WPC( nh븸k%\l^Li43 QҤ8n c.z~bO+Z*`1ȑ'f  1[cMi>v |o/{1YW2nȃkz ?WnhU/m5@l`-C,d$W|4䜋NwgW6>8vMI34'GG> %6wq#/m,,*2֛#En&]ԡknY:v?E/$t'l$E##z~-6e3 D|sIr+Gw׾#eAɘZMXODڠnW/ /2w.z8kݥ5s;BLw)ӱOXsC8QHKSE_n mt/*kM] &D$#[&O^zO9gc)lS c#v7ͩ~zT# V UNa % 0( f a - w@ 4`t h BX&X&X&X&X& D3u&u&& 0Dn' 0K'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' A'HP LaserJet 4SiHPPCL5MS,,,,,,0nLh(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($TABLE A ##Xd# DUEDEDȈ%d 3|x?|@&@?W@&@?V@&@?@&@?X@&@?W@&@@@&@@X@&@ @   X@ 4@ &@  @   X@ 4@ &@  @   ֥ 4@ &@  @   #@ 4@ &@  @   @W  &@ @W@4@&@@@4@&@@X@&@@X@&@@&@@W@&@@̳@&@@3@&@@W@&@@X@&@@X@&@@8@4@&@@W@&@@B4@&@@@&@?W@&@@^@&@&@&@@@&@ @   T@ 4@ &@ !@!!!X@!!&@!"@"""@@""&@"#@#####&@#TABLE A d%%%%'dxdLevel 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(3$ !  ( $ Figure  1  ,-.* I&mage XX=8C !  XXTRZ'ALegal Landscape3''ALegal Landscape3'T@9 SUPREMECOURTOFTENNESSEE X @??5 STATELISTFORPERMISSIONTOAPPEAL@>  December28,1998  %  '  0*  ,  .  81  0   XX*w%Xddd Xdd Xdd XXH?XH?w,<dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ,dd ," dd +    STYLE/APPEALNUMBER '\" 'COUNTY '\" 'TRIALJUDGE '\" 'TRIALCOURTNO. 'H " 'APPELLATEJUDGE/JUDGMENT 'H " 'NATUREOFAPPEAL 'H" 'ACTION \" JerryAllenEstis,etal.  p vs.WilliamCarrollKelley,etal.  H  (01A019709CV00513)   4  MauryCircuit   p RobertL.Jones 7-  p |@1759|@71759 7-+ p |@1759 |@ 7HenryF.ToddOverruled   \ Rule11   p  Denied ApplicationofWilliam  p CarrollKelley   ` CharlesF.Gaulden,etux.    vs.RobertL.Scruggs,etux.   (01A019708CH00417)  x DavidsonChancery     EllenHobbsLyle    ! 953970III    " BenH.Cantrell,P.J.AffirmedandRemandedRehearDenied  x& Rule11    '  Denied ApplicationofCharles   ( andRuthGaulden   ) JerryDwaineCammusevs.StateofTennessee(01C019709CR00440)  - DavidsonCriminal  P. RandallWyatt  P/ 90W240  P0 DavidG.HayesAffirmedRehearDenied  (3 Rule11  P4  Denied ApplicationofJerry P5 DwaineCammuse  @6 DavidCarlDuncanvs.StateofTennessee(01C019510CR00347)  X: SumnerCriminal  <; JaneWheatcraft 7- << @8991@78991 7-+<= @8991 @ 7JerryScott,Sp.J.AffirmedRehearDenied  l@ Rule11  <A  Denied,withconcurrencein <B resultsonly Applicationof (C DavidCarlDuncan  pD StateofTennesseevs.RobertA.Payne(01C019701CR00031)  DH DavidsonCriminal  I AnnLacyJohns  J 96A311  K JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed  lM Rule11  N  Grantedwithrespectto: O Whethertheoffenseofrecklessendangermentcanbecommittedeagainstthepublicatlarge ApplicationofRobert 0S A.Payne(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  d U   !V   !W   !X   !Y   !Z   ![   !\ 7f=XXdXXd7  7&\XXdXXd7  JerryCunningham d vs. Baker,Donelson,Bearman&Caldwell,P.C.