WPCF( ڶ]!))N9+ّ1棐*LZ=v ?+d'iu/ظd9JPWثp̀ߚޏ^6őGcF| 9DTH6aF" vFvJW <ҁB&^\ UZ㠌 WKs\yH%O9+ G,Xcs(`!OA|ŋb- )OOO_C-.4:~I PA GBO֛}Ry}}[fn99E-4wx}%Ĉ%h[WZv*~2 U+4O2ՓGfQ2zO>IC`OUAm_)ۆ1l8(M9|5H?Şj5V7C#"FhUhbMbVbԌt/cR֠pA?,c&# UN %m 0(sfa-w@42 h!AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA B)(HP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS0nLh(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A ##Xd# XEYZ[D\]^D_U`DaȈ%d 3|xam?X@&@?X@&@?(@&@?W@&@?V@&@?@&@?U@&@?@&@ ?   V@  &@  ?   @W@  &@  ?   @ 4@ &@  ?   U@  &@  ?   @  &@ ?@&@?r@&@?@&@?@&@?X@&@?W@&@?&@? 4@&@?V@&@?W@&@?W@&@?W@&@?t@&@?¦@&@@ @&@@X&@@ @&@ @   X@  &@ !@!!!!!&@!"@""" "4@"&@"#@###X@##&@#$@$$$W@$$&@$%@%%%X@%%&@%&@&&&W@&&&@&'@'''W@''&@'(@(((X@((&@(*@***X@**&@*&@+@+++@++&@+,@,,,W@,,&@,-@---W@--&@-....?..&@./@///W@//&@/0@000@00&@01@111@11&@12@222/@24@2&@23@333 A33&@34@444W@44&@45@555W@55&@5TABLE A d !  XXTRZ'ALegal Landscape3''ALegal Landscape3'T@9 SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @??5 STATELISTFORPERMISSIONTOAPPEAL@> December7,1998 %  '  0*  ,  .  81  0 XX*w%Xddd Xdd Xdd XXH?XH?w,<dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ," dd +    STYLE/APPEALNUMBER 'X" 'COUNTY 'X" 'TRIALJUDGE 'X" 'TRIALCOURTNO. 'D " 'APPELLATEJUDGE/JUDGMENT 'D " 'NATUREOFAPPEAL 'D" 'ACTION X" JackWayneBursackvs.LawrenceD.Wilson(01A019710CV00555)   0  DavidsonCircuit   l MariettaM.Shipley   X 96C3128   l WilliamB.CainAffirmedandRemanded   D  Rule11   l  Denied ApplicationofJack  l WayneBursack   \ StephenEarlCrabtreevs.NancyChoppinCrabtree(01A019710CV00576)  t! DavidsonCircuit   " MurielRobinson   # 96D2149   $ DavidR.FarmerAffirmedandRemanded   ' Rule11   (  Granted Applicationof  ) StephenEarlCrabtree   * RobertT.Irvinvs.FaithJohnson,etal. $- (01A019708CV00427)  . MontgomeryCircuit  L/ JamesE.Walton  L0 C12431  L1 WilliamB.CainAffirmedinPart,ModifiedinPartandRemanded  5 Rule11  L6  Denied ApplicationofRobert L7 T.Ivin  <8 JimmyKeyvs.TennesseeBoardofParoles(01A019610CH00480)  T< DavidsonChancery  8= IrvinH.Kilcrease,Jr.  |$? 953896I  8@ WilliamC.Koch,Jr.AffirmedandRemanded  hC Rule11  8D  Denied ApplicationofJimmy 8E Key  (F LionelL.Lulowvs.EarlPossandCarlPoss(01A019509CH00399)  @J CannonChancery  |K RobertE.Corlew  |L 9078  |M WalterBussartAffirmedandRemanded  TP Rule11  |Q  Denied ApplicationofEarl |R PossandCarlPoss  lS DeonBradenvs.StateofTennessee(01C019708CC00351)  !W MauryCriminal  X JimT.Hamilton 7- Y @9033@79033 7-+Z @9033 @ 7JoeG.Riley,Jr.Remanded   \ Rule11  ]  Denied ApplicationofDeon ^ Braden   _ 7VIXXdXXd7  JonasRomeCole d vs. StateofTennessee(01C019509CC00294)  ( DavidsonCriminal  d WalterC.Kurtz  d 87W637  d JosephM.TiptonAffirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofJonas d  RomeCole  T  TracyHigginbothamvs.StateofTennessee(01C019704CC00126)   l WayneCriminal   JimT.Hamilton 8.  @11128@811128 8., @11128 @ 8J.CurwoodWittAffirmed   Rule11    Denied,concurrenceinresults  only ApplicationofTracy  Higginbotham(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)   p JamesR.Jacksonvs.StateofTennessee(01C019609CR00387)     DavidsonCriminal  H  ThomasH.Shriver  4 ! 