTennesseevs.GaryL.Green(01C019706CR00207)   l DavidsonCriminal   ThomasH.Shriver   96A32   JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed   Rule11    Denied ApplicationofGaryL.  Green   StateofTennesseevs.BrianKeithHarding(01C019703CC00103)    HickmanCriminal  D ! CorneliaA.Clark  D " 965083CR,965084CRand965092CR   & JohnH.PeayAffirmed  0 ( Rule11  D )  Denied ApplicationofBrian D * KeithHarding  4 + StateofTennesseevs.MarkF.Maybrey(01C019703CC00117)  L/ RutherfordCriminal  0 0 JosephS.Daniel  0 1 M39023andM39024  t3 JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed  t5 Rule11  0 6  Denied ApplicationofMarkF. 0 7 Maybrey  4 + StateofTennesseevs.JerryM.Mullican(01C019607CC00282)  L/ WilliamsonCriminal  0 0 DonaldP.Harris  0 1 I795201  0 2 JerryL.SmithAffirmed  t4 Rule11  0 5  Denied ApplicationofJerryM. 0 6 Mullican  x 7 StateofTennesseevs.RichardD.Sawyer(01C019705CC00199)  8; FranklinCriminal  t< BuddyD.Perry 8. t= R@10404R@810404 8.,t> R@10404 R@ 8GaryR.WadeAffirmed  `@ Rule11  tA  Denied ApplicationofRichard tB D.Sawyer(Barker,J.,NotParcipating)  PD StateofTennesseevs.SueAnnTidwell(01C019610CR00445)  |H DavidsonCriminal  I ThomasH.Shriver  K GSA2471  L DavidH.WellesAffirmed  N Rule11  O  Denied ApplicationofSue P AnnTidwell  PD   E   F   G   H   I   J   K KelloggCompany,etc.vs.StateBoardofEqualization(02A019612CH00302)  TO ShelbyChancery  8P NealSmall  8Q 1072901R.D.  8R DavidR.FarmerReversedandRemanded  hU Rule11  8V  Denied ApplicationofState 8W BoardofEqualization,etal., (X ShelbyCountyAssessor,etal.  lY LeeC.Hamrickvs.StateofTennessee(02C019609CR00294)   @] ShelbyCriminal  |^ BernieWeinman  |_ P17005  |` JerryL.SmithAffirmedPursuanttoRule20  Tc Rule11  |d  Denied ApplicationofLeeC. |e Hamrick  lf JamesE.Hayes vs.BillyCompton,Warden(02C019610CC00326)  ( LakeCriminal  d R.LeeMoore  d 967507  d JerryL.SmithAffirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofJames d  E.Hayes  T  DemetriusRobertsonvs.StateofTennessee(02C019706CR00220)   l ShelbyCriminal   JosephBrown,Jr.   9603040   GaryR.WadeAffirmed   Rule11    Denied Applicationof  DemetriusR.Robertson   BarryWellsvs.RonniePickard,SheriffofLauderdaleCounty(02C019610CV00358)    LauderdaleCriminal  D  JoeH.Walker 7- D  @4850@74850 7-+D  @4850 @ 7JosephB.JonesAffirmed  0 ! Rule11  D "  GrantedandRemanded  D # ApplicationofBarryWells  4 $ StateofTennesseevs.LatavisDirayBailey(02C019703CC00115)  L( GibsonCriminal  0 ) DickJerman,Jr. 8. 0 * @15205@815205 8.,0 + @15205 @ 8ThomasT.WoodallAffirmed  t- Rule11  0 .  Denied ApplicationofLatavis 0 / DirayBailey  x 0 StateofTennesseevs.RobertDuaneBitner(02C019705CC00177)  84 CarrollCriminal  t5 CreedMcGinley  t6 96CR932  t7 ThomasT.WoodallAffirmed  `9 Rule11  t:  Denied ApplicationofRobert t; DuaneBitner  d< StateofTennesseevs.WilliamPaulBogus(02C019506CC00169)  |@ DyerCriminal  A R.LeeMoore  B C93448  C JosephM.TiptonAffirmed  E Rule11  F  Denied ApplicationofWilliam G PaulBogus  H StateofTennesseevs.FredrickButler(02C019705CR00191)  L ShelbyCriminal  TM ArthurBennett  TN P16850  TO ThomasT.WoodallAffirmed  @Q Rule11  TR  Denied ApplicationofFredrick TS Butler  DT StateofTennesseevs.JohnnyO.Clark (02C019708CR00307)  ( ShelbyCriminal  d W.FredAxley  d 9511522  d DavidG.HayesAffirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofJohnny d  