(02A019712CV00299)  ( ShelbyCircuit  d DickW.Jerman,Jr.byInterchange  P 84782T.D.  d HerschelP.FranksAffirmedandRemandedRehearDenied  (  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofJerry d Cunningham(Birch,J.,NotParticipating)  @ RobertDuaneBitnervs.BillyCompton,Warden,andStateofTennessee(02C019610CC00336)   X LakeCriminal   R.LeeMoore   967522   DavidG.HayesAffirmed   Rule11    Deniedwithconcurrencein  resultsonly Applicationof  RobertDuaneBitner   JamesLeeBlairvs.StateofTennessee(02C019610CC00339)   " LakeCriminal  0 # R.LeeMoore  0 $ 967527  0 % JosephB.JonesAffirmedPursuanttoRule20,CCA   ( Rule11  0 )  Deniedwithconcurrencein 0 * resultsonly Applicationof  + JamesLeeBlair    , JohnnyW.Brownvs.StateofTennessee(02C019612CC00463)  80 LakeCriminal  t1 R.LeeMoore  t2 967556  t3 DavidG.HayesAffirmedPursanttoRule20,CCA  L6 Rule11  t7  Deniedwithconcurrencein t8 resultsonly Applicationof `9 JohnnyW.Brown  P: JohnDerrickColemanvs.StateofTennessee(02C019707CC00291)  |$> GibsonCriminal  `? DickW.Jerman,Jr.  LA H2795  `B JoeG.Riley,Jr.AffirmedPursuanttoRule20,CCA  8E Rule11  `F  Dismissed ApplicationofJohn `G DerrickColeman(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  <I LarryDawsonvs.StateofTennessee(02C019704CC00156)  hM LauderdaleCriminal  N JoeH.Walker 7- O #@4899#@74899 7-+P #@4899 #@ 7PaulG.SummersAffirmedPursuanttoRule20,CCA  |S Rule11  T  Deniedwithconcurrencein U resultsonly Applicationof V LarryDawson  W BruceWayneFlournoyvs.StateofTennessee(02C019611CC00391)   [ MadisonCriminal  @\ RogyMorganWhitLafon  @] C9388  @^ JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed  ,` Rule11  @a  Denied ApplicationofBruce @b WayneFlournoy  0c EddieJoeMannvs.                StateofTennessee(02C019707CC00240)  ( DyerCriminal  d R.LeeMoore  d C9519  d PaulG.SummersAffirmedPursuanttoRule20,CCA  <  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofEddie d  JoeMann  T  RobertParishvs.StateofTennessee(02C019612CC00452)   l LauderdaleCriminal   JoeH.Walker 7-  @4857@74857 7-+ @4857 @ 7DavidG.HayesAffirmedPursuanttoRule20,CCA   Rule11    Deniedwithconcurrencein  resultsonly Applicationof  RobertParish   HarveyQuallsvs.BillyCompton,Warden,andStateofTennessee(02C019610CC00331)    LakeCriminal  D ! R.LeeMoore  D " 967517  D # DavidG.HayesAffirmed  0 % Rule11  D &  Deniedwithconcurrencein D ' resultsonly Applicationof 0 ( HarveyQualls   ) JamesR.C.Rogersvs.StateofTennessee(02C019610CC00343)  8- LakeCriminal  t. R.LeeMoore  t/ 967532  t0 JosephB.JonesAffirmed  `2 Rule11  t3  Deniedwithconcurrencein t4 resultsonly Applicationof `5 JamesR.C.Rogers  P6 ReginaldD.Tuttonvs.StateofTennessee(02C019610CR00351)  |$: ShelbyCriminal  `; L.T.Lafferty,Sr.J.  L= P15209  `> JerryL.SmithAffirmed  L@ Rule11  `A  Denied Applicationof `B ReginaldTutton  PC StateofTennesseevs.DarrellBraddock(02C019707CR00279)  hG ShelbyCriminal  H CarolynWadeBlackett  J 9408164,5,6,7,8  L JerryL.SmithAffirmed  N Rule11  O  Denied ApplicationofDarrell P E.Braddock  Q StateofTennesseevs.LamarFletcher(02C019803CC00098)   U LauderdaleCriminal  @V JoeH.Walker 7- @W ̳@5068̳@75068 7-+@X ̳@5068 ̳@ 7JohnK.Byers,Sp.J.Affirmed  ,Z Rule11  @[  Denied ApplicationofLamar @\ Fletcher  0] StateofTennesseevs. TimmyFulton(02C019706CC00223)  ( LauderdaleCriminal  d JoeH.Walker 7- d 3@61953@76195 7-+d 3@6195 3@ 7JerryL.SmithAffirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied ApplicationofTimmy d  Fulton  T  StateofTennesseevs.JamesH.Mabry(02C019702CR00059)   l ShelbyCriminal   JamesC.Beasley,Jr.   9511686   PaulG.SummersModifiedandRemanded   Rule11    Deniedwithconcurrencein  resultsonly Applicationof  StateofTennessee   StateofTennesseevs.ThomasL.Matthews(02C019704CR00158)    ShelbyCriminal  D   BernieWeinman  D ! 