90S948  H " WilliamM.BarkerAffirmed  4 $ Rule11  H %  Denied ApplicationofJames H & R.Jackson(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  $ ( GregoryK.Jonesvs.StateofTennessee(01C019706CR00226)  P, DavidsonCriminal  4 - RandallWyatt  4 . 93A404  4 / DavidH.WellesAffirmed  x 1 Rule11  4 2  Denied ApplicationofGregory 4 3 Jones  |$4 RobertOgburnvs.StateofTennessee(01C019801CC00027)  <8 MontgomeryCriminal  x9 RobertWedemeyer  d; 31683,31850&31851  d= ThomasT.WoodallAffirmedPursuanttoRule20  P@ Rule11  xA  Denied ApplicationofRobert xB Ogburn  hC EricPendletonvs.StateofTennessee(01C019801CR00063)  G DavidsonCriminal  H RandallWyatt  I 87S777  J JohnPeay,JerrySmith,ThomasWoodallOrderDenyingApplicationtoReopenPostConviction;OrderDenyingMotiontoReconsider  0R Rule11  S  Denied ApplicationofEric T Pendleton  U StateofTennesseevs.AltonB.Applegate (01C019608CR00370)  ( DavidsonCriminal  d FrankClement,Jr.  d SN16403  d GaryR.Wade,P.J.AppealDismissed,JudgmentofTrialCourtAffirmed  (  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofAlton d  B.Applegate  T StateofTennesseevs.DonaldEugeneBrooks(01C019703CC00099)   l MontgomeryCriminal   JohnGasaway,III 8.  @35988@835988 8., @35988 @ 8J.CurwoodWittAffirmed   Rule11   S STDenied TUApplicationofUVUdonaldUVWDonaldWXWEugWXY  YZEuZ[YGY[\g\YeneBrooks(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)YTS ST   StateofTennesseevs.RonaldL.Davis(01C019803CC00132)    MauryCriminal  D   JamesL.Weatherford 7- 0 " r@9444r@79444 7-+D # r@9444 r@ 7JohnH.PeayOrderDenyingPermissiontoAppeal   & Rule11  D '  Denied ApplicationofRonald D ( L.Davis  4 ) StateofTennesseevs.VirginiaAllenGann(01C019704CC00164)  L- CoffeeCounty  0 . GeraldL.Ewell,Sr. 8. t0 @27564@827,564 8.,0 1 @27564 @ 8J.CurwoodWittAffirmed  t3 Rule11  0 4  Denied ApplicationofVirginia 0 5 AllenGann(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  d 7 StateofTennesseevs.WilliamAlfredHolt,Jr.(01C019704CC00155)  8; MarshallCriminal  t< WilliamCharlesLee 8. `> @12844@812844 8.,t? @12844 @ 8DavidH.WellesAffirmed  `A Rule11  tB  Denied ApplicationofWilliam tC AlfredHolt,Jr.  dD StateofTennesseevs.JohnChristopherJackson(01C019704CR00162)  |H DavidsonCriminal  I RandallWyatt  J 96A243  K GaryR.Wade,P.J.Affirmed  M Rule11  N  Denied ApplicationofJohn O ChristopherJackson  P StateofTennesseevs.WillieB.Jackson(01C019702CR00054)  T DavidsonCriminal  TU SethNorman  TV 94B1262  TW ThomasT.WoodallAffirmedinPart;ReversedinPart  ,Z Rule11  T[  Dismissed Applicationof T\ WillieB.Jackson  D] StateofTennesseevs.TracieJenkinsandDavidRagsdale (01C019612CC00520)  ( WilliamsonCriminal  d DonaldP.Harris  d II1195330C  d WilliamM.BarkerAffirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofDavid d  Ragsdale(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  @  StateofTennesseevs.RobertLeeMallard(01C019705CC00181)   l RutherfordCriminal   J.S.Daniel   M36145   J.CurwoodWittAffirmedPursuanttoRule20   Rule11    Denied ApplicationofRobert  LeeMallard(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)   StateofTennesseevs.RolandH.Matlock(01C019107CR00212)    DavidsonCriminal  D   ThomasH.Shriver  0 " 90F1974  D # JerryL.SmithAffirmedinPart;DelayedAppealGranted   ' Rule11  D (  Denied ApplicationofRoland D ) H.Matlock  4 * StateofTennesseevs.MaxEugeneMartin(01C019609CR00415)  L. PutnamCriminal  0 / LeonC.Burns,Jr.  0 0 92310F  0 1 WilliamM.BarkerAffirmed  t3 Rule11  0 4  Denied ApplicationofMax 0 5 EugeneMartin(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  d 7 StateofTennesseevs.DonaldTerryMoore(01C019702CR00061)  8; DavidsonCriminal  t< AnnLacyJohns  t= 94B1017  t> JohnH.PeayAffirmed  `@ Rule11  tA  Granted Applicationof tB DonaldTerryMoore  dC StateofTennesseevs.RichardE.Nelson(01C019601CR00034)  |G WilsonCriminal  H JamesO.Bond  I 95133,95134&95135  K WilliamM.BarkerAffirmedasModified  M Rule11  N  Denied ApplicationofRichard O E.Nelson(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  Q StateofTennesseevs.GarrettRaines(01C019704CC00127)  U RobertsonCriminal  TV RobertWedemeyer 7- @X t@9961t@79961 7-+TY t@9961 t@ 7DavidH.WellesAffirmed  @[ Rule11  T\  Denied ApplicationofGarrett T] Raines  D^ StateofTennesseevs.WandaKayZaid (01C019703CC00081)  ( GrundyCriminal  d ThomasW.Graham 7- P ¦@2913¦@72913 7-+d ¦@2913 ¦@ 7JosephB.JonesAffirmedinPart;ReversedinPart  <  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofWanda d  KayZaid  T                      DonE.Gordon,etal. ( Vs.GeorgetownUniversity(02A019709CH00218)  D  WeakleyChancery  ( W.MichaelMaloan 8. l   @14869 @814869 8.,(  @14869  @ 8DavidR.FarmerReversedandRemanded  X   Rule11  (!  Denied,concurrenceinresults (" only ApplicationofDonE. l # Gordon,etal.  \ $ RandallRayFlemingvs.JacquelineYi(02A019706CV00129)  0 ( MadisonCircuit   l ) ]RoyMorgan]^WhitLafon^   l * C96117&C96122   X , DavidR.FarmerAffirmedandRemanded_RehearDenied_  0 0 Rule11   l 1  Denied ApplicationofHaulers  l 2 InsuranceCompany,Inc.   \ 3 RoseConstruction,Inc.vs.RaintreeDevelopmentCompany(02A019807CH00181)  t7 ShelbyChancery  8   9 1101621  : AlanE.HighersDavidR.FarmerDismissedNoticeofAppealandDeniedMotionforStay  `? Rule11  @  Denied Applicationof A RaintreeDevelopment,LLC  B JamesCarrvs.StateofTennessee(02C019802CC00037)  F LakeCriminal  8G R.LeeMoore  8H 987739  8I PaulG.SummersAffirmed  $K Rule11  8L  Denied ApplicationofJames 8M Carr  (N FredrickM.Sledgevs.StateofTennessee(02C019702CR00086)  @R ShelbyCriminal  |$S JosephB.Dailey  |$T P14654  |$U ThomasT.WoodallAffirmed  hW Rule11  |$X  Denied ApplicationofFredrick |$Y M.Sledge  lZ OdellSmithvs.StateofTennessee(02C019803CR00060)  !,^ ShelbyCriminal  h_ ArthurBennett  h` P05385  ha DavidG.HayesAffirmedPursuanttoRule20   @d Rule11  he  Denied ApplicationofOdell hf Smith  Xg StateofTennessee vs.AndersonD.Curry(02C019711CR00452)  ( ShelbyCriminal  d BernieWeinman  d 9613102  d JohnH.PeayAffirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied Applicationof d  AndersonC.Curry  T  StateofTennesseevs.DarrellEmerson(02C019312CC00276)   l MadisonCriminal   FranklinMurchison   94327   JerryL.SmithReversedandRemanded   Rule11    Denied Applicationof`Darrell  Emerson`aStatea   StateofTennesseevs.AaronGray(02C019707CC00270)    MadisonCriminal  D  FranklinMurchison  0  96779  D ! JoeG.Riley,Jr.AffirmedJudgmentofTrialCourt;Reversed&DismissedAppellantsConvictionforAggravatedAssault  t( Rule11  D )  Denied ApplicationofAaron D * Gray(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)   , StateofTennesseevs.DerrickMcClure(02C019705CR00192)  0 ShelbyCriminal  L1 ArthurBennett  L2 9406285,6,7,8,9  84 DavidG.HayesAffirmed  $7 Rule11  L8  Denied ApplicationofDerick L9 McClure  <: StateofTennesseevs.DanielD.Naughton,Sr.