O.Clark(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  @  StateofTennesseevs.HelenK.Davis(02C019701CR00036)   l ShelbyCriminal   ArthurBennett   950621214   JerryL.SmithAffirmed   Rule11    Denied ApplicationofHelen  K.Davis   StateofTennessevs.DoyleHart(02C019703CC00102)    LakeCriminal  D  J.StevenStafford  D  957588  D   JoeG.Riley,Jr.AffirmedPursuanttoRule20   # Rule11  D $  Granted ApplicationofDoyle D % Hart  4 & StateofTennesseevs.EarnestHawkins(02C019709CC00374)  L* LakeCriminal  0 + R.LeeMoore  0 , 977687  0 - DavidG.HayesAffirmedPursuanttoRule20  `0 Rule11  0 1  Denied ApplicationofEarnest 0 2 Hawkins  x 3 StateofTennesseevs.CTJuanD.James(02C019701CR00033)  87 ShelbyCriminal  t8 JosephB.Dailey  t9 941074446  t: JosephB.JonesAffirmed  `< Rule11  t=  Denied ApplicationofCTJuan t> D.James  d? StateofTennesseevs.KennethB.Johnson(02C019612CR00476)  |C ShelbyCriminal  D JamesC.Beasley,Jr.  F 9603012,13,14  H J.CurwoodWittAffirmed  J Rule11  K  Denied Applicationof L KennethB.Johnson  M StateofTennesseevs.TorranceJohnson(02C019610CR00350)  Q ShelbyCriminal  TR JosephB.Dailey  TS 9404486  TT JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed  @V Rule11  TW  Denied Applicationof TX TorranceJohnson  DY StateofTennesseevs.ReginaldS.Mabone (02C019705CR00181)  ( ShelbyCriminal  d W.FredAxley  d P12056  d JosephB.JonesAffirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied Applicationof d  ReginaldS.Mabone  T  StateofTennesseevs.EricaNelms,LakreashaKimble&LatashaS.Thomas(02C019604CR00116)   X ShelbyCriminal   BernieWeinman   9409901,02   PaulG.SummersAffirmedOrderDenyingRehearτSummers,Hayes,Woodall   D  Rule11    Denied ApplicationofLatasha  S.Thomas,LakreashaKimble,EricaNelms   StateofTennesseevs.LynnBrucePerson(02c019712CC00470)   " MadisonCriminal   # FranklinMurchison   % C9796   & PaulG.SummersAffirmedPursuanttoRule20   ) Rule11   *  Denied ApplicationofLynn  + BrucePerson    , StateofTennesseevs.VanceS.Ruffin(02C019612CR00445)  $0 ShelbyCriminal  `1 JohnColton,Jr.  `2 9503711,12  `3 JosephB.JonesAffirmed  L5 Rule11  `6  Denied ApplicationofVance `7 S.Ruffin  P8 StateofTennesseevs.WillieTaylor(02C019702CR00080)  h< ShelbyCriminal  L= JamesC.Beasley,Jr.  8? 9505977  L@ DavidG.HayesAffirmed  8B Rule11  LC  Denied ApplicationofWillie LD Taylor  <E StateofTennesseevs.JasonM.Weiskopf(02C019611CR00381)  TI ShelbyCriminal  J ArthurBennett  K 9502362  L JoeG.Riley,Jr.ReversedandRemanded  hO Rule11  P  Grantedandremanded  Q ApplicationofStateofTennessee  lS StateofTennesseevs.ScottyWayneWhite(02C019709CC00372)      W HardinCriminal  ,X CreedMcGinley 7- ,Y [@7515[@77515 7-+,Z [@7515 [@ 7DavidG.HayesAffirmed   ] Rule11  ,^  Denied ApplicatioofScotty ,_ WayneWhite  `   p" a   p" b   p" c   p" d   p" e   p" f   p" g LarryDempseyandwife,LisaDempseyvs.InternationalAssociationofBridge,StructuralandOrnamentalIronworkers,etal. ( (03A019709CV00436)  l HamiltonCircuit  d SamuelH.Payne  d 96CV0192  d DonT.McMurrayAffirmedandRemanded  <  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofLarry d  andLisaDempsey  T RexGalyonvs.GaryCollins,etal.  l (03A019711CH00513)   X RoaneChancery   FrankV.Williams 8.  @12809@812809 8., @12809 @ 8CharlesD.Susano,Jr.Affirmed   Rule11    Denied ApplicationofRex  Galyon   BarbaraJ.Hand,AdministratrixoftheEstateofCharlesD.Handvs.NorfolkSouthernRailwayCo.