9606668  D " GaryR.WadeAffirmed  0 $ Rule11  D %  Denied ApplicationofThomas D & Matthews  4 ' StateofTennesseevs.DavidL.Owens(02C019706CR00204)  L+ ShelbyCriminal  0 , JosephB.Dailey  0 - 9604584  0 . JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed  t0 Rule11  0 1  Grantedastowhetherthe 0 2 evidencewassufficienttoshowthatthetheftofpropertywaseffected byviolenceorputtingthepersoninfear  86 ApplicationofDavidL.Owens(Barker,J.,NotParkticipating)  8 StateofTennesseevs.GaylenAubreaScott(02C019707CC00244)  X< HardinCriminal  <= CreedMcGinley 7- <> 8@74808@77480 7-+<? 8@7480 8@ 7JoeG.Riley,Jr.AffirmedPursuanttoRule20,CCA  lB Rule11  <C  Denied ApplicationofGaylen <D AubreaScott(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  pF StateofTennesseevs.CynthiaG.Starks(02C019704CR00133)  DJ ShelbyCriminal  K CarolynWadeBlackett  lM 9507316  N JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed  lP Rule11  Q  Denied ApplicationofCynthia R G.Starks  pS StateofTennesseevs.VictorThompson(02C0198021CR00056)  !W ShelbyCriminal  X JohnColton,Jr.  Y P12933  Z PaulG.SummersAffirmedPursuanttoRule20   ] Rule11  ^  Denied ApplicationofVictor _ Thompson   ` StateofTennessee vs.AmandaTreece(02C019711CC00438)  ( ChesterCriminal  d FranklinMurchison 7- P @3539@73539 7-+d @3539 @ 7ThomasT.WoodallAffirmed  P  Rule11  d   Denied Applicationof d  AmandaTreece  T                       JamesE.Swiggettvs.CarlR.Ogle,Jr.andJ.MichaelKerr(03A019709CH00430)  D  JohnsonChancery  ( GeraldR.Johnson 7- ( ^@4702^@74702 7-+( ^@4702 ^@ 7DonT.McMurrayAffirmedandRemandedRule11Denied  D  RehearofRule11Denial  l !  Denied PetitionofJamesE. (" SwiggetttoRehearRule11Denial  \ $ DannyMillervs.HowardCarltonandStateofTennessee(03C019610CR00388)  0 ( JohnsonCriminal   l ) LynnW.Brown 7-  l * @2904@72904 7-+ l + @2904 @ 7JohnH.PeayAffirmed   X - Rule11   l .  Deniedwithconcurrencein  l / resultsonly Applicationof  X 0 DannyMiller  H 1 DavidC.Tathamvs.StateofTennessee(03C019707CR00288)  t5 MorganCriminal  6 E.EugeneEblen 7- 7 T@8360T@78360 7-+8 T@8360 T@ 7J.CurwoodWittAffirmedPursuanttoRule20,CCA  ; Rule11  <  Denied ApplicationofDavid = C.Tatham  > StateofTennesseevs.AliceCollins(03C019704CR00127)  B HamblenCriminal  LC JamesE.Beckner  LD 96CR239  LE GaryR.WadeAffirmed  8G Rule11  LH  Denied ApplicationofAlice LI Collins(Barker,J.,NotParticipating)  (K StateofTennesseevs.ThomasJ.McKee(03C019603CR00092)  TO KnoxCriminal  8P RichardR.Baumgartner 8. |$R @@56538@@856538 8.,8S @@56538 @@ 8JohnK.Byers,Sr.J.Affirmed  |$U Rule11  8V  Denied appApplicationofThomas 8W J.McKee  (X StateofTennesseevs.FredNuchols(03C019709CC00400)   @\ BlountCriminal  |] D.KellyThomas,Jr.  h_ C9688&96893  ha JoeG.Riley,Jr.Affirmed  hc Rule11  |d  Denied ApplicationofFred |e Nuchols  lf   "g   "h  8. "i X@10416X@8 8.,"j X@10416 X@ 8  "k   "l  lf #