TBA Law Blog


Posted by: Azya Thornton on Feb 17, 2025

A recent ruling by U.S. District Court Judge Jon McCalla has raised concerns about the future of the Kendrick Consent Decree, a federal order that has long prevented the Memphis Police Department (MPD) from spying on citizens, the Commercial Appeal reports. McCalla's decision modifies the decree by replacing a private attorney who monitors police activities with two lawyers employed by the city of Memphis and assigned to the Memphis Police Department. Memphis lawyer Ed Stanton has been serving in the role since 2018. The ACLU of Tennessee, city outside counsel Bruce McMullen and Stanton support the change, saying the independent monitor role was not intended to be permanent. Others — including attorney Bruce Kramer, who first sued the city in 1976 over MPD’s illegal surveillance — argue that the shift risks undermining protections against civil rights violations. The Kendrick Consent Decree, established in 1978 after the MPD was found to have spied on political activists, has been crucial in safeguarding First Amendment rights, supporters say.