March, 2013

Cover Story

There’s a scene in the John Grisham thriller The Runaway Jury where Gene Hackman, as a highly paid — and highly unethical — jury consultant, is monitoring a bank of video screens, relying on hidden cameras and microphones to covertly coach the lawyers who are relying on him through the complex voir dire process in a landmark case. Today, Mr....

President's Perspective

The Tennessee High School Mock Trial competition is the premier public service project of the TBA Young Lawyers Division (YLD), which it has sponsored since 1981. This year’s championship will be March 15-16 at the Metro Courthouse in Nashville, where Tennessee Supreme Court Justice William C. Koch will preside over the championship round.  

Letters of the Law

May I offer some random and (hopefully) unbiased thoughts abut the Collateral Source rule discussion in the December and January issues of TBJ? By way of disclosure, I am primarily an injury defense lawyer. The comments I share are mine alone and not that of any other person or entity.

Book Review

 By W. Russell Taber III | CreateSpace | $29.95 |  288 pages | 2012

I have never been much of a horror movie fan. Werewolves, vampires and other creatures going bump in the night just don’t do it for me. But to this day I cannot watch Poltergeist. It played off of the same stuff that kept me up at night as a kid...


Shuttleworth Williams is now located in the First Tennessee Plaza at 800 South Gay St., Suite 2031 in Knoxville. The new space puts the office closer to the Knox County Courthouse, state Supreme Court Building and U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee.


The Tennessee Supreme Court launched in February a volunteer recognition program to honor lawyers who provide at least 50 hours of pro bono service annually. The program is entirely voluntary and based on self-reporting. Attorneys are encouraged to begin tracking their work this year. Those who meet the goal will be named “Attorneys for Justice” by the...


TBA senior counselor HARRY WARD CAMP died Jan. 27 at the age of 83. Camp practiced law for more than 50 years in McMinnville. He graduated in 1957 from Vanderbilt University Law School, where he was president of the student body and associate managing editor of the law review. He was a member of the Christian Legal Society and served as...

Licensure & Discipline

Administrative Suspensions Now Online

Notice of attorneys suspended for, and reinstated from, administrative violations — including failure to pay the Board of Professional Responsibility fee, file the IOLTA report, comply with continuing legal education requirements and pay the Tennessee professional privilege tax — is now available exclusively...

Crime & Punishment

Whether to accept or reject a plea offer is one of the decisions the client, rather than counsel, must make.[1] The criminal defense lawyer, however, faces a heavy responsibility to make sure that decision is made knowingly, voluntarily and intelligently. Both the Tennessee Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court have noted ways in which...

Paine on Procedure

I wrote about some of these in my January/February 1990 column and in a June 2006 article. Changes since those publications mandate an update. Here it is.

Admissions by Party-Opponent Tennessee Rule of Evidence 803(1.2)(D) requires an agent’s statement to be against the agent’s interest. Federal Rule of Evidence 801(d)(2)(D) does not. Tennessee...

But Seriously, Folks

Thirty-five years ago when I became a lawyer, I bought myself two very impressive items that I felt I needed to make me look like a real lawyer.

The first was a dark blue suit. My wardrobe in law school consisted of t-shirts, blue jeans, a pair of Chuck Taylor Converse All-Stars, and a polyester plaid jacket I had purchased at JC Penny’s for fifty...