(02C019612CR00449)  T> ShelbyCriminal  8? JohnColton,Jr.  |$A 9200792  8B DavidG.HayesAffirmedAppellantsConvictions&ModifiedSentencetoReflectNineYears  @G Rule11  8H  Denied ApplicationofDaniel 8I D.Naughton,Sr.  (J StateofTennesseevs.GregoryWhitfield(02C019706CR00226)  ,N ShelbyCriminal  hO JamesBeasley,Jr.  TQ 9606370,73  hR DavidG.HayesAffirmed  TT Rule11  hU  Denied ApplicationofGregory hV Whitfield  XW    X    Y    Z    [    \    ]    ^ BettyJ.Collins,etal. d vs. DavidCollins(03A019708CH00326)  ( HamblenChancery  d ThomasR.Frierson,II  P 9699  d DavidR.FarmerAffirmedandRemanded  <  PetitiontoRehearRule11Denial  <  Denied PetitionofBettyJ. d CollinsandPantherParkBaptistChurchtoRehearDenialofRule11  , JerryJ.Harb,etux.  vs.ServiceTransport,Inc.,etal.  (03A019708CV00365)   p KnoxCircuit   WheelerA.Rosenbalm   375995   AlanE.HighersAffirmed   Rule11    Denied ApplicationofService  Transport,Inc.   JuddsIncorporatedvs.DorisL.Muir,et.vir.,etal.  " (03A019801CH00002)    # CockeChancery  H $ ChesterRainwater,Jr.  4 & 95192  H ' WilliamH.Inman,Sr.J.AffirmedasModifiedandRemanded    + Rule11  H ,  Denied ApplicationofDorisL. H - Muir,etvir.,etal.  8 . AnnC.Kingvs.DavidM.King(03A019710CH00441)  P2 AndersonChancery  4 3 WilliamE.Lantrip  4 4 95CH3588  4 5 DonT.McMurrayAffirmedandRemanded  d 8 Rule11  4 9  Denied DavidM.King  4 : JoyWalls,etc.vs.Acands,Inc.,etal.  P= KnoxCircuit  x> DaleWorkman  x? 139191  x@ HoustonM.Goddard,P.J.AffirmedandRemanded  <D Rule11  xE  Denied ApplicationofJoy xF Walls  hG PaulaM.York,etvir. H vs. I SevierCountyAmbulanceAuthority,etal. J (03A019801CV00033)  K SevierCircuit  L RichardR.Vance  M 95689II  N WilliamH.Inman,Sr.J.Reversed  Q Rule11  R  Granted ApplicationofPaula S M.York  T StephenJoeCoopervs.StateofTennessee(03C019801CR00018)  X KnoxCriminal  XY RayL.Jenkins 8. XZ @63085@863085 8.,X[ @63085 @ 8PerCuriam  X\ Rule11  X]  Denied ApplicationofStephen X^ JoeCooper(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  4` RickyHarrisvs.StateofTennessee (03C019611CR00410)  ( CarterCriminal  d R.JerryBeck 8. d @10297@810297 8.,d @10297 @ 8GaryR.Wade,P.J.Affirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofRicky d  Harris(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  @  JeffreyS.Whitakervs.StateofTennessee(03C019705CR00184)   l MorganCriminal   E.EugeneEblen 7-  /@8287/@78287 7-+ /@8287 /@ 7PaulG.SummersAffirmedPursuanttoRule20   Rule11    Denied ApplicationofJeffrey  S.Whitaker   StateofTennesseevs.ChristopherBenardErvin(03C019710CR00443)    HamiltonCriminal  D  GaryD.Gerbitz 9/ D    A210577 A9210577 9/-D !  A210577  A 9JohnH.PeayAffirmed  0 # Rule11  D $  Denied Applicationof D % ChristopherBenardErvin  4 & StateofTennesseevs.DarrellKennethMcConnell(03C019604CC00148)  L* HamblenCriminal  0 + JamesE.Beckner  0 , 94Cr305  0 - JerryL.SmithAffirmed  t/ Rule11  0 0  Denied ApplicationofDarrell 0 1 KennethMcConnell  x 2 StateofTennesseevs.StewartW.Pait(03C019704CR00149)  86 SevierCriminal  t7 BenW.Hooper,III  `9 945071  t: ThomasT.WoodallAffirmed  `< Rule11  t=  Denied ApplicationofStewart t> W.Pait d? 5