Extraordinary Appeal Granted in Brentwood Academy Assault Lawsuit - Articles

All Content


Posted by: Jarod Word on Jan 31, 2018
Last week, the Tennessee Court of Appeals granted an application for extraordinary appeal in the Brentwood Academy assault lawsuit, according to The Tennessean. This decision reignites the controversial dispute previously dismissed by Williamson County Circuit Court Judge Deanna Johnson. The suit, filed in August 2017, alleges John Doe was repeatedly sexually assaulted in a locker room by older students during the 2014-15 school year. It also alleges that school officials failed to appropriately respond to and prevent the attacks. 
 
The case took a surprising turn last month when it was dismissed by Johnson amidst an argument over the deposition of Bureon Ledbetter, an attorney for the John Doe and family. Ledbetter argued the information he was asked to reveal through the deposition would violate attorney-client privilege. Johnson said Ledbetter could file an objection but must answer. If he did not, she threatened to put him in jail for contempt, according to court documents. At that point, the Does' second attorney, Justin Gilbert, tried to withdraw the case without prejudice, with the intent to refile. However, the same day Johnson granted an order requested by Brentwood Academy attorneys to dismiss the case with prejudice. Despite Johnson's order dismissing the case, the Williamson County court docket states the case is technically still open as Johnson still needs to file a findings of fact offering an explanation as to why the case was dismissed. 
 
Both the school and the accused students have denied all wrongdoing.