(03A019704CV00123)    HamiltonCircuit  0  RobertM.Summitt   " 94CV2354  0 # HoustonM.Goddard,P.J.AffirmedandRemanded   ' Rule11  0 (  Denied ApplicationofNorfolk 0 ) SouthernRailwayCo.   * BillyJoeBourffvs.StateofTennessee(03C019705CR00189)  $. CampbellCriminal  `/ LeeAsbury 7- `0 7@88157@78815 7-+`1 7@8815 7@ 7WilliamM.BarkerAffirmed  L3 Rule11  `4  Denied ApplicationofBilly `5 JoeBourff(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  <7 NelsonB.Gravesvs.HowardCarlton,Warden,andStateofTennessee(03C019705CR00171)  T< JohnsonCriminal  L= LynnW.Brown 7- L> Ԧ@2922Ԧ@72922 7-+L? Ԧ@2922 Ԧ@ 7J.CurwoodWittAffirmed  8A Rule11  LB  Denied ApplicationofNelson LC B.Graves  <D WillieL.Hicksvs.StateofTennessee(03C019707CR00242)  @H SullivanCriminal  |I JerryBeck  |J C38,724  |K J.CurwoodWittAffirmed  hM Rule11  |N  Denied ApplicationofWillie |O L.HicksCourtrecommendsthattheCourtofCriminalAppealsOpinionbepublished(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  tT LoringC.Warnervs. StateofTennessee(03C019610CR00407)  ( BradleyCriminal  d EarlH.Henley  d M96068  d J.CurwoodWittAffirmedinPart;ReversedinPart;andRemanded  (  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofLoring d  Warner  T StateofTennesseevs.RobertWilliamBreeden(03C019606CR00217)   l KnoxCriminal   RayL.Jenkins 8.   @57436 @857436 8.,  @57436  @ 8JosephB.JonesAffirmed   Rule11    Denied ApplicationofRobert  WilliamBreeden   StateofTennesseevs.JenniferCollins(03C019704CR00143)    HamiltonCriminal  D  StevenM.Bevil 9/ D   pA201774pA9201774 9/-D ! pA201774 pA 9GaryR.WadeReversedandRemanded   $ Rule11  D %  Denied ApplicationofState  D & StateofTennesseevs.JohnC.Garrison(03C019702C00047)  L* BledsoeCriminal  0 + ThomasW.Graham 8. t- b@10436b@810436 8.,0 . b@10436 b@ 8GaryR.WadeReversedandRemanded  `1 Rule11  0 2  Granted ApplicationofState 0 3 (Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  x 4 StateofTennesseevs.MauriceT.Johnson(03C019705CR00175)  88 KnoxCriminal  t9 RichardR.Baumgartner  `; 54781,57878  t< JosephM.TiptonAffirmed  `> Rule11  t?  Denied ApplicationofMaurice t@ T.Johnson(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  PB StateofTennesseevs.CharlesE.Lakins(03C019703CR00085)  |F ClaiborneCriminal  G LeeAsbury 8. H @10562@810562 8.,I @10562 @ 8WilliamM.BarkerAffirmed  K Rule11  L  Denied ApplicationofCharles M E.Lakins  N StateofTennesseevs.CharlesEdwinLamb(03C019701CR00010)  ( HamiltonCriminal  d DouglasA.Meyer  d 206136,208565  P DavidG.HayesConvictionofFirstDegreeMurderAffirmed;ConvictionofConspiracytoCommitFirstDegreeMurderReversedand Remanded  0  Rule11  d  Denied ApplicationofCharles d EdwinLamb(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  @ StateofTennesseevs.AngelaManning(03C019501CR00012)  t   BradleyCriminal   X StephenR.Bebb   X M93396   X JosephM.TiptonAffirmedasModified   D  Rule11   X  Denied ApplicationofAngela  X Manning   H  StateofTennesseevs.GaryLynnSmith(03C019705CR00180)  `$ SullivanCriminal   % PhyllisE.Miller   & S38,737   ' GaryR.WadeAffirmed   ) Rule11   *  Denied ApplicationofGary  + LynnSmith   , StateofTennesseevs.HaroldLeonSutton,Jr.(03C019708CC00344)  0 SevierCriminal  81 RexHenryOgle 7- 82 @5511@75511 7-+83 @5511 @ 7J.CurwoodWittAffirmed  $5 Rule11  86  Denied ApplicationofHarold 87 LeonSutton,Jr.   (8   |$9   |$:   |$;   |$<   |$=   |$>  |$? <